Letters from an American

Unbelievably Irresponsible

14 min
Apr 1, 2026about 2 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

On March 31, 2026, President Trump signaled willingness to end the Iran military campaign despite the Strait of Hormuz remaining closed, prompting criticism from experts who warn of global economic consequences. The episode also covers Trump's executive orders on mail-in voting (ruled unconstitutional), defunding NPR/PBS (partially blocked by courts), and a White House ballroom project (halted by judicial order).

Insights
  • Trump's pivot away from Iran war objectives while maintaining military presence signals strategic confusion and potential admission of policy failure, destabilizing energy markets and global commerce
  • Executive overreach on election administration faces immediate constitutional challenges, with courts and bipartisan election officials rejecting claims of mail-in voting insecurity despite lack of evidence
  • Judicial checks on presidential power are functioning across multiple domains (foreign policy implications, First Amendment protections, historic preservation), limiting unilateral executive action
  • Internal MAGA fracturing evident as prominent figures distance themselves from Trump over Iran policy and past election-related deceptions, suggesting coalition instability
  • Global allies are taking independent action (UAE seeking UN resolution on Strait reopening) rather than waiting for U.S. leadership, indicating shift in international power dynamics
Trends
Judicial intervention in executive foreign policy decisions becoming normalized, with courts weighing geopolitical consequencesConstitutional challenges to election administration centralization accelerating, with bipartisan election official consensus against federal voting list creationEnergy market volatility tied to Middle East military campaigns, with global economic interdependence limiting U.S. policy isolationErosion of party loyalty among MAGA figures when personal political survival conflicts with Trump supportInternational actors (UAE, UK) pursuing independent solutions to geopolitical crises rather than relying on U.S. military commitmentsFirst Amendment protections against government funding retaliation being reinforced through judicial precedentHistoric preservation and architectural oversight emerging as constraint on executive property controlStock market responding to war-end signals rather than underlying economic fundamentals, indicating investor risk aversion
Companies
Wall Street Journal
Published exclusive reporting on Trump's willingness to end Iran military campaign and UAE efforts on Strait reopening
Brookings Institution
Vice President Suzanne Maloney provided expert analysis on economic consequences of Strait closure
CNN
Reported on judicial ruling against NPR/PBS defunding order; Mark Robinson sued CNN for defamation
Fox News Channel
Host Laura Ingram questioned whether Trump was fully briefed on Iran campaign risks
Stars and Stripes
Reported on USS George H.W. Bush carrier deployment to Middle East
Alternet
Reported on Alex Jones speculation about Trump's health affecting Iran policy decisions
Talking Points Memo
Covered Mark Robinson's admission of lying about pornography forum participation to shield Trump
American Immigration Council
Aaron Reichland-Melnick noted federal citizen list for voting does not exist
Democracy Docket
Election law expert David Becker quoted on unconstitutionality of mail-in voting executive order
National Trust for Historic Preservation
Sued Trump to stop White House ballroom construction without congressional approval
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia
Judge Randolph Moss ruled NPR/PBS defunding order unconstitutional; Judge Richard Leon halted ballroom project
Department of Justice
Appealed Judge Leon's decision halting White House ballroom construction
Social Security Administration
Directed to work with DHS to create verified citizen list for mail-in voting
U.S. Postal Service
Ordered to send mail-in ballots only to verified citizens with unique bar codes
Department of Homeland Security
Tasked with creating verified U.S. citizen list for mail-in voting eligibility
People
Donald J. Trump
Posted on social media about Iran policy, signed executive orders on voting and broadcasting, attacked court decisions
Suzanne Maloney
Called Trump's willingness to leave Strait closed 'unbelievably irresponsible' and warned of global economic damage
Paul Krugman
Characterized Trump's Iran pivot as essentially an admission of defeat
Alexander Ward
Co-authored exclusive story on Trump's willingness to end Iran military campaign
Meredith McGraw
Co-authored exclusive story on Trump's willingness to end Iran military campaign
Allison Bath
Reported on USS George H.W. Bush carrier departure and carrier strike group composition
Laura Ingram
Questioned whether Trump was fully briefed on Iran campaign complexity and risks
Alex Jones
Speculated Trump's poor Iran decisions stem from ill health; urged MAGA to move on without Trump
Nick Hilden
Reported on Alex Jones speculation about Trump's health affecting Iran policy
Hunter Walker
Covered Mark Robinson's admission of lying about pornography forum participation to protect Trump
Mark Robinson
Admitted lying about pornography forum participation and hateful social media posts to shield Trump during 2024 race
Harry Waite
Convicted of identity theft and election fraud for ordering ballots in others' names in Wisconsin
Aaron Reichland-Melnick
Noted that federal list of citizens for voting does not exist
David Becker
Called mail-in voting executive order unconstitutional, stating Constitution gives President no power over elections
Alex Padilla
Top Democrat on Senate Rules Committee; called voting order 'blatant, unconstitutional abuse of power'
Joe Morelle
Top-ranking Democrat on House Administration Committee; called voting order 'illegal, dangerous, and subversive'
Chuck Schumer
Posted 'See you in court' in response to mail-in voting executive order
Randolph Moss
Ruled much of Trump's order stripping NPR and PBS of funds unconstitutional
Brian Stelter
Reported on Judge Moss's ruling against NPR/PBS defunding order
Richard Leon
Ruled Trump cannot proceed with White House ballroom project without congressional approval
Doug Burgum
Working with Trump on fixing the reflecting pool between Lincoln Memorial and Washington Monument
Pam Bondi
Directed to investigate anyone wrongfully distributing mail-in ballots under new executive order
Heather Cox Richardson
Wrote and read the episode
Quotes
"All of those countries that can't get jet fuel because of the Strait of Hormuz, like the United Kingdom, which refused to get involved in the decapitation of Iran, I have a suggestion for you. 1. Buy from the US. We have plenty. 2. Build up some delayed courage. Go to the Strait and just take it."
Donald J. Trump4:11 AM, March 31, 2026
"Having started a war, the US and Israel cannot walk away from the outcome. Energy markets are inherently global, and there is no possibility of insulating the US from the economic damage that is already occurring."
Suzanne MaloneyEvening, March 31, 2026
"The President of the United States is the steward of the White House for future generations of First Families. He is not, however, the owner."
Judge Richard LeonCourt ruling
"The Constitution clearly gives the President no power over elections."
David BeckerMarch 31, 2026
"Trump's run off the edge of a cliff and I don't think he's coming back from it. We cut bait on Trump and we mobilized against the Democrats. Trump is just a minor figure."
Alex JonesMarch 31, 2026
Full Transcript
March 31, 2026. At 4-11 this morning, President Donald J. Trump's social media account posted, All of those countries that can't get jet fuel because of the Strait of Hormuz, like the United Kingdom, which refused to get involved in the decapitation of Iran, I have a suggestion for you. 1. Buy from the US. We have plenty. 2. Build up some delayed courage. Go to the Strait and just take it. You'll have to start learning how to fight for yourself. The USA won't be there to help you anymore, just like you weren't there for us. Iran has been essentially decimated. The hard part is done. Go get your own oil. President DJT 3. While this morning, Trump appeared to wash his hands of his Iran war, there was an undertone of panic in his post, especially coming as it did just before an exclusive story by Alexander Ward and Meredith McGraw in the Wall Street Journal, reporting that Trump has told aides he is willing to end the military campaign against Iran, even if the Strait of Hormuz remains largely closed. Economist Paul Krugman noted this evening that this is a essentially an admission of defeat, and Suzanne Maloney, Vice President of the Brookings Institution think tank and an expert on Iran, called Trump's suggestion that he is willing to leave the Strait closed, unbelievably irresponsible. Having started a war, she said, the US and Israel cannot walk away from the outcome. Energy markets are inherently global, and there is no possibility of insulating the US from the economic damage that is already occurring and will become exponentially worse if the closure of the Strait continues, she told the Wall Street Journal reporters. Nonetheless, the idea the Iran war would end soon was a signal investors wanted to see. On the strength of the hope for a short war, the stock market posted its biggest one-day gain in 10 months. Meanwhile, another aircraft carrier, the USS George H.W. Bush, left its home port, Naval Station Norfolk in Virginia, today, to head in the direction of the Middle East, although it is not clear if it will support Operation Epic Fury. According to Allison Bath of Stars and Stripes, the carrier will pick up other elements of the carrier group, including the destroyer's USS Ross, USS Donald Cook, and USS Mason as it crosses the Atlantic. The George H.W. Bush Carrier Strike Group also includes several aircraft squadrons and detachments that make up the 70 or more aircraft in Carrier Air Wing 7, along with more than 5,000 sailors and military personnel. Nearly 3,500 sailors and marines from the Tripoli Amphibious Ready Group arrived in the region on Saturday. Yesterday, host Laura Ingram of the Fox News Channel wondered, was the president fully briefed about the risks of all this from the beginning? And was he then able to take it all in and understand the complexity of this? How complex it could actually get? And further possibilities of casualties or other damage? The difficulty of dealing with these people? Or was he told this would be relatively quick in and out? Nick Hilden of Alternet reported that MAGA leader Alex Jones speculated today that ill health is contributing to Trump's poor decisions on Iran. Trump's run off the edge of a cliff and I don't think he's coming back from it, Jones said. He urged MAGA to move on without Trump. We cut bait on Trump and we mobilized against the Democrats, he said. Trump is just a minor figure. Hunter Walker of Talking Points Memo picked up the story of another MAGA figure distancing himself from Trump. When he ran for governor in 2024, former North Carolina Lieutenant Governor Mark Robinson flat out denied stories about his participation in pornography forums and social media chats where he attacked Jewish, Black, gay and transgender people as well as flirting with Holocaust denial and calling himself a Black Nazi. He even sued CNN for $50 million for defamation, calling their story about him a high-tech lynching before dropping the suit after losing the election. Walker noted that Robinson recently admitted on a podcast that he was lying all along. He had to ignore the truth at that moment, he said, because he was shielding Trump. I certainly don't want to be the person that costs the President of the United States the election, he said. Didn't want to cost anyone else their election. Asked if he would do it again, he answered, I'd make the exact same decision. I'd fight in the exact same way. After Saturday's No Kings rallies around the country and the world and after new polls showing his job approval ratings have dropped to new lows, Trump this afternoon signed an executive order attacking mail-in voting. Although both Democratic and Republican election officials insist mail-in voting is secure and reliable, Trump claims it permits Democrats to cheat. Ironically, earlier this month, the story broke of a right-wing activist in Wisconsin who ordered ballots in other people's names to prove that mail-in voting enabled voter fraud. Last week, Harry Waite was convicted of one felony count of identity theft and two misdemeanor counts of election fraud, suggesting mail-in voting is not as insecure as he thought. Nonetheless, Trump is ordering the Department of Homeland Security, or DHS, to work with the Social Security Administration to create a list of verified U.S. citizens who are eligible to vote in each state. The order directs the U.S. Postal Service to send mail-in ballots only to voters on the list and to mark each ballot with its own unique bar code. It threatens any states refusing to cooperate with the order with a loss of federal funding and directs Attorney General Pam Bondi to investigate anyone wrongfully distributing mail-in ballots. Aaron Reichland-Melnick of the American Immigration Council notes that there is no such thing as a federal list of citizens. It does not exist. This is unconstitutional on its face, election law expert David Becker told Junior Reavos of Democracy Docket. The Constitution clearly gives the President no power over elections. The Senate Rules Committee oversees federal involvement in elections and its top Democrat, Alex Padilla, a Democrat of California, called the order a blatant, unconstitutional abuse of power, adding that Trump has no authority to commandeer federal elections or direct the Postal Service to undermine mail-in absentee voting. Representative Joe Morelle, a Democrat of New York, the top-ranking Democrat on the House Administration Committee, said that the order is illegal, dangerous, and subversive and that Donald Trump fears the American people and is willing to violate the Constitution to stop them from voting. See you in court, posted Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, a Democrat of New York. You will lose. Another of Trump's executive orders was in court today when Judge Randolph Moss of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ruled that much of Trump's order stripping NPR and PBS of funds was unconstitutional. As Brian Stelter of CNN reported, Moss quoted a Supreme Court ruling when he wrote, The First Amendment draws a line which the government may not cross at efforts to use government power, including the power of the purse, to punish or suppress disfavored expression by others. Republicans in Congress have since voted to cut federal funding from NPR and PBS, but the decision is a victory for the First Amendment. Judge Richard Leon of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia also stymied Trump today when he ruled that Trump cannot proceed with his plans for a giant ballroom on the site of the demolished East Wing of the White House without approval from Congress. The National Trust for Historic Preservation has sued Trump and a number of federal agencies to stop construction of the ballroom, noting that Trump skipped reviews and approvals that were required by law. The decision by Leon, who was appointed by President George W. Bush, begins, The President of the United States is the steward of the White House for future generations of First Families. He is not, however, the owner. It goes on to say that no statute comes close to giving the President the authority he claims to construct his East Wing ballroom project and do it with private funds, and points out that Trump appears to be relying for authority on a law permitting him to conduct ordinary maintenance and repair of the White House. Leon also noted that the White House has offered vague and shifting information about who is actually in charge of the project and that the public has an interest in the appearance of the White House. Leon said the ballroom construction project must stop until Congress authorizes its completion. The Department of Justice has already appealed. Trump exploded at the judge's decision, posting on social media, The National Trust for Historic Preservation sues me for a ballroom that is under budget ahead of schedule, being built at no cost to the taxpayer and will be the finest building of its kind anywhere in the world. I then get sued by them over the renovation of the dilapidated and structurally unsound former Kennedy Center, now the Trump Kennedy Center, a show of bipartisan unity, a Republican and Democrat president, where all I am doing is fixing, cleaning, running, and sprucing up a terribly maintained, for many years, building, but a building of potentially great importance. Yet, The National Trust for Historic Preservation, a radical left group of lunatics whose funding was stopped by Congress in 2005, is not suing the Federal Reserve for a building which has been decimated and destroyed inside and out by an incompetent and possibly corrupt Fed chairman. The once-magnificent building is billions over budget, may never be completed and may never open. All of the beautiful walls inside have been ripped down, never to be built again, but The National Trust for Historic Preservation never did anything about it. Or have they sued on Governor Gavin Newskam's railroad to nowhere in California that is billions over budget and probably will never open or be used? So the White House Ballroom and the Trump Kennedy Center, which are under budget ahead of schedule and will be among the most magnificent buildings of their kind anywhere in the world, gets sued by a group that was cut off by government years ago, but all of the many disasters in our country are left alone to die. Doesn't make much sense, does it? President Donald J. Trump. Hours later, he posted, Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum and I are working on fixing the absolutely filthy reflecting pool between the Lincoln Memorial and the Washington Monument. This work was supposed to be done by the Biden administration, but Sleepy Joe doesn't know what clean or proper maintenance is the President and Secretary do. Tonight, Summer Said, David S. Cloud and Michael Amon of the Wall Street Journal reported that the United Arab Emirates is trying to get a United Nations Security Council resolution to call for the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz. The UAE says it will help the U.S. and other allies open the Strait by force. Letters from an American was written and read by Heather Cox Richardson. It was produced at Soundscape Productions, dead in Massachusetts, recorded with music composed by Michael Moss.