Reflecting on the year in tariffs
6 min
•Apr 2, 202616 days agoSummary
This episode examines the economic impact of tariffs imposed over the past year, finding that consumers and small businesses bore most of the costs while few promised benefits materialized. It also explores the growing private credit market, where unregulated firms are increasingly lending to businesses, with experts suggesting cautious optimism about systemic risk.
Insights
- Tariff costs were primarily passed to consumers and small businesses rather than achieving stated policy goals, with actual rates roughly half of threatened levels
- Private credit funds are structurally more stable than traditional banks due to lower leverage and long-term capital structures, reducing systemic financial crisis risk
- Tariff uncertainty has created a lobbying boom, with a six-fold increase in trade-related lobbying as industries seek exemptions
- Private credit sector poses moderate risk (4-5 out of 10) but banking sector leverage and interest rate exposure present greater systemic concerns
- Retail investor entry into private credit markets represents a shift in how non-bank lending is financed and distributed
Trends
Increased lobbying activity around trade policy as businesses seek tariff exemptions and protectionGrowth of private credit market as alternative to traditional bank lending for business financingExpansion of retail investor access to private credit funds previously limited to institutional investorsSupply chain cost inflation driven by tariffs on imported materials and packagingRegulatory arbitrage in financial services as non-bank lenders operate outside traditional banking oversightStickiness of interest rates limiting monetary policy effectiveness and banking sector stabilityHidden risks in banking sector balance sheets related to interest rate exposure
Topics
Tariff policy and economic impactSupply chain disruption and cost inflationTrade lobbying and exemption processesPrivate credit markets and non-bank lendingFinancial system stability and leverageInstitutional investor capital allocationBanking sector interest rate riskRetail investor access to alternative creditInternational trade relationsSmall business cost pressures
Companies
Botnia
California-based skincare company experiencing 50% cost increases on imported oils, packaging, and herbs due to tariffs
Competitive Enterprise Institute
Think tank where economist Ryan Young analyzed the broader economic impact of enacted tariffs
Cato Institute
Policy institute where Scott Lincecum documented six-fold increase in trade-related lobbying activity
Columbia Business School
Academic institution where Professor Tomasz Piskorski conducted research on private credit fund stability
People
Tomasz Piskorski
Reviewed 1,200 private credit funds and assessed systemic financial risk from non-bank lending sector
Justine Kahn
Skincare company executive discussing how tariffs increased costs from $10,000 to $15,000 on typical orders
Ryan Young
Analyzed that enacted tariff rates were roughly half of what was threatened at Rose Garden press conference
Scott Lincecum
Documented six-fold increase in trade lobbying as industries seek tariff exemptions and protection
Kimberly Adams
Reported on tariff impacts and economic consequences throughout the episode
Subri Benishor
Hosted the episode and conducted interviews
Quotes
"And so what used to cost, you know, if we placed a $10,000 order, now costs us $15,000. And so that has really impacted our business."
Justine Kahn, CEO of Botnia
"The tariffs were mostly paid by us. Consumers and small businesses."
Kimberly Adams
"Private credit funds are much more conservatively structured. 65 to 70% of the capital comes from these limited partners, the equity holders."
Tomasz Piskorski
"For a typical bank to suffer a loss on the private credit fund loan, the assets of these funds would have to decline 60, 70%. Compared to only 10% for a regular bank."
Tomasz Piskorski
"What worries me more is the state of the banking sector in US. The banks are still very heavily levered."
Tomasz Piskorski
Full Transcript