Welcome to Night Vale

278 - How to Solve a Murder

29 min
Nov 15, 20257 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

This episode of Welcome to Night Vale presents a fictional murder mystery investigation centered on the death of angel Marcus Vanceden, found locked in his library with mysterious objects. Host Cecil Baldwin reads from a WikiHow article on solving murders to guide former mayor Dana Cardinal through an amateur investigation, while a second murder occurs at the radio station itself during the broadcast.

Insights
  • Fictional narratives can explore investigative methodology through comedic deconstruction of how-to guides, revealing the absurdity of amateur detective work
  • The episode uses nested storytelling to blur reality and fiction, creating tension between the host's objective reporting and subjective experience of events
  • Community-driven investigations and citizen involvement in solving crimes can be both helpful and dangerously destabilizing to personal safety
  • The proliferation of accessible how-to content online may create false confidence in complex problem-solving domains requiring professional expertise
Trends
Podcast narrative experimentation with meta-commentary on instructional content and how-to mediaGrowing audience interest in true crime and mystery investigation content across entertainment platformsBlending of educational content with fictional storytelling to create engaging narrative experiencesCommunity engagement through listener participation in fictional investigations and ongoing story arcsUse of absurdist humor to critique DIY culture and amateur expertise in specialized fields
Topics
Murder investigation methodologyAmateur detective work and citizen investigationsHow-to guide effectiveness and limitationsWorkplace safety protocolsCommunity involvement in crime solvingFictional narrative storytelling techniquesPodcast production and audio dramaEvidence collection and analysisSuspect interrogation and accusationMurder board creation and investigation visualization
Companies
Pinkberry
Frozen yogurt franchise temporarily closed due to metamorphosis into a black hole in Night Vale's science district.
Michael's
Craft store referenced as necessary shopping destination for murder board supplies including yarn, poster board, and ...
Cisco
Delivery service mentioned as experiencing occasional implosions near the Pinkberry black hole location.
Spotify
Music streaming platform referenced in murder investigation methodology regarding deceased's last listened song.
IMDB
Online database mentioned in context of podcast 'Best Worst' discussing rated best and worst television episodes.
People
Dana Cardinal
Former Night Vale mayor and former radio station intern who leads private investigation into Marcus Vanceden's murder.
Marcus Vanceden
Local billionaire and angel found deceased in locked library, central figure in the episode's murder mystery investig...
Cecil Baldwin
Host of Welcome to Night Vale who assists Dana Cardinal's investigation and reads WikiHow murder-solving guide on air.
Carlos
Cecil's scientist husband who briefly advises on murder investigation methodology before returning to Pinkberry exper...
Tabitha Littlefield
Town founder and ravenous entity responsible for devouring eight citizens in the previous week.
Esteban
Cecil's son whose witchcraft hobby demonstrates importance of following instructions precisely to avoid unintended co...
Maury Campanio
Pinkberry franchise owner managing resolution of black hole metamorphosis and collecting contractor bids.
Quotes
"Listeners, there has been a murder. Okay, this isn't exactly breaking news. It's the same murder I reported on before, but like it's still true, you know."
Cecil BaldwinOpening segment
"Solving a murder is hard work, but if you apply good reasoning skills and are willing to let yourself succumb to a spiraling obsession that takes you to the brink of madness and erodes your personal well-being and relationships, you'll be well on your way to becoming an amateur homicide investigator."
WikiHow article (read by Cecil Baldwin)Mid-episode
"No detail is too small and no question is irrelevant. For example, on what day of the week did the murder occur?"
WikiHow article (read by Cecil Baldwin)Investigation methodology section
"I know who you are, the note says in a bold childish scrawl, but you don't know who I am."
Anonymous note (read by Cecil Baldwin)Step 6 of investigation
"Together, I'm confident we can once again make Night Vale a safe place to live, aside from the countless other things that can cause bizarre and sudden deaths here on a daily basis."
Cecil BaldwinClosing remarks
Full Transcript
Howdy, it is Jeffrey Kranor telling you that welcome to Night Vale is coming to Europe. Specifically, we will be in Edinburgh on May 27th, 2026. Manchester on the 28th, London on the 29th, and Amsterdam on May 30th. Those tickets are on sale right now. So go get them and come see our newest live show, Murder Night in Blood 4, is that last week of May of 2026. Murder Night in Blood 4 is maybe the funniest wildest show we've done for a live show tour. So I really hope you all can come check it out. Tickets are available at welcometonight Vale.com slash live. And hey, if you like other things that we make, you can check out some other podcasts like Random Horror 9, where Cecil Baldwin and I talk horror movies or best worst, where Joseph Fink and Meg Bashwinner discuss the IMDB rated best and worst episodes of important television shows. And of course, Alice isn't dead is returning April 13th, so make sure you are subscribed to that. Okay, and now on to your Night Vale episode. And hey, thanks. Listeners, there has been a murder. Okay, this isn't exactly breaking news. It's the same murder I reported on before, but like it's still true, you know. There has been a murder. It just happens like the longer ago now than when I first reported on it. And even if the murder gets solved, which it currently hasn't been, I will probably continue to open each show from now on with listeners there has been a murder. Because it will always be true. And it's a great hook. To recap, the angel called Erica, formerly known as local billionaire Marcus Vanceden, was found deceased in his private library, which was locked from the inside. The body was surrounded by the following objects, a dead venomous snake, a ceremonial dagger from an archaeological site in Lufnark, a length of rope tied into a knot known as the Devil's Handshake, and a book of dirty lemurics with every fourth word circled and the hand-written note it is finished on the last page. His death has cast doubt on the immortality of angels, and finally answered the question of whether angels have blood. According to the coroner's report, Marcus' body was filled with a dizzying galaxy of stars, but I forgot to mention there was blood in there as well. Quite a bit of blood. Way more blood than a typical human body would have. Also six splines and no other organs. Of course it's reductive to some of a man's life by his body parts. He also had lots and lots of money, which is what truly defined him as a person. Angel. Whatever. But the real story here is that former Nightville Mayor, Dana Cardinal, who has been largely absent from public life since stepping down from office, has decided to lead a private investigation into the Vanston murder. Dana was my intern at the radio station for several months back when she was in college. She used to edit our community calendars, print our traffic reports and make coffee. In other words, she's a highly trained researcher, and I feel a certain responsibility as her former mentor to help her achieve her goals, which is exactly what I'm going to do on today's show. And just like when she was an intern, I am taking it upon myself to inundate her with advice. Despite her not asking for my help. But first, the headlines. The Pinkberry is temporarily closed due to its metamorphosis into a black hole. Franchise owner Maury Campanio would like to assure the yogurt loving public that the issue is being resolved. She is collecting bids from contractors right now and anticipates the store will be up and running again early next year. One of the neighboring businesses in the strip mall have been affected, aside from the occasional implosion of a Cisco delivery truck that pulls up too close to the curb. As the Pinkberry is located in the science district, many laboratory researchers are flocking to the site daily to throw objects into the black hole and giggle and high five each other when said objects disappear forever. In other disappearance news, town founder and ravenous entity Tabitha Littlefield has been on a real tear lately, devouring eight citizens last week alone. We unfortunately don't have time to name them all here, since the obituary section has been getting kinda out of hand lately. But if you haven't heard from a friend or family member or neighbor lately, that's probably what happened to them. Now back to the venstin murder investigation. Much like Dana, I don't have any formal detective training, other than being a hard-hitting investigative journalist, so I asked my scientist husband, Carlos, what he would do. And even though he was totally preoccupied with his experiments at the Pinkberry, he thought fully mumbled on his way out the door that I should try googling it. I took his advice and immediately discovered a wiki how article called How to Solve a Murder, parentheses with pictures. It's crazy there's so many unsolved murders out there when this simple step-by-step illustrated guide is so readily available. Anyway, I hope you're listening Dana because I am now going to read this helpful How-To Over the Air and all you have to do is follow along, complete each step, and soon will have this murder and whatever centuries old secret it may be covering up totally solved. Let's get to work. Have you ever been confronted with a murdered corpse and found yourself wondering things like why did this happen? And who did it? Selling a murder is hard work, but if you apply good reasoning skills and are willing to let yourself succumb to a spiraling obsession that takes you to the brink of madness and erodes your personal well-being and relationships, you'll be well on your way to becoming an amateur homicide investigator. Step 1. Ask Questions When investigating a murder, no detail is too small and no question is irrelevant. For example, on what day of the week did the murder occur? Let's say it was Wednesday. Wednesday was named for the Norse god Odin. Woodens Day. In some folkloric accounts, Odin is killed by a wolf monster. Ask yourself, could this person have been killed by a wolf monster? If you live in vermilion falls, that is often the solution. In some accounts, Odin required human sacrifices. Could this person have been a human sacrifice? Also, keep your ears open. What species of birds are chirping in the vicinity? Listen closely for the squawk of a parrot who may have inadvertently witnessed the crime and can mimic the incident back to you verbatim. What was the last song the deceased listened to on Spotify? Was it what a feeling by Irene Cara from the flash dance soundtrack? Or Freak on a leash by corn? Did you know that every murder in the last 40 years has occurred while one of these two songs is playing? Not necessarily playing at the murder, but just playing somewhere in the world at that exact moment. Use your eyes as well. Is there anyone hiding out near the dead body who might be the murderer? Are they grinning in an unsettling way and reaching for something in their pocket as they advance slowly toward you? Write it all down. At this point you are objectively collecting data, and no single piece of information is more important than any other. Avoid jumping to conclusions just yet. And there's an illustration of a pencil writing squiggly lines in a composition book that's labeled my first murder investigation. In the background there's a shadowy figure holding a sigh. I'm not sure if the figure is the literal murderer or a metaphoric depiction of death, but I guess that's the point, right? Take in the data and don't make assumptions. Wow, I'm learning a lot already. I don't know if Dana has a notebook like this to take notes in, specifically the kind with the black and white marbled cover and tear-away sheet, so we'll give her time to go pick one up before we continue with our how-to. One thing I've learned mainly through watching my son Esteban's journey with his witchcraft hobby is that it's important to follow instructions to the letter. One little improvisation can create a very active black hole where the pink berry was. While we wait for Dana to go by a composition book, let's take a side trip on our educational journey to the children's Fun Fact Science Corner. Fingerrues cannot walk backwards. They also can't look backwards physically or inwardly and have no memories. Because of this, time works differently for them. They are creatures of pure momentum. They only move forwards. Think only forwards. They do not self-reflect. They are free from trauma or regret. These qualities prepare them to be incredibly successful in business. They're naturally good gamblers as well. They also tend to rise in the political ranks more quickly than other species, which is why we have so many kangaroo politicians. When a kangaroo dies, its spirit continues hopping through space-time in an ever-forward chronology. Animal physicists hypothesize, however, that time itself is not an ever-forward chronology that it ultimately bends and loops back on itself. Therefore, when the first ghost of the first kangaroo returns to its origin point, it is a sign of the end of all things. This has been the children's Fun Fact Science Corner. Now back to solving the venstan murder. Let's see where we are. Yes, here we go. Step 2. Make a murder board. This will involve yarn, a lot of yarn, and glossy photographs, newspaper clippings, poster board, glue sticks. You're going to need to go to a Michael's craft store maybe more than once. Once you make the board, it's important that you look at it for hours without sleeping, pacing around, drinking coffee, and mumbling about how it should all add up to something. And why can't you see it? However much yarn you think you need for this, you will need more. Step 3. Accusations. Pick a few of your best suspects, or just people at random, and accuse them of doing the murder to see how they react. Accus them as dramatically as possible. Really have fun with it. If they confess, you did it. You solved the murder. Step 4. If you did not obtain a confession in Step 3, go back to your murder board and stare at it even harder, and pace around in a real frenzy this time huffing and puffing and running your hands through your hair and working up a sweat. I know there's something here. Some connection I'm missing. You say to yourself, it should be so obvious it's staring right at me. That's when you look out the window and see a twisted face on the other side of the glass in the rainy darkness, literally staring right at you. In a flash the face is gone. You can almost believe you imagined it. But you know what you saw. Step 5. You rush outside, but of course, no one is there. Step 6. As soon as you return to the safety of your office, you hear a scratching sound outside. A note is shoved under the door. I know who you are, the note says in a bold childish scrawl, but you don't know who I am. The message is punctuated with a smiley face. You don't open the door this time, you lock it with the deadbolt and look around desperately for a weapon in case you need to defend yourself. But HR did a workplace safety sweep recently and there isn't even anything with a sharp edge on it. No scissors, no thumbtacks, nothing. Everything is dull and soft and safe. It's probably just a prankster anyway. You say to yourself, but you don't really believe that. Do you? That's interesting. The illustration for this one looks a lot like the outside of my office here at the station. Flimsy plywood door at the end of a long, dark hallway. A glowing on-air sign? The perspective on it is a bit odd, like it's from the POV of someone crouching down in the office supply alcove near the restrooms. I know because I've crouched in that closet myself many times. Whatever I need a little break. Wait a second. I think I hear someone out in the hall. Weird. No one should be in the building right now. Well, sometimes intern applicants drop in without a scheduled interview. There has been a lot of renewed interest in the internship program lately since Dana's been back in the news. Hmm. I better check it out. While I do that, let's go to the weather. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. I know. snakes, but there is a book of dirty lemmarics, this time with every third word circled, and the handwritten note it has begun on the last page. And someone has tied a spare XLR cable from the supply closet into another complicated knot. I mean, I'm no expert, but it looks like, you know, like maybe a shoelace knot. What's that called? A bow, yes. Now, of course, we can't be sure if this is the same killer or some cheap copycat. And we don't know if this unfortunate pre-intern was the intended target, or just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. Step one said, avoid jumping to conclusions just yet. Okay, let's look at the evidence and see what we can learn. I've picked up the dirty, limmeric book, so let's start there. Here's the first poem circled words only. Mm-hmm was from, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, and, mm-hmm, said, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, with, mm-hmm, and mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Let's, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, every, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Oh, wow. That was a lot, Phil, if you've been I expect it. I apologize listeners for reading that on the air. I'm sure I'll be hearing from the FCC tomorrow. Not sure about the significance of these words yet, but step one is just to objectively collect data, right? What was step two? Listen for parents. Dana, are you out there? Did you buy your composition notebook yet? I'm a little, uh, I'm a little bit over my head. Right now. Um, I should probably get the Sheriff's secret police over here too, and someone who can identify this body. I should also put this limmeric book back where I found it. I think it was over here in the blood pool. Or was it by the victim's outstretched hand? Uh, either way, to the friends and family of whoever this is, I want to extend my sincere condolences. I'm sure your loved one would have made a great intern. I guess I should just go out and read the name of the resume, but I think I better wait for the professionals to handle this one. I'm not actually sure amateur detectiveing is something I want to get involved with at this moment. I've been really busy lately with work and family stuff and the whole homicide investigation thing seems pretty time consuming, but if anyone wants to come over and take a look at this body, please feel free to come on over. I'll just, I'll be here. Locked in my booth. Until sun up. Of course, I guess that's no guarantee of safety, is it? Uh, Marcus Vanceden was locked in his library when they found him. Oh, wait, I never finished the wiki howl article. Okay, maybe this will give us some insight about what to do now. Let me skip to the last step. Okay, okay, okay, here it is. Step 12. Solve the murder. It's just a bunch of lines and loops that seem to be growing, converging in a frantic scribble all over the web page, obliterating everything that was once here. I can't see the other steps at all anymore. Just a dense tangle of letters and images layered on top of each other. I can, I can almost make out the letter R and oh, a giant eyeball, I think, a freaky insect of some kind. Maybe I can't be sure. Underneath the scribbling, I can see the website source code bleeding through like the aluminum powder behind the screen of an etchis sketch. Beyond the code, a dizzying galaxy of stars, beyond the stars, a black hole, no. A portal, a glimpse into another place and time. I see dinosaurs running across a grassy plain. I see great buildings rising to the sky, then falling back into dust. I see water and fire becoming one smoke and steam blending into an endless opaque vapor covering the earth. Oh, good news listeners. Looks like one of the secret police's undercover hologram helicopters is landing outside the station as we speak. I mean, it's impossible to see it, of course. Since it blends in flawlessly with the evening sky and the pavement stripes and even my Cecil only parking sign, but the ultra loud sound of the chopping rotor blades is a dead giveaway. I better go out into the hallway and point at the body and scream so they know where to look. Anyway, I really hope we get to the bottom of this alarming situation soon, and I hope that how to guide was helpful to you, Dana, and any other amateur sleuths out there. Together, I'm confident we can once again make Night Vale a safe place to live, aside from the countless other things that can cause bizarre and sudden deaths here on a daily basis. Like our town founder, for instance, she's trouble not one. Stay tuned for a seemingly inconsequential event that will have drastic irreversible effect on the rest of your life. Good night, Night Vale, good night. Oh my god, it's a body! A body from a murder! It's right here! Welcome to Night Vale's production of Night Vale Presents. It is written by Joseph Think, Jeffrey Kramer, and Bri Williams. Sound design and production by disparition. The voice of Night Vale is Cecil Baldwin, original music by disparition. All that can be found at disparition.net. This episode's weather was Camelot by Dessa. Find out more at the link in our show notes. Comments, questions, email us at info at welcometonightvale.com or follow us on Blue Sky at Night Vale Radio or on Instagram, Tumblr, and TikTok at Night Vale Official. Or listen to a flower. They're tired of only being looked at and smelled. But mainly check out Welcome to Night Vale.com where we have a twice-monthly mailing list that is the best way to keep up to date directly from us to you. Where people, your people, let's do people stuff. Like communicate with each other. Today's proverb, you are what you eat. You turkey. You lasagna. You little pudding cup. What do you want to know? Or are you a horror lover who likes thoughtful conversation about your favorite genre? Join me, Jeffrey Kramer, and my friend from Welcome to Night Vale's Cecil Baldwin for our weekly podcast random number generator horror podcast number nine, where we watch and discuss horror movies in a random order. Find, here's the short version, random horror nine wherever you get your podcasts. Boo.