Financial Coaching for Women: How To Budget, Manage Money, Pay Off Debt, Save Money, Paycheck Plans

10 Top Tips to Pay Off Debt and Stop Using Credit Cards | 579

19 min
Jun 15, 2026about 1 month ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Financial coaches Shayna and Vanessa share 10 actionable strategies for paying off debt and breaking credit card dependency. The episode emphasizes establishing a realistic budget first, choosing flexible debt payoff methods based on monthly cash flow, and paying debt immediately upon receiving income to avoid spending temptation.

Insights
  • Credit card balance is not a budget—using credit cards for everyday expenses creates a false sense of financial control and typically increases spending by 10-15% compared to cash/debit methods
  • Debt payoff method selection should be flexible and monthly-dependent rather than rigid; clients can switch between snowball, avalanche, and minimum payment methods based on current financial circumstances
  • The psychological impact of seeing debt balances decrease immediately after payment is critical for behavior change and long-term financial identity reformation
  • Establishing spending baseline (groceries, gas, personal money) must precede both savings bucket funding and aggressive debt payoff to prevent budget failure
  • Buy-now-pay-later services (Klarna, Afterpay, PayPal Credit) deliberately use zero-interest promotional periods to confuse consumers and lock them into spending patterns
Trends
Growing consumer reliance on BNPL (buy-now-pay-later) services as alternative debt products, particularly among younger demographicsShift in financial coaching methodology from prescriptive one-size-fits-all debt payoff to personalized, flexible monthly strategiesIncreased emphasis on behavioral psychology and identity reformation in financial coaching rather than pure mathematical optimizationStore credit card marketing strategies targeting checkout moments with aggressive discounting (30-50% off) to overcome consumer resistanceRising awareness among financial coaches that credit card spending increases 10-15% vs. cash/debit due to psychological distance from moneyDebt deferment and payment plan negotiation becoming standard coaching practice to create short-term budget reliefPaycheck-aligned debt payment timing emerging as critical behavioral intervention to prevent discretionary spending of allocated debt funds
Companies
PayPal
Criticized for using zero-interest promotional periods to trap consumers into ongoing credit usage through confusing ...
Klarna
Mentioned as a buy-now-pay-later service that coaches advise clients to avoid due to debt accumulation risks
Afterpay
Referenced as a BNPL service that uses marketing strategies to encourage consumer spending beyond their means
Venmo
Noted for launching a credit card product that coaches warn clients against using
Dave Ramsey's Organization
Training organization for the hosts; Shayna and Vanessa are master financial coaches trained by Dave Ramsey
People
Shayna
Co-host and co-founder of the podcast; provides debt payoff strategies and client case studies
Vanessa
Co-host and co-founder of the podcast; discusses behavioral psychology in financial coaching
Quotes
"Your credit card balance is not your budget. You're playing a game that you didn't know you were in."
Shayna or VanessaOpening and recurring theme
"You're not actually in control of your money. You're not actually budgeting when you're using that for everything or when you're using it to bail you out."
Shayna or VanessaMid-episode
"If you pay off your car, you get $800 back in your budget tomorrow."
VanessaDebt prioritization discussion
"It's literally a whole different way that you handle your finances. And so being able to implement one part at a time, yes, it may not happen as fast as you want it to happen, but you're going to be successful longer."
Shayna or VanessaMindset and habit formation section
"We love math because money doesn't lie or numbers don't lie."
Shayna or VanessaBudget accountability discussion
Full Transcript
Your credit card balance is not your budget. You're playing a game that you didn't know you were in. Everybody wants to get right to the savings buckets. Everybody wants to get right to paying off debt. But the first step is your spending column. Figure that out first. You're not actually in control of your money. You're not actually budgeting when you're using that for everything or when you're using it to bail you out. It's literally a whole different way that you handle your finances. Do you make good money but have nothing to show for it? Are you tired of living paycheck to paycheck? Do you have big dreams for your financial future? Do you want to get debt-free but you don't want to live on beans and rice? Or you don't want to give up those pumpkin spice lattes? If you don't already know how to budget or if you're using credit cards to get through the month. If you want to seem like you have your finances all together or you're not on the same page with your spouse when it comes to finances. We know what you're doing probably isn't working. But guess what? You're in the right place. We're Shayna. And Vanessa. We're best friends, business partners, and master financial coaches trained by Dave Ramsey. We've been in business since 2019 helping hundreds of amazing people like you create budgets, get out of debt, stop living paycheck to paycheck, and know exactly what to do with their money. In this podcast, we'll share with you everything we know plus everything we're working on with our clients so that you have the best chance at reaching your financial goals. We want to help you take the guesswork out of your budget, improve your marriages, and even bring your kids in on the conversation. We can help you no matter where you're at, whether you're the single mom who's never had $500 in her savings account, or the millionaire who's paid off four real estate mortgages. And we're not gonna shy away from the tough love. We'll tell you what you need to hear and encourage you at the same time. This is the Financial Coaching for Women podcast. All right, if you're trying to pay off debt but still feel like nothing is working, this episode is for you. We pulled together 10 of our best debt payoff tips to help you stop spinning your wheels, stop making debt wars, and start making real progress with a plan that actually fits real life. So what other people tell you is to put extra on debt, pay, double, do your snowball method or whatever. How do you know how much you can do? This is how you figure out how much you can pay. You have taken your income, you've subtracted your minimums, you've subtracted all your bills, you've subtracted what you're gonna spend on groceries, gas, spending money, your haircuts, your kids, your pets, whatever you're gonna spend on your life every month, and you've subtracted what you need to be saving for so you don't have to use debt right in the future. And so now all of that equals, hopefully not zero, but it'll equal a number, and that's how much you can put extra on debt to begin with. So let's talk about paying off debt. How many, like, do we always recommend the snowball method or how many different ways do we talk about how to pay off debt? Yeah, so the most popular way that you probably have heard a lot of talk about is the snowball, but we, in our budget system, all of this is in our budget system, all of the math does it automatically for you that we're gonna talk about. But we also list the avalanche method and the minimum payment method, okay? Just really quickly, the snowball method is gonna go, you're gonna pay each card off by balance, right? By the minimum, or the current balance, and it's gonna be the lower one first, and then you're gonna go from there. The avalanche is actually gonna look at the biggest balance slash biggest interest rate, and you're gonna look at the biggest interest rate and try to get that one knocked out because otherwise you're paying so much more just to have the card every month. And then finally, the minimum payment method is you look at, I have a client right now, they have, I'm not kidding you, they have a $1,200 or $1,800 balance, and the minimum payment is $320 a month, okay? So I'm like, whatever we do, even though that's not your smallest one, you're gonna pay that one off first because you get $320 back in your budget. So we look at the minimum payment, and that's how we decide that one. I think that's really big. I had a lady come in for a free call one time, and she was like, she completely bypassed her car payment. She had $3,000 left to pay on her car, but her car payment was like $800. Yes, exactly. And I said, just pay off your car, and she's like, yeah, but the interest rate's 6%. I'm like, doesn't matter. If you pay off your car, you get $800 back in your budget tomorrow. And she was like, oh, that was an aha moment for her, that light bulb moment. She was like, oh, I didn't realize that. So we're not always recommending the snowball. What we always do recommend is if you have that $1,000 and you're gonna put it on debt, then the next time when you pay off the whatever one you do, whether it's avalanche minimum or snowball, you're gonna still roll that other minimum payment into this new amount of money that you have left over each month. Yeah, the extra on debt, that you're budget on purpose each month. Yes, so now you're rolling all of that over, but it doesn't necessarily have to be in the snowball method, but you're still taking all that extra money and putting it towards debt. Sometimes you may get a bonus, and so one month, actually, I'm gonna do the debt avalanche this month, this time, because this works better for me right now. It doesn't, oh wait, once you choose a method, doesn't mean you have to stick with it every time. Right, and it really does depend on the set on the moment. So you might do the snowball throughout the year, and then every once in a while, when you get a bigger chunk of money, or when you have a different situation, and you might go one or two months to an avalanche or a minimum payment method, and then you go right back to the snowball. But really, it is up to your budget, and that's why knowing that extra on debt is so important, and actually, every month, it might change because you might get overtime, you might have a garage sale, you might do some other things to get you more extra on debt, and so if you only have $300 regularly every month, but then this month, I worked a bunch of overtime and I have $1,300, that might change which debt you pay off, it might change your answer to that question, and that's why it's so important to have that whole list of them, and see all of it. You can see the minimum payment amount, you can see the current balance amount, you can see your interest rate, you can see it all, and make an informed decision each month. And you may have two debts, let's talk about this. One has $13,000 and one has $14,000, okay? And your $13,000 one has a interest rate of 16%, but your $14,000 one has an interest rate of 31%. You better be sure that we're gonna be tackling that $14,000 balance one first, if you are coaching with us, because the balance is right there. You're playing a game that you didn't know you were in. I think that's really what happens, is you're doing this for so long and then all of a sudden you look up, become the ostrich in the sand, and you look up and you're like, what is happening? How did I get myself on this situation? It's because you're exactly where they want you to be. And I hate to say it, I'm not trying to be ugly, and even a lot of people come to us and they say, yeah, but I don't pay any interest because I pay it off every month, but you're probably, and we've seen it nine times out of 10, you spend more money naturally because you're using a credit card versus using a budget. If you were using a debit card, instead of using a credit card, you would spend less money because you're more conscious of your spending habits. So it really does make a difference. Your credit card balance is not your budget. Washing that go up every month is stressful, it's unnecessary, and it again, is not a budget. Yeah, it's not a budget, and I think we're just relying on it because we're in the throes of life, the throes of busy life, but you're not actually in control of your money, you're not actually budgeting when you're using that for everything, or when you're using it to bail you out. But we understand it's not necessarily the easiest thing to do, but and so what we often do with our clients is they will, we will come in, we will put everything on one piece of paper, and they will say, oh, I have more money than I thought, oh, I don't need to use a credit card, and if we can just start there, it doesn't mean you necessarily will be able to pay off all of your debt month one, right? But your first step to breaking up with your credit cards is to not use them anymore. That's what we wanna do, we wanna not use them, use our budget, use cash, use the debit card, like Vanessa said, get on a budget. And then when you see that budget altogether, you'll see how much extra you can start to put on debt and get those, and then you can start really, truly building wealth, investing whatever it is you wanna do, and be in control of your money, be in control of your financial future. So there's one thing that you heard, or you're gonna hear out of this entire podcast, it's swap the credit card for the debit card, and it's gonna be hard, especially when you've been relying on credit for so long, we get it, but you have to start somewhere. So anyway, PayPal though, can we just say, please don't do it. We advise against all debt, but definitely PayPal. Don't open that, even though I think now there's a Venmo credit card and stuff, don't get sucked into any of it. Or the karma, afterpay, sizzle, all that. Clarna, yeah. All of those are big enough for you, but PayPal is very interesting because they, zero interest periods, they loop you in with that. Oh, it's super sneaky. And it's zero interest for another month or whatever. Who could keep up with that? I've had several clients try. I think that's the point though, right? They try to confuse you enough so you don't even do anything about it. It gives you enough, in your mind, enough wiggle room. Oh, okay, I'll be able to pay this off for sure in six months. But no, the answer is you're not going to, for the most part. But just don't play, what is the phrase, love you. Saying this with love. Play stupid games, get stupid prizes. That's what we're doing. We're not playing stupid games. We're not getting stupid prizes. You don't need a store card. Here's a bonus tip, I don't use debt. Every single time you go to checkout, they'll say, would you like our store card? You're gonna say, no thank you, I don't use debt. Or find a phrase and just get used to saying it. Don't care what their offer is, don't care what their deal is, it's a hard pass for you. You don't even think about it. Just the words are coming out of your mouth as they're saying it to you. So you don't get tempted. Cause that's 30% off, 40% off, 50% off or whatever. You guys have to understand that their marketing strategies, like their marketing budget is more than we'll ever make in a lifetime because they know that if they can just get you to open the card, you're gonna spend so much more money with them. And you don't need it. When you need new clothes or whatever it is, buy it with cash, you don't need the temptation to spend more, be nice to yourself and don't do that. Call every one of those creditors, debt companies, whichever ones that you're listing out in your debt tracker, you're gonna call them all. You're gonna see if they can offer you a lower interest rate or deferment sometimes. So I have a client right now, we're actually strategically waiting for her, which months she's gonna ask for her vehicle to be deferred because we're gonna need that. We're gonna need that coming up, right? But you can get your vehicle loan one month deferred, it'll just add it to the end of the loan and that will free up that money for one month. And sometimes that's really gonna help you. It's gonna help you get ahead or something. So we want you to do all of that. Go through, contact them, see if they have any payment plan or something that's gonna be more advantageous to you or make your budget life easier. And then also maybe if you can defer something here or there, that will help too. It's time to enter your coaching era because making good money should feel like making good money. Yeah, imagine six months of private coaching where we'll tell you exactly what to do. No guesswork, no confusion and absolutely no judgment. It's a done for you system that actually works. You don't know what you don't know and that's not your fault. And that's why we're here. Financial coaching with us looks like two coaching sessions a month, personalized recaps and after hour support you can text an email. So you're never stuck wondering what to do next. Together we're gonna build your budget, set up your system and tackle any challenges that come up along the way, which by the way they always do. If what you're doing isn't working and you're tired of trying to figure it out on your own, sign up for financial coaching at budgetbesties.com forward slash coaching before all of our spots fill up and we will help you go further faster. Six months from now, you'll wish you started today. We have all the time, Vanessa, we have clients that come in and they're paying just a little bit extra than the minimum. So my payment's $30 and I'm paying 100 and I'm basically doing a really great job. And it's no, and they're doing that on several cards. So that's when we're gonna tell them, no, we're gonna shift that to where you're gonna put every extra dollar you have that month on the one card because that is gonna save you the most money and make the most progress in the long run. And we have a lot of clients that when we tell them to do this, we're like, oh, look, you can actually pay off two cards this month. And they're like, really? And then the idea is to take those minimum payments that you were making plus all the extra and you're gonna snowball it, right? Again, Avalanche Method, if you're choosing the highest interest rate because you have some balances that are close by, that doesn't matter. The point is you're getting all that money that you can and putting it on one other card. Yeah, the snowball method has you put all your extra dollars toward your lowest balance credit card, right? And then Avalanche has you do it toward your highest interest, which just goes along with this conversation. We as coaches want you to do whichever one makes the most sense with your budget this month, really. Because some months you might be able to throw $5,000 and get one complete knocked out and we're gonna want to do that so that you end up paying less interest and you're done and that's great. And then some months, all you can do is really tackle a very small credit card and just try to, and that's really how it's gonna snowball into really good progress. But either way, that's why these methods are popular because we want you to always focus all your extra dollars on one credit card and get that one gone and then move on to the next one. And what we don't recommend is you're splitting up the debt payments and going, okay, I'm gonna put an extra 50 here, an extra 20 there, an extra 100 here. Don't do that. Pick one debt that you're gonna tackle, okay? And that's the one that you're focused on. There are a couple savings buckets that you have to focus on. The wedding or something, we keep saying that over and over again. It has to be a high priority item that's coming up that you have to save for. So pick the one or two buckets that you need to save for and you can put a little bit of money in there. Like Shayna said, the majority of your money needs to go towards the debts, but the one. All the ones, it's a good debt. And I giggled when you said that because I just had a session this morning. We get that question a lot, right? We had paid $650 on her credit card already and then this month, and then they had $1492 and I said, the Columbus sell the ocean blue. They had $1492 left in their budget to pay, this paycheck to pay on debt. And he's, oh, let's put it on my credit card now. He said, it's my turn. And I said, that's one option. But then also the other option is to continue to pay off the one that's lower that we started with. And then you can see that progress and they did. They were so excited that that number was at like 9,000 and it's now like six, it's a high six, but it's on the six. It's exciting to see it go down. And now they can focus on that one and then that will be gone. And then that's a good feeling versus let me try to keep up staggering it. Staggering with the interest. That's not fun. I think this is an important thing to think about in the order of operations here, right? So like Manas always say, everybody wants to get right to the savings buckets. Everybody wants to get right to paying off debt. But the first step is to make sure, like this lady we talked about, get your gas and groceries, your spending column, figure it out, figure that out first. Then let's work on the savings buckets. And then once we feel like those are good, then let's go to paying off debt. And it's okay because as you kind of alluded to, not, or funding this is gonna allow me to not put it on debt. So we are still in the debt category by not adding to it, by making sure that we're taking the steps that when these things pop up, we don't have to add the debt later. But it really, again, if you want how to not live life and how to not be allowed to go to restaurants and how to live on rice and beans, and so that you can pay off debt, there's someone out there that you can listen to. Here, we want you to be able to live your life to feel like you know what's going on with your money. And like I said, there's a step, get your spending, figure out your savings, then let's go hard on that debt, right? There's just like, there's a couple of steps you gotta get to before all of this. And then we like to tell people, look, we know you heard the podcast, you heard all of our steps, you're so excited, and you want it all tomorrow. But unfortunately, building the whole system isn't gonna, it doesn't work that fast. It's not a quick fix. It is a lifelong change of how your mindset, your habits, all of that is how you handle your money. And that's what's gonna make you successful long term. We're not just putting words and numbers on paper and calling it a budget. It's literally a whole different way that you handle your finances. And so being able to implement one part at a time, yes, it may not happen as fast as you want it to happen, but you're going to be successful longer. So the idea is you want to take your money, when you get paid, divvy it up, figure out how much you're gonna spend on groceries, gas, personal money, and then all that leftover that you're just gonna wait till the end of the month to use to pay off debt, you're gonna actually pay off the debt right now. You're gonna go and you're gonna do it the second you get paid. Cause you wanna make sure that money isn't there. If you remove the temptation from your bank account, you're going to be less likely to stumble and you're gonna be more likely to stay on course. If this is you, don't worry, because it's all of our clients. Yeah, you're not alone. But that's why they come and work with us because they're just spinning in circles or whatever. They just can't figure it out. And when we make them do it, they're different. I can think of several clients where this is the case and they just want to wait till the end of the month. Are you sure? Are you sure? And we're like, no, no, right now though, right now. Here's the thing too, is we love to say, we love math because money doesn't lie or numbers don't lie. So you're sitting here doing the budget and you're like, you literally got paid this amount. Hey, guess what? Your expenses were this amount, which means you have this amount leftover. And so when you see that on paper and you hold yourself accountable and you're saying this is what I'm going to do, then you have that money. The money is there to be used for debt. That's the whole purpose. It's the whole reason why you're getting financial coaching. It's the whole reason why you're wanting to get on a budget and hold yourself accountable to only spending a certain amount of money. So when that money is there, put it on debt now. Yeah, a lot, like when I started with one of my clients, if he saw money in the bank accounts, he thought it was to spend. And he's not like that anymore. But for sure, when we started, it's absolutely, you have to pay it right now because you're going to think, when you see that the money's in there, that it's available for you to spend and it's not. And with another one of my clients, it was not that client, but the spouse. That was the case. So one good thing about it is it removes the ability to spend it because you've already spent it, right? So it really makes you accountable early on. Yeah, I have two of my clients and it's the husbands and they're very, well, we're going to save it. And we're just in case, we're just going to make sure. And then the end of the month, we'd have our second meeting. I'm like, okay, where's that money? Oh, we needed it for this. So we needed it for that. And I'm like, we actually didn't need it for those things. You just saw the money. Like Shayna said, it was in the account and it's your quote unquote buffer that you allow yourself. And then you spend it and then you get mad at yourself. Like Shayna was just telling another fight. You get mad at yourself because you spent it and then you're reaffirming to the fact that I can't do this. This isn't working because you're not changing your habits. Yeah. So the whole process of paying it off early is we've got to change your mindset and your habits in the way that you operate with money. Whereas before it is, I don't want to pay it because I want to make sure I have the money. And then by the time you get to the end of the money, you don't have the money, which like Vanessa said, it reinforces this image that you have and this identity of yourself that you're not good with money. You don't do what you're going to say, which by the way probably makes you spend more or give up on budgeting or whatever. So we're going to reverse that. We're going to circumvent that. We're going to be your accountability partner by doing it right when you get paid. Like the day, so the way that we set your budget up in your paycheck so you can feel confident that on the day I get paid or whenever you talk to your coach or whatever the appointment is really close to the payday, I can make the step payment because I know everything else is covered. And so then when you do that, you make the payment, you get the dopamine, exciting, urge, reward cycle, whole thing going on of seeing the number go down, of doing it, you know, that you're actually taking action to do it. But then also you just start to reinforce that new identity of who I am. Cause it forces you to stay on your budget cause the money's not there. If you make good money but have nothing to show for it, this quiz will help you figure out what's really going on with your money and what your next step should be. You'll get a personalized result and a simple action step to help you feel more organized and less stressed. Go to budgetbesties.com for slash quiz and take the free quiz today. That's budgetbesties.com forward slash quiz to find out what's really going on with your money.