Letters from an American

Trump Under Pressure

13 min
May 26, 2026about 2 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard resigned on May 25, 2026, citing her husband's cancer diagnosis, though sources indicate President Trump forced her out. Trump faces mounting pressure over his military actions in Iran, with Congress preparing to invoke the War Powers Act, while he negotiates a potential deal that critics argue amounts to a complete U.S. surrender.

Insights
  • Trump's relationship with appointees is transactional and volatile—Gabbard lost favor after opposing military action, then failed to regain standing despite backing his extremist initiatives
  • Congressional oversight mechanisms like the War Powers Act are being tested as Trump seeks to conclude military operations before Congress returns and can force his hand
  • Trump's use of social media for diplomatic messaging is undermining actual negotiations, with Iranian officials publicly noting his posts are 'for promotional purposes' and should be ignored
  • The proposed Iran deal represents a dramatic reversal from Trump's first-term foreign policy, suggesting either negotiating weakness or a strategic pivot driven by economic and political pressure
  • Republican congressional unity on Trump's foreign policy is fracturing, with figures like Senator Wicker openly opposing the Iran agreement
Trends
Executive branch instability and high-turnover appointments in national security rolesErosion of War Powers Act enforcement as presidents use technical arguments to circumvent congressional authorizationSocial media as a primary diplomatic tool creating credibility gaps between official messaging and actual negotiationsGeopolitical realignment in Middle East with potential Iran-U.S. rapprochement contradicting prior Abraham Accords strategyRepublican Party fracturing on foreign policy between Trump loyalists and traditional national security conservativesEconomic leverage of energy markets (Strait of Hormuz closure) driving rapid policy reversalsUse of AI-generated imagery in political communication and messaging campaignsCongressional pressure on classified document transparency (Epstein files) as political leverage
Topics
Director of National Intelligence resignation and Trump administration turnoverWar Powers Act enforcement and congressional oversight of military operationsIran military conflict and ceasefire negotiationsStrait of Hormuz blockade and oil market impactsU.S.-Iran nuclear deal negotiations and JCPOA comparisonMiddle East diplomatic strategy and Abraham AccordsPresidential social media messaging and diplomatic communicationsCongressional Republican opposition to Trump foreign policyIntelligence community coordination and ODNI oversightEpstein files transparency and document release requirementsAI-generated political imagery and disinformationSaudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar, Pakistan, Turkey, Egypt, Jordan, Bahrain diplomatic engagementIsraeli-Iranian tensions and Netanyahu coordinationU.S. military operations and force deployment decisionsEnergy market volatility from geopolitical conflict
People
Tulsi Gabbard
Resigned effective June 30, 2026, citing husband's cancer diagnosis; sources indicate Trump forced her out after she ...
Donald J. Trump
Central figure facing pressure over Iran military operations, negotiating ceasefire deal, using social media for dipl...
John Bolton
Called Gabbard 'a hand grenade ready to explode' when Trump appointed her to ODNI
Mike Johnson
Republican of Louisiana; sent representatives home early to prevent War Powers Resolution vote against Trump's Iran o...
Roger Wicker
Republican of Mississippi; condemned Iran deal as disaster, urged Trump to continue military operations
Thomas Massey
Republican of Kentucky; lost primary after Trump backed opponent; demanding release of Epstein files on Meet the Press
Benjamin Netanyahu
Participated in Saturday call with Trump regarding Iran deal negotiations
Barack Obama
Negotiated JCPOA with Iran; Trump criticizes deal and accuses him of treasonous conspiracy; Gabbard called for his pr...
Ro Khanna
Democrat of California; Trump posted AI image depicting him as devil, calling him sleazebag
Jonathan Landay
Reported that Trump forced out Gabbard, citing source close to situation
Aaron Blanco
Co-reported with Landay on Trump forcing out Gabbard
Nick Schifrin
Reported that Trump considered Gabbard's nuclear warning video an attempt to dissuade him from Iran strikes
Shane Harris
Noted Gabbard was posting beach photos while Trump prepared Venezuela invasion
David Schuster
Posted analysis of Iran deal terms from Al Jazeera reporting, calling it total U.S. surrender
Ibrahim Al Fakhar
Posted AI image of Trump kneeling before Iran's supreme leader with caption 'the end'
Heather Cox Richardson
Wrote and read this episode analyzing Trump's Iran negotiations and political pressures
Quotes
"while I very much wanted to be with my son Don Jr. and the newest member of the Trump family, his soon-to-be-wife Bettina, circumstances pertaining to government and my love for the United States of America do not allow me to do so"
Donald J. TrumpWeekend social media post explaining absence from son's wedding
"An agreement has been largely negotiated, subject to finalization. Final aspects and details of the deal are currently being discussed and will be announced shortly. In addition to many other elements of the agreement, the Strait of Hormuz will be opened."
Trump social media accountSaturday afternoon post
"American officials have acknowledged in multiple messages to Iran that Trump's tweets are primarily for promotional purposes and media consumption within the United States, and they have recommended that no attention be paid to these statements"
Iran state mediaResponse to Trump's Iran deal announcement
"It would be a disaster. Everything accomplished by Operation Epic Fury would be for naught. Wicker urged Trump to allow America's skilled armed forces to finish the destruction of Iran's conventional military capabilities and reopen the Strait."
Senator Roger WickerImmediate response to Iran deal announcement
"If I make a deal with Iran, it will be a good and proper one, not like the one made by Obama, which gave Iran massive amounts of cash and a clear and open path to a nuclear weapon. Our deal is the exact opposite"
Trump social media accountSunday post defending Iran negotiations
Full Transcript
May 25, 2026 Last Friday, just before the long holiday weekend, Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard resigned, effective as of June 30, citing her husband's recent cancer diagnosis as the factor that forced her decision. A source told Jonathan Landay and Aaron Blanco of Reuters that President Donald J. Trump had forced her out. Certainly, he has sidelined her. Congress created the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, or ODNI, in 2004, after concluding that intelligence failures, including a lack of communication across agencies, had contributed to the vulnerability that permitted the 9-11 attacks. The ODNI is supposed to oversee the 18 different intelligence agencies and to coordinate the information they produce. Gabbard did not have deep experience in intelligence and had endorsed Russian talking points about Russia's invasion of Ukraine when Trump named her Director of ODNI. Trump's former National Security Advisor, John Bolton, called her a hand grenade ready to explode. Gabbard ran into trouble with Trump by June 2025 when she released a video warning of nuclear holocaust because political elite warmongers are carelessly fomenting fear and tensions between nuclear powers. They were bringing the world closer to the brink of nuclear annihilation than ever before, she said. She released the video days before Trump launched his first attack on Iran, and a former intelligence officer told Nick Schifrin of PBS that Trump considered the video an attempt to try to convince him not to launch the strikes. Afterward, Gabbard seemed to try to regain Trump's favor by backing his extremist pet projects, including accusing former President Barack Obama of leading a treasonous conspiracy and calling for him to be prosecuted over the FBI's investigation of the ties between Trump's 2016 campaign and Russian operatives. She also foresaw an FBI raid at the Fulton County, Georgia election headquarters, during which the administration scooped up all the physical ballots from the 2020 presidential election, as well as ballot images, tabulator tapes, and the voter rolls from that election. But she never recovered her standing with the president. As Shane Harris noted in The Atlantic, while Trump was preparing to invade Venezuela and extract its president and his wife, Gabbard was posting pictures of herself on a Hawaiian beach. Trump stayed in the White House over the weekend, missing his son Don Jr.'s wedding in the Bahamas, with a social media post explaining that, while I very much wanted to be with my son Don Jr. and the newest member of the Trump family, his soon-to-be-wife Bettina, circumstances pertaining to government and my love for the United States of America do not allow me to do so. I feel it is important for me to remain in Washington, D.C. at the White House during this important period of time. Whatever else might be going on, Trump is under pressure to find a way out of Iran. Not only are prices skyrocketing, owing to the rising cost of oil after Iran shut the Strait of Hormuz in response to attacks from the U.S. and Israel, but the clock has run out on any authorization he could have claimed for his military adventure in Iran, and Congress seems ready to force his hand. Congress alone can declare war, but the 1973 War Powers Act permits the president to act against an imminent threat, so long as he notifies Congress within 48 hours. Then he has 60 days to get congressional approval. That timeline ran out on May 1st, and the administration claimed it didn't need authorization because it had declared a ceasefire on April 7th, although it continued to maintain a blockade against Iranian ports, an act of war, and to exchange fire with Iranian forces. Republicans in Congress appeared to accept that argument for a time, but last Thursday House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Republican of Louisiana, had to send representatives home a day early to keep members from passing a War Powers Resolution that would order Trump to remove U.S. troops from his war on Iran. The House and Senate will come back on June 2nd, and Trump clearly would like to have an agreement with Iran in place before they do. Trump's social media account over the weekend was active. He twice posted an image of himself leering over Greenland with the caption, Hello Greenland, and repeated suggestions that China loves Trump. He posted an AI image of Representative Ro Khanna, a Democrat of California, as a devil, I think, calling him a sleazebag and a Democrat, and an image of eight lawmakers or officials in orange jumpsuits, except for Obama's Tan one, claiming they had caused tremendous damage through weaponization. And he posted a number of images of colorful fountains. But much of the account's attention this weekend was on Iran. On Saturday morning, the account posted an image of Iran covered by a U.S. flag, and at 4.30 that afternoon, it posted that Trump had just had a call with leaders from Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates or UAE, Qatar, Pakistan, Turkey, Egypt, Jordan, and Bahrain, and then a separate call with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu about Iran. All the calls went very well, according to the post. An agreement has been largely negotiated, the post read, subject to finalization. Final aspects and details of the deal are currently being discussed and will be announced shortly. In addition to many other elements of the agreement, the Strait of Hormuz will be opened. But Iran's state media immediately posted that Trump's claim that the Strait would reopen as it was before the war was not true, adding that it should be noted that American officials have acknowledged in multiple messages to Iran that Trump's tweets are primarily for promotional purposes and media consumption within the United States, and they have recommended that no attention be paid to these statements. Firm details about the deal were scarce, but as journalist David Schuster posted, Al Jazeera reported that the deal included unfreezing billions in Iranian funds, lifting U.S. blockade, pulling U.S. forces away, reopening the Strait of Hormuz, though with tolls to Iran, and allowing Iran to keep its enriched uranium. This would be a total U.S. surrender, Schuster noted. Iran's military spokesperson, Ibrahim Al Fakhar, posted an AI image of Trump kneeling before Iran's supreme leader, with the caption, the end. Senator Roger Wicker, a Republican of Mississippi, chair of the Senate Armed Services Committee, immediately condemned the deal. He told reporters it would be a disaster. Everything accomplished by Operation Epic Fury would be for naught. Wicker urged Trump to allow America's skilled armed forces to finish the destruction of Iran's conventional military capabilities and reopen the Strait. Further pursuit of an agreement with Iran's Islamist regime risks a perception of weakness. We must finish what we started. It is past time for action. By Sunday morning, Trump was, once again, posting AI images of U.S. bombers attacking Iranian ships, complete with bodies flying through the air, and insisting that the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, or JCPOA, negotiated between the U.S., China, France, Germany, Russia, the United Kingdom, and Iran during the Obama administration was one of the worst deals ever made by our country. Under the JCPOA, Iran agreed to reduce its stockpile of enriched uranium significantly and allow inspections in exchange for relief from some sanctions. The Strait of Hormuz remained open. Although inspectors said Iran was honoring the deal, Trump took the U.S. out of the JCPOA in 2018, and the following year, Iran resumed work on enriched uranium necessary for a nuclear weapon. Trump added that he expected Middle Eastern countries, including Iran, to join the Abraham Accords, the deal hammered out during Trump's first term, under which the UAE and Bahrain formally recognized Israel. According to Barack Revead of Axios, Arab leaders met Trump's suggestion of such a recognition during the Saturday phone call with silence. Then his account posted, If I make a deal with Iran, it will be a good and proper one, not like the one made by Obama, which gave Iran massive amounts of cash and a clear and open path to a nuclear weapon. Our deal is the exact opposite, but nobody has seen it or knows what it is. It isn't even fully negotiated yet, so don't listen to the losers who are critical about something they know nothing about. Unlike those before me who should have solved this problem many years ago, I don't make bad deals. This morning, Trump's account posted, I laugh at all of the Democrats, Rhinos and Fools who know nothing about the potential deal I am making with Iran, things that haven't even been negotiated yet. They are losers. The deal with Iran will either be a great and meaningful one, or there will be no deal. It will be the exact opposite of the JCPOA disaster negotiated by the failed Obama administration, which was a direct and open path to a nuclear weapon for Iran. No, I don't do deals like that. Meanwhile, on Meet the Press Sunday, Representative Thomas Massey, a Republican of Kentucky, who last week lost the primary for reelection to his seat after Trump backed his opponent and Trump's supporters through a gobsmacking $35 million at the contest, reopened fire from a different direction. Massey has been key to demanding the release of the Epstein files, and the administration continues to ignore the Epstein Files Transparency Act, which required the Department of Justice to release all the files no later than December 19, 2025. When host Kristen Welker, noting that Massey had named names from the files in the past, asked, Can we expect you to name more names in the coming weeks and months? Massey answered, Yes. Letters from an American was written and read by Heather Cox Richardson. It was produced at Soundscape Productions, in Massachusetts, recorded with music composed by Michael Moss.