The Journal.

The Man Who Wants Netflix to Save Hollywood

20 min
Jan 8, 20265 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

The episode explores Ted Sarandos' rise from video store clerk to Netflix co-CEO and his aggressive push to acquire Warner Brothers, which would create a streaming and studio behemoth. It examines how Netflix transformed Hollywood through creator-friendly deals and original programming, while also detailing the regulatory and competitive challenges Sarandos faces in closing the $72 billion Warner deal.

Insights
  • Netflix's early success came from inverting Hollywood's payment model—paying creators upfront for full ownership rather than promising backend syndication revenue, which fundamentally changed creator incentives
  • As Netflix grew from disruptor to market leader, Hollywood's perception shifted from enthusiasm to fear, driven by reduced spending power, opacity around viewership data, and rejection of theatrical distribution
  • The Warner Brothers acquisition represents Netflix's evolution from pure tech company to traditional media conglomerate, requiring Sarandos to master political lobbying and regulatory navigation—skills Netflix previously avoided
  • Netflix's refusal to release viewership data creates information asymmetry that now works against creators, making it difficult for talent to assess fair compensation relative to actual audience reach
  • Sarandos' strategy of standing by controversial talent (Dave Chappelle) signals Netflix's commitment to creative freedom but also reflects its market dominance and reduced need to appease traditional Hollywood gatekeepers
Trends
Streaming consolidation accelerating with mega-mergers (Netflix-Warner) reshaping media landscape and reducing independent distribution channelsCreator compensation models shifting from upfront buyouts back toward transparency demands as streaming platforms mature and reduce spendingTech companies expanding into traditional media ownership, blurring lines between Silicon Valley and Hollywood power structuresRegulatory scrutiny increasing on streaming mega-mergers, with government agencies and trade groups (cinema owners) mobilizing against consolidationPolitical lobbying becoming essential for tech-media deals, with streaming companies hiring DC insiders and courting executive branch approvalTheatrical distribution declining as streaming platforms prioritize home viewing, fundamentally challenging cinema industry economicsViewership data opacity becoming competitive advantage and liability—platforms withholding metrics while creators demand transparency for fair dealsStand-up comedy becoming high-value content category as streaming platforms compete for prestige and subscriber acquisition beyond scripted drama
Topics
Netflix-Warner Brothers acquisition deal structure and regulatory approval processStreaming service consolidation and anti-competitive concernsCreator compensation models in streaming eraTheatrical vs. streaming distribution strategyViewership data transparency and creator fairnessOriginal programming investment and content strategyPolitical lobbying and regulatory navigation for tech-media dealsCompetitive bidding between Netflix and Paramount for Warner BrothersHollywood labor relations and creator relations managementStand-up comedy as streaming content categoryTed Sarandos leadership philosophy and decision-makingSilicon Valley disruption of traditional media business modelsFCC and DOJ regulatory review of media mergersCinema industry advocacy against streaming dominanceNetflix's content acquisition strategy evolution
Companies
Netflix
Central subject; pursuing $72 billion acquisition of Warner Brothers and transforming Hollywood through streaming and...
Warner Brothers
Target of Netflix's $72 billion acquisition deal; major Hollywood studio with significant IP portfolio and production...
Paramount
Rival bidder competing with Netflix for Warner Brothers acquisition; backed by Oracle co-founder Larry Ellison throug...
HBO
Competitor that dominated stand-up comedy specials before Netflix aggressively signed major comedians like Dave Chapp...
Oracle
Larry Ellison's company; Ellison personally guaranteeing $40+ billion to support Paramount's competing bid for Warner...
The Wall Street Journal
Co-producer of The Journal podcast; provided reporting and analysis for this episode on Netflix-Warner deal
Spotify
Co-production partner with The Wall Street Journal for The Journal podcast series
People
Ted Sarandos
Central figure; rose from video store clerk to lead Netflix's content strategy and now pursuing Warner Brothers acqui...
Reed Hastings
Netflix founder who hired Sarandos in 2000 to oversee content acquisition for mail-order DVD business
Joe Flint
Wall Street Journal reporter providing analysis and commentary on Netflix's Hollywood impact throughout episode
David Fincher
Director who partnered with Netflix on House of Cards; received upfront payment and creative control under Netflix's ...
Kevin Spacey
Star of House of Cards; benefited from Netflix's upfront payment model that differed from traditional Hollywood deals
Dave Chappelle
Stand-up special creator; Sarandos defended his controversial special against internal and external criticism, signal...
Chris Rock
Major stand-up comedian signed to Netflix deal as part of strategy to compete with HBO's comedy dominance
David Ellison
Leading Paramount's competing bid for Warner Brothers with backing from father Larry Ellison
Larry Ellison
Oracle co-founder personally guaranteeing $40+ billion to support son David Ellison's Paramount bid for Warner Brothers
Greg Peters
Netflix co-CEO alongside Sarandos; toured Warner Brothers lot in victory lap photo shoot before deal closure
Donald Trump
Expressed both praise and concern about Netflix's size; Sarandos visited Mar-a-Lago in December 2024 to build politic...
Ryan Knudsen
Host of The Journal podcast episode analyzing Netflix-Warner deal and Sarandos' rise
Quotes
"I said in this world where we're going to be a digital channel, and I don't know of any network that exists that doesn't have some form of original differentiating program from each other."
Ted SarandosEarly in episode discussing Netflix's original programming strategy
"He chose money over power. In this town, a mistake nearly everyone makes."
Joe FlintDiscussing David Fincher's House of Cards deal with Netflix
"No, we're saving it. The box office is down. The film business is shaky. People are out of work. Your competitors market share is sinking. But Netflix business is thriving."
Ted SarandosResponding to criticism that Netflix is ruining Hollywood
"One thing I think people respect, Ted, for at least on the talent side of the business is that he has shown a willingness to stand up for his talent."
Joe FlintDiscussing Sarandos' defense of Dave Chappelle special
"The guy in a video store ends up running all of Hollywood."
Joe FlintSummarizing Sarandos' potential legacy if Warner deal closes
Full Transcript
Ever since Netflix announced a deal to acquire Warner Brothers back in December, some Hollywood creatives have been shaking in their boots. A lot of the concern is just sort of that these guys are the disruptors from Silicon Valley. They're a tech company. That's my colleague Joe Flint. What are they going to do? We're all going to be making movies and TV shows based off their algorithms and creativity will fly out the window. So all the Netflix boogie monsters are coming out right now. The deal isn't yet finalized, but if Netflix is successful, the merger would create a Hollywood behemoth, marrying the world's biggest streaming service with one of Hollywood's most storied studios filled with important IP. But Hollywood would prefer that no one buy Warner Brothers because anytime one of these companies gets sold, there's one fewer entity to sell a project to. There's one fewer company to do business with. And one of the men who'd be at the helm of this new entertainment juggernaut is Netflix co-CEO Ted Serandos. Does Ted Serandos want to be the king of Hollywood? Some might argue Ted is already the king of Hollywood, but if he gets the Warner deal, he'll have a castle to go with his kingdom. Welcome to the Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Ryan Knudsen. It's Thursday, January 8th. Coming up on the show, the rise of Ted Serandos and his fight to win Warner. All right, let's talk about Ted Serandos' origin story. Where is he from and how did he even wind up in the entertainment industry to begin with? Well, Ted grew up in Arizona and he took a job in a video store when he was in between high school and sort of going to college. And he was a movie buff and he always, honestly, he kind of loved the types of movies that weren't ever coming to Phoenix. He was a little bit of an indie movie fan. Serandos rose to the ranks and worked his way up from store clerk to regional distributor. He's getting to know people and doing deals with studios to acquire content to put on the shelves. So in the course of doing that, he starts to get a little bit of a reputation as a sharp guy when it comes to doing these sorts of deals. Serandos eventually got on the radar of Reed Hastings, who was just a couple of years into launching a mail order DVD company called Netflix. In 2000, Hastings hired Serandos to oversee content acquisition. But soon Serandos was thinking bigger. As Netflix kind of began to move its business from mail DVDs to online, Ted was a very early advocate that, hey, we will need to do original programming of our own. Basically, it will help us control our own destiny. The more content we can own, the better for the future of this business. Here he is talking about this in a podcast a few months ago. I said in this world where we're going to be a digital channel, and I don't know of any network that exists that doesn't have some form of original differentiating program from each other. So Serandos set out to make some new TV shows. And the way he and Netflix approached Hollywood was totally different than the way things used to work. Historically, traditional studios paid directors, actors, and movie producers less upfront and then if the show was popular, there was the promise of more money later on for reruns. Netflix flipped out on its head. They would pay more upfront. They say, Joe, we love your show and we're going to buy out whatever we think the back end, the rerun money will be. So we're going to give you all this money upfront. And in return, of course, the show's ours now. You know, we're going to keep it for ourselves. It's going to live on our system. We're never going to take it out anywhere else. You just got to trust us that we're giving you the value it is. And at first, this was like the town was like, oh, this is awesome. This is awesome. I don't have to wait around for this money. I have to wait 20 years for reruns. And here's a big fat check. Here's a big fat check. This is how Serandos and Netflix were able to land their first big hit, the political drama House of Cards. He chose money over power. In this town, a mistake nearly everyone makes. So Netflix went out and famously went to David Fincher, who was shopping a American version of the TV show House of Cards with Kevin Spacey, went to him and said, hey, we'll give you a two year commitment. We will guarantee you two years, you know, two seasons, no, you know, no pilot, no nothing. Here's the money. Make your show. Netflix became very creator friendly. And part of it was out of necessity to get deals. And I think part of it was to give themselves a little bit of an edge over their competitors. And the town reacted to that. They liked that. Netflix continued growing its original programming catalog with hit show after hit show. There was the gritty character driven women's prison dramedy. Orange is the new black. Tell her he said, thanks. I don't say nothing. I'm just working next. And the revival of the cult favorite sitcom, Arrested Development. Now the story of a family whose future was abruptly canceled. The supernatural nostalgic coming of age drama, Stranger Things. Stop it. You're freaking me out. He's freaking me out. I bet you. Death. So we talk about House of Cards. We talk about Orange is the new black. We talk about Stranger Things, all these very expensive high end dramas. But, you know, Netflix has to expand, of course. And Serrando's, you know, one of the areas he really leaned into and is still leaning into is stand up comedy, which, of course, had been HBO's bread and butter. And Netflix went out. They signed Chris Rock and Dave Chappelle and all these other big standups to huge deals. At a time when HBO was reassessing how much this genre was actually worth, Netflix thought, no, these specials are good. They build attention and publicity for us. And we want to be in the comedy business. After leaving the charge on multiple hits, which helped bring in tons of subscribers to the platform, Serrando's was promoted to co CEO in July 2020. And not long after taking the job, Serrando's faced one of his first controversies involving one of those comedians, Dave Chappelle. One thing I think people respect, Ted, for at least on the talent side of the business is that he has shown a willingness to stand up for his talent. We saw that with Dave Chappelle a few years back. He did a stand up special. He had jokes and commentary that upset the transgender community. There was some upset at Netflix as well. There were protests outside Netflix. Netflix employees were upset. You Ted stood by. You know, he didn't take the special off. He didn't issue any statements condemning what Chappelle said. But I think that that sent a message. So Netflix in its early days was wooing Hollywood, AKA the town. And you said that at first people there liked it. So how did they become a company that people started to fear? Well, anytime you get big, you start to toss your muscle around. So Netflix grew, had tremendous success, grew a lot of subscribers. And with that comes, you know, power. Because they were growing so fast and spending so much, they became kind of the one place you could come to do business. But at the same time, once you've sort of taken over the landscape, well, you don't spend as much. You know, you spend a ton of money to get the talent in there. But once you've got that, well, you don't have to spend as much money anymore. Netflix also doesn't release much data about how many people are watching it shows. So it's hard to know what a show's market value actually is. Some creators begin to wonder, but I'm getting paid enough. Is this really fair? I'm how do I really know how popular it is if we don't test the waters to sell the rerun somewhere and Netflix is very cautious about the information they release in terms of who's viewing it. So I don't really know. Everyone's like, oh, wait a minute, maybe this wasn't so good for us after all. The other thing that's irked Hollywood is how Serandos has approached releasing new movies. When Netflix got into movies, they made a big deal of not embracing the theatrical model. So that became a concern to a lot of sort of Hollywood purists will call them, as well as the movie theater industry, of course. Oh, my God, you can't not put a movie in the theaters. Are you insane, man? Yes, they do release some movies theatrically, usually for award consideration or a big enough director has the clout to persuade Netflix to drop it in a theater for a couple weeks. But yet, Ted's belief was, hey, people want to watch stuff at home. And we're we're about the customer first. OK, in the movie going experience, yes, maybe it's maybe it's great for some things, but most people would just as soon sit at home. So, you know, that that was kind of a turn off to a lot of old Hollywood. All of this is why Hollywood was shaking in its boots when Netflix announced the deal to acquire Warner Brothers. Netflix has already transformed the industry. And by buying another major player, things are probably only going to change more. How has Ted Sarandos responded to all of these concerns in Hollywood? Ted has said when he's asked that, are you guys ruining Hollywood? He will say, no, we're saving it. The box office is down. The film business is shaky. People are out of work. Your competitors market share is sinking. But Netflix business is thriving. Have you destroyed Hollywood? No, we're saving Hollywood. You're saving Hollywood. They would tell you that they're spending a ton on content. How can we be ruining Hollywood? Look at how much money we invest in movies and TV shows. And we have a global system that reaches everyone. We believe in all this. We're not here to ruin it. We're here to build it out and persevere and find even more of an audience and a new way to reach them. But to actually get Warner, Sarandos has a couple of fights ahead of him. That's next. When the tax year ends on the 5th of April, valuable tax allowances may be lost simply because people left things too late. Thankfully, Vanguard is here to help you make well-considered decisions, not rushed ones. Their tax year end hub is full of clear guidance, helpful tools and timely reminders to help you understand your allowances and give your investments the best chance to grow. Search Vanguard Investor to learn more. When investing, your capital is at risk. Tax rules apply. Getting instant insights is amazing. But if there are too many data points, it can be hard to see what works. So I'll ask my AI assistant for recommendations. And with PDF spaces in Acrobat Studio, it's easy to remix documents and transform it into a new product. And with PDF spaces in Acrobat Studio, it's easy to remix documents and transform insights into standout content. So you can go from idea to creation in record time, all within an AI-powered workflow. Do that with Acrobat. Learn more and try it out on Adobe.com. Before Netflix can seal the deal for Warner Brothers, it has to do two things. First, it has to fend off a rival bidder, Paramount. Then, it'll need to persuade regulators to approve the deal. Let's start with Paramount. The company has deep pockets behind it, those of Larry Ellison, one of the richest men in the world. Paramount is still aggressively pursuing Warner. They are not taking no for an answer. David Ellison, Paramount's CEO, says they are, quote, finishing what they started after making six total offers. Paramount Skydance amending its $30 per share all cash offer for Warner Brothers' discovery. The Oracle co-founder and father of Paramount Skydance CEO David Ellison, on Monday said he will personally guarantee more than $40 billion for the deal. So far, Paramount's pursuit of Warner hasn't been successful. In a letter to shareholders made public earlier this week, Warner said the amended Paramount offer wasn't superior, or even comparable, to the $72 billion Netflix deal. The question becomes, is Paramount going to come back now with a sweeter offer? And if they do, does Netflix come back with a sweeter offer too? Or does Netflix say, eh, no, we're out? Paramount has set its offer superior to Warner Brothers' agreement with Netflix, and quote, represents the best path forward. If Netflix is able to fend off Paramount, it will then face its second challenge, getting the deal past government regulators, who will get to weigh in on whether the merger creates anti-competitive issues. Clearly, President Trump has expressed a lot of interest in this deal. Typically, normally, a president doesn't necessarily weigh in on deals that are going to go before independent agencies, whether it was the FCC, the DOJ, the FTC. President Trump, yeah, he's expressed some concern about Netflix. He's praised Netflix and Ted Serandos, but also said their size is a concern. At a congressional oversight hearing yesterday, Cinema United, a trade organization representing movie theater owners, argued that this merger would be disastrous for movie theaters, local economies, and consumer choice. Serandos has said that Netflix is confident the deal will win approval because it's quote, pro-consumer and pro-innovation. He spoke about it last month. So we think it's going to be great for consumers, really great for creators. You know, we invest heavily in production, and then we intend to run those businesses exactly like they run today. So what is Netflix doing in DC? Netflix kind of went on a PR offensive, if you will. They've got a website set up, and it has all these, you know, details on the deal. Why Netflix and Warner means even more choice and value for fans, why it will define the next century of storytelling, why these are complementary businesses to deliver more choice and value for consumers. So they're doing that right now. Serandos has also had a couple meetings with President Trump. He visited Mar-a-Lago in December of 2024 after Trump won, but before Trump took office, Ted was one of the many CEOs who went to give their respects, I'll say, and dine down there. And, you know, he did go to the White House before this deal with Warner was officially announced. Netflix has been hiring lobbyists as well, who have close Republican and Trump ties. Their head of their DC office was in Trump's first administration. So there's a lot of that sort of road paving going on, if you will. So, you know, not a surprise, but nonetheless, for Netflix, something new, because, you know, this is the other part of the game they've kind of stayed out of. They produced House of Cards, but they haven't really had to play House of Cards. Right. They haven't had to play House of Cards. So, yeah, this is a new sort of thing for them to have to go there and really, you know, grease the wheels, if you will. Late last year, Serandos and his co-CEO, Greg Peters, had a photo shoot on the Warner Brothers studio lot, alongside the head of Warner Brothers. They toured sound stages. They met with some other execs and people there. It was almost a victory lap, even though the deal hasn't closed, you know, walking around the lot and seeing all that history. And look, Ted Serandos is, you know, a lover of old Hollywood. He loves creatives. He loves the quote-unquote Hollywood magic. For Serandos, acquiring Warner Brothers would mark the culmination of his rise, from just a guy who loved movies working in a video store to one of the most powerful people in Hollywood. If this deal goes through and is successful, I mean, you just, you'd pitch it as a movie. The guy in a video store ends up running all of Hollywood. But yeah, it has been an amazing and incredible run for him. That's all for today, Thursday, January 8th. The journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. Additional reporting in this episode by Lauren Thomas and Jessica Tunkle. Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.