5-4

Movie Review: Average Joe [TEASER]

5 min
Dec 16, 20256 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

The 5-4 podcast reviews the 2024 Christian film "Average Joe," which dramatizes the Supreme Court's 2022 Kennedy v. Bremerton School District ruling that upheld a football coach's First Amendment right to pray on the field. The hosts critique the film's poor narrative structure and characterize it as Christian propaganda with incoherent storytelling.

Insights
  • Recent Supreme Court decisions on religious freedom are being adapted into feature films, indicating growing cultural politicization of judicial rulings
  • Christian filmmaking often prioritizes ideological messaging over fundamental cinematic craft and narrative coherence
  • The Kennedy v. Bremerton ruling represents a significant expansion of religious expression rights in public institutions
  • Media consolidation concerns are reshaping consumer preferences, with viewers accepting less-ideal corporate outcomes as alternatives
Trends
Politicization of entertainment: Supreme Court cases becoming source material for feature filmsReligious freedom litigation expanding into public institutional spaces like high school sportsDeclining quality expectations in niche ideological filmmakingMedia consolidation creating forced consumer choices between undesirable corporate entitiesStreaming service fatigue and choice paralysis affecting viewer engagement
Topics
Supreme Court First Amendment JurisprudenceReligious Expression in Public SchoolsKennedy v. Bremerton School District RulingChristian Filmmaking and PropagandaSeparation of Church and StateMedia Consolidation in EntertainmentStreaming Service Market DynamicsFilm Narrative Structure and StorytellingPublic School Policy and Religious Rights
Companies
Netflix
Discussed as potential acquirer in media consolidation scenario; hosts debate supporting Netflix over Paramount as le...
Paramount
Media conglomerate criticized by hosts as undesirable alternative in potential Warner Bros. acquisition scenario
Warner Bros. Discovery
Subject of hypothetical media consolidation discussion regarding potential acquisition by Netflix or Paramount
People
Joe Kennedy
High school football coach at center of Supreme Court case Kennedy v. Bremerton; subject of film Average Joe
Peter
Co-host of 5-4 podcast; participates in film review and Supreme Court analysis discussion
Riannan
Co-host of 5-4 podcast; participates in film review and Supreme Court analysis discussion
Michael
Co-host of 5-4 podcast; participates in film review and Supreme Court analysis discussion
Leon
Host/announcer from Prologg Projects introducing the 5-4 episode
Quotes
"This is 5-4. A podcast about how much the Supreme Court sucks."
5-4 hostsOpening
"The result is a muddled bit of Christian propaganda that is much less fun to watch than it is to make fun of on a podcast."
Leon/5-4 hostsTeaser
"Look, I'm a Marine, and the Constitution means something to me. It's always been a freedom thing."
Joe Kennedy (from film)Film excerpt
"A bunch of Christian dipshits who don't understand how a film needs to be structured in order to be coherent."
5-4 hostsFilm critique
Full Transcript
Hey coach, could I pray with you? Free country. Hey everyone, this is Leon from Prologg Projects. On this subscriber-only episode of 5-4, Peter, Riannan, and Michael are marking the holiday season by watching the minor motion picture Average Joe. As you'll hear, the film is only kind of about the Supreme Court, but it does in its way, center around the courts 2022 ruling in favor of Joe Kennedy. Football coach at a public high school claimed a first amendment right to pray on the field during games. You weren't trying to convert them? Look, I'm a Marine, and the Constitution means something to me. It's always been a freedom thing. The result is a muddled bit of Christian propaganda that is much less fun to watch than it is to make fun of on a podcast. This is 5-4. A podcast about how much the Supreme Court sucks. Welcome to 5-4, where we dissect and analyze the Supreme Court cases that have done a hostile takeover of this country. Like Paramount taking over Warner Brothers. I'm Peter, I'm here with Riannan. Hey everybody. And Michael. I'm so upset that I have to root for fucking Netflix to consolidate media and buy Warner Brothers Discovery because the alternative is Paramount. Fuck Paramount. Yeah. Fuck the Ellisons. Fuck the Ellisons. Well, when I look at the Warner Brothers catalog, I think what would a bunch of pervert freaks do with this? You know, I'm curious. I need to see it. Wait, does that mean that you want to see Netflix? What Netflix does with it or what the Ellisons do with it? I was referring to the Ellisons. Unfortunately, we're forced to root for Netflix here. Which by the way, I was just thinking about this. I was reminiscing the other day. Do you guys remember when Netflix sort of like first dropped? Streaming or just like DVD rental? I mean streaming. I mean streaming specifically. Because when I first booted up Netflix, that first year, I feel like you didn't have the same choice paralysis that you get now. Right. You were just like, there's a bunch. Like I can watch all of these movies. And they're just putting prestige television. It's beautiful to have all these choices. It's incredible. And now when I hear that little dintin, I'm like, here we go. It's a burden. Just me and my wife just scrolling through 100 different options being like, no. No. Moody in the toilet. No. And then we're like, fine. Great British big and show whatever who gets a shit. Who gets a fucking shit anymore. All right. Holiday Special folks. We've made it a bit of a tradition to do a movie review episode during the holiday season. Unfortunately, we're pretty low on Supreme Court themed movies. Thankfully, one popped up last year about a recent Supreme Court case that we've covered. So topical, so relevant. Germain. If you guys remember, there is a case, Kennedy V. Bramarton School District. This is the praying coach. There was a coach on a high school football team who started praying in the middle of the field. And then the school district was like, hey, I don't know if you can do that because separation has returned to state. And then he's shooting took it up to the Supreme Court and won. And they made a movie about it, folks. And by day, I mean, a bunch of Christian dipshits who don't understand how a film needs to be structured in order to be coherent. Or narrative or dialogue. Writing visual storytelling. None of it. They don't understand any of it. So the movie is called Average Joe. It came out last year, 2024, I think. We have to talk about the format first. It's done in the format of like a meta documentary where you have Joe, coach Joe and his wife. And they are narrating. Hey, folks, if you want to hear the rest of this episode, you're going to have to subscribe. This episode is one of our premium Patreon only episodes. Membership starts at just five bucks a month. If you want to hear the rest, join us at patreon.com slash five four pod. That's five four pod all spelled out. Members get a bunch of stuff. Not only do you get access to the premium episodes, but access to subscriber only events, discounts on merch. And at the $10 a month level, you get bigger discounts on merch and membership in the incredibly rowdy five to four slack. So again, that's patreon.com slash five four pod five four pod all spelled out. Become a member today.