Summary
李诞与哲学家刘擎在南极进行深入对话,探讨现象学、存在的本质、爱情的哲学意义,以及如何在现代生活中保持精神觉醒。两人讨论了海德格尔、胡塞尔、维特根斯坦等哲学家的思想,以及哲学如何帮助我们理解生存的真实意义。
Insights
- 现象学强调直接经验而非概念框架,通过保留第一现场的感受来理解世界的本质
- 意识的本质是虚无性——它是装东西的容器,通过意识结构我们才能将现象转化为经验
- 爱情不仅是交易关系,而是一种共生的时间存在,体现了无条件付出的人性本质
- 哲学的价值不在于提供答案,而在于启发我们的敏感性,让我们觉察日常生活中被遮蔽的东西
- 语言既构造了我们能认识的世界,又限制了我们超越语言的理解可能性
Trends
哲学思想在大众传播中的复兴——通过播客等新媒体形式普及深度思想内容对现代生存焦虑的哲学反思——人们在物质充足后开始追问存在的意义东西方哲学传统的融合对话——中国传统哲学(良知、名心见心)与西方现象学的比较深夜对话文化的兴起——非正式、自由的思想交流成为精神生活的重要形式体验式哲学学习——通过极端环境(南极)来深化对存在和自然的理解
Topics
现象学基础理论与应用海德格尔存在论思想胡塞尔意识现象学维特根斯坦语言哲学爱情的哲学本质主体性与自由意志语言与世界的关系现代生存的精神困境东西方哲学传统比较科学认识论的局限性身体经验与存在感受人文学者的学术生涯深夜思想对话的价值自然体验与哲学启蒙知识生产体制的反思
People
刘擎
哲学家,在南极与李诞进行深入对话,讲授现象学、海德格尔等西方哲学思想
李诞
播客主持人,在南极与刘擎讨论哲学问题,分享个人的存在体验和思想感悟
海德格尔
德国哲学家,其存在论思想是对话的核心,强调人的此在与存在的关系
胡塞尔
现象学创始人,其意识现象学理论被讨论为理解世界的科学方法
维特根斯坦
奥地利哲学家,其语言哲学思想被讨论,强调语言游戏与世界的关系
萨特
存在主义哲学家,其主体性思想被批评为过度强调个人自由
阿伦特
政治哲学家,其关于人的行动和复数性的思想被提及
何怀宏
哲学学者,2005年曾到访南极长城站进行学术考察
葛建雄
历史地理学者,2005年曾与何怀宏一起到访南极长城站
马克思
被提及为具有高远境界的思想家,相比海德格尔更理性地看待历史进程
柏林
20世纪政治哲学家,其自由主义思想被刘擎的研究领域涉及
罗尔斯
当代政治哲学家,其正义论思想被刘擎作为研究对象
哈贝马斯
德国哲学家,其交往理性思想被刘擎的研究领域涉及
康德
启蒙哲学家,其先验哲学被讨论为西方形而上学传统的重要代表
尼采
德国哲学家,其思想被提及为西方哲学传统的重要环节
Quotes
"现象学就是第一现场,就第一种出现的事情,你先把它留在那儿,你别急着给他用一个框架来描述"
刘擎•中段
"意识总是对某物的意识,他自己没有这个东西,但是你还是要保留那个意识"
刘擎•中段
"爱情他的界定性特征啊,他的那种共生性啊,一起创造,他是时间的存在"
刘擎•后段
"哲学一定不是给你什么答案和策略,是一种启发和一种敏感性"
刘擎•后段
"我们对水的理解,就是在这些形状里,杯子瓶子碗,我们只能通过这个来把握水"
刘擎•中段
Full Transcript
Today I have a special experience with Dan with a special experience in the car. It's like drinking a lot of water. I'm not drinking a lot of water. I feel like drinking a lot of water. I'm not drinking a lot of water. I love it. I love it. . . . . . . . . . comes from this This He's also uma of course He asked Ich zeh First getting to the O-P Wioi jaan unos 기 Anh Open Er Jaan Yans Yaan Puro Jaan Yans Es Yung Is Di In nature, you don't hear anything with lots of matches with the אזs. You see him shaking, you will question it is as strong as it goes, you feel like I'm soстран I'm a Petutацию, different culture and I think it's a very natural, like the南极 is the most of the natural, of course. It's like a natural, right? It's too natural. It's just... It's just a natural, we can't see. We've already become... We've been in the world. But it's the most of the natural, the most of the natural, the most of the natural, the most of the natural. And then it's the... It's the天气, what's the influence of the... It will... The natural現象 will just let you feel. We don't want to think about it. It's just a... 现象学意义上的存在感 我就今天想跟刘老师 当然我们也是闲谈 聊聊南极 就想请教一下现象学 我出发之前 直播的时候就跟大家说 我要跟刘青老师 在船上坐好多天 我一定要抓住刘青老师 谈一些最虚的问题 最务虚的问题 我说没有比南极 更适合聊什么是存在 什么是活着的意义 这些问题的地方 因为我们在船上来都来了 人家邀请来 刘老师也做了讲座分享 我做了两场 我只做了一场 我觉得我也挺混的 因为人家是让我做个什么分享 我也不知道分享啥 我说那就还是大家写信 我给大家写信 我今天下面听我觉得特别好 而且你就是你有一个把它延展出来的这些能力 然后讲到这些经历 特别真切 我觉得我讲的 I'm just a little trying to tell briefly I just put a background on fixed with another So we discussed several When we routed a那我們 The station really even We wanted to hear so And it was like a cut-off thing to fall it like that.çosland Yeah So kind. There is a great danger. Um I set a này And it's like a accident to be titled I'm feet because we're aall 穿越德雷克,终于到了南极圈 其实是一个深过来的半岛 其实我们没有去南极州的大陆家 大陆家有一天还是到了 但是太那个 太边缘的,太边缘的 南极行有的船呢就是开过来以后他们不能上岛 他就是船贴着岸边让你看 或者你可以做一些小冲锋舟沿着看 我们这个船有登陆资格 所以这个南极行的玩法就是船到一个岛旁边都是要提前申请报备对很严格而且每次上岛的人数人数时间因为要保护哎你就上去看看完回来每天就是这样上午一个下午一个要么就是今天就不登了就有的人去划皮划顶嗯还有跳水有的人往水里跳这就是南极型然后回去呢又要坐个一天多的一天半两天的船嗯这样颠簸然后再坐穿过德里克海峡这个形成是性价比非常差的 very expensive, but it's true that it's a good one. It's a good one. And I said this is a good one. I don't want to be able to pay for it. So I'm not paying for it. I'm not paying for it. We are invited to people. So I'm going to spend a bit. This is to let me pay for it. I'm going to pay for it. I really want to pay for it. I want to think about it. We are looking for a lot of people. So this is a long time. There are some people who are called a culture. Ç equilibrium for them about overlay, well you think that dimin���y form education is a cycle of doing this study through Congratulations, and here you see some of what is mainly hypundeep The post ministrine Until I heard the Navy The plane that tells us that the you. Two, three thousand years Which I remember not being a human There was an end but The mountain is a Cruise Add to once This Cuando所以我们没有进入南极州大陆驾的重身地带,没有那个船 milenika 呗那就材了要破冰没办法而且那个是保护的比较好的而且离南极州的南极点我问他们一些长城站的他们说他们都没有去过南极的那很难不太遥了最近的一个可考的站是美国的说在那儿降落他们飞机过去降落然后再到南极点还要开车两两三个小时所以南极点我没有去 Callas 郭城站也挺兴奋的,就是那个看到国旗在这么遥远的地方能看到国旗,真的很激动,你控制不住的觉得哇就那一刻就哇,就是我太离就是不敢想,虽然新闻上知道是,但你在一个简直是这个什么叫荒芜人烟,这是真的荒芜人烟的地方突然看到了五星红旗觉得,哎好,然后那是20年前那时候我知道我认识两个学者吗?何淮宏他是做哲学的还有那个葛建雄他是做历史地理的他们2005年就来了然后就在长城站住了一个月吧哇那时候我就好羡慕呀我但是我想好奇妙的体验然后终于到那个地上确实南极山有很多学者我我就不是就人文学者就现在他也都是科学科学家而且是那个跨学科有做地质的科学家 Are there pelo气候, are there cyplayerína? I asked them, the cage亲 are the whole outras 3 coming years then by the World Health and буду caring Maiden's work, the physical care in the清 obviamente These are so지news, they're all going has to get rid of it. And that's why our kids grow together a group of Simone They talk about liebe��다, they are so curious to hear the equipment That's about it. They always feel real, actually those科学家 You know that that is crazy, how are you차んで up here? Those point of thought?? which time date it an individual l 所以我就是我上去 我一下反映过来 我就本能的那个风太大 太 脸 脸痛 我就本能的开始倒着走 对 我看到就是我背着风走 我也适合呢 我一瞬间就 我说我上一次这样倒着走 还是我未成年的时候 这个感受就一下就脸 灿热 就一下就连接到一个小时候的那种心情 因为那种经常刮这样的风 你没法顶着风走 就是 倒着走 And then after that, I've seen ... Blacked, Thank you very much. I saw a thing to know when it was the工 gad. As Aqua, at the end moments I sent It's not a small thing. It's a small thing. It's a small thing. It's a small thing. It's a small thing. I was asked to ask my friend how to do this. I was very happy to send a picture to him. He said, wow, the world is really beautiful. I'm so small. I'm in the situation. I never thought about this. I'm not feeling like I'm not. Actually, um. It's beautiful. Your eyes are completely pulled away. You can't think I'm very small. He said, ah, it's very small. I'm just going to say, I'm just going to say, that's just a small thing. But it's just a small thing. Or, you can feel that we're very small. This is a self-impact. It's still a small thing. I can say that it's a現象-学. Actually, it's a現象-学. 因为但总就是一直说让我给他讲 现在我太好奇我根本不是任何意义上的 现在我觉得的专家因为你知道我本行是政治 社学嘛我像像我比较熟悉的研究的可能就是 像罗尔斯啊柏林啊阿伦特啊哈贝马斯啊 这些20世纪的那你追溯到可以到尼采啊什么 康德这些但现在学是另外一个传统但是 这个呢是特别迷人的所以我是一个票友 所以我今天要说错什么同行喷也没关系,大家觉得不对也没关系但是我放心吧没事,我觉得好我觉得哲学居然还能有争论都很珍贵哲学家其实我其实挺希望大家过来争论对,就是现象学是其实你去看那些书啊,解释现象学的书我那时候也曾经想,学的时候看不懂吗因为这个是我读书的时候并没有在我的系统里自己学的时候呢 I think you can find these. What you to discover, we usually think, it was a difficult notionvem what Erin, ok baby me, pal he found the following some kind of opposition the database Just to put, Something is Like the concept So Actually, General for 任何判断嘛,你就不要用概念,不要用,但是呢,他这里面有一个矛盾,你不要用任何概念,你如何来描述这个你感受到的东西,他讲现象,就是他认为现象这个事情他就是第一现场,就第一种出现的事情,你先把它留在那儿,你别急着给他用一个框架来描述,但是呢,他这里面有一个叫玄智嘛, We just know what we were stehen in the line. Number one, he said something like this exactly like we're open Christmas on the occasion. Where we are, he is not say goes on any salary Then he would make it Just to find out Just a bit like de he Sara Esquity But he has still said So he used here Embr dakika , he said it was apparent 包括记忆啊想象啊认知啊这个意识呢他是有意象性的那么他在这里想说的什么呢我们实际上没办法直接看到直接理解或者感知或者捕捉到那个现象的本体嗯那个客观我们总是通过意识的但是我们要研究什么意识是如何让现象成为我们的经验的嗯好了 there was no beとか a little bit now with old deposition one of students of course is just one and then what part you do this world? I'm going to be able to overcome this kind of self-reported. I'm going to admit that I'm not going to use some kind of ideas. But I'm going to use the most low-reported idea to look at what we're going to do. What's going to do to our mind-setting system? We're not going to have a mind-setting system. So you can see it long ago. I think it's like it's like water. This is my example. If I'm not sure if I'm not sure. I'm just going to say it. 这个东西呢 我们只能在它的形状里 这个形状呢 要么放在一个瓶子里 要么放在一个杯子里 要么放在一个碗里 哪怕是海里 要么放在比如说一个草地里 我们浇水了 我们要明白 我们对水的理解 就是在 这些形状里 杯子瓶子碗 草地草地可能就是有点乱的 浇水嘛 我们只能通过这个来把握水 uh, we will understand how those2020 Merry-ructive Okay let's say ... shand'm alright I need to understand how you know how's the state of John controle So we have a process and situation and situation. And we can clean it out. And then we can know what is the water. Or we can know what we do the world's experience. This thing is very exciting. There is a time Mr.嘉英 in the interview in the 13 year old. He said that he said that he was a question of the world. He said that he was a question of the world. I think that he was a question of the world. It's not that big. But maybe he is a question of the world. He will have different ideas. I think it may be so bad. Because it has two problems. One is that it is a kind of of the tradition. It is said that we cannot see it. We are always looking at it. This is actually a tradition. He will say that we can can be able to take the idea of the idea of the condition. We can see the world's world. We just know what we know. So we have to know we are trying to understand the background and is 都是要克服足柯体二元论的这 Unaいう东西但是海德格尔就说 你弄了半天 你把意识简化成 那么意识 他就说 最后就是异象性了 意识总是对某物的意识 他自己没有这个东西 颇这个东西 但是你还是要保留那个意识 所以我觉得 呃胡塞尔是意识到这个问题 就是西方 一大堆形而上学的什么概念啊 形而上学内一些假设呢 你会把自己搞糊涂 就是你没有科学的ic anal胡塞尔是一个极其科学的人,他无论是说科学就自然科学道德和艺术都是经由我们的意识这样这样塑形的,他就说要把意识塑形这个现象的这个过程给理清楚然后我们就会可以抛出很多我们现在迷失的被遮蔽的这些东西但是你还是在用这个意识结构吧所以你还是有一个主体在那这是海德格尔不满意他的地方 So I think the appeal is still to be rocks under the White Horn. It was in signs that they published in 1927. It was his photo to Hitler for the White Horn, then he used to pris partysłoning. Because he was much deeper than he was forced. The thing he browsed is that he 00 nuisance himself, and said to him he is even a universityial. The problem is that there are these different language in the world. Thetill that it's thisike. I'm still, it's still there, this was an agreement itself was about. I don't know what else is something that early body is. Maybe Minister himself said it was something important I do not work Like we used at least talk with their understander discourse. He had to talk about figuring out. Like this sort of mind. Put up to the labels in the headlines. Therefore, he has been talking about ei-computer because he doesn't know any ähnism. But what's it called when Jenny Laniehead đây was the emotion the future. To the end of Roger Gross of Alexander like I was trying to dov Song of the experience. 一个现象怎么在我们的经验中意识经验中呈现成什么样子 但是这个我呢是已然在存在中的 你看这话听起来很玄啊 他的意思是说海底盖尔的关怀就是说存在这件事情太大了 我没法定义他他存在的事情开篇就说嘛 用了柏拉图一句话你仔细问我 因为他不能用存在是一个巨大的东西而且它不是一个东西,它是一个进程,和时间在一起的进程,beeing,是beeing,big being,但是呢,这东西你不能用暑假种差的方法来定理,所以呢,他说那有一个方法就是我们这个是人是可以beeing,就是此在是可以意识到存在的,这是人特别厉害的地方万事万物他们都存在著嗯他們都在他們的空間時間中展開著自己的進程但他們沒有這種自覺意識嗯而人是有的人是可以意識到自己的存在嗯通過意識到自己的存在就是生命的存在可以意識到他用的是理解或者我覺得現在是感悟可能更好那個德文詞感悟到這個存在存在是存在的 We are using our own life to our own life. We know that all things are存在. So we are not a body of existence And we are not a body of existence We are not aware of it We are already in this existence 而存在呢 大的存在吧 就是我們講的萬事萬物之所以如此這般的存在 或者如此這般的事 它也是事嘛 它是我們的存在本身就是這個大的存在顯現的一個方式 is the image as us, just This place is you see There is no portrait at most normal and still in there for And Ad の all, let's deny in our armor and outlet and make our DNA , oum, 72 years There is now a new item , it seems like a 무랜 jam using our mother to experience inside as an image of , the distinguished was Central Derkame Bocker yazans and concept coming up , it actually doesn't matter We don't give up toara So, Huichar told me why it was a pretty good thing To use the oil force to store water He has a cooking change This Yoar is soful Okay, so I was looking at this The launch of the proof Thank you for declining The sound that we look like It's not without this Like it only is here I can feel the That means This Well I have two Hertz. That 18 years, in the form ofimi, I expected it to read the download. It's over six times. I've Hai've Гä Boghainev saying 70 years, has said. I didn't study Guy so you could learn so. And then everyone would see. I was back to another username when I went to come into a movies in the US. Several years ago they have implemented it. That's the name of Gene Jun, is also in the English period. Duke H variance sitting in orchestra in Central Central, I just made my shower and left my dinner with my lunchHHHH that morning, that is what... Mmm, like a teacher L A- like a game called 불heir Falling with people understand the했다 Elizabeth purely but he right 一个他就说他是这个佛教起点就是现象学 起点就别你们走了很多弯路我们我们起点就是现象学 海德格尔他只是解释了我们的处境我们是如何存在的我听到目前 那他怎么解释认识世界呢他的认识观上他有什么说法吗 认识世界他其实并不是反对科学啊什么 但他说你要明白这个科学是在我们存在之内的一种方式一种方式就是我们为了不得已我们做一些假设主体 课题 逻辑这些都没有问题但是到最后由于它本来是我们一种认识世界的方式或者工具之一我们再点点但这个东西太膨胀了它就变成了一个座驾我们生活在这个座驾里有一点我们只能比喻我们跟世界关系其实是难极一种方式但是我们大部分人 is living in the room and then we will put the room I understand the way this way to look at the world its own we have some we have some we have some tools we have some tools we have these things we have to be And it's the most important thing. We're at the equipment level of thinking about this. It's a big thing. It's a whole thing. It's a whole life in our lives. It's a big thing. It's a big thing. We think that the high-level building is a big thing. This is too old. This is too old. This is the old building. But it's not the end of the building. It's not the end of the building. Right. but That highlighted when we're Fraser today It seems It's like that Blue But there the point is anyway It still gives chinese It is calorie Using things like my research And some mistakes Because I started Love I had a講 stuff I say season Li cracking so this is good here photograph bitch to do oh London is financial Oh Multi biscuit お墨 slows our decision for a bookeurysmum Girl loud ororphskWorld Young Beautiful Andminded soccer Don't you know It's a kum A Mini The Man Um It's you You know Can存在联系在一起存在在这里才没有被遮蔽才没有被遗忘你主要是看那个湖的样子品牌的时候真这么想他真是个很幸福的人我不知道他生活状态是什么我没读过这个他的生活状态很焦虑因为他认为这个世界是错了对呀所以他没有真这么想所以有的时候他说应该如此我们不如此他也没有这样他还是在分析 I don't like to talk to my friends. I don't know if this is a friend. Or I have to do some worship worship. Or I love to drink. I just said this. It's too 통. There are people who worship this. Just worship this. Just worship this. This is too 통. But it's not a philosophy. Because in. In the way of doing this, I'm going to be able to do this. I'm going to be able to take this joy and knowledge of this feeling of joy. It's because of the joy. I'm not going to make the world become this way. I'm not going to make the world not to be able to make the world. I'm not going to be able to make the world a little bit. But I'm going to feel this way. I like music. TheVA was one person you can do from the web. I get a lot from the expose. I could take a quick effect in an answer. Beautiful weather... a little more into... not that secret, is still there about the medieval general 2019 were not after the look for the flower you said the i and the i now 但是我知道他很 但是多纠结啊里面啊 那个我就很关心他自己 我这种关心是真的关心啊 我不是质疑 我不是说哎你怎么到底都想通过 你过不好你自己的日子呢 我是很关心 因为我知道很多人能过好 比如休默 就是我最喜欢的就是休默这种 哦海特克尔他是这样 哎呦那他其实很容易过上幸福的时候 但他他有雄心 他因为西方的这样一个 整个的这样一个历史就是走向奇迹 天哪 然后他啊希特勒那时候来他觉得可能会有点希望就改变这一切 之后 靠他政治上是个幼稚鬼 对 就是就是后来人家说其他他后来就知道 希特勒是靠不住他要借力他哲学家自己能改变什么 他想借一场运动 那你看我亲爱的祖师爷马克思韦伯境界就比他高了 Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah I would I would I think it's a little bit more than I can feel. I can feel it. I think I got it. I just from there once in the Congo, I don't know. It's a very good thing. I don't know what it is. I just have a day in the street. I just look at the wind. I feel like I was walking in my heart. I just like it. It's like I'm so... We're such a... It's a... There's a lot of things. You find you just... You're always a normal... You're always a normal... Right? I don't think it's a sea... Or... I think that's just me. I just... I just... I'm with the earth in a place. This situation will always be forgotten. Yes, I'm wrong. I'm going to think that the money is going to be in the future. I'm going to think that the school will be invited to me. It's a book. It's a book. It's a book. I'm not sure I'm going to say I'm not going to get your own. It's not a good thing. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. En NYBC, I don't know if they truly see this. Your supports are traditional. I'm not saying that the only practice does this is It's just like historians would be understanding. I mean that one way of light is u-needing two slice or two symbols. All the other Edwards saw this one 屎尿什么里面都看到大道 这种人也极少 存在什么精致的利己主义什么这种人也极少 大多人在这个之间只不过程度不一样或者比例不一样 摇摆 对吧摇摆 而且会忘了 我觉得我这种程度 我已经很幸福了 我今天看到了我拍不能自如 他是就像那个大海他 我被他捕捉到 就如果说是个这个大的存在的话 我常常是这个大的逼印把我给 So you have to close the wall, you have to close the wall, no one in the wall. I'm always going to close the wall. I've always been able to close the wall. I've always felt very happy. I'm talking about the devil's heart. Just this one. You have to be able to get the world. Actually, it's a different way. In the most recent years, the world is different. But the way the way it is, it's a very strong. It's a tradition. It's a tradition. It's a tradition. But I think the way the way the way it is, is this thing. look at it he movie so he said the сол Allison I think he found that I don't know And then Heidegger actually there is a whole body of the body It's not that we have body and body But the rest of the body is very clear to me That body is a主動 thing In our experience of the world, the body is very important It's not a big thing It's not like the one who said I have a... I was in my body The body is a big thing Like a thing he said the body was Check the body I was walking in the air, I was walking in the air, I was walking in the air, or the wind, the wind was going to go to my face. I saw the fish in the tail and the small sea of the sea. I thought there was a human in this wild, extreme, extreme, in this area. There was a fish in the tail of the tail. It was a very残忍 of体悟. It was a little bit of a苦涩. But I also felt that I was the same with the fish in the air. I think that's the鲸鱼. We are such a living. We have a little bit of experience. I think it's the most real, the most real level. I can feel this kind of thing. I think that we actually have this kind of sense. But the philosophy is a双重. You think this is a lot. You think that's not what you think. 这种感受,一天到晚再分析,对不对? 但是好的时候呢,不用说,哲学一定不是给你什么答案和策略,是一种启发和一种敏感性。 就这时候你就要开放自己,不要在自己的生活的那个轨道里边,我们每天打工上班,赚钱,买房子贷款,然后怎么样过好的生活,这个当然是肯定要的,但是这不是全部。 and you can create your own new newnormal something now the� scraping the I would You just see You just see I really like the translation I like the teacher I'm a teacher He was a teacher He was a teacher He said I was in the translation It's a problem He said I was I was I was It's like abrakampfi of people in this whole An My My 抽履化了 因为意识没有实质内容 这是胡塞尔的名言 意识总是对某物的他有异象性 那意识本是什么 意识就是虚无啊 他是装东西的 所以他是存在就是虚无 然后他后来一弄到最后他就变成 特别羔羊的那个主体性 主体性这件事情 其实蛮害人的 就到最后现在就是我的主体性 你说最后是萨特吗 萨特呀 就是 这种哲学家我是很怕的 萨特的影响很大 但是海德格为什么他 人道主义关于人道主义通信里面 He is to be with Sartre, He is to be a very high-end person. I'm afraid he is too bad. He is to put a big existence in the world. Yes, it is to be a big existence. We are the existence of the existence of the existence. And this is the existence of the existence. We are敏感 to We are to be with a big existence. This is a human being. But because of this human being, You can be a wise. You know, We are in the world of existence. 再世行他讲的那种再世行 阿伦特就后来是就继承了这个阿伦特是卡德高尘里再世行的这个这个概念是特别强 我没读他那个我就读他那个最小的那本书 谈谈方法 谈谈方法 他的那个国际推导过程中 它是倒过来的 他不是说先宣扬我和死 他其实是什么口号 什么不考号 什么不考号 到最后比较这一点 That's a lot of trouble. The second thing is, How do you know you have a body? And then he used the way to say, God is not going to be骗ed. But the devil is not the devil. So there is another one. There was a girl, a teacher, a teacher, a teacher, She asked her, She said, He said, He said, He said, He said, He said, He said, He said, He said, He said, Right? This is completely impossible How can we share the body? How can we walk in our body? This is how many people work. I say that Barlow Anne Yei is the most indeed able to do research He was such a doctor But she used the idea I忘チF even it was only a helpful But, today has more scary This is warnings Let me spend a lot about that Lastly wipe It's not Is there any idea Which We know we're all fully official experience, the tranquil泳 schwוגEt And we're going to Hold organism During the77s, the natural VERPA's so these are veryica to form it all was in order to get to not all In the case of the pandemic, we had a few people out there. And then, Mr Higin used to use different kinds of ideas for him to respond to him And he used to say Mr Higin said said he said he said because he in the movie he still a good guy Yeah, he said, he said, he said, that's a bad guy. Why is he like that? Because he said, he said, he said, he said, he said, he said, You can't do it? You can't do it? You can't do it. We have a lot of food. He can't do it. You have a lot of food. He can't do it. They become a science. It's a science. It's a science. He's a science. He's a science. I don't know. I was 80% to 85% That's too scary. So, I'm in this tradition. I think we're old. It's not a human. It's not a human. It's not a human. It's not a human. It's not a human. I think there's a real thing. And you don't want to be a human. I don't have a human. I don't have a human. I don't have a human. You think people have a sense of knowledge, it's just a self-picture. We're honest, we're just that the old generation of the world, the whole process of the process. After all, it's a lot of複雜. It's not a self-picture. It's not a self-picture. It's not a self-picture. I agree with that. I don't believe that I'm not a self-picture. You don't feel your life. You're living in your life.包括自由意志这件事谈哪可以谈很久车达的你躲不躲吗就是我经常问大家,就这一个问题你不要跟我说什么自由意志,还有什么大脑的什么这那的,就车达的你躲不躲他就方便,我不追究这个本体啊因为我们共享的理念就是社会事实社会事实它的客观性是什么意思就是我讲客是这样,集体主观就是客观就是比如我们大家都信宗教吧,你一个人不信没用 So this is was for us to Christ. It turns out the hypothesis on the command. If you have committed it... It's more political, then just sekissimo and all then we got you this pension... I'm not paid the else, are they cabeça was are can you just by vite I think I my mind angle don't heading I have nothing face I knew tomorrow feeling accepting it so 英国也没有对他可以在这个凶残的程度上自由一人英国就他是是是这种层面上的本质嗯但日子过得很对 我觉得这就但是你想他就你说啊什么就经常人家引用的叫理性只不过是激情的奴隶对但这句话你是不可能靠激情发现的嗯你实在是理性发现的嗯对 大概就是这样一个状况所以我们今天也不是在讲现象学的课啊就是 理你这个东西我就觉得为什么我会谈爱情这件事情让我们可以用这种方式来把叠加在爱情上的一大堆乱七八糟东西给他甩掉一点嗯然后我也不是要一个存而又存的存爱我说那个爱他的界定性特征啊他的那种共生性啊啊一起创造他是时间的存在啊这东西我们明白了然后他放在生活里我们油盐降醋啊 大家有需求啊相互要尊重啊满足对方啊然后大家怎么过日子啊照样但是那个爱情他不能说他就是全是这些交易全是对 那么你说朋友之间大家也有需求吧也也把你就是作为人脉啊或者说哎呀谁帮我一个忙这是非常通情达理但是有没有情意在呢有的时候还是有有有情意在的 It's a good thing. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. Um, that's what we do. We have to go to a good thing. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. But we're going to go to the end of the day. We're going to be in a good thing. It's like this big thing. It's like a huge thing. There are some shocks. There are some shocks. Or there are some悲悯. I don't know if it's a bad thing. You can't say that. We can do it with the world And of course, it brings us to oroid It believes we have no similar It belongs to be a opposite This thing is called humanity And...esen mentioned Humanity is focused in being humans And we now let Don't look at the energy for everyone's body Yeah, it's a very good at end Hey, hey I used to comment on tomorrow's review That's A 이야기'słos parically These four words There are still an issue 大家还挺好玩的 其实你把它理解为用爱情这个角度切入进去 讨论了我们现代人的生存处境也蛮好 这门客在这个程度上 你如果好奇我们在过一种什么样的现代生活 你听这个因为人人都经历过 向往过爱情 你从这里好切入 这第一第二有很多你想不明白的关于爱情的事情 可能很容易想明白就是这个可以和小红书那个小麦铺的来信答疑要结合在一起就好了哎这是相通的对他有的把他浪漫化神秘化把他举的太高了因为有的时候又把他哎呦弄成了一个没有没有这世界上没有爱情哎大家就是利益交换就很烦躁就是所以我今天说那个他们问我 I said my life's worth. It was the Excellent To not be loved at times It was a very beautiful 昨天就跟討論說你不是我們說過就說有的時候我不說人所有的事在愛情裡面就是你的快樂比我自己得到快樂還要快樂嗯最後評審我都快了總會感到的吧對我們不是實實這樣總會的大家說寵物我說這個養寵物至少有一個好你能理解什麼就要不條件的那是真的是存付出 但是做过父母的人也知道就有的时候你饿了就是孩子吃上一口饭 那我们现在一般很少进入这种局面对不对 都会什么都准备好了 我小时候就是会有这种情况 就是那口饭 一块肉最后是给孩子吃 自己 大人给孩子吃了大人自己是快乐的 他是饥饿的仍然是快乐 这其实很常见这就是现象学的嘛 你不要去想那么多什么的你付出我得到你直接的 抛弃这些乱七八个东西 直接第一反应是什么 那这确实 这用我们这个中国的哲学 印度哲学 名心见心啊 杨思明会讲良知啊这种东西 良知 对 知良知 感受就是当下确实很准确啊 就是这种感觉 那可能我有一个理论 或者我经常会读现实 我也跟大家说 I learned that while I'm buying Michael Plann which was possible when weουari Word is changed only part of that which is just being narrowed Yeah. But the idea is to have a hindsight you can't know and it's、 okay. So, that's what is thinking, he cried That is some При formation The people exist It's like thinking It's a supposed element The understanding behind What we need is we need this The fighters I He said that pseudo-gluid He said that according to the theory of the history of the people of the world, there are some people who say some words, just like that, just like that? Lewis is a very strong religious, he is a very strong religious, he is a very strong religious, so he thinks that he has a real power and reason for the reason. There are some people we don't see themselves. I'm a young generation of old times and new generation. I can't understand the old spirit. I can understand the Lewis. I think that he is a big one. The big one is in the first place. I don't know what he is. He is a big one. I don't know what he is. I think he is in the first place. So, this is the case of this is and the case of this is or the case of this is and there are some things that are I think it's good to know through this question you can understand this that's the word that's commitment that's the word you say commitment to suicide you can't say it it's a very difficult word but you can open it but you can open it and you can say it's a it's a it's a it's a it's a There is a desire to be. That's when the promise is a little bit. Commitment. Commitment. The promise is a very豐富. Um. Yes. Every time there is a strong feeling, I feel like this is B. I have to understand a little bit Kant or Bato said that. It is like that in the back. It is in the end of the day. We can't see it. But the image is how to describe it. He sounds 책 quesarjuk Beside indicator Every corruption So Pleasing The laid no松 Faikki Peace Jaw There is a real world of a real world. He is a real world of a real world. He was in a court, he said he was going to be a交通案. And then he said he said this is a real word. Actually, the law of the judge is not so simple. He actually has some of his own. He later just thought the word word is a real thing. It's a real thing. We play a game. It's not a real game. Who gave a example? He said 一個籃球比足球大對吧 這個是一個比較極的一個矽子 但你昨天喝的酒比前天的 還要沖 嗯這也是個比較 還有一個矽子是 我這次失戀 比以往任何一次都痛 痛不欲生了 三個都是比較極的 其實是三種不同的語言 嗯 第一個就是說像指設的一種一樣 籃球足球它確實 它就客觀的你可以量一下 你喝了酒呢 是有主觀的 But if you have a drink, you can't get it. But you feel it's not a drink. It's actually your heart. So you're just happy. You're just happy. You're just happy. But, it's not a thing that you can't get. You can feel it. It's just a thing. It's not a football game. You can't get it. It's not a football game. It's a lot of different things. It's a good thing. We have a lot of people here who use falseOLD to evitar the game, not only our hope not to be in the absolute If it is not that the game itself is Semance obviously We have to develop itself And We have no one one two one It's The key one foreign so he has a lot fantastic very kind of for a ninja He said he said I am a for a He said Like you say. Like I said, I'm going to be able to get to it. I'm not going to be able to get to it. That's the name of them. But he said, you can't see it. It's not the same. It's not the same. I think it's the same. Yes. So I think we talk about some things. Of course, it's a趣味. Like you're in the show. You're in the show. There are times you'll feel. We're in the life. Actually, it's very沉默. There's a趣味. I'm going to get it. It's a good one. But it can be better. I just want the contour to be a bit younger than me. Like certains of us who are the kind of people there are like lawyers. Trust how you deal with.. I was thinking yo m Oh haha he's also a kind Add it ok it feels busy ok love how about you love the people you with the world deep in the world and you have these things hard and hard and good and good and good I said that I'm not sure you have all you have all you are the world you are the world you are the world you are the world you have to be no you have to be in this world no you have to be that's a shame right actually I often I was at the beginning of the year old, I was always saying that I was a different opinion. You say to the南极, but this is a fun. This kind of a lot of things are difficult, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard, it's hard. It's hard to get to it. It's hard to get to it. It's hard to get to it. It's hard to get to it. I have to listen to a bit Krist hay. For me, I want to pay attention. He drew the perdut. I never felt like I knew that. I've never thought I knew. If I fall down my self- cannons, I don't know. But I don't have to believe that,to study a lot... Well, I .. Which is Prop Virginia, 寫的太好. I think that's a lot of So I'm going to say my understanding I'm going to give you a little bit I'm going to understand the right I don't know what I'm going to understand I think the first thing he is a He is a question of the question He is why he is so much to ask this He is still standing in a He is still in a He is trying to make this thing It's not clear He is not like it's clear I think he is He is trying to make it clean He is still in a It's on the top of the top of the top of the top of the top of the top. It's like a lot of people who are in this level. I wrote it in the first place. But the first one I was looking for. The first one I was looking for. The last one I was reading. The first one I was reading. I don't understand it. I don't understand it. It's the traditional thing. He was able to play this game He was able to play this game He was able to say We're able to say this level We can say it We can say it This is the word system We're able to say it He was able to say it He still didn't That's the real That's the real thing You can say There are many many questions He is a cuidad He can send if there are no Scheidnov or to harvest It is crucial to even investigate the x-ч He went dude Da Jackson With all questions But Wieders-Kern's志向他是想在逻辑数学和世界建模建个模以后他就是说我们能够在语言逻辑和数学这些特别清楚的一致的无矛盾的来把握世界然后世界可能会有这样一个模型但是世界会有他的粗糙的是真的部分他的核心是是对的是真的 It's a search for確定. It's a search for確定. But he has been reading the literature on some of the research. He is not a a research scientist. If he is, he will not be able to get this. This is the question is, who is? I'm a teacher, he told me, he said, you don't have to read it. Don't read too much. are you already deben the third dose of this post, you decide, it would be enough to write, and you will how to write suffered, and you go to watch, look like a media. is more intense, you think people are too bad, no longer right, but there are some jeguks where I know I can imagine They've always 그때. I'm almost likeio, the ideas of words here's this obvious. The ideas we are saying is toheure it's like we were officially in the upperàn workload You want to write one topic, You can see all the information, and see all the information. And then you can see it. Oh, I don't know. You can't see it. You're already in the car. It's just one of the three-thirds. Think about it. To this point, Wittenstein is really not a good thing. He didn't know how to read it. When he first met him, he didn't know this guy was a fool. He gave him a sign. He came to a guy. He came to a guy. Yeah, yeah. After a week, he said he was a good thing. Then the hearings were made in the it been this results for Protestants with someleans have no idea It is about to talk to thearch The arc problem is it is 这个不用说了,跟那个海德格尔是一样的,对不对? 是语言的存在,语言其实它不是一个发出声音嘛, 它是制定这个世界是什么,为什么,怎么了,应该怎么的, 一到头,所有的语言都是有规则,有隐含的行动,隐含的指涉的命令, 什么在里面,它现在分析的特别细,但是它的那个贡献呢, 在于他好像推翻一个妄想 就是这个妄想说我们能够 以非常绝对和高超的 高于以语言局限的方法来认识直接 你就在语言里内部的 而对于语言外部的事情呢 我们是没办法言说 没办法知道 他也不是否认非语言经验的可能性 that he did not understand the person今天的 view But heойden Oh my can you see the action that did not learn is noб no What 5 well I was able to create a personal name to define my own because I don't know what I'm going to do I know what I'm going to do and then he did some research for example he said I'm in a journal I wrote a I'm going to write a feeling I'm going to write a word for a word and then every time I'm going to write I'm going to write and then I'm going to write and then he said he said he said ber responses, you just see where you, but it's not easy to open, jazz its not able to ties in its government a lot.she was not going to describe it in a indo tanto system Yeah she said that she only a little vrij is what this lease has been strange an e it's called Gehrs ơi! Oh my! Is it This end of Ógal It didn't repeat. because kind of for people to empower what kind ofbtsun it came to a horrible thing Look, this is asяжêu thispackao is how to use 用甲虫来指代了疼 但疼痛是不能这样指代的 所以他 威登先生自己在这里造成了一个 理解的麻烦 这个三言两语肯定是讲不清楚 大家去看 嘉胤可能写过对威登先生他阐释的那种书 他是我觉得国内写的最好的 也有课也有书是 那他最后给我们的这个遗产是什么呢 遗产就是以往做哲学的方式不能说误入歧途了就是有的时候你会发现它是徒劳的做那些事情你越界了但是是在做一个利所不及的事情你没有这么大的功力能够穿透语言的这些能够达到那个境界所以我们能够认识的世界就是就是我们语言所构造的世界但是呢语言可以其实是慢慢慢慢演化了 也游戏也是各种各样的 是多样的 嗯 威德克斯坦我应该再去看看 他回答了好多问题 比如说 像他心问题啊 这种东西 就是别人的心能 他其实有的时候是 说告诉你这样想是不对的 对 而且他有的时候他 他上课是这样 站在想半天 然后会会说 我怎么我怎么这么傻 连这个都搞错了 我觉得他最大的启示是 he提了一些问题和一些说法你看他哲学研究是一句句一段一段让我们把一些自己完全不自觉的不敏感的习以为常的东西挑出来了极其精彩的方式极其锐利的方式挑出来了我这样想原来是一个自己理所当然的以为这个就是这样的不是其实这里边要谈的话应该找到很多理想我好张言被读为这个词带了 Take out Trenjan 1 to 4 times s. I'm very very curious this guy . He has been showed pretty well But he is mm bad He is a he is not so clean If estabas It's evil He is that Trying to make imagine그inars that it 유�кив agency And TMF I just was just a back then. You just want to read two. Play some odors 又花了很多年去读他越读越糊涂我就到了这个传记那本传记哎稍微感觉我又那个传记是很好的入口我觉得我理解了他的一点因为他是思想传记 对他思想传记是一种文体他不光是做了什么什么情感他是给你的思想发展弄在一起 我理解他一点年以后 就没有那个野心了就是不是很想把他就是每年都想把他弄懂后来就没有那个野心了我觉得 I think the Wittgenstein is the most important thing. It is a false statement and a false statement. It tells you what is wrong. What is wrong? What is wrong? But what is wrong? We don't know what we've noticed. I don't know if it's not true. I don't know if it's not true. I don't know if it's true. I don't know if it's true. 太强烈 但我会会实时想到这个 但是玻璃罩子是会透清光的 对 我就老想到就是他是一个玻璃罩子 而且我觉得他是实话 就是他最后他说他过了去告诉他们过个幸福的一生 他可能就正在这种体感里他感受到 他的好多磋商跟同性恋那个也是有点关系 是 然后还有一个他不被理解 其实读威登斯坦最有意思的就是 He was up like him and the computers. Like the guy from been up for the man 환ers that I wanna talk to you This is a lot in an authentic way. Before she spoke of everything. That's what I想. Like feminists were gonna talk the history of the stammering cách And he was a very fabulous student. That person was always قbros He will come up like it's this way. You can even explain a bit more with this versión in his darauf Um, I shouldn't have been mine if it's been my own aussi to go out and say a good stuff. So much a really good thing But you said, you say, what are you doing? It is for you? You were speaking what is your surpassing? Maybe it is you, yes? Be sure to haveローブAL anti kör read But you live itself like that person and young·l twoAs Just like the wonder Was relevant to him or was it even after the idea to walk? You understand, it is too tense with some love. I heard this. My fatherился, he said to me I talked about the truth. He said it's our dare to talk to himself too, which is slightly to be done. He was also talking to Philip St. I was talking to you abouticos dependent on the music, he wrote that in David Stoudakule. I said he atleсп�. He said it came up to you. He used to understand the music. I was like, I said, why do you like it? I said, why do you like it? The reason is what he is. He suddenly got a little bit of a laugh. He said, actually, he said, I'm the only one of the real天赋 is I'm the only one of the best. I'm the only one of the best. It's a very self-doubt. But it's like a lot of people like that. It's like a lot of people like that. He's very funny. So I wondered telling them, that these folks were in their meetings. That's very honourable. Let me see an invisible character.HHHH, And they go over here. Not only me. Trans there. My teaching that's a lot of things that are very good at the end of the day. He became the teacher of the school. That really really震撼 me. I said I can't think of this problem. I said I don't know. I said this man can't think of it. He is a lot of things. What kind of world? He is a... It's not like a standard. But this is a way of thinking. I like it. Yeahut I was important topan The first thing might happen from the table When I was a kid Mr.osas These are consciousness and the work so I clocked in a 1.4 Doing that. Questo eschere how the belonged, he just应该 I would argue. Among I, a douche, what was dasci, or a few. The thing that I didn't know is a good thing at the grocery store. I think that's only doesn't get money to go there. That's your job. Isn't that Balmantr Winfrey? Price is pretty good. He's aspire for lessons and learning is a very real 있었. I love you together. . . . . . .学术体制,它是一个知识生产机制,大家要讲,知识生产,它有标准流水线的,你博士毕业一定要面对这个圈子里内部提出的问题,解决了熬到我们这种快退休,佳印已经退休了这种,但佳印是不一样,他们50年代出生的人,他是那种在文革时期就可以接触到一些书,虽然那时候不是很多,他们一开始关心的就是时代整个精神生活, It's not from the school. Now the children from the school of school. This is very different. This is not just... It's a very important thing. It's a very important thing. Now the children are good. They are good at the same time. But if you don't do the school of school, you are too散. It's a very important thing. But you are just a bit of a shame. It's a good thing to do with the world. Yeah, yeah, yeah. If you're interested in this, I'm interested in the book. I'm sure you're interested in the book. You're interested in the book. It's very hard to read. It's a good book. It's a good book. It's a good book. I recommend it to read it. It's like I'm so big. He wrote a book called The travel book. It's a good brain. ... ... ... ... ... They have a small house. There are various places. There are some of them. There are some of them. So they are in the middle of the university. They already have a kind of spiritual life. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. It's a good thing. I have to watch it.尤其是这种车船上我就不是一次读完你就是拿出来看一篇得低很好玩所以我们弹总也是有很好的精神生活了那我的精神生活已经太好了然后在直播间里给大家给点乙路滋养也是普惠大众太好了我的荣幸陪伴大家真的太好了因为我的那个播客叫夜思我是失眠者也不是失眠者 You are asleep. You are also asleep. Yes, three, four. You said you were in the morning. I remember when you woke up, you were in the morning. You were not sleeping. So you think the morning and the day are what difference? Just a little. Just a little. Yes. Yes. You said the whole thing. I don't think I was in the morning. I was in the morning. So I was able to get to the old people of the King of Jesus. He has a lot of奇思. You know, I think it's a very long time. I think it's a kind of a mental trust. My life of my life in many different things I've had a lot of time. I've had a lot of time. I've had a lot of time. I think I'm going to get it. I'm going to get it. You're going to get it. You're going to get it. You're going to get it. Then you come a mentorship that you wrote poetry, Write a paperuffs. You are like, wow. ... You can count it ... But you must be a simultaneous記 retention Including for a novel written genomes... ... ... ... ... ... ... There's a book for a woman, Muhammad, and he will mang характер him. He大的 gifts, he'll have time to pay tribute.腰 mism DSAD 유. What about did thisariki shit? The five key DCs to Digit Leia He'sorek bike. He'sholar being part of WNU excuse me, body'll be good. He's trained well when he's acting hot. I'm not, I'm all. This is the semi-expression character. I was always singing to D Finanian in free in Mark. they said I think that's the end. they said it is and stuff. They're not for the case. Oh, they are weak, I was not that I would answer, I know of which I think of what our employees were . He's always of his executive former Giovanni海 There are times is a good idea, there are times are the most important ideas. So I think this is a dream of thinking of the故乡. It's a family. You can trust it. You can trust it. You can trust it. And at the same time, it's a real life. It's a real life. It's a real life. It's a real life. It's not a lonely situation. I was able to enjoy it. I could always expect that I immensely elementary school. I am at older 15 able to get me. me as much as possible. I'm able to get up to 90, 17 open and 15 albo months center. I have some empathy too. If you speak and go .. I don't eat well through 30... I like the party也是发生在深夜就我这播客上一期我跟我那个画家小哥们我们就是讨论马列维奇到天亮天光大马列维奇是画家我肯定看过就一个白色的纸上画一个黑色的方块就是他先干的就这件事是他先干的立体主义还是什么他叫现代主义或者就也不知道他那些主义太怪了就各种各样的他给自己起名 起名叫 我忘了他们的流派前面还有个叫智商主义 这开始就很诡异了 你就有点听不懂 二十一周月就好 一大都那些东西吧 反正就是这种 这种东西 一听就知道是什么东西吧 特别思想性的 画作 其实已经不是画作 主要是一种思想性观念 观念 观念人 对 我就征问这个何多伟后 他认为他是画的很好的 他画的非常好 而且他人是一个非常的那种生活的人 He can live with the He is a very good person He said he's the most liked the artist Wow this is so weird I said this is a lot I said this is a lot This is a lot of people Because he is a real person He is a very honest He is a very honest I think that's the most important thing I think that's the body You can write what you want You can write what you want so we couldn't argue. And, he at the time was an대 cohen When it wasn't in the evening, well, it's not easy. It's possible to deal with this point. Very happy My happy Cont rituals made before I was huge But I think you know,青cat January ここ is so much familiar to talk toconnect About永 kill It's just because of the conversation. You would think you drink it after two personalities? No, I'm just going to be more broad. I drink it after, I'm going to be too much. I don't drink it after I'm going to be too much. I'll say it will be a good time for a while, a good time for a while. But I drink it after I'm going to say just like that. 什么什么就是什么什么就会说没有逻辑的断言 但那个是很小说的 这你有一个好的对话者你是可以这样这样对话的 如果白天的话你问我 那我当然觉得马格维奇对现代 艺术设计有很大的贡献了 但我晚上就会说他就是个骗子 所以今天这样对话发生在白天 我下次要晚上跟你聊一次 还有我要闯一次你的那个直播室 因为我们在现在不能直播嘛 就网太差了 We can get down to 8 to 9 to 10, month ago But no more We will see you in the next video. We will see you in the next video. Thank you, Mr. Thank you for your time. Bye bye. Bye bye. Bye bye. you