Morning Wire

How Girlhood Became a Product

12 min
Jun 14, 2026about 1 month ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Author Freya India discusses her book 'Girls: Generation Z and the Commodification of Everything,' arguing that social media and consumer culture have transformed girls into products. She explores how the collapse of traditional institutions like family, community, and religion created a vacuum that tech companies exploited with simulations of human connection.

Insights
  • Social media platforms didn't create insecurity in girls—they filled a pre-existing vacuum left by weakened families, communities, and religious institutions
  • Girls perform their entire lives publicly from puberty onward, managing reputation and image constantly, which differs fundamentally from previous generations' private coming-of-age experiences
  • Industries profiting from female insecurity (beauty, wellness, therapy, social media) use language of loneliness and belonging to position themselves as replacements for human connection
  • Young people increasingly attribute their suffering to personal disorders rather than recognizing systemic and environmental causes of their distress
  • Generational lack of exposure to stable relationships, in-person communities, and religious institutions creates fewer models for healthy adult life
Trends
Commodification of adolescence and emotional vulnerability as a business modelMental health professionalization replacing family and community support systemsOnline performance culture as a primary driver of anxiety in young womenInstitutional collapse creating market opportunities for tech and wellness companiesGenerational gap in understanding community—older generations unaware young people have never experienced in-person religious or neighborhood communitiesDepiction of gender relations online contributing to relationship pessimism among youthReplacement of human connection with professional intervention and medicationSocial media as primary source of relationship and community models for Gen Z
Topics
Generation Z mental health and anxietySocial media impact on adolescent girlsCommodification of girlhood and adolescenceInstitutional decline (family, community, religion)Online performance and reputation managementBeauty and wellness industry targeting young womenMental health professionalization and over-diagnosisLoneliness epidemic in young peopleGender relations and relationship pessimismConsumer culture exploitation of insecurityAbsence of in-person community experiencesTechnology as substitute for human connectionTherapy and mental health industry incentivesPornography's role in shaping relationship expectationsIntergenerational differences in social experience
Companies
Instagram
Discussed as primary platform where girls perform relationships, community, and identity from puberty onward
Reddit
Mentioned as online substitute for in-person community that young people experience instead of real neighborhoods
People
Freya India
Author of 'Girls: Generation Z and the Commodification of Everything' discussing commodification of girlhood
Georgia Howe
Co-host of Morning Wire conducting interview with Freya India
John Bickley
Executive editor of Daily Wire and co-host of Morning Wire
Quotes
"We have had our families break down. We don't know our neighbours. We don't have communities. So we don't have any of these anchors. And that is why I think when the social media platforms came in, they really destroyed young women because they offered substitutes and simulations of these things that we didn't have in the first place."
Freya IndiaEarly in interview
"We're performing everything for other people. So we're performing our first relationships, our first crushes, even if we have a heartbreak and a breakup, we're having to post that online and kind of manage our reputation and our image."
Freya IndiaMid-interview
"They're actually bad incentives with this new version. So for example, the therapy companies were almost offering a replacement for friends and family. They were saying that they could give us advice through coming of age."
Freya IndiaMid-interview
"Young people who have been put through so much, so much change in the world and then are thinking that they're the problem and getting diagnosed with a disorder."
Freya IndiaMid-interview
"There's been a lot of young men who are worried about the girlfriends or their sisters or women in their lives and want to help. And I think if you scroll through Twitter, you wouldn't expect that. But I think it is happening."
Freya IndiaClosing remarks
Full Transcript
I feel like I'm getting robbed when I bet the Stanley Cup on a sports book. Dude, to lead that up, you need to be using Poly Market. Poly Market? Poly Market is a prediction market, not a sports book. You trade against other fans, not the house. That means more money for you and less for greedy sports books. Even during the Stanley Cup? Especially during the Stanley Cup. Poly Market is an official prediction market of the NHL. No way. What's the catch? No catch. It's available in all 50 states. Poly Market is so confident you'll never go back. They're giving you $50 free on your first trade. I'm deleting my sports book app. How do I get started? Download Poly Market now and use promo code DRAW for $50 free for your first trade. Stop letting sports books steal from you. Download Poly Market and use promo code DRAW for $50 free on your first trade. Use promo code DRAW. Trading unavailable in all jurisdictions. Check local regulations before trading. All restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. We have had our families break down. We don't know our neighbours. We don't have communities. So we don't have any of these anchors. And that is why I think when the social media platforms came in, they really destroyed young women because they offered substitutes and simulations of these things that we didn't have in the first place. That was author Freya India discussing her new book, Girls, Generation Z and the commodification of everything. India argues that the deeper story is how technology, social media and modern consumer culture have transformed girls from people into products and turned nearly every aspect of adolescence into something to be bought, sold, measured and monetized. Freya joins the podcast today to discuss her new book and the broader issues facing girls today. I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire executive editor John Bickley. This is a weekend episode of Morning Wire. Morning walks, coffee runs, beach days, weekend trips, whatever it is for you this summer, you'll end up reaching for the same comfortable clothes again and again. That is unless you pick up something new from Fabletics. Then you'll reach for that. I just picked up running and even in the early mornings it is such a hot and sweaty endeavor. So having something from Fabletics has been a total game changer for my routine. The materials are soft and breathable and have pockets which is really helpful so there's no more running with keys in my hand. One thing I love about Fabletics beyond the material is that it makes refreshing your summer wardrobe way less expensive. When you sign up as a new VIP you get 70-80% off everything. Fabletics makes it easy to stock up on athleisure and everyday summer staples like linen pieces and this quality has totally blown me away. What I like most is how easy everything is to wear. You can throw on a matching set for a workout, errands, travel days or just being out and about and still feel put together. Shop now at fabletics.com slash wire to get 70-80% off everything when you sign up as a new VIP. Take a quick style quiz and be sure to select wire when prompted to unlock this offer. This is a limited time offer so don't wait. Again that's fabletics.com slash wire for 70-80% off everything as a new VIP. Spring is here and your yard probably needs some love after winter. Our sponsor Fast Growing Trees is America's largest and most trusted online nursery with thousands of trees and plants and over 2 million happy customers. Think of it as your local nursery available anywhere with a bigger selection than you'll find anywhere else. From fruit and privacy trees to flowering varieties, shrubs and house plants, every plant is worth growing with care and guaranteed to arrive healthy. Simply click, order and grow to create your dream yard with options that fit your climate, space and lifestyle. I ordered two Bambino Fiddlely figs so they're small but they are so adorable and they arrived in beautiful condition. Healthy, happy and my living room is forever changed. They're alive and thrive guarantee ensures your plants arrive happy and healthy. Back my ongoing support from trained plant experts to help you plan, choose and care for your new greenery. Right now they have great deals on spring planting essentials up to half-off on select plants. And listeners to our show get 20% off their first purchase when using the code wire at checkout. That's an additional 20% off better plants and better growing at fastgrowingtrees.com using the code wire at checkout. Fastgrowingtrees.com code wire. Now is the perfect time to plant. Let's grow together. Use wire to save today. Offer is valid for a limited time, terms and conditions may apply. Joining us now to discuss the book is author Freya India. Freya thanks for coming on. Thank you so much for having me. Now the title of your book is Girls with a little trademark symbol. What does that symbol represent and when did you start to feel that girls were being turned into products rather than just growing up? Yeah, I wanted to basically have some kind of concept for how radically different girls experience the world today and see themselves versus previous generations. And my argument in the book is yes, that we've become something more like products. And honestly, I just felt that way growing up. I felt that so much of my anxiety was to do with marketing myself online, marketing my relationships, basically figuring out all of the stress of growing up but doing it publicly on Instagram. Now, you make an important distinction in the book that girls have always struggled with insecurity and fitting in of course every female listener and probably most male listeners will agree with that. Just the challenge of finding your place in the world as you grow up. What do you think makes the experience of growing up today fundamentally different than what previous generations dealt with? I think mostly we're performing everything for other people. So we're performing our first relationships, our first crushes, even if we have a heartbreak and a breakup, we're having to post that online and kind of manage our reputation and our image. And we're doing this from a very young age from puberty. And so sometimes people say to me, why do young women make these certain decisions? Why do girls behave this way? And I think a lot of the time it really makes sense if you think about where we've grown up. We've grown up on these platforms where we're being rated and reviewed by other people all of the time and that influences how we view ourselves and what we value. And it influences our future as well, what decisions we make, the relationships we have. It's all to do with performing for other people. And I think that it might look vain to older generations and to men, but I think for women it really is insecurity and it's an exhausting way to live. Now a lot of people are going to point to smartphones and social media and say, well, there you go. There's the cause. It's not rocket science. But you argue that those technologies are only part of the larger story. What aspects do you think people are missing? So I think really two things happened to my generation. So decades before the smartphone, we were having so many of our foundations and our grounding being taken away. And so our families were falling apart. We had collapsing communities. We were less religious in previous generations. And so I think we had so little to hold on to. And then when social media platforms came along, they provided these perfect simulations of things that we'd never experienced in the first place. And so our first experience of community was on Instagram or our first experience of relationships was from online porn. And so I think we had this vacuum that companies were ready to feel and exploit. Now one theme throughout the book is that industries increasingly are profiting from girls insecurities, whether it's beauty or wellness or therapy or just social media apps in general. When did you start to suspect that some of these institutions that were actually claiming to help young women were also benefiting from their distress? I think because, like I said, it was a lot of simulations being sold to us. And I almost just started to realize that this was not the real thing. They're actually bad incentives with this new version. So for example, the therapy companies were almost offering a replacement for friends and family. They were saying that they could give us advice through coming of age. They could help us with dating. They could do all of these things that parents used to do. And all throughout the book, I talk about these companies that use the language of loneliness and belonging because they know that's what young girls and young men are feeling. They really desperately want to belong somewhere. And so we have social media companies and porn companies in the mental health industry all offering their alternatives to human connection. People really underestimate how much young people think that their problems can be solved through professional intervention or even medication. And so I think a lot of the institutions and the foundations we spoke about that have fallen apart or stepped back, we've replaced them with professionals and experts. And so you have young people who have been put through so much, so much change in the world and then are thinking that they're the problem and getting diagnosed with a disorder. So I think it really is the worst two things happening at the same time where young people are really suffering, but then they're being told that they're suffering because they think wrong with them. Now, the book talks a lot about loneliness and disconnection. What do you think the primary driver for this loneliness epidemic is for your generation? I think it's a few things. I would say that obviously we're spending more time on screens, more time simulating, being in person together and replacing human interaction. But also there's the background to that. There's growing up in unstable families. There's just a sense as well, I think, that relationships can't last. I think for a lot of young women and young men, they haven't actually seen stable relationships. And so it's then magnified by growing up online where you see these really depressing takes on men and women. You see men and women more divided than ever. You might grow up watching online porn and your version of relationships is just so depressing. And I think we just have way fewer examples of a life than previous generations once did. Now, you've argued that, of course, there's the technology that came up with your generation and mine as well to some degree, but also that institutions weakened at the same time. Which institutions do you feel were the linchpins holding things together that have become weaker at this point? Yeah, I think there's a few. I think that older generations don't quite realize how little experience my generation has of community. So we don't know our neighbors. We haven't had that experience. All we really think about when we think about community is Instagram and Reddit and all of these online substitutes. And then you think of something like a religious community that a lot of older generations would have grown up in or around. And for my generation, we've never experienced anything like it. And sometimes I talk to conservatives and they have no idea that there's young people who have literally never stepped into a church or spoken to a Christian or had any experience of an in-person community where you meet up every week and you're expected to have obligations to one another. I think that we've had so few practice of socializing with people and having to turn up to something. Now, you've obviously written about all the things that have gone wrong. Is there anything that gives you hope for this next generation? Yeah, I think actually the response to the book has given me hope. I think that when I was growing up, I often just thought this is just me struggling with these things. I've been really reassuring to have young women say they've also felt so anxious and not quite had the language to describe why. And also having a response from young men. There's been a lot of young men who are worried about the girlfriends or their sisters or women in their lives and want to help. And I think if you scroll through Twitter, you wouldn't expect that. But I think it is happening. We are starting to care about each other. Freya, thank you so much for coming on and talking about this. Thank you so much. I really loved it. That was Freya India discussing her new book Girls Generation Z and the commodification of everything. And this has been a Weekend Edition of Oney Wire. Who helps America go farther? Fly higher. Dream even bigger. People do. Since 1879, our people have been more than a source of energy. They've been a source of progress. Today, that same progress is helping deliver record U.S. energy production. Fueling the workers, the makers, the boundary pushers and risk takers who spark the breakthroughs that move America forward. Learn more about what our people do at chevron.com slash USA 250.