The Lost Sci-Fi Podcast - Vintage Sci-Fi Short Stories

Seller of the Sky by Dave Dryfoos

24 min
Feb 11, 20262 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

This episode presents "Seller of the Sky," a 1955 science fiction short story by Dave Dreyfus about an old wanderer named Arch who sells certificates for access to Earth's natural sky to children living in sealed domed cities. When two children finally demand proof and venture outside, they witness a sunrise and experience nature firsthand, fundamentally changing their perspective on the artificial world they inhabit.

Insights
  • Isolation from natural experiences creates vulnerability to manipulation and false promises, even when well-intentioned
  • Direct experience of reality can catalyze mass behavioral change more effectively than years of rhetoric or warnings
  • The tension between safety and freedom is a timeless human dilemma that transcends technological advancement
  • Marginalized individuals often serve as bridges between disconnected worlds and hold knowledge others have forgotten
Trends
Dystopian fiction exploring controlled environments and information asymmetry remains relevant to modern concernsStories examining the psychological impact of environmental isolation resonate across generationsNarratives questioning institutional safety narratives and encouraging individual agency in decision-makingScience fiction examining the cost of technological convenience versus natural human experience
Topics
Dystopian FictionEnvironmental IsolationGenerational Knowledge TransferRisk vs. Safety Trade-offsSealed Habitats and Domed CitiesComing of Age NarrativesRadioactive Contamination FearsNatural World DeprivationSocial MarginalizationInstitutional Control Systems
Companies
Prime Video
Featured in pre-roll advertisement promoting Fallout season 2, The Witches of Oz, and Wicked content
People
Dave Dreyfus
Science fiction author whose 1955 short story 'Seller of the Sky' is the focus of this episode
Quotes
"Why the lock? Why the plastic bubble over all, and why the guards? There's no pollution. Am I not alive?"
Old ArchEarly in story
"I want you to know Earth, your own country, the one planet on which these plastic-covered cities are unnecessary, where you can actually go out and roll on the grass."
Old ArchMid-story
"There isn't any sky. It's all talk. The certificates were just for begging."
My grandfather (Ham)Confrontation scene
"That's what I've lived for. And he smiled and stopped living."
Old ArchFinal moments
Full Transcript
Prime Video offers the best in entertainment. The end of the world continues with the season 2 of Fallout. A worldwide phenomenon, inbegreed by Prime. I heard you about what to do in this situation. Look at the epic end of the unwritten story of The Witches of Oz. Buy or buy? Wicked for good now. I'm taking you to see The Wizard. There's no going back. So whatever you want to look, Prime Video. Here you look at everything. Prime is a good idea, especially to buy or buy. Inhoud can advertise 18+. All the rules are of use. A wandering old man keeps selling something no one believes can still exist. And two children decide it's time to demand proof. What follows forces a choice between safety and a single moment that can never be taken back. Cellar of the Sky by Dave Dreyfus. That's next on the Lost Sci-Fi Podcast. Dave Dreyfus made his debut on the podcast less than two weeks ago, and I enjoyed Some Like It Cold so much, I began searching for another one of his stories. This one was the last story ever published by Dreyfus. His first story made his presence known late in 1950, and this wrapped up his science fiction career less than five years later. First published in If Worlds of Science Fiction in February 1955 on page 22. Cellar of the Sky by Dave Dreyfus. There have always been the touched, the blessy, God's poor. Such a one was old Arch. Archer Jakes, the wanderer of the plains. They say he was born on Earth in 3042 and taken to Mazepa as a child, that he learned pilotage and mining, but that he was injured in a cave-in on Heretni in 3068 or thereabouts, and then his wife died in a landing accident, and his child was taken from him and adopted by people he never could find. Those things are too far distant in time and space to be verified now. But it is a fact that by four thousand, when my grandfather, Hockington Hammer, was growing up in New Oshkosh, old Arch was a familiar figure in all the domed cities of the plains. He looked ancient then, with his deformed back that people touched for luck, and his wild hair and beard and ragged cast-off clothing. On his back he carried a roll of cloth he called his bed, though it looked like no bed any city man had ever seen. In his right hand he carried a staff of wood unless someone bought it from him and gave him a plastic rod in its place. And in his left he carried what he called a billy can which was a food container with a loop of wire across the top for a handle and the bottom blackened by what he said was fire. It would have been like no fire any city man had ever seen. Even the water in the can would be poison to a city man. When he came in the airlocks, the guards would make him throw it away. Why the lock? he'd demand, coming into a city. Why the lock, and why the plastic bubble over all, and why the guards? There's no pollution. Am I not alive? The guards would touch his hump and make circular motions at the sides of their heads and raise their eyebrows as if to say, yes, you're alive. But are you not crazy? Still, they would admit him, the only non-resident to walk between the domed cities of the plains and enter all of them, the only man to pass unharmed through the camps of the outsiders who lived in the open on the plains at the heart of the North American continent of Ur. An old arch would go to the residence buildings and he'd knock on someone's door, any door, chosen at random, and he'd say, Have you seen the sky and do you know it's blue? Have you felt the soft kiss of the breezes? I can show you where to breathe fresh air. Maybe the people would say, Phew, does it smell like you, this fresh air? And slam the door in his face. Or maybe they'd say, Come on around to the back, old man, and we'll find you something to eat. Then old Arch would shoulder his bed and pick up his billy can and his staff and walk down the stairs and go around to the back and walk up the stairs to the rear door. It might be an hour before he appeared there. It might be two. When he did, the people would ask, Why didn't you say something? You should have known they wouldn't let you in the elevator. and twenty flights down and twenty flights up again is too much for a man of your years. Then the next time he came, they would do the same thing again. In the kitchen, he would refuse all the pills and potions and shots, and insist on bulky foods. These he would eat neatly, holding aside the long white hair around his mouth and brushing the crumbs from it often. What he couldn't eat right away would go into his blackened billy can. The children would come before he finished, those of the household and neighbor kids, too. First they'd stand shyly and watch him from a doorway. Then they press closer By the time he got through they be fighting to sit on his lap The winner would climb up and sit there proudly One of the losers trying to prove he hadn lost much might wrinkle up his nose and say, What's that awful stink, old man? An arch would answer mildly, It's only wood smoke, son. Then the children would ask, What's wood, please? And what's smoke? and he would tell them. He would tell of the wind and the rain and the snow, of the cattle herds that roamed to the west and the cities that lay to the east and the stars and the moon that they had never seen. He would claim to have been in the endless forests and on the treeless plains and to have tasted the salt ocean and drunk of the freshwater lakes and rivers. The children would have heard in their lessons and from their elders enough to know what he was talking about. Sometimes they would tire of it and ask him to tell of the distant planets and their far-off suns. But this he would not do. You already hear too much about them, he'd say. I want you to know Earth, your own country, the one planet on which these plastic-covered cities are unnecessary. where you can actually go out and roll on the grass. Then the children might ask, What's grass? But their fathers would pointedly say, What about the radioactivity, old man? I'm alive, he'd reply. There's no radioactivity out there. But they'd say, How can we be sure? There are individual differences of susceptibility. Probably you are unhurt by dosages that would kill any normal person. And the mothers would say, Eat some more, old man. Eat and go. Bring our babies dreams if you like. But don't try to tempt them outside. Even if it isn't radioactive there, you've admitted it gets hot and it gets cold and the wind blows fiercely hard. Our babies were born under shelter and under shelter they must stay, like us, and our parents before us. So old Arch would brush off his whiskers one last time and maybe put on an old shirt the father dug up for him and then go out the back way. In spite of what might have been said, he would have to walk the twenty flights down to the ground because he wouldn't be invited to walk through the apartment to the front hall where the elevator was. Sometimes people were hostile when he spoke to their children and they would have him arrested. He was then bathed and barbered in the jail and was given all new clothes. But they'd always burn his bed and he'd have trouble getting a new one. And sometimes a jailer might covet the pocket knife he carried or take away his billy can. On the whole, I think he preferred not to go to jail except perhaps in winter when it was cold outside the city. There were always those ready to talk of asylums and the need to put him away for his own good. But nobody was sure where his legal residence was, so he wasn't really eligible for public hospitalization. He kept to his rounds. My grandfather remembers standing in his mother's kitchen listening to Old Arch. It was like meeting one of Joseph's brethren and being told exactly what the coat looked like. Something exciting out of a dream from the remote past, when all the worlds had on them those bright, moist diamonds Arch described as morning dew. My grandfather wanted to see the morning dew, though he knew better than to say so. Old Arch understood. He tried to make the thing possible, but an opportunity to see the morning dew was something he just couldn't give to my grandfather, or anybody else. So he decided to sell it. He persuaded a charitable lithographer to make him a batch of stock certificates. They looked very authentic. Each said plainly it was good for one share of blue sky, though the fat half-draped woman portrayed in three colors stood outside a domed city, pointing not at the sky, but at a distant river with forested hills behind it. Art sold his certificates for a stiff price, $10 apiece. He could do it because by this time his wanderings followed a fairly definite route. The people who hated or feared or despised him were pretty well eliminated from it, and most of his calls were at apartments where he was known and expected and even respected a little. My grandfather's was one of these, or rather, my great-grandfather's. When Arch first brought his stock certificates, my grandfather was a little fellow everybody called Ham, maybe seven years old. He had a sister named Annie who was five. He's given me a mental picture of the two of them, standing close together for reassurance, and from an open doorway, shyly watching the old man eat and listening to him talk. When my great-grandfather bought a $10 stock certificate in my grandfather's name, my grandfather took it as a promise, and his little sister Annie was so jealous that the next time old Arch came around, my great-grandfather had to buy a share for her. As they grew to be 9 10 11 12 every winter when old Arch would come around my grandfather and his sister Annie would ask When are you going to take us to see the sky Arch And he would say When you older when your folks say you can go, and when it's summer, not too cold for these old bones. But when my grandfather was fourteen, he followed old Arch out and down the stairs after the old man had paid his annual call, and he stopped him on a landing to ask, Arch, have you ever taken anyone outside? No, Arch said, sighing. People won't go. I'll go, said my grandfather, and so will my sister Annie. Arch looked at him and put a hand on him and said, I don't want to come between any boy and his parents. Well, said my grandfather, you sold them a share of sky for each of us. Do you really want us to have that? Or do you just want to talk about it? Of course I want you to, but I can't take you outside, boy. My grandfather was disgusted. There isn't any sky, he said sadly. It's all talk. The certificates were just for begging. No, said Arch. It's not all talk, and I'm not a beggar. I'm a guide. But it's hard to see the sky right now because it's winter, and there are clouds all over. Let's see the clouds then, my grandfather said stubbornly. I've never seen a cloud. The old man sat down on the stairs to consider the matter. I can't do this thing to your parents, he said at last. But you can do it to me and my sister, my grandfather charged wildly. You can come to the house year after year and tell us about the sky and the wind and the moon and the dew and the grass and the sun. You can even take money for our share of them. But when it comes time to produce, when we're old enough to go where these things are supposed to be, you think of excuses. I don't believe there are any such things, he shouted. I think you're a liar. I think you ought to be arrested for jipping my dad on the stock deal. And I'm going to turn you in. Don't do that, boy, Art said mildly. Then take us outside. Today. Hey, it's winter, my boy. We'd freeze. You said it's pretty in winter. You took the money for the certificate. I suppose you'll grow away from your parents soon anyhow. I suppose you have to get your warmest clothes and meet me at emergency exit four. My grandfather talked it over with his sister Annie, and of course they didn't have any warm clothes. But they'd heard so often from old Arch about the cold that they put on two sets of tights apiece and two pairs of socks, and then they hunted for the emergency exit. They'd never been there before. They didn't know anyone who had. The signs pointing to it were all worn and defaced, and it was a long way to go. After a while, Annie began to hang back. How do we know the exit will work, she asked, and how will we get back in if we ever do get out? You don't have to come, my grandfather said, but you'll have to find your own way home from here. I'll bet I could, she said, but I'm not going to. I don't think old Arch will even be at the exit. But he was. He looked at them carefully to see how they were dressed. You mean trouble for me, girl, he told Annie. They'll think I took you long to make love to. She had just reached that betwixt and between stage where she was beginning to look like a woman, but didn't yet think like one. Poo, she said. I can run faster and hit harder than you can, Arch. You don't worry me a bit. Old Arch sighed and led them through the lock. They stepped out into a raging snowstorm, which soon draped a cloak of invisibility over them. Neither my grandfather nor Annie had ever smelled fresh air before. It threatened to make them drunk. Their nostrils tingled, and their eyes misted over, and their breath steamed up like bathwater. For the first time in their lives, they shivered. When the city was out of sight in the storm, they stopped for a moment in the ankle-deep snow and just listened. They held their breaths and heard silence for the first time in their lives. Old Arch reached down and picked up some soft snow and threw it at them. They pelted him back. And then, because he was so old, attacked each other instead, shouting and throwing snowballs and running aimlessly. Old Art soon checked them. Don't get lost, he said. We're walking downhill, don't forget that. We're going into a draw where there are some trees. He coughed and drew his rags about him. The city is uphill, he said. If you keep walking around it, you'll find a way in. His tone was frightening. Annie clung to my grandfather and made him walk close to the old man. It was clear the old man didn have enough clothes on He staggered and leaned hard on my grandfather They kept moving down the slight grade They saw no sky and little of anything else The snow was like a miniature of the city's dome, except that this dome floated over them as they walked. Its edges were only about fifty yards off. Where are the outsiders? my grandfather asked. Aren't there people here? They're miles away, Arch told him, and indoors. Only fools and youngsters are out in this blizzard. Fools is right, Annie said tartly. There was supposed to be sky, and there isn't. Old Arch staggered again. To my grandfather, he said, Could you carry my pack? My grandfather took it, and they went on, stumbling blindly through knee-deep drifts, getting more and more chilled and less and less comfortable, till they came to a small clump of trees with a solidly frozen creek running through it. Here old Arch made a lean-to shelter of wind-fallen limbs. Annie and my grandfather helped as soon as they understood the design. Arch spread part of his bed over the lean-to, breaking the force of the wind, and put the rest inside. Just outside, on a place scraped bare of snow, he built the first wood fire my grandfather and Annie had ever seen. He chipped ice from the creek and put it in his billy can and hung the can by its bale over the fire, and in due course they had a little hot tea. The youngsters felt cold but happy. The old man shivered and coughed. He kept moving till the tea was made. He sat still to drink it and couldn't get up. Go to bed, Annie told him. Ham will get on one side of you and I'll get on the other. We'll keep you warm. Old Arch tried to protest but was almost beyond speech. The youngsters didn't know enough to brush the snow off him or themselves. They helped him roll up in his bedding and crawled under the lean-to after him. There they all lay in a heap, getting colder and damper and more miserable, till finally my grandfather couldn't stand it anymore. He got up and looked around. The inverted cup of visibility was smaller. Darkness fell like a dye stuff, turning the white snow to gray to black. It was a bitter night. The first he'd ever had outdoors. It was the first Annie'd ever had. The first either had ever spent at the futile task of holding off death. They knew old Arch was dying. As the night wore on, he sank into semi-consciousness. They hugged him and rubbed his lean old limbs. Just before morning, the snow stopped. The old man roused a little, became gradually aware of his surroundings. Go look at the sun, he murmured. Go see the sunrise. They went out to look. Neither had ever seen a sunrise before. It was mauve first, then red, then gold, then blue. Venus led the way and the sun followed. The moon, deep in the west, was like a tombstone to the dead night. A bird chirped. A clot of snow fell from a tree with a soft ruffle of cottony drums. My grandfather held his sister's hand and looked and sniffed at the great earth, from which he'd been separated by the fear-inspired plastic over his city, so near now in the clear morning light. He climbed with Annie up the side of the draw and looked out over snow-covered plains, stretching to a horizon farther away than the longest distance he'd ever imagined. He went back and took old Arch's head up on his knees and said, Is it like this every day? And the old man said, No, each day is different. And my grandfather said, well, I've seen one anyhow. That's what I've lived for, said old Arch. And he smiled and stopped living. Annie and my grandfather left him there and went back to the city and told the guards and their family. A burial party was sent out, guards in their helmeted spacesuits. People heard about it and followed. Everyone was curious because they'd all seen old Arch and wondered about him. Hundreds of people went out the gate. So many, the guards couldn't stop them. They saw the lean-to and the open fire and the woods and the snow and the frozen creek. They smelled the air and the smoke. They heard a bird. They tossed snowballs. And then they went back and flung rocks through their city's dome. Next on the Lost Sci-Fi Podcast, Earth's most powerful leader discovers that the counsel he trusted most may soon be gone, just as the stakes become irreversible. When guidance disappears, the final responsibility cannot be delegated, delayed, or avoided. Final Exam by Sam Merwin Jr.