But Why: A Podcast for Curious Kids

When did volcanoes start existing?

26 min
Sep 19, 20257 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

This episode explores the origins and mechanics of volcanoes, featuring University of Iceland volcanologist Professor Frästen Sigmundson. The discussion covers how volcanoes form, why they erupt, how scientists predict eruptions, and the benefits and dangers of living near volcanic regions.

Insights
  • Volcanoes are continuous geological features with lifespans measured in millions of years, making human civilization appear infinitesimal by comparison
  • Modern volcano monitoring relies on three primary techniques: earthquake measurement, ground movement tracking, and volcanic gas analysis rather than visual observation alone
  • Volcanic regions provide significant economic and environmental benefits including geothermal energy (70% of Iceland's power), fertile soil for agriculture, and new terrain formation
  • Volcanic eruptions are inherently unpredictable despite scientific advances, comparable to forecasting illness symptoms—preparation and monitoring are more reliable than prediction
  • Public education about volcanic activity is critical for community safety and informed decision-making in volcanically active regions
Trends
Increased volcanic activity globally in 2025 with simultaneous eruptions in Iceland, Russia, and Japan raising public awarenessGrowing reliance on geothermal energy infrastructure in volcanically active regions as sustainable alternative to fossil fuelsAdvancement in real-time volcano monitoring technology using seismic, geodetic, and gas analysis data integrated with computer modelingClimate and environmental implications of volcanic ash dispersal affecting air traffic and atmospheric conditions across continentsEducational focus on volcano science for younger audiences to build scientific literacy and preparedness in at-risk communities
Topics
Volcanic eruption mechanics and magma pressure buildupTectonic plate boundaries and volcanic system formationGeothermal energy generation and utilizationVolcano monitoring and eruption prediction techniquesSubmarine volcanoes and underwater eruption processesLava field cooling timelines and post-eruption hazardsVolcanic soil fertility and agricultural benefitsVolcanic ash atmospheric dispersal and air traffic impactEarthquake measurement for volcano activity assessmentGround deformation monitoring using geodetic toolsVolcanic gas detection and analysis methodsIceland's volcanic systems and mid-Atlantic ridge geologyExplosive versus effusive eruption typesDormant volcano reactivation warning signsCommunity safety and evacuation planning near volcanoes
Companies
Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of Natural History
Maintains global database tracking active volcanoes and volcanic activity, reporting 40-50 continuing eruptions with ...
University of Iceland
Research institution where Professor Frästen Sigmundson conducts volcano research and studies internal volcanic proce...
Vermont Public
Public media organization that produces and distributes the But Why podcast series
People
Frästen Sigmundson
University of Iceland volcanologist specializing in internal volcano processes and eruption prediction methodologies
Jane Lindholm
Host of But Why podcast who interviews experts and presents volcano science to curious children
Quotes
"Volcanoes are not like a clock. They are very irregular."
Frästen SigmundsonMid-episode
"It is like if you jump into a swimming pool you float up. The same is happening with the magma inside the earth."
Frästen SigmundsonEruption mechanics explanation
"Forecasting when a volcano will erupt is like forecasting when you will throw up if you have a stomach disease. It is difficult."
Frästen SigmundsonPrediction challenges
"They are beautiful, spectacular and they feel stir at them for a long time. Stir into the red glow."
Frästen SigmundsonVolcano appreciation
"Mankind, we are very small in comparison to the lifetime of volcanoes."
Frästen SigmundsonVolcano age discussion
Full Transcript
At But Why, we believe that Curiosity is key to learning. That's why we bring kids' questions to life with experts, fun stories, and fascinating facts in our podcasts and video episodes. But we can't do this without you. Support from people who love the show and believe in what we do helps keep Curiosity thriving. Head to buttwyekids.org slash donate to become a Butt Wife fan club member, or make a gift in any amount to support the show. Thanks and stay curious! This is But Why, a podcast for curious kids from Vermont Public. I'm Jane Lintel. On this show, we take questions from curious kids just like you and we find answers. You know, it's been a big summer for volcanoes. You might have heard that back in July, a volcano erupted in Iceland, and then in August, a big earthquake struck off the coast of Russia, triggering multiple volcanic eruptions in the region. While the eruption in Iceland was related to a couple of years of ongoing volcanic activity in that region, the one in Russia had been dormant, inactive, quiet, for hundreds of years. And as we're putting this episode out in September of 2025, an active volcano in Japan has been spewing ash into the air. The Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of Natural History in the United States keeps a list of all the active volcanoes and volcanic activity in the world, and says that at any given time, there are typically 40 to 50 continuing eruptions, and out of those generally around 20 will be actively erupting on any particular day. I did not realize there was that much volcanic activity all the time. You definitely don't want to be near a volcano while it's erupting, but if you ever get a chance to view it from a safe distance, volcanic eruptions are fascinating. You might see bright, hot, orange lava flowing down mountain slopes, making really cool patterns. And when you look up into the sky, you could see giant plumes of smoke filling the air. Melody Joey and I were kind of hoping to get that safe viewpoint to watch an eruption while we were in Iceland earlier this summer. And it turns out we just missed one. It was only a couple weeks after we left that Iceland's Suntnikor crater row erupted right near where we had been. If you don't live in an area with volcanoes, they can seem really mysterious. Why do they erupt? And how? And how can we know in advance so we can make sure to stay safe? If you live in areas that are very volcanically active, you may already know a lot about volcanoes and how to stay safe around them. You've sent us a lot of volcano questions over the years, and since Iceland has so much ongoing volcanic activity, we figured while we were there, whether we could see a live eruption or not, we should find someone who studies volcanoes in Iceland who could answer all of your questions. My name is Fräest and Sigmundson. I work at the University of Iceland with the resource to better understand how our planet is working and I study volcanoes. Does that mean you're a volcanologist? Yes, a volcano is a very broad field. You can study the rocks on a volcano. What I try to do is to study what is inside the volcanoes. Iceland has about 30 volcanic systems, with about 130 volcanoes within those systems. You can think of a volcanic system as a network of volcanoes. So it's a good place to be if you're a volcanologist. And living so close to so many volcanoes when he was young, made Professor Sigmundson really curious. When I was a young kid, there was a period of very high activity of eruption in Iceland, so I saw a lot of co-ordids of that. And I guess that pushed me into the study of volcanoes. I did not see volcanoes growing up in New England, the northeastern part of the US. And there's a reason for that. Most volcanoes form at the boundaries of Earth's tectonic plates, these large pieces of the outer shell, the lithosphere of the Earth. Iceland sits right on top of the mid-Atlantic ridge, where the North American and Eurasian tectonic plates are slowly drifting apart. And Iceland is a hot spot, meaning the underlying ground is warmer than the surface area above. These factors make for a lot of volcanic activity. But to get volcanic activity, you have to have a volcano. And what's a volcano? A volcano is, in essence, a crater that has erupted a magma. And in most cases, we would expect it to have erupted more than once. So it builds up some kind of a mountain. The crater is at the top of the volcanic mountain. But it'll look a little bit like somebody's taking a big scoop out, leaving a bowl-shaped round hole right at the top. That's the crater. Do you know what magma is? Here's how Professor Sigmundson explains it. What is inside volcanoes? We call it magma. It's more than rock. You can think of it as a human body. We have blood inside our human body. We'll kind of have magma. This molten rock magma is extremely hot, so hot that it has become liquefied. It gets that hot because the core of the earth is really, really hot. An eruption happens when more and more magma accumulates under the surface, building pressure. The magma can move upwards through cracks or weakness in the material around it, making its way up and then breaking through the top layer of the earth's surface and boom! That liquid rock plus gas and ashes come out onto the surface in an eruption. We have basically two types of volcanic eruptions. In one type of eruption, magma comes out of volcano and flows on the surface of the earth like a liquid. The magma changes into lava and it just solidifies as black rock on the surface. The other type of eruption is explosive and they are often more dangerous. Liquid that is inside the volcano when it comes to the surface of the earth, it explodes into tiny particles and it goes up into the air and it can stop air traffic. There can be so much of this particles that it becomes completely dark. I am five years old and I live in a very park, Ohio. I was the first ever volcano to explode and turn into magma. I'm Lucifer from Pasinena. How many of you stay rockinos that you get there? Lucca is wondering how many years ago did volcanoes start existing and Fritz is wondering if we know what the first ever volcano to explode was. The existence and evolution of our planet is all about volcanoes. So the first volcano was really born when the planet was forming. We don't have a name for the first volcano. So we cannot say what was the first volcano but we can ask other questions like if you are in some specific region, we can ask when did the first volcano forming this region? And often the timescale or the time for that is measured in millions of years. Like I live in Iceland. Iceland is an island in the middle of the ocean and the reason Iceland exists are volcanoes. And Iceland started to form as an island about 20 million years ago. That is when the first volcano appeared here. Typically a volcano here in Iceland is about half a million years. So mankind, we are very small in comparison to the lifetime of volcanoes. My name is Navy, I live in Llangan, how do volcanoes erupt? My name is Boas, I'm from Israel, I'm age year old. What is the pressure that makes the volcano erupt? My name is Oliver, I live in one of the times I'm a statistic and I'm six years old. How do volcanoes erupt? My name is Zoe, I'm seven years old and I live in Singapore. How do volcanoes erupt? My name is Roe Bayt, I live in Canada and six years old. Why do volcanoes form? How do volcanoes form and how do they erupt? Volcanoes form because of this heat that needs to escape from the interior of the earth. So there is somewhere rock is melted, there's a liquid inside the earth. This liquid wants to rise up to the surface because it is boiled, it is last time. So it is like if you jump into a swimming pool you float up. The same is happening with the magma inside the earth. And therefore they form because this liquid is coming towards the surface of the earth. And often a vendor has been sort of one path for magma, it is utilized by more magma. So they are repeated a flow of this liquid and the eruptions, when do they occur exactly? Well, pressure is building up inside where magma is accumulating in a very similar manner as what happens if you have a balloon and you blow air into it and you continue to blow. You see it gets always more and more difficult, that's because there is more pressure inside the balloon. Same happens with volcanoes in more new liquid that flows into a volcano, the pressure increases. But if you continue very hard to blow into your balloon, it may explode. That is the same thing that happens for a volcano. The eruption starts when the pressure is too much inside the balloon that is collecting magma inside the volcano. And there we go, we have an eruption. My name is Tudor Hal, the volcano rise up inside the sea. Can you talk a little bit about volcanoes that form underwater? Yes, we have super many volcanoes in the oceans under water, lots of submarine volcanoes under water. What happens is inside the volcano the process is very similar, but the eruptions are different. Often we form both lava, similar as on the surface, but the lava will be of a little different types. If the eruptions happen in shallow water or water depth of 100 meters, it becomes explosive. What happens then is that the lava when it comes into the ocean, it can explode into fine particles, similar as in explosive eruptions. And then it can pile up and eruptions can create mountains. And we have had new islands created off the coast of Iceland in an eruption that was first under ocean water and the volcano rose out of the sea. And it was calvant at five result. I live in New York City, which one's hotter, the sun or the volcano? The red glow of this liquid that comes out of the volcano means it is very hot. Thousand degrees Celsius, this is about 1800 degrees Fahrenheit, so it is super hot. But inside the sun it is much hotter. Scientists say the core of the sun is as hot as 15 million degrees Celsius, that's 27 million degrees Fahrenheit. So the heat from underneath the earth is definitely hot, but if we're comparing about a thousand degrees in a volcano to 15 million degrees in the core of the sun, the sun is much, much hotter. Coming up, how do we know when a volcano is going to erupt? This is But Why. I'm Jane Lindholm and today on the show we're learning all about volcanoes with University of Iceland, Professor and Volcanologist, Frästen Sigmundson. So as we just heard, when a volcano erupts magma or hot molten rock flows onto the earth's surface. And at that point, we give it a new name, lava. We've got some questions about lava and how it forms. Hi, my name is Alana and I'm a used old and I live in Derwak, California and my question is why do volcanoes have lava in them? And how does the lava even get in there? My name is Landis, I'm seven years old. I live in San Antonio, Texas, where do volcanoes get their lava from? My name is Charlie, I live in New Zealand. I am six years old. What is lava made out of? Lava is made out of rock that has become so hot that it melts. And you see, many of the features of volcanoes can be explained by this heat. So the volcano scatter magma in a celly that is when the lava is inside the volcano, because of heat. The rocks started to melt and form liquid. So the liquid inside the volcano comes to the surface and then we call it lava. So it is a hot liquid and many volcanoes have a lot of hot liquid inside them. And that's when we have an eruption, this liquid comes to the surface and we have lava. So that's the story, basically, of the lava. It's all about the earth trying to release heat from its interior. My name is Trixi and four are in Virginia. My off the cave of lava is orange. Why is lava orange? Yeah, similar regions, the sun is yellow. It is transmitting energy. It is so hot that it starts to radiate energy. The sun is radiating energy, but it's still hotter than the lava. That is yellow. The orange color is simply radiation from different temperatures. When Melody, Joey and I were in Iceland, we didn't see an eruption. But we did visit a solidified lava field from volcanoes that had already erupted just a few years ago. The lava there was no longer bright orange because it had cooled and hardened back into rock. But I could see the different textures and patterns of the lava as it had flowed across the surface. And I was really surprised to see that there was still smoke coming out of the solidified lava field, even though it had been more than a year since the last eruption. We even saw signs warning people not to walk on it because it might still be very hot underneath. So I asked Professor Sigmundsen how long can it be hot underneath that hard surface? And how long can a lava field be dangerous after an eruption? For years, because it takes a long time to cool a lava field, it depends of course how thick it is. But if it is like a few meters as tall as an adult. Yes, or twice or three times that is made be typical for lava fields here in Iceland. They can have really liquid magma inside them for possibly for months or years. But there is also another danger simply related to the rocks. You know it is liquid that is transforming into rock again on the surface of the earth. And the structure of lava fields is very intriguing. Many of the lava fields here in Iceland are very irregular on the surface. So you also have the danger of just falling. So they are dangerous. Yes, so you need to be aware of that. My name is Harberg and I am five years old and I live in Scottsdale, Arizona. Why can't we live on volcanoes? Lots of people live on volcanoes and lots of people live close to volcanoes. In Iceland we live quite close to volcanoes. I mean the capital of Iceland right here is not far from volcanoes. Here in Iceland there are two villages that are practically on a volcano. But worldwide there are many people that live on volcanoes. And the reason people live on volcanoes like in Indonesia is because the soil on a volcano can be very fertile and you can grow crops there. Professor Sigmundson says living close to volcanoes can come with other great benefits. In Iceland for example geothermal energy powers about 70% of the country. We have cold winters but we heat most of the houses in Iceland by water that comes from the volcano's hot water and it just goes into a radiator directly from volcano and heats our houses. We have very hot houses here in Iceland even if the winters are cold. And many volcanoes stay dormant which means they're inactive kind of a sleep for hundreds or even thousands of years. So it's entirely possible for someone to live close to an inactive volcano their whole life and not experience an eruption. The tricky thing though is that volcanoes don't always stay asleep. If you can't talk about the volcano's hot water living creature in their lifetime most of the time they are sleeping. So they only wake up occasionally some of the work I do is try to understand what happens when a volcano is trying to wake up and yeah it is difficult to forecast for example if you're sick if you do not feel very well in your stomach you may need to throw up occasionally and forecasting when you will throw up if you have a stomach disease. Maybe difficult. You almost throw up but then suddenly it comes and maybe we are not prepared. The same is with volcanoes it is difficult to forecast when they throw up. I like that way of thinking about it and yes in my experience sometimes you think oh I don't feel good oh my gosh now I'm throwing up it can be a very surprising thing. Same for volcanoes what volcano is not trying to do some of our work is to forecast the activity and better prepare society that you're listening to this podcast is very good because we need to more people to understand what volcanoes are doing. Hello my name is Alain and I live in Canada and I'm five years old and about to be six to do volcanoes around the winter. What we know about volcanoes is that they are very irregular they can have a 10-time of the year. Volcanoes are not like clock. My name is Jennifer and I'm a result of an Ohai. How can I go down just now of volcano is going to erupt? That is my job, part of my job to understand what happens before this yeah so we need to measure their activity and we can measure what is happening inside the volcano with different techniques mainly three techniques. We can study earthquakes how the ground is shaking in a volcano because the waves from earthquakes come to the surface and we can measure the waves and then figure out what is happening inside or we can measure how the ground of a volcano is moving and thereby maybe try to understand how the pressure is building up like in a balloon or we can measure what we can call volcanic gas that is like if you smell something is burning in your stove then something serious may happen unless you start the process. It's basically the same thing we can try to sense or sniff in a sense what the gas that is coming out of the volcano. When something is burning in your stove that's a very familiar smell like I can picture the smell of burning toast. The smell of a volcano that is getting active, what is that smell? Is that a sulfuric smell which sometimes people describe as kind of like rotten eggs? It can be increasing that it can also be increased in gas types that has no smell that we need special instrument to measure so we need some technology. Normally we cannot use our our nose for it. Are there things that you can look at if I was looking at a volcano and say oh something is happening or do you need special tools and special maybe even computer models to be able to understand what's happening? Sometimes we can see it with our eyes. For example a signal if there is no hot liquid coming into a volcano the heat of the rock around it can increase and we can start to have more geothermal activity or basically steaming from a volcano so we can get visual steam from a volcano basically meaning it is hotter but we typically need equipment. We need to study the earthquakes we need to see how the ground is moving or we need to measure the gases that come out. Can typically to understand how volcano's behave both in this time period before an eruption and during an eruption we need this monitoring data and we take it all together and try to understand what is happening inside the volcano or during an eruption and often we need the computer model for that. So even if I'm a volcano I'd say it's most of the time I'm in front of a computer. Scientists have been studying volcanic activity for a long time but there's still a lot we don't know about how they work. For Professor Sigmundson he says his goals are to keep learning more about what's inside volcanoes and how that might help him understand better the warning signs volcanoes are giving. That way people could be informed before a volcano erupts. That's especially important for people who live close by of course. Volcanic eruptions are a forceful release of extreme heat and energy. They can destroy homes, they can make nearby towns unsafe, require residents to evacuate or leave. Sometimes all the ash from an eruption gets high up into the atmosphere and causes problems like planes needing to find new roots or not being able to fly at all. And remember our recent episode about smoke traveling from forest fires, ash from volcanoes can of course also get into the atmosphere and go very very far from where the volcano has originally erupted. Given all of that it makes sense that we often think of volcanoes as something kind of scary and unpredictable and dangerous and bad. But Professor Sigmundson says it's important to be respectful of the power and destruction of volcanic activity but to also recognize the beauty. If you look at some photographs or videos of volcanoes it's a beautiful thing to see a small eruption. You also have some nice red magma being thrown up into the air and flowing so. So I was a young kid that had the opportunity to see eruptions until about them. They caught my interest. They are beautiful, spectacular and they feel stir at them for a long time. Stir into the red glow. You can be challenged. And volcanoes are also very important. Not only did they shape the landscape we know today on Earth but they continue to do that. New islands and new terrain is constantly being formed by volcanic eruptions. Plus volcanoes are important for things like geothermal energy, how we can heat and cool our homes and buildings. And they can create very fertile soils meaning it's easier to grow things like fruits and vegetables. So volcanoes are all of those things at once. A little bit mysterious, maybe scary sometimes, occasionally dangerous, but also beautiful, interesting and important. Thanks to Professor Frastin Sigmundson at the University of Iceland for speaking with us about volcanoes and answering your questions. As always if you have a question about anything, have an adult record you asking it on a smartphone. You can use an app like Voice Memo's or Recorder. Then have your adult email the file to questions at butwhykids.org. But why is produced by Melody Bodette, Sarah Baker and me, Jane Lindholm at Vermont Public and distributed by PRX. Our video producer is Joey Palombo and our theme music is by Luke Reynolds. If you like our show, please have your adults help you give us a thumbs up or a review on whatever podcast platform you use. It helps other kids and families find us. We'll be back in two weeks with an all-new episode. Until then, stay curious. From PRX.