Screen Time: Less is More
27 min
•Mar 27, 20262 months agoSummary
Jonathan McKee discusses how excessive screen time and social media are fragmenting family connections and mental health, particularly among young people. He argues that while screens are valuable tools, they often distract from meaningful in-person relationships and create unhealthy comparison culture, offering practical solutions like digital fasts and intentional screen-free time.
Insights
- Screen time paradox: Despite unprecedented connectivity, depression, anxiety, and suicide rates among teens have spiked to all-time highs pre-COVID, suggesting more connections don't equal better mental health
- Influencer economy creates unrealistic expectations: 8 in 10 young people aspire to be influencers, but only 1 in 2,250 can sustain it full-time, creating widespread pressure and comparison anxiety
- Post-engagement anxiety is a measurable psychological effect: The waiting period after posting content for likes and validation creates emotional stress even among those with large followings
- Family screen time has replaced family time: Average parents spend more time on screens than with each other or their children, mirroring Martha's distraction parable from Scripture
- Digital fasts create measurable relationship improvements: Structured media breaks (like 'No Tech Tuesday') demonstrably increase family bonding and help reset unhealthy screen dependencies
Trends
Mental health crisis linked to social comparison on visual platforms like Instagram and TikTokPost-engagement validation anxiety becoming recognized psychological phenomenon in emerging researchShift toward digital wellness and intentional technology use rather than complete abstinenceGrowing awareness among Gen Z that face-to-face relationships provide deeper satisfaction than online connectionsParents recognizing need to model healthy screen habits rather than impose restrictions on children aloneRise of structured digital fasts and screen-free time blocks as family wellness practiceInfluencer economy creating unsustainable career expectations for youth demographicCOVID-19 accelerated screen dependency but also increased awareness of loneliness despite connectivityFaith-based organizations addressing technology's impact on spiritual and relational healthEmerging research on psychological effects of social media metrics (likes, follower counts) on self-worth
Topics
Screen time and family relationshipsSocial media comparison and mental healthInfluencer culture and unrealistic career expectationsDigital wellness and intentional technology usePost-engagement anxiety and validation seekingDepression and suicide rates among teenagersDigital fasts and media breaksParental modeling of healthy screen habitsFace-to-face vs. online relationshipsInstagram and TikTok's impact on body imageCOVID-19's acceleration of screen dependencyFaith-based approaches to technologyDistraction and loss of presenceYouth mental health crisisFamily bonding activities
Companies
Instagram
Cited as platform creating constant comparison culture, particularly affecting young girls' self-image and mental health
TikTok
Referenced as primary social media platform where young people consume content and seek influencer status
Focus on the Family
Publisher of Jonathan McKee's book 'Parenting Generation Screen' and host organization of the podcast episode
People
Jonathan McKee
Primary speaker discussing media's impact on families and presenting research on screen time and mental health
Jim Daly
Host of Focus on the Family podcast conducting interview with Jonathan McKee
John Fuller
Co-host introducing guests and providing commentary on episode themes
Quotes
"This is a great tool for connecting people outside the room, but we're learning that it kind of interferes with our relationship with the people inside the room."
Jonathan McKee•Opening segment
"We're all living the life of an 80s rock star. What do my followers think?"
Jonathan McKee•Mid-presentation
"Comparison is the thief of joy."
Jonathan McKee•Discussion of Instagram's impact
"Martha, Martha, chill. Have a pizza."
Jonathan McKee•Biblical application section
"We realized that less was more."
Jonathan McKee•Family media fast conclusion
Full Transcript
Is your marriage struggling, communication breaking down, trust fading, conflict that never seems to resolve? There's still hope. Hope Restored Marriage Intensives by Focus on the Family help couples step away from daily life and focus fully on rebuilding their relationship. And right now, through the Marriage Investment Initiative, Hope Restored is investing $1,000 toward marriage intensives. Visit HopeRestored.com slash Marriage-Investment. Today, Jonathan McKee shares ideas about human connection and how that's influenced by all the screens we use in our daily lives. But let's just be honest, we haven't figured this thing out. This is a great tool for connecting people outside the room, but we're learning that it kind of interferes with our relationship with the people inside the room. Welcome to Focus on the Family with Jim Daly. I'm John Fuller. Well, Jonathan McKee always has a lot of insight to share when it comes to media and its impact on the family. And today is no exception. Jonathan is a social researcher, a popular speaker, and an author of many books, including Parenting Generation Screen, Guiding Your Kids to Be Wise in a Digital World, published by Focus on the Family. And he's also a contributor to our plugged-in entertainment reviews, so he's really part of this family, so to speak. Here now, Jonathan McKee at First Woodway Baptist Church in Woodway, Texas on Focus on the Family with Jim Daly. If I were to walk into the typical American home at 7 p.m. on any night, it's not just young people staring at screens. Let's be honest. Dad is sitting there looking at a big screen. Mom's sitting next to maybe watching that screen, but also looking at a screen of her own. You go upstairs, definitely sister is looking through TikTok videos on her phone, brother is playing games on his device, toddlers flicking shapes across the screen, and a family dog is on the treadmill because no one will walk him. I mean, this isn't a young people problem. This is a, we love our screens issue here. And the question we need to maybe ask ourselves is, is there a chance that even the fact that there's more screens, more screen time, more connections, you know, than anyone in history, are we more satisfied? Is there a chance that maybe less could be more? I'm being very real with you. I like my screen. This screen can be fun. It is a great device for connecting with people outside the room when it doesn't interfere with the people inside the room. And what I'm just wondering is there times that this screen is very helpful? And is there times where maybe it just belongs in the pocket? It's funny to watch how things are changing from screens. It's changing the way we enjoy moments. We used to just enjoy moments. Now we have to post about the moment. It used to be that we would just enjoy a cup of coffee, but now we got to let our followers know how good our cup of coffee was. We're all living the life of an 80s rock star. What do my followers think? You know, I just got to think about my followers. And because it's all about the number of followers or friends we've got. So we live in a country right now where eight out of 10 young people want to be an influencer in one way or another. What's happened is this is kind of creating a lot of pressure on us because that number now is very important. And here's what it does to us just emotionally. It's kind of an interesting thing. And not a lot of people are talking about this because again, this is brand new. So this is kind of new research. It's just emerging. But what people have started to see is that there's this moment that everybody does talk about where you post something. Look, I'm enjoying a moment. Let me post about it. But what we aren't talking about is after that moment, after we post about it, the waiting. Because after we post, there's this moment where we're waiting to see if the likes come in, see if the traffic goes up, see if we're getting the amount of followers we should have. And so some people are going to more lengths to try to, hmm, if I do this, I've noticed I've, you know, get a little bit more likes or this is when the followers start to spike. If I do this, and there's this moment after post where it's affecting a lot of us because even if we've got a bunch of followers, even if we got a bunch of friends, there's always someone with more followers. How come I only got 637 likes? Taylor got a thousand one hundred and twenty two likes. I don't understand. And so it's starting to affect us. And we're seeing this number in particular be something crucial. Let's try something real quick. Let's talk about this influencer thing for just a quick second. Let's pretend that this room right here is America who is, and by the way, we're talking, you know, literally when it comes to what percentage of America is online, it's almost pretty much everybody. You're in the very high nineties. When it comes to young people pre-COVID, it was like 97 percent have access online. And during COVID because of schooling, everything like that, we're like, we need to get everybody. So I mean, we're at the 98 or 99 percent mark. So let's just say that this is America right here. This room is, let's try something. If your birthday is January 1st through November 10th, go ahead and stand up. We are real quick. Let's just do something. January 1st through November 10th, go ahead and stand up. Okay. This is how many young people want to be influencers today. Go ahead and look around you. If this was America, this is how many young people want to be influencers today. So just look to your right and left real quick. Okay. Sit down unless your birthday is May 3rd and you were born between 12 a.m. and 3.53 a.m. Sit down unless you're May 3rd and you were born between 12 a.m. and 3.53 a.m. Do we have anybody? Do we have anybody? We got, hey, we have two? Yes. Give them a hand. Look at that. Or maybe even three. Okay. You may sit down. They right there represent the one 2,250 second that actually can make it as an influencer full time. Okay. That's just what the numbers are. Okay. They represent that. And we got to be careful here because I mean, we don't want to squash. I mean, honestly, that's better odds than making it in the NBA. Okay. You know, we don't want to tell LeBron, Hey, buddy, you know, the odds aren't good. We don't want to squash LeBron's dreams. There might be a future LeBron right here. You know, but the fact is there's a lot of young people out there who are trying. And the question we need to start asking is what kind of effect is it having when a lot of us aren't making it or aren't quite seeing ourselves as being as popular as liked as everybody else around us. And as a guy who studies this a lot, interview after interview, study after study of people with hundreds of thousands of followers who are saying the pressure was too much. Those who even made it to the top. And this isn't just a social media thing, folks. A lot of people who made it to the top can't handle the pressure. We've seen it a lot. And in the world of screens right now, what we're seeing is we're seeing depression spiking more than it ever has before. And folks, this research went before COVID because a lot of people consider go well with COVID. No, no, pre COVID depression had spiked more than ever had before. Each suicide among teen girls was at an all time spike anxiety, everything. And of course, people are looking, hey, screen time is going up, depression is going up, people started drawing those lines. Of course, some people started putting blame right away. So we start seeing studies come out. We start seeing people saying, hey, these technology companies knew about this. We're seeing reports coming out, naming certain social media. Hey, comparisons on Instagram are making it really tough out there on young girls because there's this constant comparison going on. How come I'm not getting as many likes? How come I don't look as good? My daughter and I embarked on a book. We were actually finishing it up last time I was here two years ago. And as we wrote this book, it was fascinating to hear her perspective on this because of someone who loved social media and who actually enjoyed Instagram. She was very vulnerable in this book. And she said, every time I posted something on Instagram, she goes, in all honesty, I thought everybody else looked good in the pics and I couldn't help but compare. She said that's the one thing Instagram always does to me. It makes me compare. And she says, comparison is the thief of joy. Then COVID came along. And when COVID came along, basically all of a sudden it hit a generation. It was already pretty lonely. It's ironic, more connected, but less intimate friends. COVID comes along and all of a sudden it's hitting us in the face and a lonely generation got even lonelier. And we started to see actually depression and suicide go up, but also we saw an awareness where a lot of people start to admit, hey, you know what? I like face-to-face relationships, but is there a point where maybe enough is enough? What do we do as parents and grandparents and people who care about this generation? But the question I want to focus on right now is I want to ask, as a family, as a church body, is it too much? Are there possibly some unforeseen consequences to being so over-connected that we don't connect anymore? We live right now in a country where the average mom and dad spends more time on a screen than they do with each other or their kids. Is there a chance that we are so over-connected that we don't even connect anymore? What's the answer? Well, to get the answer, let's go to a place where I think all the answers are and let's go to Luke chapter 10. And just to prove to you that I don't think screens are bad, I'm going to go on my screen right here. Here we go, Luke chapter 10. And honestly, it's because I can make the font really big and that really helps me. Yeah, no. I mean, I got a big. It's like for God so loved. Yeah, there. Okay, I can read that. There we go. Okay, Luke chapter 10. Here we go. I started with verse 38. It's amazing how this, by the way, 2000 something years ago, so perfectly relevant today. I'll start in verse 38. As Jesus and his disciples were on their way, he came to a village where a woman named Martha opened up her home to him. She had a sister called Mary who sat at the Lord's feet listening to what he said. But Martha was, what's the next word? Distracted by all the preparations that had to be made. She came to an asked Lord, don't you care that my sister has left me to do the work by myself? Tell her to help me. Okay, let's pause right there for a quick second. Picture this. I mean, I love this, that we see this story about these two sisters and we don't know exactly what went on, but it was something like, here's two sisters that wanted to connect with Jesus. We thought if we do the meal thing, we'll be able to connect with Jesus. Mary, she gets it immediately, plops at Jesus' feet and is just soaking him in. But Martha was distracted. Let me ask you a quick question. Anything wrong with cooking? Anything wrong with the gift of hospitality? No, I mean, that's a good thing. Those are good things. There was nothing wrong with what Martha's intentions were. She with good intentions set out to do something that would help her connect with Jesus. The problem was that she got so focused on that something that she forgot about the connecting with Jesus part. As a matter of fact, she allowed it to become a source of bitterness between her and her sister. And next thing you know, she's coming to Jesus and going, can we do something here? I mean, tell her to do it. Because I mean, come on, I'm doing all the work here. She was so distracted by something that she set out with very good intentions to connect. And that very thing that she was using to connect kept her from connecting. Hmm. Kind of weird, huh? She was so distracted by what she was trying to use to connect that she forgot about connecting. I got an opportunity to perform a wedding for a young girl who grew up at our house all the time. She was friends with one of my daughters. And when this young girl decided to get married, she asked if I would do the wedding as a minister. And I said, sure. And as we were talking once about kind of some of the lessons of, you know, prepping for this wedding, I said, I said, can I share something? She said, sure. I said, I've done several weddings and here's just something I've noticed. I've noticed a lot of brides, when they get to that wedding day, they're so stressed out by having tried to make this day that's supposed to be one of the greatest days on earth. They were so focused on having such an Insta perfect wedding that they're so stressed. It literally is, I'm standing in the back room with the bride beforehand. She's ready to walk down the aisle. She's guzzling Pepto Bismot to deal with an ulcer that she's got from trying to make this day so perfect that she wasn't able to enjoy the day. Sometimes in life we get so distracted with something. Did it, it distracts us from the connections, from the stuff that matters. And a lot of us, when I say there's something that's distracting us, you know exactly what it is. It would fill in that blank. If we were to fill that out. Sometimes I allow blank to become a distraction in my life. You know exactly what it is. So what does Jesus say? What does he tell us about these distractions in our life? Let's keep reading because his answer is amazing. So we left with Martha coming up and saying, Lord, Lord, don't you care that my sister has left me to do all the work by herself? Tell her to help me. And Jesus says, Martha, Martha, the Lord replied. You are worried and upset about so many things. How many of you by the way are right there? Worried and upset about so many things. But indeed, few things are needed or indeed only one. Mary has chosen what is better and it will not be taken away from her. I love this. Modern translation. Here's what it would be. Martha, Martha, chill. Have a pizza. And I love the fact that Jesus doesn't even name what the one thing is because it's so obvious. Martha, you're so distracted by so many things. You're so distracted. This went probably a little deeper than just prepping a meal. You're so distracted about all these things when only one thing is needed and your sister's found it. And it's interesting because when we look at this one thing throughout Scripture, so many of us were going through life and maybe with good intentions, we allow other things to become a distraction, other connections to become a distraction from the one connection that matters. Some of us are actually connecting with people, complete strangers, and we're hurting in relationships with people around us, our sister and our Lord who is begging us to just sit at his feet. Martha allowed her cooking to become the one thing instead of Jesus. Jesus talks, by the way, this one thing is nothing new in Scripture. We see it all through Scripture. As a matter of fact, one of Jesus' followers, Paul, talks about it later in his letter to the Philippians. He says, brothers and sisters, I don't consider myself yet to have taken a hold of this, but one thing I do for getting what's behind, straining toward what's ahead, I press on towards the goal, which is Christ Jesus. That's the one thing. We see later in the book of Hebrews. Hebrews does this summary, this cliff note version of the heroes of faith in the Bible. It says, look at all these people, look at all these heroes of the faith. And the next verse says, considering these cloud of witnesses, these great people of faith, let's do something here. Let's strip off all that hinders that sin that so easily entangles, and let's do one thing, let's fix our eyes on Jesus. We keep seeing this over and over again. We have these things that so easily entangle us, and we allow them to become a distraction. For a lot of us, that one thing that we would ride in that blank, we know it's something that's entangling us and needs to go. What do you need to trim? I love mountain biking, and I won't say I'm a great mountain biker, but I live by some great mountain bike trails. I live in California at the base of the Sierra Mountains, right near Folsom. You can literally go right up the hill to one of the most beautiful places on earth. I'm not exaggerating Lake Tahoe, the deepest, bluest lake you've ever seen, and it's set up at an elevation so high that it's surrounded by snow, cap, mountains, and pine trees. Gorgeous. And when you look at it, the blue is entrancing. It's just, it's so majestic. It's amazing. I'm going on this mountain bike ride with my friends, Mark and Amy, who coach mountain biking. I don't coach mountain biking. Okay? I have a mountain bike, and my mountain bike is worth about the same amount as their back wheel of their mountain bike. And it's funny that I mentioned the back wheel because right before the ride, Mark says, okay, Jonathan, today there's lots of distractions on this ride. And he goes, listen to me if you don't want to die. I said, you got my attention. He says, we're going to be up on some precarious trails. We're going to be next to some edges that if you fall off, you'd probably die. And so what I want you to do is I want you to focus on my back wheel. You can't take your eyes off this trail. I'm going to be in front of you. So just watch my back wheel. You're going to be tempted to look. He goes, we could sightsee later. He goes, when we're going on this precarious trail, do not look to your right or left. Keep your eyes focused on. And he said it, one thing, my back wheel. I said, okay, back wheel, don't die. Got it. That's good. I'll try it. And so we started on this ride and he was in kid, man, this was a crazy ride. We're going and it's like, we're going left. We're going right. We're on this trail. And I'm just sitting around. I'm like, don't die. Watch the back wheel. Don't die. And I'm doing that. And pretty soon we go up and we hang this left and we're in this clearing where I see from my God given peripheral vision, this beautiful blue, big something over there. But I'm going, watch the back wheel. Don't die. Don't look right or left. Watch the back wheel. But it was blue and it was there and it was open. It was entrancing. And I was just like, maybe I could just, just, oh my gosh. I mean, it was, it was, it was amazing. It was there. And I was like, it was gorgeous. It was surrounded by snow, cap, mountains, trees, gorgeous. And that's why I didn't true story. See the trail turn left and mark turn left. I went straight right off the edge. True story. And as I go off, it's happening in slow motion. And I'm like, oh darn. And there's this pine tree right there. And I just grabbed it like elf, man. I just grabbed it. And as my body kept going, the, and I'm like, my bike is hooked to my feet, you know, and I just go like this. The pine tree goes, I literally just grabbing this poor little Christmas tree. And when it got all bent down like this, the Christmas tree was like, hey dude, you need to lay off the pizza a little bit. I'm like, shut up. You're a tree. And Mark comes back and he goes, you took your eyes off my back wheel, didn't you? I was like, but the lake is so beautiful. Is there anything wrong with looking at a lake? The fact is sometimes things become a distraction from the one thing that's important. What do you got to trim? I'll close by telling you this. A few years ago, my, when my kids were still in the house, they've grown up now, got out of the house. They were getting ready to go on a missions trip. And on this missions trip, the youth pastor decided to do something kind of kind of bold. He said, I want to prepare our hearts for the missions trip. So we're going to try something. We're going to do a media fast. We're not going to fast from food. We're going to fast from screens and music and your timp media. We want to fast a little bit. And everybody's like, okay. And they're like, and he said, so if we want to do this missions trip, we're going to fast for the month before the trip. And everybody starts freaking out. My kids are like, a month. I'm not going. I mean, literally kids are like, I'm not going on this stupid trip. And you know, and we as parents are like, ah, come on, grow up a little bit. And then the youth pastor literally says, and his family is it'd be unfair for them to do it. So we're going to do it too. And they're like, this is stupid. You're not going on this trip. You know, I mean, I mean, we're just, you know, come on. I don't want to miss NCIS Waco. I mean, come on. So we're, so we all were kind of like rebelling a little bit. And we're like, you know, and finally we're like, okay, let's pray about this. And so we prayed as a family. And as a family, we're like, okay, let's try it. And I remember like literally the first couple of days it was just weird. We got in a car. I was like, I'm going to jump on the radio and my kids were like, dad, don't. And I'm like, it was Chris Tomlin. I thought it was okay. I'm sorry. You know, and literally like at night, my kids would finish the homework like four or five o'clock and they'd come downstairs and they'd be like, what are we going to do? I'm like, I don't know. Here's the ball. Let's throw it at the dog. Dog lost 30 pounds that month. All right. I mean, it was amazing. We started hanging out as a family. We started, we, I mean, literally we were like, what are we going to do? So we'd sit there and we'd light a fire in the living room, which is really weird because we don't have a fireplace. But I mean, we just, we're like doing anything, you know, just hanging out. When the 30 days were up, they went on the mission trip. They came back and I'll never forget they're like, dad, we, we can't go back the way it was. They said, and they weren't ready to give up screens or anything. I mean, I think we literally did a Lord of the Rings extended edition trilogy day where we were like for 12 hours sitting on the couch like must have screen. You know, we kind of soaked it back in, you know, right into our veins. But we talked as a family and we came up with an idea and for our family, we came up with no tech Tuesday. It was just a taste. It was like, Hey, on Tuesdays, what do you say when we're done with homework, whatever, that we just make that a night where we just sit and read by the fire because we realized that less was more. And with that image of a family enjoying some quiet time together around a fireplace, we come to the end of this presentation from Jonathan McKee on focus on the family with Jim Daly. You know, John, I like that picture. That's the perfect spring day here in Colorado to have a fire and just hang out together. I really appreciate the wisdom that Jonathan has shared with us today. And if you'd like to try a digital fast with your family, we've got a free resource for you. Our plugged in media team has put together an emergency kit that will help you fill all of that time that is currently spent on screens. We'll give your family ideas for a week's worth of games, reading time and other activities that will build closer relationships in fun ways. Look for the free guide called Screen Fast 2026 when you follow the link in the show notes. And if you want to go deeper, let me recommend Jonathan's book called Parenting Generation Screen, Guiding Your Kids to Be Wise in a Digital World, published by Focus on the Family. It will equip you to have important conversations with your children about social media, screen time and entertainment. It's so important to be wise in our media choices today and help our children do the same. Listen to this note we received from a man I call Kevin who desperately needed help and had a consultation with one of our counselors. He said, you guys do such good work. Well we appreciate that. He went on to say, I spent years listening to very sick music and it took me a long time to clean up my mind. A friend introduced me to Focus on the Family and I'm so thankful. Your staff is so wise and they've helped me tremendously. That's really powerful. It is. Media choices have consequences. Think how much we fill our mind with media choices. It's amazing. And parents need to be involved in those choices with their children as much as possible. And I also hope you'll consider supporting Focus on the Family as we do our best to help families to thrive in Christ, which is our goal. And when you make a donation of any amount, we'll send you a copy of Parenting Generation screen as our way of saying thank you for being part of the ministry. Yeah you can donate online. Just follow the link in the show notes or give us a call. 800, the letter A, and the word family. And be sure to look for the free resource we have for you at our website, a Parents' Guide to Today's Technology. It really is a comprehensive look at how kids are using their mobile devices and how that impacts them physically and psychologically, emotionally and socially. Thanks for listening to Focus on the Family with Jim Daly. Take a moment please and leave a rating for us and a comment in your podcast app. Share this episode with a friend. Help us spread the word about this great content. I'm John Fuller inviting you back as we once more help you and your family thrive in Christ. Live your truth. A lot of people say that, don't they? But truth isn't something we decide. God has decided it for us. And it's our job as believers to share His truth with a world in need. I'll encourage you to do that through my podcast, Refocus with Jim Daly. I visit with fascinating guests about important topics like gender confusion, cancel culture, and more. I'm helping you share God's love with others. Listen at Refocus with JimDaly.com.