WSJ What’s News

Can a Chatbot Be Charged With Murder?

14 min
Apr 22, 20266 days ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

This episode examines Florida's criminal investigation into OpenAI's ChatGPT for its role in a mass shooting, explores market resilience amid geopolitical tensions with Iran, and covers emerging trends in EV battery technology and weight loss drug accessibility through Amazon.

Insights
  • AI companies may face unprecedented criminal liability for user-generated harms, setting potential legal precedent for the industry
  • Retail investor participation has reached 30% of US stock market activity, driven by behavioral psychology and app-based accessibility rather than fundamental analysis
  • Market gains during geopolitical crises suggest investors are pricing in government support and long-term growth narratives over short-term risk
  • EV charging technology is rapidly closing the gap with traditional combustion engines, with sub-7-minute charging now commercially viable
  • Non-tech sectors like defense, industrial equipment, and energy security are attracting investor attention as alternatives to AI-focused portfolios
Trends
Criminal liability expansion: Governments exploring whether AI companies can be held criminally responsible for user actionsRetail investor dominance: Behavioral finance driving market movements more than fundamentals or institutional strategyEV charging convergence: Battery technology breakthroughs eliminating refueling time as a competitive disadvantageGeopolitical risk decoupling: Markets rising despite international tensions, suggesting confidence in government interventionDiversification away from AI: Investor interest shifting to defense, uranium, lithium, and industrial technology sectorsHealthcare accessibility through e-commerce: Major retailers entering pharmaceutical distribution for weight loss medicationsRedistricting as political leverage: State-level gerrymandering efforts significantly impacting national electoral outcomes
Companies
OpenAI
Under criminal investigation by Florida AG for ChatGPT's alleged role in advising mass shooter on timing and location
CATL
Battery maker unveiled new battery technology enabling EV charging in under 7 minutes, advancing EV competitiveness
BYD
Chinese EV giant previously demonstrated 9-minute charging capability, competing with CATL's ultra-fast battery techn...
SpaceX
Secured option to acquire AI coding startup Cursor for $60 billion ahead of planned IPO
Cursor
AI coding startup with $60 billion acquisition option from SpaceX, previously rebuffed offers from major AI companies
Amazon
Rolling out program to deliver Novo Nordisk's Wegovy and Eli Lilly's Mounjaro GLP-1 pills for as little as $25/month
Novo Nordisk
Wegovy weight loss drug now available through Amazon's new pharmaceutical delivery program
Eli Lilly
Mounjaro GLP-1 medication now available through Amazon's pharmaceutical delivery program
Hims and Hers
Stock pulled back following Amazon's announcement of competing weight loss drug delivery program
Weight Watchers
Stock declined after Amazon entered weight loss drug market with lower-cost delivery option
Boeing
Scheduled to report earnings alongside IBM and Southwest Airlines
Tesla
Set to report earnings this afternoon, with Elon Musk's company facing market scrutiny
IBM
Scheduled to report earnings alongside Boeing and Southwest Airlines
Southwest Airlines
Scheduled to report earnings alongside Boeing and IBM
AT&T
Providing updates this morning as part of earnings season coverage
BWX Technologies
US enriched uranium company up 160% in the last year, benefiting from energy security focus
Albemarle
Lithium producer up 260% in the last year as alternative energy supply gains investor interest
John Deere
Evolved from agricultural specialist to technology and network company, attracting investor interest
Caterpillar
Industrial company mentioned as non-tech investment opportunity with strong fundamentals
Philip Morris International
Sponsor discussing investment in American manufacturing and community support initiatives
People
James Uthmeyer
Leading criminal investigation into OpenAI's ChatGPT role in Florida State University mass shooting
Ben Kumar
Behavioral finance expert discussing retail investor psychology driving market gains amid geopolitical uncertainty
Luke Vargas
Hosts WSJ What's News AM edition and conducts interview with Ben Kumar on market behavior
Terrell Wright
Covered Virginia congressional redistricting measure and its impact on House majority dynamics
Hannah Arendt-Lang
Co-reported on S&P 500 gains during geopolitical crises and market resilience patterns
David Huberti
Co-reported on S&P 500 gains during geopolitical crises and market resilience patterns
Dalvin Brown
Reported on financial realities of divorce including housing market complications and lifestyle adjustments
Elon Musk
SpaceX secured $60 billion option to acquire AI coding startup Cursor ahead of planned IPO
Donald Trump
Extended ceasefire with Iran while maintaining port blockade; pushed Republican states to redraw congressional maps
Quotes
"ChatGPT advised the shooter on what time of day would be appropriate for the shooting to interact with more people and where on campus would be the place to encounter a higher population."
James Uthmeyer, Florida Attorney GeneralOpening segment
"If it was a person on the other end of that screen, we would be charging them with murder."
James Uthmeyer, Florida Attorney GeneralOpening segment
"This is crowd psychology. This is maybe five, six, seven, eight years of people buying the dip. And now they don't even wait for the dip. They see the bad headline and they hit buy immediately."
Ben Kumar, Seven Investment ManagementMarket discussion
"We don't have an informational edge. No one knows what Trump or Iran is going to do. We don't have an analytical edge because there's not much information to analyze and we haven't got better models."
Ben Kumar, Seven Investment ManagementMarket discussion
"The current housing market complicates it for people who are going through divorce or wanting to go through divorce."
Dalvin Brown, Wall Street JournalDivorce segment
Full Transcript
Find your perfect home on Realtor.com. The perfect home in the perfect neighborhood, in the perfect school district, perfectly close to work, but perfectly far enough away to escape to. With over half a million new listings every month on Realtor.com, you won't miss out on your perfectly perfect home. Trust the number one site Real Estate Professionals Trust. Search now on Realtor.com. Based on average new for sale and rental listings July 2024 through June 2025. Number one trusted based on August 2025 proprietary survey among real estate professionals. Florida probes open AI over messages between ChatGPT and a mass shooter. Now, of course, ChatGPT is not a person, but that does not absolve our office, my prosecution team, of our duty to investigate whether or not there is criminal culpability here for a corporation. Plus, imagine charging your EV in six and a half minutes. Battery maker CATL says that'll soon be a reality. And future Iran peace talks may be in doubt. But nobody told investors. We'll look at the enthusiasm fueling yet more market records. It's Wednesday, April 22nd. I'm Luke Vargas for The Wall Street Journal. And here is the AM edition of What's News. The top headlines and business stories moving your world today. In one of the first attempts to hold an AI company criminally liable for deaths, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeyer is probing ChatGPT's role in a mass shooting at Florida State University last year that left two people dead. Here was Uthmeyer yesterday, courtesy of WTVT. Chat GPT advised the shooter on what time of day would be appropriate for the shooting to interact with more people and where on campus would be the place to encounter a higher population. My prosecutors have looked at this and they've told me if it was a person on the other end of that screen, we would be charging them with murder. The suspect in the shooting has pleaded not guilty to charges of murder and attempted murder. The shooting is one in a string of incidents in which users consulted with chatbots before carrying out acts of violence or self-harm. A spokeswoman for OpenAI said the company doesn't believe that ChatGPT was responsible for the shooting and that it continues to cooperate with authorities on the case. Earlier this year, the company said it was implementing more flexible criteria for referring accounts to law enforcement agencies following a school shooting in British Columbia. In a potential boost for Democrats nationwide, voters in Virginia have narrowly approved a measure to redraw the state's congressional map. Virginia's U.S. House delegation is split almost evenly, with six House Democrats to five Republicans, but new districting lines would shift that to a dominant 10-to-1 Democratic advantage. It's a swing that the journal's Terrell Wright says is substantial enough to chip away at Republicans' current five-seat House majority, even if the lines will be redrawn again in five years. Tuesday yes result will give Democrats an extra four seats in the U House of Representatives helping solidify their chances of winning back control of the chamber this fall in the midterm elections Mid redistricting efforts are taking place in other states like Florida but Virginia measure is among the most consequential according to election analysts. President Trump pushed for Republican states to redraw their congressional maps in the GOP's favor. While states like Texas redistricted their congressional maps to add Republican seats, voters in states like California voted to add Democratic seats, offsetting Republican gains. Despite last night's vote, the redistricting push isn't set in stone just yet, as Virginia's Supreme Court considers whether the legislature broke procedural rules, a case that could render last night's results meaningless. Iran has attacked a container ship near the Strait of Hormuz, causing heavy damage just hours after President Trump extended a ceasefire with the country. Trump didn't set an end for the truce and said that the U.S. would keep blockading Iran's ports until its leaders got serious about wanting to end the conflict once and for all. And yet, looking at U.S. markets lately, you'd be forgiven for saying, no peace talks, no problem. The journals Hannah Arendt-Lang and David Huberti report that four of the S&P 500's five biggest daily gains of the year have come during the war, with potentially more to come, as futures point to U.S. market gains today. To discuss this, I'm joined by Ben Kumar, the head of strategy at Seven Investment Management. Ben, you've got a specialty in behavioral finance, which is an apt perspective, I think, to bring in here because it's vibes sustaining investors now. Investors sort of seemingly unaffected by daily news or by concerns around fundamentals. Yeah. So fundamentals, let's start there because it's boring. The world wasn't broken before Iran. It's not broken yet, and companies are still making money. So you could make the case that investors are behaving very sensibly and rationally and taking a 10-year view. But we all know that's never happened in the past. So what's going on here? I don't think this is fundamental. I think this is crowd psychology. This is maybe five, six, seven, eight years of people buying the dip. And now they don't even wait for the dip. They see the bad headline and they hit buy immediately. Now, I did a quick search on Google Trends for Iran and when the interest peaked and when it's faded. And you can literally see a direct inverse correlation as interest in Iran or Straits of Hormuz, you can pick your term, declines. The S&P 500 just ticks back up and up and up and hits its all-time high. And I think part of the psychology side is that people see other people making money in spite of the headlines, in spite of the fear, and they think, I want a piece of that as well. And the final point, you can do it on an app. To be clear, when you refer to these people, investors, are we talking about retail investors? Because I feel like if they're the ones sustaining it's a, that's a big deal in and of itself, but two, they're going to have a different risk appetite. Maybe their experience in the markets is very different from a professional portfolio manager who's actually weathered true downturns in the past. So every institutional manager I speak to, and including ourselves, everyone's reaction to this has been wait and see, right? We've got no edge. I think it was either Buffett or Munger said, you can have an informational edge, an analytical edge, or a behavioral edge. We don't have an informational edge. No one knows what Trump or Iran is going to do. We don't have an analytical edge because there's not much information to analyze and we haven't got better models. And our behavioral edge is just sitting here and doing nothing and waiting. So I think most institutional investors are doing nothing The average retail participation in the US stock market is up to about 30 30 retail participation That pretty serious right So there is more money moving around that's maybe slightly less informed. And when it comes to risk tolerance, I think quite a lot of investors using great apps like Robin Hood, they probably don't know what the words risk tolerance means, right? We talk about risk tolerance and we talk about volatility. They think you press this button and you get the chance to win some money. Although I do see those stories coming around of people put their whole savings into one stock. That worries me. But there is this idea that you can invest and if you've got the fortitude for it, you'll end up at the other side of it a little bit richer. And an underlying assumption here, Ben, seems to be that the current administration just isn't going to let the US stock market fail. Are people necessarily wrong to think that? I mean, they haven't been wrong so far would be my gut instinct. And there are a lot of great American companies that people can get really, really excited about that are not in the tech space, whether it's defense companies like Boeing, whether it's some of the industrial companies, Caterpillar and so on. John Deere. John Deere is a fascinating one. I could talk for hours about John Deere. Moved from an agricultural specialist to basically a technology and network company. People can get really excited about them. And I think people are looking for these long-term themes that have good narratives behind them. So I've been banging on about uranium stocks, for example, for the last three years, and no one's kind of taken much notice. But now people are thinking about energy security. They are. So there's a company called BWX Technologies, which is in the US, does enriched uranium, is up 160% in the last year. Or Albemarle, who do lithium, an alternative energy supply, they're up something like 260% in the last year. There are these narratives out there that people can cling on to that aren't about AI. They're a bit more tangible. So it's not just AI, big tech. It's, OK, what else is there that I believe matters? Ben Kumar is the head of strategy at Seven Investment Management. Ben, a pleasure. Thank you so much for being with us on What's News. Thanks so much. Coming up, SpaceX tries to catch up with the giants of AI by securing its own AI coding tool. And we'll look at the financial realities of divorce after the break. How are the U.S. businesses of Philip Morris International invested in America? We're invested in advancing science, giving adults who smoke better options. We're invested in American manufacturing, helping local economies thrive. We're invested in community, supporting military veterans and their families, disaster relief, and economic empowerment. Because we're proud to be invested in America. See how at USPMI.com. If you've already got an Amazon cart going, why not put your weight loss drugs in it? Amazon is rolling out a program to let shoppers get Novo Nordisk's WeGovi and Eli Lilly's Foundao GLP-1 pills for as little as $25 a month with insurance, saying it thinks reliable delivery to patients will help them stay on their medication. Several companies in the weight loss market, including Hims and Hers and Weight Watchers, saw their stocks pull back after the announcement The battle for ultra EV charging is heating up with CATL last night rolling out a new battery that it says can almost fully charge up in under seven minutes topping a roughly nine charge shown off by Chinese EV giant BYD last month Analysts at Bernstein say the breakthroughs have effectively closed the gap between EVs and cars equipped with internal combustion engines. Elon Musk's SpaceX says it's secured an option to buy AI coding startup Cursor for $60 billion ahead of a planned IPO for SpaceX that's likely to fill up its coffers. The potential future tie-up could give SpaceX an additional arrow in its quiver as tech companies scramble to respond to customer interest in productivity-boosting coding tools. We previously reported that Cursor had rebuffed acquisition interest from a number of major AI companies last year. And another Musk property, Tesla, is set to report earnings this afternoon alongside IBM and Southwest Airlines. And before that, we'll get updates this morning from Boeing and AT&T. And finally, lawyers are expensive, but they're only the tip of the iceberg when unwinding a marriage. This week, The Wall Street Journal is exploring the cost of divorce. And for many people going through one today, years of stubborn inflation, high interest rates, and soaring home prices mean that the financial landscape looks a lot different than it did before they were married. Personal finance reporter Dalvin Brown spoke to divorced couples who've also had to break up with a lifestyle that they've gotten used to. The current housing market complicates it for people who are going through divorce or wanting to go through divorce. I looked at some data that suggested that there are a lot of invisible divorces that are happening in households where people don't make a ton of money or feel like they maybe can't support themselves as an individual. So then they still stay together. What I also saw was that people may have gotten married or bought their house when interest rates were better. And so now interest rates are higher. They're like, oh, I would be paying twice as much for half the house. The main person that I spoke with had a huge house when she was married. I think it was five bedrooms. She had a room specifically for her Peloton. And then when she divorced, the housing market was totally different. And she wound up paying more for her rent than she was paying toward her mortgage. To read more, we've left a link to the journal's Cost of Divorce series in our show notes. And that's it for What's News for this Wednesday morning. Today's show was produced by Hattie Moyer and Daniel Bach, Our supervising producer is Sandra Killhoff, and I'm Luke Vargas for The Wall Street Journal. We will be back tonight with a new show. And until then, thanks for listening. The Capital Ideas Podcast.