Otherworld

The Life of John Dee [Patreon Preview]

12 min
Apr 1, 202617 days ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

This Otherworld Patreon episode explores the life of John Dee, a 16th-century English polymath, mathematician, and advisor to Queen Elizabeth I who blended science, magic, and alchemy. The hosts draw parallels between Dee's influence on historical decision-making and modern concerns about outsourcing critical decisions to poorly understood technologies like AI-guided military systems.

Insights
  • Historical decision-making by powerful figures based on poorly understood esoteric knowledge mirrors modern reliance on AI systems we don't fully comprehend for critical military and strategic choices
  • Intellectual reputation and expertise can provide protection and advancement even during politically dangerous periods, as demonstrated by Dee's survival through multiple regime changes
  • The blurred lines between science, religion, and magic in the 16th century created space for polymaths to influence major historical events in ways that would be impossible in more specialized modern contexts
  • Personal relationships and institutional positioning (tutoring royal children, becoming a chaplain) provided more security than formal court titles during unstable political transitions
Trends
Outsourcing critical decisions to non-human or poorly understood sources creates similar risks across historical and modern contextsIntellectual authority and specialized expertise serve as protective mechanisms during political instabilityThe convergence of multiple knowledge domains (science, mathematics, spirituality) creates unique influence opportunitiesPersonal networks and informal advisory roles often provide more power and longevity than formal positionsReputational management and strategic positioning are essential for surviving regime changes and political purges
People
John Dee
16th-century English scholar who served as trusted advisor to Queen Elizabeth I and influenced major historical decis...
Queen Elizabeth I
English queen who relied on John Dee as a trusted advisor for navigation, cartography, and astrological matters
King Edward VI
11-year-old English king who granted John Dee a pension and court position after being presented with astrology books
Queen Mary I
Catholic queen known as Bloody Mary who persecuted Protestants; John Dee was imprisoned for calculating her horoscope
Jack Wagner
Host of the Otherworld podcast discussing John Dee's life and drawing parallels to modern AI decision-making
Wolf Fleetwood Ross
Extensively researched John Dee's life and serves as primary educator on the historical figure in this episode
John Dudley
Most important person at court during Edward VI's reign; John Dee became his advisor and tutor to his children
Edward Bonner
High-ranking advisor to Queen Mary who rooted out Protestants; became John Dee's employer as personal chaplain
King Henry VIII
Father of Mary and Elizabeth; his divorce from Catherine of Aragon set events in motion affecting John Dee's life
Quotes
"This was back in a time when science, religion, and magic sometimes weren't all that different from each other."
Jack WagnerOpening
"Outsourcing major decisions to a third party nonhuman source that we don't fully understand yet."
Jack WagnerMid-episode
"It was thought of as like NSA spying basically, you know."
Wolf Fleetwood RossMid-episode
"He snitched. He had to have done a huge medieval, or I guess post medieval snitching."
Jack WagnerLate episode
Full Transcript
Welcome to the Otherworld Patreon. I'm your host, Jack Wagner. In this episode, I am once again joined by Wolf Fleetwood Ross to dive into the life of a historical figure who had a profound influence on all of the things that we cover on Otherworld. This time, we're talking about John Dee. John Dee was born in 1527. He is a preeminent English polymath, mathematician, and astronomer who served as a trusted advisor to Queen Elizabeth I. John Dee was many, many things as you're about to hear. But I feel like the simplest way to explain him is that he's the real life inspiration for the medieval scholar, magician, or wizard archetype that you've probably seen replicated in so many books, TV shows, and movies. John Dee was that. This was back in a time when science, religion, and magic sometimes weren't all that different from each other. And during that time, John Dee made significant contributions to navigation and cartography that helped lay the groundwork for the British Empire. However, he spent much of his life pursuing alchemy and having angelic conversations, believing that the secrets of the universe can be unlocked through mathematics and the supernatural. And you're about to hear all about it. Part of what makes John Dee's story so interesting is that this took place over 400 years ago, and humans didn't know as much about the world and how it works. So it's fun to hear about the Queen of England and other powerful people relying on this strange man who's using alchemy and divination to make extremely critical decisions that affect the course of history for the entire world. But recently, after recording these episodes, I started thinking that we've begun seeing militaries use artificial intelligence, not only to navigate bombs, but even to choose targets. That's very frightening to me, but it's also not that different at all from what we're talking about in this episode. Outsourcing major decisions to a third party nonhuman source that we don't fully understand yet. So I think these episodes accidentally ended up being very relevant to our modern times. And maybe things aren't so different right now after all. I barely knew anything about John Dee before making this episode. Luckily, I have Wolf, who spent tons of time researching him, reading every book he could find about it. And he is here now joining me in this two-part episode to do his best to educate me on the very surreal life of John Dee. Previously, we did episodes on Jack Parsons and Alistair Crowley, and I feel like John Dee is the perfect figure to complete this trilogy. So this is the life of John Dee, part one, and you're listening to the Otherworld Patreon. If you want to hear the full version of this episode and the second part when it comes out, you could sign up at patreon.com slash otherworld. So Dee is in the low countries in, not called the Netherlands yet, but you know, he's getting this reputation as a map maker, an astronomer, a mathematician. He would even get so big that kings from other kingdoms, big ones, would send him letters to offer him positions in their court, and he would turn them all down, and he would live to regret that. So in the 1550s, he's in Paris, he's lecturing on Euclid's elements, which imagine this, like that was like packed hall, that was maybe the punk band of the night, was Dee, like they had to usher people back from the hall because everyone was trying to get into his lecture on Euclid's elements. That sounds great. Yeah, his presence is growing, and he's ready to come back to England and sort of like claim his spot as a top philosopher in England or a top intellectual, and he finds England much changed. Obviously, King Henry has died and put his very, very young son, King Edward on the throne, who's 11 at this time, and who's famously dangle off the throne. And Dee gets an audience with him, presents him with two books about theories on astrology that are extremely complicated. The 11 year old. Yes. Like presents them like. He's like playing peek-a-boo. Yeah, does not understand it. And fame like does not know what is going on in these books. But he gives John Dee a pension and a small role at the court, sort of like helping with maps and minor astrological matters. If there was a comet, he would be the one that was called in to sort of talk about it. And funnily enough, even though Dee would have a much closer relationship with future Queens, he will never get this high in court again. So this is this is as high as he goes. The 11 year old just liked the cut of his jib. Yeah, basically. Honestly, that's probably better in some ways. No. And if King Edward had just stayed, I mean, John Dee probably would have had a fairly normal life. We would not be talking about him. So then after getting his pension and his small place at court, it's kind of confusing. John Dee goes to work for John Dudley, who is protectorate of the king, and he becomes an advisor to him as well as tutor of his children. So while his role at the court is small and his pension is small, he's ingratiated with the most important people. He's teaching their children. The future is probably looking really bright until King Edward died, basically. How old was he when he died? I think off the top of my head, he was probably 14, 14 or 15. Oh, he died from tuberculosis. He was heard praying, Lord God, deliver me out of this miserable and wretched life and defend this realm from papistry and maintain thy true religion. Okay, so yeah, he did not want this to go back to the pope. No, no. So if you'll remember, King Henry split the church. His first wife was Catherine, who he had a daughter with called Mary, and he divorced Mary's mother and had subsequent marriages. So Mary probably feeling pretty fucking angry about everything that's happened in her life. And Mary is next in line for the crown. Mary is a Catholic. She will become to be known as Bloody Mary because she will unleash a war basically on everyone who has done her wrong in the court, who is mean to her mother, who sided with her father. Like it is a crazy shakeup. Separated them to King Henry would not let the daughter see the mother ever again until they died because he was terrified of Spain taking them or them escaping in some way. Like Mary had a really, I mean, everyone kind of had a rough go of it, but Mary really had a bad time after her dad divorced her mother. So she's very angry. And now she is like in complete control of the levers of power. She brings back a lot of Catholic rituals, but doesn't go back to the pope. She puts back the cross and the decorations and a lot of churches, and she starts burning people at the stake. Yeah, that's, yeah, that's why she's known as Bloody Mary. I think she'll burn around 350 people during her reign, roughly. So Dee sort of senses what's going on around him. And he does the only sensible thing when she goes and gets himself ordained as a Catholic priest, even though he's married at the time, which he's not allowed to be. He sort of enters, enters seminary or does it very fast, gets ordained, and just sort of as a please leave me alone. I'm on your side now. He also starts making more plan planetary charts in secret. And he does one for Mary's reign, which is at this time, it is considered treasonous spying to do charts about monarchs. To his credit, he does call a sort of calamitous short horrible reign for Mary and a great new age for Elizabeth, Mary's sister, who will enter the story in a little bit. Does he keep this secret or is he presenting it to her? No, he's keeping it secret. There are rumors that he might have done it with future Queen Elizabeth, but those are unsubstantiated. He's definitely telling people that he's doing this but he's telling the wrong people because over the next couple months, his sort of like intelligentsia friends will get arrested and will squeal on him. So unfortunately, somehow someone told the Queen about the horoscopes and the planetary charts and he gets taken to Hampton Court and put in solitary confinement. He was charged with calculating and conjuring the Queen's horoscope. It's treason could lead to death. That's an incredible crime. Yeah, it's a crazy crime to be talking about. Calculating a horoscope is the actual name of the crime. That is really wild. Yeah, well, it was thought of as like NSA spying basically, you know. Yeah. Like there are when our phones are being tapped, that's what they were sort of foreseeing. And then, okay, this is like, you could say we don't know maybe magic. Somehow, he gets out of it. So we like find him in prison on the historical record. And then there was another character called Edward Bonner, who goes by several nicknames, bloody Bonner, bloody Bishop, bloody Baron, all his nicknames have bloody in them. He was quite high up in the court. He was an advisor to Mary. But really what his day to day was is was rooting out a secret Protestants or spies within her court and sort of burning them. And he would have been the guy probably interviewing John D while he was in confinement. So we don't know what happened. But the next time we find John D, he is Edward Bonner's personal chaplain, as well as chaplain to his children. And is potentially living in Edward Bonner's palace. How he pulled this off, we have no idea. He snitched. He had to have done a huge medieval, or I guess post medieval snitching. Somebody who's in there watching, watching John D in the medieval interrogation room eating the equivalent of McDonald's yapping of a storm. He was eating a turkey leg. But I mean, it goes beyond that because then he's like, he's this, he becomes this cops like personal chaplain.