Crowdsourced Fixes Vol. 2
42 min
•Dec 23, 20254 months agoSummary
In this crowdsourced episode, hosts Elizabeth Reese and Marjorie Punnett review listener-submitted fixes for major companies including Carnival, Amazon, USPS, and Uber. The discussion focuses on how companies can better manage loyalty program changes, improve customer convenience, and create personalized experiences while maintaining transparency and accountability with their most loyal customers.
Insights
- Loyalty program changes require transparent communication about the 'why' and a phased implementation approach to avoid alienating best customers
- Personalization at scale is achievable through data-driven tiered benefits menus that let customers choose what matters most to them
- Convenience-driven partnerships (like postal services in grocery stores) can solve real customer pain points while driving foot traffic and revenue
- Companies must deliver on promised loyalty program changes or risk mass customer exodus and permanent trust damage
- Surprise-and-delight rewards combined with functional benefits create stronger emotional loyalty than transactional rewards alone
Trends
Shift from transactional to experiential loyalty programs across travel and delivery industriesRise of customizable loyalty tiers allowing customers to select preferred benefits rather than one-size-fits-all rewardsIntegration of convenience services into existing retail footprints to maximize customer touchpointsData-driven personalization enabling predictive customer service and cross-platform recommendationsCorporate accountability and transparency becoming key differentiators in loyalty program redesignsPhased implementation strategies replacing abrupt loyalty program overhaulsOmnichannel service expansion (e.g., Amazon returns at Whole Foods, postal services in grocery stores)Competition driving innovation in ride-sharing and delivery loyalty structuresCustomer segmentation by usage pattern to build targeted loyalty packagesHybrid reward models combining functional benefits with experiential perks
Topics
Loyalty Program Redesign and GrandfatheringCustomer Communication During Service ChangesPersonalized Rewards and Benefit CustomizationPhased Implementation StrategiesRetail Partnership and Convenience ServicesSurge Pricing Protection in Ride-SharingDelayed Shipping and Inventory ManagementOmnichannel Customer ExperienceData-Driven Personalization at ScaleCorporate Accountability and TrustPorch Piracy and Delivery SecuritySubscription Program Value PropositionCross-Platform Service IntegrationCustomer Segmentation by BehaviorExperiential vs. Transactional Rewards
Companies
Carnival
Loyalty program changed from nights-based to spending-based tiers, alienating platinum/diamond members and driving cu...
Amazon
Discussed for baby registry delayed shipping feature, Prime membership value erosion, and planned 2026 departure from...
United States Postal Service
Facing partnership loss to Amazon, budget cuts, and operational challenges; proposed expansion into grocery store loc...
Uber
Lacks airline-style loyalty tiers; listeners propose bronze-platinum program with surge protection, priority pickup, ...
Whole Foods
Amazon-owned retailer offering convenient return kiosks for Amazon packages, demonstrating successful omnichannel int...
Lyft
Competitor to Uber with personalization features like driver preference selection, showing market differentiation thr...
Staples
Already hosts USPS services in stores; cited as precedent for postal service retail expansion strategy
Aldi
Proposed grocery store partner for USPS mail counter expansion to improve customer convenience
Trader Joe's
Proposed grocery store partner for USPS mail counter expansion to improve customer convenience
Albertsons
Proposed grocery store partner for USPS mail counter expansion to improve customer convenience
Wegmans
Proposed East Coast grocery store partner for USPS mail counter expansion to improve customer convenience
Harris Teeter
Proposed East Coast grocery store partner for USPS mail counter expansion to improve customer convenience
Walmart
Referenced as example of successful front-of-store retail partnerships with multiple service providers
Kroger
Suggested as major grocery chain partner for USPS pilot program expansion
Publix
Suggested as potential grocery chain partner for USPS service expansion
OpenTable
Proposed partnership opportunity for Uber to provide restaurant recommendations and reservations to business travelers
Waymo
Mentioned as emerging competitor in ride-sharing market alongside Uber and Lyft
Uber Eats
Amazon-owned food delivery service; discussed as cross-promotion opportunity for Uber loyalty program expansion
People
Kristen
Carnival frequent cruiser from Austin, Texas; platinum member frustrated by loyalty program changes from nights-based...
Jack Oliphant
Founder and CEO of Oliphant Strategies (Santa Monica); proposed delayed shipping feature for Amazon baby registries
Kathy Seabuck
Founder of MarketExture (San Diego); proposed USPS expansion into grocery stores to improve accessibility and efficiency
Chris
Marketing professional in New York City; proposed airline-style loyalty tiers for Uber with surge protection and prio...
Quotes
"It's a classic case of alienating your best customer base."
Host discussing Carnival's loyalty program changes
"You did everything you asked and then it's still not good enough. You changed it on me."
Host describing customer sentiment on loyalty program changes
"It's not necessarily also makes the person who's been a loyal customer like Kristen feel very good, right? Because it's kind of a surprise."
Host on importance of communication in loyalty program changes
"The ultimate test is always that so what? And we've used that question a lot... does this make my life better? My relationship better with this brand stronger?"
Host on evaluating company changes
"Moving from transactional, which is what it feels like right now... versus now you're getting to know me as the customer and you're providing me with a well-rounded, full experience."
Host on evolution of loyalty programs
Full Transcript
Hey, I'm Elizabeth Reese. And I'm Marjorie Punnett. We host a podcast. It's called Best to the Nest. If you want to bring love, balance, and joy to your home, relationships, or parenting, listen, we do too. We want your home to be your favorite place to be. We bring in experts to guide us along the way. We also chat about pop culture and how it plays in our lives. So learn and laugh along with us as you bring your best to your nest. Best to the Nest, the podcast that brings you home. Get it wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to We Fixed It. You're welcome. The show where we take over companies, you come along for the ride, and we try to put them back better than we found them. It's that time of year again. Yeah, it's the holidays. Who cares? It's also the end of our season. So break out the ugly sweaters, because we have a tradition of our own. As fearless fixers, that's us, our work is never done. Things keep breaking, and we keep fixing them. But this time, that's not our problem. We get to relax and put our feet up, because this time, you all did the fixing for us. You picked the companies, share what you'd want to fix about them, and how you'd do it. All we have to do is listen and tell you what we think. I feel up to the challenge. It's fit. All right, let's do it. Before we do, thank you to everyone who submitted a fix to throw at us. We love hearing from you all. Like last time we did this on the show, our producer picks it out for us and whatever we don't get to we may just use on a future episode at the end i'll share how you can send in your own fix if you missed it so yeah let's get straight into it here is our first crowdsource fix hi my name is kristen calling from austin texas and i'm curious about the carnival rewards program changing as a frequent cruiser and somebody who's been loyal to carnival i have reached platinum status and with the new changes carnival is saying that too many people have become platinum and diamond and so they're going now on a reward system where you earn your points based on how much money you're spending not on how loyal you are to the company prior you receive your platinum or diamond status based on how many nights you stayed on the ship. I'm curious how this is going to affect Carnival and reading on social media people are very frustrated about this and are starting to look at other cruise lines and I'm wondering if there could have been a better system for grandfathering in platinum and diamond members to keep their loyalty. I wish that we had been given an opportunity to be more creative instead of just giving us a deadline and the system being only to spend more money. Perhaps they could have taken better care of their customers by all of the people who are platinum and diamond at this point to be able to pick a reward that they're able to use each cruise. My favorite is to be able to board first and also to disembark first at the end of the cruise. If they had been able to say, hey, you're not going to get everything, but we're going to let you pick every time you cruise and keep the platinum status, that would have felt a lot better. All right. So Kristen is willing to make some compromises, say, okay, loyalty programs are getting crowded. I know there's might be some trade-offs and it's a classic case of alienating your best customer base. So what do you think about what Kristen's proposing here? You know, one of the first things that I think about when companies are changing their loyalty programs or increasing fees or all of those things is communicating the why and communicating early so that customers have an opportunity to prepare for it, whether it's financially, emotionally, or otherwise. And so, you know, I'm not super familiar with Carnival's loyalty program, so I can't speak to all of the ins and outs. You know, maybe they did, but, you know, from the company side, that's always the recommendation that I have and the approach that I would take. Again, just helping the customer just prepare, especially now. And I think at any point, customers are always thinking about their wallets and they're also thinking about the loyalty that they've shown to their preferred, again, in this case, cruise line, hotel, credit card, what have you. So just helping them understand the why. You know, maybe there was or is an opportunity. It sounds like this is already rolled out, but I think the other thing is taking some sort of phased approach, I think would be another good opportunity. Again, it kind of eases the customer into what might be happening. And, or the other thing that is a possibility that could be done and I've seen done is saying, okay, customers that have been with us for a long time, we're going to keep it the same for you for this year or even into next year. Again, it gives more time. It gives you time to prepare. that also shows some loyalty. If you're a new customer coming on, here's the new program. But if you've been with us for a number of years, we're going to kind of roll this out or phased approach over the next year so that, again, you've got time to plan. So I thank you of the ways that when I think about helping customers kind of absorb the shock, if you will, of changes that could have gone a long way. I think on the customer side, customers expect changes to happen, whether we like it or not. We expect the changes to happen. But again, I think it's also in the how. It's done and the why. And that goes a long way in communication. I agree 100% communication is non-negotiable. I think you have to be transparent. They obviously have not done a great job of explaining besides the fact that it's going from X to Y. It's not necessarily also makes the person who's been a loyal customer like Kristen feel very good, right? Because it's kind of a surprise. And so I love what you've said, Kadira, about a phased in approach, because I think part of loyalty programs is creating a sense of community, right? You're creating that like, oh, we're like high, we were high volume travelers. We always do this, but, you know, around our big milestones in our lives, graduations and birthdays and things like that. And so it's more, it's more than just miles. It's more than just dollars. So it's really important to kind of understand that that's what drives loyalty. And so I love the idea of sunsetting an old program gracefully, but there has to be that clear communication and transparency about what's in it in the future. And I think that it needs to be more than 10% off. It needs to be more thinking about like, what were the key fundamental pillars of those loyalty programs and what drove people to get into the highest status? You know, I always laugh because also when we've had companies merge and then they've broken up and things like that. And so it really kind of convolutes the loyalty programs when you think about it. Like when you think about an airlines, for example, which is very similar, I think, to the cruises. You know, I remember when somebody got bought and the other people bought them USA or whatever it was. and remember going to like board and there were like nine categories of like diamond platinum sapphire and then it was like this whole other tier like tiger you know cub whatever yeah it didn't even match you know and so by the time like I was like what the I am so confused about when I am supposed to be boarding but like it has to be intentional it has to be thought through And I do think it needs to be focused on the end all client. I love what you said about the why, but I also think for companies, the ultimate test is always that so what? And we've used that question a lot when we've talked about, you know, within our podcast episodes is like, so what? Who cares? Right. And so does this make my life better? My relationship better with this brand stronger? Like what is the purpose of changing things up? And if you can answer that clearly and communicate that with empathy and transparency, guess what? You're going to take care of your customers through the change. Yeah, for sure. Yeah, what consumers and especially loyal customers don't like is that feeling that the rules have changed. You know, I did everything you asked and then it's still not good enough. You know, you changed it on me. So I was, I hit the mileage tier and then I was platinum. But now there's a Sapphire level and you tell me I can't have it. You get that petulant little kid feeling of like, wait a minute, it's not fair. Sure. So if it's an idea, so I do, I like everything you're both saying about a phased approach or clear communication, especially to your most loyal customers. And I, I like what Kristen's saying about the adaptive or adaptable loyalty program. So don't just tell me I can't have that or I can't have any of it or I can't have some of it. Let me know what I can have or let me be a partner in choosing. But so especially like with customer experience and also the logistics of it is a practical to let everyone have these like hyper personalized customized experiences at scale and something like a cruise or an airline like it gets the management of that side. I think it's really tricky to you can mess up there and disappoint on that level too. I totally agree with you, but I do think we're in an age where you can leverage data to personalize those experiences. And I think that what you can also do is offer tiered segmented experiences that are a little different. And the personalization goes more from like just my miles equals X amount of dollars, right? But like having almost like a menu of benefits that you can choose from, I think is the best way to move forward with that. Because you've provided the structure and the framework in that menu, right? Like those are things that you're willing to actually do as a company, but then you're allowing the person to say, yeah, you know what, for me is more important is getting that experience. So like, I want to be invited to a members only experience of a dinner with the chef on the cruise, right? Like I would rather have that than get maybe upgraded to a different cabin. Cause I'm already going to pick the cabin I want. And so again I think having that availability to the choices that are really personalized but also to your point Erin keeping those within the scope of what that business is So if the business is cruises think about that Like what about what are the different kinds of things that you can offer from a loyalty perspective? It's the offshore experiences, right? That this is kind of like the secret menu, you know, people only if you're in this platinum tier for the cruises, are you going to be offered this horseback riding on the beach with a dinner and whatever, whatever. You know, everyone else is going to be going into the marketplace or whatever. So I think that's possible. I think that in today's world, with just the mass amount of data we have, to be able to utilize it that way is something that will really help to drive loyalty and retention. Yeah, totally agree. And my biggest caution is if you come up with a consolation prize or a new evolution of what the rewards look like or what your experience looks like when you can't have something and you feel like it's being taken away from you and then there's a compromise or some kind of agreement that has to stand up like well you know i chose the other experience well we don't offer that anymore we just continue that you know that's where you lose people and they do mass exodus and they say we gave you a chance and now we don't trust you so whatever you come to a new level of understanding with your customers especially your loyal customer base and they say okay now deliver on this new thing you told us about if that doesn't hold their attention if that's not what you agreed to and you don't come through on that, they're out and they have every right to be. Right. It's accountability. We've always talked about that. It's about corporate responsibility and it's about integrity and character that the company carries through. I think that that's really important. And, you know, I think that you often talk about this, Kadira, but like having that understanding of every action you take, every word you say, every inaction you take says something, right? So it's really the responsibility, corporate responsibility of the cruise lines to really do right by these loyal customers, because that's what's gotten them to the profitability that they're at now. That's what's gotten them to the fact that like they have, I mean, they have a good thing. They have like too many people wanting to join their loyalty program. Right. You know, that's a great thing, you know, because they're, I mean, cruises, there have been issues. So like, it's a great thing for them, but this is like a turning point because we've seen this with big companies, with big brands, where they choose maybe an easy route. They choose a route that is not necessarily really aligned to what their moral mission is. And you just, it ends up making things a lot worse. So jump on the opportunity. All right. Thank you, Kristen. And let's go on to our next. Hi, my name is Jack Oliphant, and I am the founder and CEO of Oliphant Strategies, a revenue operations consultancy out of Santa Monica, California. And my big fix is for Amazon's baby registries. You should be able to delay shipping. Not everyone lives in a big house. And for those of us in apartments with limited space for all the generous gifts that our friends and family are able to give us, need a place to store. So instead of having to go out and get a storage unit, I think you should be able to delay shipping by two to three months on Amazon's baby registries. So that's my big fix. What do you think? I think Jack's brought up a very good point. I think it's also not just baby registry. I think it's wedding registries too, right? Any list that's a large gift list, like you think about that, that brings up a really good point. And also with all of the porch pirates these days, like, do you want those things delivered somewhere safe, right? That is a very interesting thing. And with the baby registry, right, and a wedding registry, you get to choose where it gets delivered. So it would be interesting if they said, yeah, for, you know, we would love to just have a list of everything that was purchased so that we can thank everybody. but we would like it delayed because we're moving after we get married or, you know, and we'd love to have that delayed for up to X amount of months. I think that's a great idea. I love that. I love that. Not even if I'm having a baby or getting married. I mean, there's just times where, you know, I need to order something, but maybe I'm traveling, right? I'm going to be out of town and maybe it's not a month's delay. You know, if someone's living in an apartment or like you said, even in a neighborhood, even the safest neighborhood, right? Those porch pirates are, you know, taking things. And so, wow, that would be so cool. I don't know if this exists. I feel like they probably are thinking about this, but like, is there an opportunity? This kind of takes us off the path, but is there an opportunity for like even lockers, right? And maybe they already do this, but you know, maybe for a couple of extra bucks, your packages can go to this locker. Now, probably not for two or three months, right? In the case of like a baby or wedding registry. But like even that in-between time of like, hey, I can't get this at home right now, but I need it to go somewhere and it can't come to my house at this time. So I love that fix. That would be so cool. And I can't imagine they're not working on this. I've seen the lockers. I haven't seen them as much recently. That seemed like a COVID era phenomenon, but I'm sure it's situational dependent of where you live And if it makes sense for you to receive deliveries or pricey deliveries at home versus, you know, somewhere where you can go retrieve it. But yeah, can we take it a step further? And why registries only? Why couldn't we? Amazon has subscribe and save so I can order something now and get it again in three months. What if I want something? I'll pay for it now. Maybe I'll even pay a premium for it now. But I want it Wallachs in stock and I want it in advance of something that I need it for later. And I don't want to think about it later. So I want, you know, I want to make sure that I get it. And it's in my head right now. Why don't I order something and maybe I want it up to a year from now. Could I be a viable customer for that? I mean, I think it's a cool idea. The thing that I'm thinking about on the business side is like how they manage that inventory. And, you know, is it just sitting there? I mean, you paid for it, right? I paid for it. And so if I wanted a six months from now, I want it from a year. I want it, right? Like, I don't want to hear that it's now out of stock because 10 other people or 100 or 1,000 other people have ordered it. And so how companies are going to or would manage, like in this case, Amazon, you know, would manage if you order something a year from now, we're going to make sure that working with Plyer or whatever, that they're going to have it and is going to be available. I think that's going to be an interesting thing that they would have to manage. But again, I love the idea. And again, I don't feel that they are that far off from developing something like this. I do think that they have some personalization of those lists. But to Erin's point, it's an interesting concept about the delayed, like, or even having that as set as a preference, right? So like when we set preferences for communication, we say we want an email or we want snail mail, whatever, whatever. similarly like when we think about porch pirates for example like we could set it up and say we only want deliveries on like the days that you may know that you're actually going to be at your place of residence right so you could say I only want deliveries on Sunday and Monday because that's when I'm actually at my house right I think that would be a very cool thing and I know that like you know on Amazon Prime right now they have it set up structure that like they give you the choices, like the fastest is, you know, tomorrow morning at 5am, which people are like, okay, I guess some people want that. Or you can do it anytime tomorrow, or you can put all your Amazon packages together and deliver them on Amazon Tuesday or whatever the day is, right? So they do give you a little bit of that, but I think that it's not to the point of, you know, personalized to what your actual needs might be. And I really love that because I think that there are a lot of different situations where that could be very helpful. For example, my husband's in a wine club. And so you have to have somebody over 21 to sign when, when they come. And then also, you know, it was the same kind of thing that like when we lived in San Antonio and they would, they would be like, we're not going to send them to you, the wine to you during the summer months, because it's 110 outside and there's no way we can ensure that it's not going to boil. So those are the kinds of things that I think it's an interesting concept. And I think it can be, you know, really set across many. It's just logistically, can they do that? I think they can. I think they're probably already kind of doing that, but not to the nth degree. Yeah. And it's also investing in price features too. You ever go to your Amazon cart and then it says, oh, you have something in your cart and it went up by $7 or it went down by 30 cents or, you know, so if you buy something now, you're kind of locking it in at today's price. And it could be, you know, if you want it seven months from now or in the future, you're playing the long game, I guess, and trying to game the odds by saying, is this commodity going to go up or down from today's price? It's funny because I just saw something online, like literally today. So this is an interesting thing. And somebody posted on social media, they were like, wasn't there a time where a subscription to Amazon Prime meant you got it tomorrow? Because now that's not guaranteed. And so it's like, why are we paying for Amazon Prime again if we're not getting everything tomorrow? Like, that's kind of a good point. We kind of gotten habituated into a way of things. Kind of was, I think it had to, you know, they kind of slipped when COVID happened because everybody was ordering everything online, you know? So it was kind of like, okay, you know, and then it just never went back. Yeah, and Amazon Prime's another one of those loyalty subscriber programs. where you get everything but then you get amazon video but then you get it with ads or you get amazon music but it's very restrictive so we got you in you know and you're part of the but the rules are going to change a little bit and they've been you know they've explained along the way so i'm not faulting them for it what what comes with the base level of prime membership when they introduce prime plus or prime premium and then you start paying more for what you used to have it's a delicate balance but jack we're with you we think uh registry at least delaying the shipment for registry, that's kind of a no-brainer. So we're with you on that. Thank you. All right, we got another Here we go Hey Aaron it Kathy Seabuck the founder of MarketExture located in San Diego So I was reading this week that Amazon is planning to cut ties with the U Postal Service in 2026 because they now going to be delivering their own packages We all know that the post office has been struggling for decades. The lines are long, they rarely have enough staff, and when you go there, it's usually not the best experience. Now add on to that the federal cuts this year, and if this partnership is going to go south, that's only going to be another blow. So here's an idea. Maybe the post office needs to expand its partnerships with local grocery stores. They're already in Staples. So now maybe just add Aldi or Trader Joe's or Albertsons or if you're on the East Coast, Wegmans, Harris Teeter, pick one and set up a mail counter in the grocery store. So just like you would have staff to do a cashier checkout, then you could rotate that staff to actually manage the mail counter. I know as a small business owner, I have to mail out at least one or two packages a month. Definitely get stamps and anything else from the post office. So why not do all of that while I'm grocery shopping? Saves me time, gas, and a trip. So food for thought. I'm curious to hear what you think. I was going to say, I mean, there are, I think it's Walmart, for example. I mean, if you go in any of the big box stores or like a Walmart, they do have kind of that front of the store concept where you've got other retailers set up. And so, yeah, what's stopping the post office from also, you know, using some of that space? And I love the idea of like, hey, if I'm already in here shopping and I don't want to drive across town to go and wait at the post office line, I can just do it while I'm already here picking up a sewing kit or getting my tires changed. So I love that. I sometimes wonder if with all the bureaucracy and all the things with the U.S. Postal Service, could those types of partnerships happen as easily as, say, some of the other, like a retailer, for example, and or what is stopping them from making that happen? Again, I imagine, again, when I think about folks sitting around some of these brainstorming tables and thinking about, you know, how do we show up more efficiently, provide better customer service? Like, one, are there teams asking those questions? I would imagine they are. But then, you know, are these types of like partnerships where it's like, how can we help with foot traffic? How can we join forces? How can we create partnerships to show up for the customer and the public? Are those questions that the U.S. Postal Service is asking? I don't know. I don't know, but I definitely think this would be a really cool opportunity, so I'm definitely with you on that. The others are doing it. Why shouldn't they? I would agree 100%. It's very much, if you think about it, it's also, it makes so much sense. You know, for a long time, this is dating me, but like, you know, you could, when you used to get your groceries, they'd ask you, you know, this is not self-checkout. This is when there's a cashier. they'd say hey do you need stamps do you need cigarettes do you need you know like anything behind the counter kind of thing and they always had stamps in their tray right and you could get you know a book of stamps or you could even get a roll of stamps to me it makes sense that it's the idea of convenience right um and you know when you think about uh if you've ever had to return something from amazon so gosh we keep talking about them but if you ever had to return anything from Amazon, like now you can go to Whole Foods, right? Because Whole Foods actually is Amazon. So they have a kiosk where you can return something. And I've had it happen where there's a line at the kiosk and the guy at the counter where he's selling, literally selling flowers is like, hey, bring over your Amazon return. I can do it for you and scans it and then puts it, and he's probably going to put it in the big bin later on. Right. But like super easy, super convenient, you know, and I agree that I think that like, not just grocery stores, but stores where you actually even like those kinds of big box stores where you're actually maybe having to send something to like buying something and then sending something would be a great opportunity, right? Like at a Barnes and Noble or, you know, just those kinds of things where you're able to like build that muscle and get that training of people to think, oh, like this is where I can get all my things done. And it's the busy holiday season. I don't need to go drive to the post office and wait in line there. I'm already in line here for other things. So I love that idea. I think it's a great idea. And I definitely think they should start with a big partnership with, you know, Kroger's or somebody, you know, Publix or whoever it might need to be. And vet it out. I just, I think that's a great idea. When you mentioned like, for example, like kiosks, it had me thinking like the last time I was at the post office and you all have probably seen this as well. They have a kiosk and it's self-serve. So maybe that's what you test, right? To see how many people actually would use it, right? Exactly. And right. The vending machine, you know, the vending, the amps and tape and all the things. I think that's, that is how you kind of lean into it and then see like, oh, you know, this is, you know, we're getting a lot of traction here. And then maybe you do need a person there. Maybe you don't. Maybe you just figured out how to shoehorn Starbucks in the grocery stores and there's no more Redbox kiosks. So there's room for, there's some space for the post office. I really actually, I think that's a great idea. I love the idea of starting with the kiosks and seeing like, again, what the demand is, right? I think that it is interesting going, you know, because some of those post offices are pretty big spaces, right? Well, and I get it because they're distributing mail, you know, that they might be the hub for distributing mail for a city or whatever. But like when you think about it and you think about like the mailing, mailboxes, et cetera, or the UPS stores, you know, those are in little spaces. And so I do feel like, you know, you could definitely get your little space in big box store. I don't know if you heard of this before that Amazon is talking about creating their own delivery service or competitive delivery service with the postal service. Do you think they'll actually do it? Do you think it's just for some type of price consideration or is it just for attention? Do you think that they're actually sitting down and working out the logistics, investing in a service that maybe will compete with, if not replace the postal service with something with something privatized? Is that even a, you know, is that a point of consideration? I don't know if they'll ever replace the postal service, again, regardless of, you know, all the things, right? The long lines, the experience you have, whatever. replacing? Maybe not, but I don't think it's a bad idea at all, given what they do and how they do it and what they promise. And if they want to get back to, you know, being able to deliver your packages overnight, why not? Again, the rumors are true. And I've also heard that buzzing around. I am so surprised if they don't actually move forward with it and figure out how to make it happen. Now, I do think they think there's strength in numbers and all the partnerships we see with, And, you know, again, the Postal Service. And I've had Amazon packages delivered from, you know, I believe other carriers even. And so I'm like, oh, this is cool. Someone just pulls up in their car, right? It's not even marked. And I'm like, oh, great. You know, as long as you can get it here fast. And so, yeah, they absolutely should be thinking about, you know, a broader, bigger, like, way to transport everything that they do. And again, now that, you know, they own Whole Foods and yeah, absolutely. Why not? I agree with Kadira. I don't know that that's necessarily their end goal, Erin. I think their end goal is controlling their delivery logistics and, and MAP, right, currently. So I think, to be honest, I wouldn't be surprised if the reason they're cutting ties with the post office is because they're a really crappy partner. There's too much red tape. It's bureaucratic. We can't trust them. You know, there's usually notes on delivery. Like I have notes. I live in the mountains. I have notes on my delivery, like delivered to the front door and our mail person will constantly just leave it on the side of the road. Right. And it's snow, you know, whatever. And, you know, I'm lucky the elk are the ones that are going to eat my packages, not anybody else. But that's annoying, you know, and I feel like that's the kind of service. Then I bitch to Amazon about that. And it's not them. It's because they had the U.S. Postal Service deliver. And they're like, it's printed on there, delivered to front door, and they still don't. Right? So I have a feeling that it's a control issue and it's a partnership issue. And it's that they don't like how that partnership is going and they feel like they can do a better job, Kadira, like having their own fleet, which they do. They have their own fleet of vans. You see them everywhere, right? Getting partners who will 99% of the time get it there on time and will accept responsibility if they do not. I just have a feeling that because it's so bureaucratic with the U.S. Postal Service and they're having their own issues, like, you know, who knows what's going on there, that they're trying to figure out what is the best way for us to move forward. And so I do think it's corporate control issue. I think it's also, it would be great if there was some privatization of the U.S. Postal Service to make it more efficient. But I'm not sure that that's like something Amazon wants to take on now. I mean, who knows? Because I think that Amazon has looked at other different things. They've looked at, you know, insurance. They've looked at different things and realized, oh, wait a minute, like, you know, let's get back to our bread and butter. Right. And so, again, I think it's a great idea, but I don't know that that's something that they, I would think that they have bigger things to go after than that. Let the Postal Service flail on their own, right? Okay, but we're not against Amazon entering into that. No, no, no, no. But I mean, I'd like them to fix some other things first. So I think they could. All right. Well, Kathy, thank you. And of course you know retailers want to maximize every square footage that they can of their retail footprint So yeah let go for it Put it in a post office Why not We have time for one more Hi Aaron My name is Chris I work in marketing I live in New York City. I've got a fix for Uber. I wish they would introduce real loyalty tiers like airlines do. Say like a bronze, silver, gold, platinum. And then each one of them could have perks, like for instance, like a priority pickup, automatic surge protection maybe, and then maybe like a free upgrade to Uber Comfort. I feel like people who use Uber a lot would stick with it even more. So what do you think of my fix for Uber? I like this one too. I definitely have thought about, you know, I use Uber quite a bit and I absolutely have thought like, hey, you know, how are they going to reward me? Shouldn't they be rewarding me for the upgrade that I'm, you know, already engaging in here. And so the fact that, like, this thought that, like, reward me for this, or even, like, again, the surge pricing that you just called out, I love that, right? Because let me tell you, I've been in different cities, let's say, for an event. And again, I'm a very loyal Uber rider, but the surge pricing gets me, or there's been times where I've been coming back home at the airport waiting for an Uber, surge pricing. So again, based on the amount of times that I use an Uber, I would love if there was some sort of loyalty program that I could tap into. I love that. Why are they not thinking about this? Let's make it happen. Well, they have kind of this interesting, they have like Uber One or something like a subscription program, but I don't think that's the same as what Chris is talking about, which I love what he's talking about. And I agree, especially when you have a lot of people that use Uber now, it's like a lot of business travel. It's any, any type of travel, right? You know, it's, it's just a, to me, it makes a lot of sense. I love that. Like, maybe you could pick just like we were talking about with the cruise, you could pick what you wanted your perks to be. So if for him, because of he's using it for commuting, he might say, I want to protect against surge pricing because I'm always traveling during commute hours. That's what I do, right? Um, another person might be like, I want priority pickup because I'm using it to go to bars and to restaurants. And I, you know, a single woman in New York city late night, I don't want to have to wait on the sidewalk for very long. Right. So I love this idea and then kind of customizing it, you know, based on what tier you're at or what you're in, you might be even willing to pay into that tier, right? To be able to say, okay, I want, you know, I want free Uber Eats. That's what I want, right? You know, that's what I, you know, so I just love that idea. I do think that they could expand it because currently their program is very, it's, to me, it seems very limited. I'm just using this as an example, you know, rode an Uber 10 times this month, give me 25% off, 50% off, upgrade me to Uber Black, right? Because once you get a taste of that Uber Black, You don't want to go back. And so, you know, you think about it like that's also a way for them to potentially be upgrading. So I wrote an Uber black because I got it as a freebie based on my loyalty program. I want Uber black the next time I go out. So I'm going to order that right when I'm having a date night or a special night out with my friends or what have you. I love the idea of being able to pick and choose. They absolutely should be cross promoting it with Uber Eats. right so there is a lot of opportunity here again I am just imagining when folks are sitting around those tables brainstorming why this hasn't come up and maybe it has right I mean I imagine that it has but like I would say rush to get that to market right and I think that there's a lot that you can do around personalization and customer segmentation right so understanding who your segment and customers are if you're like a college student right then you know you're using Ubers, like I was mentioning, going to bars, maybe going, you know, you know, maybe going to the airport once in a while, like once a semester, whatever. But like Uber Eats is a perk they would want, right? Because college kids always are using Uber Eats. So like you would know to build that package for that customer segment and that customer profile. And I think the same goes for like what Chris is saying, as a business professional, I need a commuter package, right? That I'm using. Or for business traveler that I am going to from city to city to city all over the globe, I need to have some sort of thing that I, you know, that I don't have to think about like, oh, my gosh, now I'm in London. What do I do here? Right. You know what I mean? And, you know, having like those kind of programs that are really built for that customer profile, I think would be amazing. Those kind of loyalty programs. Yeah, for sure. And Synergy is a wonderful thing. So between getting you somewhere and Uber Eats and maybe other rewards programs that exist through credit card companies, you know, if they're already taking you somewhere, they can give you an experience too. So you didn't have a reason to leave the house, but now you do because Uber is taking you to this experience. Well, of course, you're going to take an Uber to get there. But I do. I like the idea of that baseline level of rewards of like, yeah, I can choose what I want. I want flex surge price protection, you know. um and but i like that idea of like and we got you like yes we you know you ordered the the compact economy we're sending you the nice one this time um just because you know those types of things i think that would go a long way in in making creating preference for uber um and then also like i said not just those functional rewards or functional benefits but those surprise and delight ones yeah okay you know I booked something standard and you're also giving me something really memorable well I mean like I love the idea of like a business traveler having like an uber concierge so to your point like you you book it from the airport to the hotel right and you're in a you're you're in Minneapolis I've I've never been there I don't know where I'm going, right? I'm going to a conference. And while you're going there, you get a notification from Uber that says these restaurants near your hotel. And we've curated that list based on the restaurants you've gone to, because we know what your open table reservation list looks like. So we know that you love Indian food. We know that you love, you know, a great steakhouse, you know, da, da, da, da. And these are, would you like to set up a reservation through OpenTable, right? That would be like really kind of a cool experience where it's more and it's leaning into partnerships and it's leaning into like really taking that rewards and up-leveling it. For sure. Would you like a reservation? We know you're not driving the night first drinks on us. Yeah. Yeah. Why not just feel taken care of? Yeah. I love that. Your rewards user to the highest level. I mean, one, Uber, hire Chris, but two, free game. This is some good free game right here. I mean, and look, again, I think all three of us were talking about, you know, again, whether we use Uber or we've used Uber Eats or whatever, and Chris has chimed in here. I mean, the customer would be all over this type of opportunity. And again, it's just going to drive their, you know, engagement and revenue and all the things up. So again, it's hard to imagine that they're not thinking about this, but it definitely should come into play. Yeah, I love that it kind of takes them to the next level because I think that there's personalization that's going on. And like, I know I, you know, one of the things I love, like when I get a Lyft in San Francisco, it knows that I would like, I would prefer a female driver. And I love that it's, it'll tell you, it'll say, you know, there's only X amount available at this time. So are you willing to wait 10 minutes? And I'm like, yeah, of course I'm willing to wait 10 minutes. Some people are right. Depending on your situation. Again, it's that personalization of understanding what your needs are and what you're willing to compromise and not. And I think that like building that kind of relationship with your overall customers, because Uber has a lot of competition now. You've got competition. You've got Waymo. You've got Lyft. You've got other, you know, driving, the original driving services. You have taxis. You still have all of those things. So how do you differentiate and how do you keep your customers coming back? I think you're going to have to be creative. Yeah, totally. And I like that leaning on the experiences too. So as they can get more predictive with your data and find out what your other interests are, you know, would you like tickets to this show and to be picked up and dropped off for this? Here's the, here's the consumer price. Here's what your price is because you're one of us. You want in? Yeah. Like I said, I wasn't necessarily going to go out that Thursday, but yeah, I want to do that. Right. Yeah. Here's my money. I like that. Yeah, to me, it's like it's moving from transactional, which is what it feels like right now. I want a car. Come and pick me up. Drop me off. We're done. Versus, you know, Melissa and Aaron, to your points, you know, now you're getting to know me as the customer and you're providing me with a well-rounded, full experience. And my ride is a part of that experience. So, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, Melissa Kadira, I'm not going to ask you whether we fixed it this time because we didn't do the fixes. Well, we polished them up a little bit. So it was a team effort. Thank you to everyone who sent in your fixes and for everyone listening. I hope you played along and said your own fixes out loud to what we were talking about to no one in particular and got really steamed about them. If you want your own moment of glory on our show and there's a company that's been on your mind, send us your own fix to myfix at wefixeditpod.com. That's my fix at we fixed it pod.com. You can also pitch yourself as a potential guest at we fixed it pod.com. We're going to go hibernate, but don't go anywhere. We'll be handpicking and replaying our favorite episodes of the season starting next week. You won't want to miss it. Kadira, Melissa, I wish you the happiest of happy holidays. For all you fixaholics out there, thank you for listening and telling others and saying such nice things about our show. Happy holidays to you. Keep an eye on those companies and we will see you next time.