Conan O’Brien Needs A Friend

Staff Review With Laurie Kilmartin

25 min
Mar 19, 20262 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Conan O'Brien interviews staff writer Laurie Kilmartin about her role as both a stand-up comedian and Oscar joke writer. They discuss the creative process behind developing material for the upcoming Oscars ceremony, including how jokes are tested at comedy clubs, refined based on current events, and organized for live performance at the Dolby Theater.

Insights
  • Testing comedy material in intimate club settings provides essential feedback before high-stakes performances, allowing comedians to gauge audience reaction and refine delivery
  • Oscar joke writing requires real-time adaptability—material developed months in advance must be updated based on breaking news and shifting cultural relevance
  • Separating personal comedy voice from writing for others is a distinct professional skill that requires understanding different comedic perspectives and audiences
  • Behind-the-scenes creative processes benefit from deliberate downtime and tangential discussions, which can paradoxically improve overall output quality
  • Organizational systems and physical workspace setup significantly impact live performance execution, especially for high-pressure events with multiple contingency jokes
Trends
Live comedy testing as quality assurance for scripted television performancesReal-time content adaptation in response to breaking news and cultural momentsCross-platform comedy development (stand-up clubs informing late-night television)Collaborative creative processes that blend structured writing with improvisational explorationImportance of physical organization systems in high-stakes live broadcast environments
Topics
Oscar ceremony joke writing and developmentStand-up comedy material testing and refinementComedy writing for television versus personal stand-upLive performance preparation and rehearsal strategiesComedy club ecosystem in Los AngelesReal-time content adaptation for current eventsWriter's room dynamics and creative collaborationStand-up comedy career developmentAudience feedback and material evaluationBroadcast production logistics and backstage organization
Companies
HBO
Conan mentions HBO travel show production and editing work happening at his office
TBS
Laurie Kilmartin mentions starting her television writing career with a TBS show packet
The Tonight Show
Laurie references writing a packet for The Tonight Show early in her career
Late Night
Laurie mentions writing a packet for Late Night 2 before her TBS work
Saturday Night Live
Laurie references working on SNL and doing seat-filler stand-ins at VH1 awards during that time
VH1
Laurie worked as a seat-filler stand-in at VH1 awards show while working on Saturday Night Live
SiriusXM
Podcast sponsor offering three free months of service to listeners
People
Laurie Kilmartin
Long-time writer and stand-up comedian who serves as Conan's life coach for Oscar joke testing
Conan O'Brien
Late-night host preparing Oscar ceremony material with his writing team
Jimmy Kimmel
Conan recommended Laurie Kilmartin to Kimmel for his writing staff
Brian Kiley
Fellow writer on Conan's team who contributes jokes and participates in writer's room discussions
Robin Williams
Historical reference to early stand-up comedy scene in San Francisco mentored by John Cantu
John Cantu
Bartender at Holy City Zoo in San Francisco who mentored early comedians including Laurie
Isabella Rossellini
Oscar nominee referenced in joke writing about her bed and breakfast in Rye, New York
Jesse Buckley
Oscar nominee whose Irish Civil War family history was researched for potential joke material
Timothy Chalamet
Referenced as example of A-list celebrity who might have stand-in at Oscar rehearsals
Brad Pitt
Referenced as example of A-list celebrity attending Oscar ceremony
Ariana Grande
Referenced as having stand-in at Oscar rehearsal who sang during performance
David Bowie
Laurie recalls announcing him as Oscar winner when working as seat-filler at VH1 awards
Mary Lou Retton
Referenced in context of Conan appearing in old TV clips from when he was younger
Sophia Carla Gascon
Oscar nominee whose controversy was discussed as potential joke material topic
Quotes
"There's never been a joke I've written for you or anybody else that I would have done myself. People always think that, you know, it must be so hard to give up that joke. It's like, no, no, it would not work in my act about me complaining about being a mother."
Laurie KilmartinMid-episode
"When something's no longer magical and fun to me, I can't fake it."
Conan O'BrienMid-episode
"The true inspirations are people like, how did that ass get up there? Exactly. Exactly. So I saw a bunch of that."
Laurie KilmartinEarly episode
"I maintain that wasting time is somehow useful if we're all laughing. But I might just be trying to justify."
Conan O'BrienMid-episode
"You just have to navigate, is that scandal? Wait, what's the trajectory now? That's the big story today. Yeah. But will it still be the big story in a week or how do we handle it?"
Conan O'BrienLate episode
Full Transcript
Okay, in the past, this slot has usually been a time when I would talk to fans around the world. But today is a little different. I'm going to talk to someone who's definitely not a fan of mine. No, we've been doing this lately and I'm really enjoying it. Writers are coming up soon. As we tape this, I think it's about three weeks away. And we've been working very hard. I'm working with an incredible team of writers, many of them I've worked with for a long time. And I've been having them come upstairs and chat with me a little bit. And it's been really fun. And that continues today with Lori Kilmartin. Lori, thank you for coming on out. Oh, I hope it continues today. Yes, that's it. You're out. No, Lori. He was right. It was fun. Get back down there. Lori, you are an incredible stand-up comedian and you've worked with me for a long time. And always done an incredible job and worked with me on the Oscars last year. And Lori has a very special role, which is Lori, because she's a great stand-up, she's the one that has become my life coach when I go out into the world and try Oscar jokes out. So Lori's the one that says, we're going to get you out there now, Conor. And I say, all right, okay. And you're very verbally abusive. And then you've been picking all these amazing spots. Some of them I've been to before, some of them I haven't. And it's really fun. But you're so dialed into these places. And then you watch me do my set and you have great instincts about which ones work, which ones may need a tweak, which ones should probably go by their wayside. But let's go back to the beginning, which is you come to my attention. How did that happen? I'm trying to remember. Well, I started on the TBS show. So I think that was my third packet. I think I'd done a packet for The Tonight Show and Late Night 2. So the third one worked, I guess. Yeah. Well, The Tonight Show, there wasn't a lot of time there. Yeah, I don't know if you got it or you're reading it. Yeah, I was starting to open the envelope when that thing blew up. And subsequently, when you first came to work for me, I had not seen your stand-up. And then we toured together. Oh, yeah. And I got to see your stand-up every night, which is phenomenal. Just phenomenal. Oh, thanks. I don't know. I look back and I'm like, oh, that bit was still, I was still working on it. I got sharper. But I'm glad you liked what you saw. Because you have that kind of mind, you're never going to say, oh, yeah, thanks. You're going to say, this was a little... But I'm telling you, it was phenomenal. Oh, thank you. You have such a good eye and ear that you've been just a great help to me in terms of what stuff works, how to tweak a joke when something isn't hitting the ear quite right. And that's really helpful. And I'm just curious, when did you decide, okay, I'm going to be a stand-up? Because that's the leap that everyone comes to differently. How did it happen for you? I had dropped out of college and I had a breakdown due to various things all colliding at once in my head. You were a very good athlete. I was okay. I was a swimmer. I swam for UCLA, but I was like, they were in a rebuilding phase. I would never make the team now. They were low-level division one when I was there. And so, yeah. And then I had quit swimming and whatever. So you go through this period of your life where things are rough. And then I started to, I don't know, I went and saw some stand-up. And I'm not the only one who's come to stand up this way where you see some great stand-up and you're like, oh, I could never do that. That's amazing. And then you see someone who's not good and they're on the bill and you're like, wait a minute, that person's a comic. They're the true inspirations. No one ever says that. The true inspirations are people like, how did that ass get up there? Exactly. Exactly. So I saw a bunch of that. And so I started in San Francisco because I'm from the Bay Area. So that's right. And San Francisco is such a great place for stand-up. Yeah. Yeah, it's weird. There's this guy named, oh my God, his name was, I forget his last name. He was a former porn star who, and Native American, and was like one of like 11 or 16 children, some crazy backstory. But he was the bartender at the Holy City Zoo. And he knew Robin Williams and he was around when Robin had started to. And so he was sort of the mother bird of all of us newer comics and giving us stage timing tips and stuff like that. And like, even though, I don't know, I never had a bad situation with him, even though his backstory sounds troublesome. Yeah. But he- John Cantu. Yeah. And he saw something in you. He was like, okay, he was encouraging? Yeah, he was encouraging. But he's also running a class. So anytime someone's paying, they're always encouraging. But they're encouraging, but also they don't think you're ready just yet. One more session. I ran the same thing in improv. Same thing in improv. Right. You're very good. I think a little more work. Really? How many levels does this go? People are really laughing right now. Yeah. There's 11 more levels. You said this was the last one. I forgot about the other 11. So just make that check out too. So you're doing that and had you worked on television shows before, had you written for other comics? Because that's a very different thing. You write for yourself and then writing for someone else's voice. Yeah. It is a big thing. And it's weird because you can definitely separate those two voices. There's never been a joke I've written for you or anybody else that I would have done myself. People always think that, you know, it must be so hard to give up that joke. It's like, no, no, it would not work in my act about me complaining about being a mother. You know? It's really funny. Yeah. Many times I've seen you do. Kona's like, I'm not a single mom. Why does she keep giving me this stuff? I tried it last night. It killed. Yeah. It's fascinating to me because that's another fun thing I get to do. If I see you or Brian Kiley tell a really funny joke, I get to say, oh, oh, too funny for me, huh? Like, why didn't you give me that? You'd be like, idiot. You never breastfed. Oh, oh, oh, you're right. Kiley did though. So he was a teller. Yeah, exactly. I breastfed Kylie. What the fuck? Hey. One tag too far. Yeah. I always go too far. I don't do the late night, my late night show anymore. And I think a while ago, Jimmy Kimmel contacted me and he was asking me about this, Laurie Kilmerton. I said, you are an absolute fool if you do not hire Laurie Kilmerton. I can't believe that conversation happened. She is the best. She is the best. But Jimmy was high at the time and he forgot. And then I had to call him and tell him again. He was like, oh, yeah, yeah, okay. But so you've been killing it, not just for me, but for Jimmy as well. And now we're once again working on the Oscars. And I'm curious, how do you think it's going so far? We're getting close. I think we're way ahead of where we were this time last year. I think we have a lot more jokes that are ready. We have a lot of jokes. We do. And it's like they could all change in the next three weeks too. Because we keep coming up with. Yeah, it's. We keep coming up with new ones. And then we always allow for, last year I remembered, the actual show is a moving target. You can't lock down what you're going to do a month out because in the world we live in now, things change day to day. And something that's a joke we might have thought was really funny in December is now like, what were we thinking? That's not even something people think about anymore. That's out of the news. No one cares about that. The big thing I have to fight is sometimes I just start to get tired of a joke because I've, it's been with me for a while. And that's always been a little bit my issue when we toured together and I had a, I don't know, like a 40 minute stand up hunk. I remembered sometimes being, I don't want to say that again. I said that last night. So I think that's one of the luxuries I've always had is just riffing foolishly about different things. And I get bored if I have to say the same thing over and over and over again. I know. In fact, there's one joke you told last night. I'm like, oh, you got to give that one a rest for a little bit because I think you are tired of it. You know? So I don't want to say it now, but yeah. Right. That's good. We should try them all out right now. Yeah. Let's do it. And everyone's really, all the writers are really mad at me. You just, that thing went out. What? It just burned 80 jokes. It just burned 80 jokes. Yeah, that can happen where I just start to feel, it's almost like my brain becomes overly familiar with it. And it's no, when something's no longer magical and fun to me, I can't fake it. Well, yeah. Plus with you every night, you've told different jokes. So you, you aren't used to going up and doing the same jokes and then finding, like trying to take two months to find a tag or something like that, you know? So for you, it's, it's got to feel really, really repetitive. But also I love the joking around between the jokes so much. I know, I know, I know. That sometimes I'm getting off on some jag and people in a club are liking it. And I'm sure you guys are watching saying, we're trying to try out these jokes and you're going off on a 10 minutes about your brother, Neil, and you're getting laughs. And so you're getting drunk off of it. Get to the jokes. But I do think that's what's so great about doing these little sets is, is you're clicking into your stage persona, which is different from podcast and bursting into the writers room. And so I don't know that it's that different from bursting in the writers room is sort of more of my like MMA persona. Yeah. Yeah. But it gets, it gets that very unique muscle, you know, going again. And because you can't like do 10 minutes about Neil at the Oscars. Oh, I'm going to. That would be amazing. Just see Timothy Chalamet and Brad Pitt streaming out. People who are up for an Oscar leaving early. Okay. So we bought a lot of televisions. Yeah. Yeah. But you get it out of that part of your system now, but you also get that muscle ready for when you're in the big show. And then you had some really funny riffs after the jokes last night that we all thought would work with the jokes. You did too. Oh, good. I'm really loving it. Yeah. I enjoy going to, as I said, some of the places I've been before, but there's this ecosystem in LA of all these cool little spots. Some are way out in Covina. Some are, I mean, really, I mean, who lives in Covina? Oh, hi, Edward. Oh, how are you? Oh, shut up. Shut up. No, no, it's fine. You know, I have my passport. I changed my currency. Oh, my God. No, no, it's, no, but it was, and that was one of my favorite clubs. It's fantastic. Chatterbox, yeah. But, and Chatterbox in Covina. It's really fun because you get to hang out with the comics outside. And it's this, it's very communal. It's really fun. I like all that young energy. People are really nice. And each club is very different. There are places that I'm guessing you've played all these places. Yeah. Yeah. And so, and you do stand up, you do stand up a lot. I do. I do. I try to do it for, I'll say four nights a week. That's a lot. Yeah. But here in LA, it's like one spot at night. It's not, it's not great. Like in New York, you can do, when I go back to New York, I can do like at least six a night, you know, on a Friday or Saturday. And then, you know, one or two, at least on a, on a day trip. It's covering the distances. Yeah. It's literally, I mean, last night I was in, was it? Atwater Village. Yeah, TGs. Yeah. TGs. I was at TGs in Atwater Village. And so, that's a long haul to get to. Yeah. And, but once you're there, it's again, really fun. It was great. It was great. I mean, it was packed and it's great to have people so close to you, you know, just your surround sound of laughter. Yeah. It's also fun to be a surprise. Yeah. There's some, somehow the pressure is off. Yeah. For sure. They don't, you know, they're there and then suddenly I show up and you can always see them registering, you know, how I've aged when I first get up there. Oh, I don't think so. No, it's funny. No, it's just funny how people are like, if there are people that have only seen you on TV and some of them have been seeing me on TV since I was, you know. Or clips are coming up. Clips are coming up and they just saw me last night talking to, you know, Mary Lou Retton when I'm 30. Oh my God. You know what I mean? Yeah. But you're also a big presence. Like you're a big person and you're like stumbling, not stumbling. I don't stumble. I'm sorry, I know. As soon as I said it, I was like, you're not stumbling. Well, maybe I was stumbling. Like a giant. Yeah. I mean, you know, it's. It's been. It's been a good time. Now, it's what's really strange. This is all behind the scenes stuff is we're sort of we're here at the office. This is where we do the podcast. This is where we do the production and editing for the HBO travel show. We have all different kind of meetings here and different projects. It's like our little Kiebler Elf tree. And what's going to happen in two weeks is we're going to move into the Dolby Theater. That's going to be I remember that last year being, oh, wow, this is real. Yeah. We've been living here and imagining things. And then you actually see the space. Yeah. And then we get into, you know, we ordered some kooky prop and it shows up. And I'm like, we wanted a stuffed mule and we didn't. I'm just making this up. But stuff, mule would be great. Yeah. You know, I want one now. Get a stuffed mule. Yeah, I know. Yeah. And then you're arguing with really serious, talented people about how the mule should be. Oh, my gosh. You pictured it differently. And how is it going to fire a rocket out of its ear? You know, all that kind of craziness. Yeah. That's the part that where things really level up. Yeah. Which is exciting. And I remember sitting at a rehearsal last year and a lot of a lot of the celebrities had stand-ins or, you know, they just use you stand-ins and a stand-in for Ariana Grande and they started singing and I'm like, oh, my God, she sounds just like Ariana Grande. And it was her. Which I didn't think. What? Yes. She was at rehearsal singing. It was like 25 of us in the audience. I'm like, it was a stand-in. Yeah. Hey, she's not bad. Did you tell her, you know, maybe you should try. That's really funny if all of the A-list celebrities, because they do have actors often who look nothing like them. Yeah. And they all get up. They don't know who the winner is, but they'll say and the winner is Timmy Chalamet and then a, you know, a black woman will get up on stage, but she'll give a real speech as Timothy Chalamet. And it's kind of cool. Yeah. Yeah. And I channel that sometimes because I did that once. I did that once. I think we talked about this, but I did it years ago at like a VH1 award when I was working on Saturday Night Live and I heard, hey, they need seat filler stand-ins for this VH1 award. So I, you know, sat in the audience. We weren't working at the time. I think I got like, I don't know what I got, like $100 or something. But I went and I sat in the crowd and then they said, on the winner is David Bowie and I got to stand up and thank everybody. And I'm going to do that. It was fun. That sounds fun. Yeah. Yeah. You're fired. Now you can go do it. Oh. So yeah, that's going to, things are going to get real. What else do you remember from last year? Well, what I remember now, what we were all talking about in the mono team is that we want to make sure we have big cork boards up and back where we are so we can keep track of jokes a little bit better. I think we were just like flipping through cards and trying to. It looked like we were doing an illicit three card money game last year. And you think this is the Oscars. And I'm performing for all these people around the world. And we're like, where's that joke? I don't know. And then it's attached to someone's ass. Come on. Right. I mean, we'll have the mono set, but the stuff like, you know, that you'll say later in the show, if something wins or something gets on a streak, I guess we. Yes, then that it's almost like coding. Yes. You know, if this movie wins, we have this great joke. If that movie loses, we have this great joke. Yeah. I remember us just like going, wait, we had something and kind of panicking. And then thought of it at the last second, but. But it'll be nice to have that a little bit more organized. And I think we hadn't gotten backstage until in our area until the show was starting in an hour, you know, so we didn't realize, oh, that would have been nice to have had we had we thought that. So, you know, that's the we'll be doing that better this year, I think. Yeah, it is fun, I have to say. It's a lot of work and it's nerve wracking, but it is fun. And then, you know, you just. And then you're always thinking, I hope it's a good room. Last year, I was I mean, I think last year I was thinking, how is it going to be a good room and they were good? Yeah, I mean, we had the fires, of course, you know, and then I feel like at this time last year, we were also a wash and Sophia Carla Gascon drama. Yes, we have so many. Amelia Perez. Yes. And, you know, we were just trying to figure out again, is that scandal? Wait, what's the trajectory now? That's the big story today. Yeah. But will it still be the big story in a week or how do we handle it? And we want to be there. Is she going to be there? And what's a joke that isn't doesn't go too far this way or that way? And just it's a lot of trying to navigate. Yeah. You know, let's pitch the sail correctly so it catches the wind in just the right way. And it's and we boy, we get into arguments. You know, which is probably happening right now just before below us. Yeah, my ritual is I like to come. I like to kick the door open in a very dramatic way. Yes. And you guys all go, whoa. And then I come in and I think I waste time mostly. You do. I do all my bits. You guys are patiently. Yeah, we watched. What's the what did we watch yesterday for like a half hour? Sarah Jessica Parker. The sequel. Just like that. Just like that. Yeah. Yeah. Someone was talking about there's something on that show. So we watched that. Yes. I said, let's call it up. And so we're watching that. And then we all, you know, and I said at that moment, if someone from the Academy comes by and we're all watching it just like that and just like that, they're going to say, we're screwed. Yeah. But yeah, we will pull up things on the internet. I mean, it's a typical writer's room. Yeah, you got to waste time. You have to waste time. I maintain that wasting time is somehow useful if we're all laughing. But I might just be trying to justify. I was going to say, I think you're just telling yourself that so you can waste everybody's time. And just like that, you guys watch that for a half an hour. It was so it was really enjoyable. The way we. Episode. Yes. It was an episode specifically. It took place in a stand up club and yeah. Of a comedy concert. Yeah. I know what you're talking about. So it was just, you know, it's one of those things where, you know, we start chatting and then the next thing you know, we're all watching television. And then I can always tell that, oh, I should have left 10 minutes ago. What I try and do is leave on a laugh. If I get a big laugh, I try and get out the door fast. But if someone stops me on the way out the door, then I think I have to get another laugh. It's terrible. Well, it's the version of a writer's room, what you do on stage when you're messing around with the audience of friend. It kind of gets your gets that part of your brain going, but it's not the official jokes. You know, I think it's a good reprieve for the brain. And then we all go back to trying to deal with the the setup that Sinners has 16 Oscar nominations. Well, that's the other thing too, is we're always looking for premises. And sometimes we look too hard and a writer will write all these jokes about, you know, did you realize that the first best cinematography award was handed out in 1947? And then they write five jokes about that. And I think I've lost the audience with the setup to that joke. That I still get me fun of because last year we were sweating and Isabella Rossolini was nominated. So one of my setups was that she had a bed and breakfast in New York. That's right. That's right. Did you know Isabella Rossolini is nominated for an Academy Award? Did you know she has a bed and breakfast in Rye, New York? Can you imagine like that would be your top 15 jokes at the Oscars? I look down and one of the scars guards is just like, what the fuck? Yeah, Rye, New York. Yeah. Yeah, you can. You can take the teaconic. But when Brian loses audience after a strong start, or Brian went on a 30 minute discourse and how hard it must be to run a bed and breakfast in upstate New York. But Rossolini is booked for the rest of the year. It's great advertisement. Oh, she'd be thrilled. Yeah, really, though. She does. She does. Is she there at the bed and breakfast? I don't think so. Are you going to repitch this joke? I will. And this will be even funnier because it's like Isabella Rossolini not nominated this year. But as you know, she has a bed and breakfast in upstate New York. Well, I did find out that Jesse Buckley's great grandmother was he in the Irish Civil War fighting for the Irish. Oh, there you go. Yeah. Yes. Well, that's always bringing up the Irish Civil War. Always get some laughing. Great premise. Yeah. That's a good one. Yeah. How about the famine? You got any good Irish famine jokes? Of course, we won't have that problem tonight because we got plenty of food at the buffet. Well, I'm just saying I'm allowed to do it. Oh, man. Oh, my God. Well, this is really fun. And I am honored and thrilled that you helping me out again because you're the best. Thank you for having me back. You are the best. And thank you to Jimmy Kimmel for letting me have eight weeks off to come here to. Yeah. I'm sorry, Jimmy. But yeah, and he's mad about it too. I'm mad. No, you know what? And true thanks to him because when you were on my staff writing jokes for me, I would not have let you go for eight weeks for anything. If you were doing a blood transfusion, I would not let you go. But so thank you very much, Jimmy. And yeah, let's get back downstairs. Let's get back downstairs. Conan O'Brien needs a fan with Conan O'Brien, Sonam of Sessian and Matt Gourley, produced by me, Matt Gourley, executive produced by Adam Sacks, Jeff Frost and Nick Leaugh. Incidental music by Jimmy Vivino. Take it away, Jimmy. Supervising producer Aaron Blair, associate talent producer Jennifer Samples, associate producers Sean Doherty and Lisa Berm. Engineering by Eduardo Perez. Get three free months of SiriusXM when you sign up at SiriusXM.com slash Conan. Please rate, review and subscribe to Conan O'Brien needs a fan wherever fine podcasts are done.