The Journal.

Germany’s Economy Is Spiraling. Can War Fix It?

19 min
May 5, 202625 days ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Germany's economy is stagnating due to declining auto sales, energy crises, and Chinese competition. The government is pivoting the manufacturing sector toward defense production, betting that European security threats will drive sustained demand for weapons and military equipment.

Insights
  • Germany's economic stagnation since 2018 is forcing a fundamental industrial pivot from consumer goods to defense manufacturing, representing a strategic bet on geopolitical instability rather than peace.
  • The defense sector offers German manufacturers protection from Asian competition because allied nations preferentially buy from allied suppliers, creating a captive market advantage.
  • Existing German manufacturing infrastructure can be rapidly retooled for defense production without massive capital investment, leveraging existing supply chains and worker expertise.
  • Germany's economic health directly impacts all of mainland Europe through integrated supply chains, making the country's recovery essential for regional growth.
  • American defense manufacturers' inability to meet global demand due to Ukraine and Middle East conflicts is creating a supply gap that European and German companies are positioned to fill.
Trends
Geopolitical risk driving industrial policy: Governments using security threats to justify economic restructuring and manufacturing relocationDefense sector as economic growth engine: Weapons manufacturing becoming a primary growth strategy for developed economies facing stagnationReshoring and allied-nation supply chains: Preference for domestic and allied suppliers over cost-competitive Asian alternatives in strategic sectorsRapid industrial adaptation: Manufacturing companies pivoting between consumer and defense sectors using existing production capabilities and workforceNATO spending surge: European defense budgets expanding dramatically as U.S. commitment to NATO weakensSupply chain fragmentation: Breaking away from Russian energy dependence and Chinese manufacturing competition through strategic diversificationSkills transfer between industries: Defense sector absorbing displaced automotive workers, creating employment continuity in manufacturing regionsConstitutional reform for defense spending: Governments removing fiscal constraints to enable massive defense investmentGlobal weapons shortage: Depletion of Western weapons stocks in Ukraine and Middle East creating sustained demand for new production capacity
Topics
German Economic Stagnation and Manufacturing DeclineDefense Industry Pivot and Industrial PolicyNATO Defense Spending and European SecuritySupply Chain Resilience and ReshoringGerman Auto Industry Competitiveness CrisisChinese Competition in Electric VehiclesEnergy Crisis and Russian Gas DependencyWeapons Manufacturing and Export StrategyLabor Market Transition in ManufacturingConstitutional Reform for Defense SpendingU.S. Military Commitment to EuropeGeopolitical Risk and Economic PlanningPatriot Missile Systems and Defense ExportsIron Dome and Israeli Defense PartnershipsEuropean Supply Chain Integration
Companies
Porsche
Luxury car manufacturer posting nearly 1 billion euro loss in Q3, exemplifying German auto industry crisis
Volkswagen
Major German automaker experiencing 40%+ decline in net profits; exploring defense contracts with Israeli government
Mercedes-Benz
Luxury car manufacturer facing 40%+ year-on-year decline in net profits amid economic stagnation
Deutz
World's oldest engine maker successfully pivoting to defense; grew 15% in revenue by supplying Patriot systems and dr...
Gazprom
Russian gas firm that cut off natural gas pipeline to Germany, triggering energy crisis and manufacturing sector disr...
People
Boyan Panczewski
Reported on Germany's economic crisis and defense industry pivot; provided analysis of manufacturing sector transform...
Jessica Mendoza
Hosted episode discussing Germany's economic pivot to defense manufacturing
Katharina Reicha
Led constitutional reform and created defense manufacturing matchmaking platform to drive economic recovery
Olaf Scholz
Called confidence vote and triggered snap elections in response to economic stagnation
Vladimir Zelensky
Noted depletion of American weapons stocks, highlighting supply gap for European defense manufacturers
Quotes
"Germany is basically losing roughly 15,000 jobs from manufacturing each month. It's a bloodbath."
Boyan PanczewskiEarly in episode
"They're pivoting from cars to cannons."
Jessica MendozaMid-episode
"Once you enter that zone, the defense industry, you are no longer exposed to the competitive pressures from Asia and elsewhere because it's just the way it works. Allies buy from allies."
Boyan PanczewskiMid-episode
"Without Germany, the European Union economy is essentially an old people's home with a huge mortgage."
Boyan PanczewskiLate in episode
"They're not banking on war. They're banking on the anxiety and the fear of war."
Boyan PanczewskiClosing segment
Full Transcript
Germany is well known for producing high-quality vehicles. Its luxury car companies are the crown jewel of the country's manufacturing sector. But recently, those companies have been flashing warning signs. After years of roaring down the Autobahn, a speed bump for Porsche. Volkswagen and Mercedes-Benz posting year-on-year declines of over 40% in net profits. The iconic sports car maker notched up a spectacular third quarter loss of almost 1 billion euros. There is sort of a creeping sense of panic. Our colleague Boyan Panczewski covers Europe, and he's been reporting on the pain being felt throughout Germany's economy. Germany is basically losing roughly 15,000 jobs. from manufacturing each month. Wow, wow. This is a striking figure. Per month? Yeah, it's a striking figure. It's a bloodbath. Yeah. And obviously it's a situation that requires urgent action, both on behalf of the businesses, on the enterprises, and the government who is desperate to help them and stop the bleed. German officials and companies have been feverishly looking for a way to inject life into the economy. And that led to a big aha moment. While luxury car brands have suffered, another kind of precision manufacturing shows some real promise. Weapons. There is money to be made in the arms industry, which is one of the very few branches of the economy that's actually booming. And they seem to have coalesced around the idea of going into the defense industry, which is now kind of crucial in Europe. So they're pivoting, basically, from the car business to the business of war? That's right. They're pivoting from cars to cannons. Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Jessica Mendoza. It's Tuesday, May 5th. Coming up on the show, Germany is reinventing itself as a weapons factory. Bajan, how would you describe the role that the German economy plays in Europe? Oh, you know, when Germany, Germany is this giant sort of beating industrial heart of Europe smack in the middle of the continents. Essentially, a lot of countries, if not most countries in mainland Europe, are entangled in the German supply chain. And when German manufacturing is stuttering, these countries are also losing growth. I mean, one example is Austria, one of the richest countries in Europe, and it's completely embedded in the German supply chains. The same is true also for countries like Hungary or the Czech Republic. So, you know, everyone suffers if Germany suffers. And Germany is not only a major economic force in Europe. It's also deeply important to the continent's security. After the U.S., Germany contributes the most money towards NATO. When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, it both threatened Europe's stability and hurt Germany's economy. Russia had been Germany's biggest supplier of natural gas and a major supplier of other energy resources. Russian gas firm Gazprom is scheduled to switch off its largest natural gas pipeline running to Germany today. The war in Ukraine sent energy prices skyward, and those price increases rippled throughout the manufacturing sector. That was devastating to the German car industry, which is already facing stiff competition from overseas China once basically a customer of Germany has turned into its most fierce rival and is producing things that are as good or cheaper than what Germany has to offer I mean, their electric cars are in part better than the German cars, which is unheard of so far. You know, the Germans were always comfortable as being the best on the market. Combined, all of these headwinds have stalled Germany's economy. The economy hasn't effectively grown since 2018. It's the longest period of time of stagnation since the Second World War. So it's alarming, essentially, at this stage. Chancellor Scholz announced last week he would call a confidence vote and trigger snap elections. In February of last year, Germany held a big election. And in the run-up, it was clear that voters were looking for a change. Polls are showing that people have a very dim view of the future. The majority thinks that their children will be worse off than their parents. The stagnation of Europe's biggest economy has been one of the burning issues of the campaign. Others have been support for Ukraine. The election proved to be a major turning point. Incumbents were voted out. The far right and the far left surged. The party that got the most votes was the Christian Democratic Union, with a conservative and business-friendly platform. They vowed to turn around the economy with investment and deregulation. And the face of that turnaround is the new minister of the economy. And the minister of the economy is a woman called Katharina Reiches. She comes from business herself. She used to be in energy, in the energy trade. She dealt with gas and so on. And she's very, very much attuned to the mood inside the business community. We need speed in investments and we need private capital. And that will be another topic I will take care of. With the ongoing security threat from Russia, Reicha bet that there would be higher demand for weapons across Europe and that Germany could make them. So Katerina Reicha, the economy minister, figured that out and realized we need to onshore manufacturing for these things. We need to start making these things ourselves in Germany, but also in Europe. or then start exporting them to our partners elsewhere. RICA and the new government spearheaded a change to the German constitution that unlocked billions for defense manufacturing. Berlin has since pledged to spend more than half a trillion dollars on defense over the next decade. And the government didn't stop there. RICA also launched a program that encouraged existing German companies to connect with new defense customers. So she came up with this idea of setting up a platform, a matchmaking platform, where businesses from across the manufacturing economy can log in and offer their services in manufacturing things that the defense industry needs. Say you're a manufacturer that makes screws. You could get matched with a company that makes drones, learn their needs, and start making screws for them, too. And for these manufacturers, there's another benefit to getting on board with defense. Once you enter that zone, the defense industry, you are no longer exposed to the competitive pressures from Asia and elsewhere because it's just the way it works. Allies buy from allies. They're not going to buy from adversaries. In the years since Raika and her party were voted into office, there's been even more reason for Germany to lean into defense. President Trump's tariffs have further squeezed German exports, piling pressure onto the auto industry. Trump has also pulled back on U.S. support for NATO, and more recently, he's announced the withdrawal of around 5,000 U.S. troops stationed in Germany. In the face of this U retreat Germany is anticipating Europe will need their weapons more than ever I wondering was there any pushback at all to making weapons the focal point of Germany industrial economy Like is there any stigma still attached to this idea I think, you know, there used to be a stigma because Germany is a very pacifist nation for obvious reasons of history. And has, until the war in Ukraine, been extremely restrictive with government contracts for weapons, factories, with exports. Now all that is gone. Now with Russia becoming super aggressive, with America becoming detached, I think the mentality has basically fundamentally shifted. So is this big pivot working? That's next. So the German government is encouraging manufacturers to go into defense. But how hard is it exactly for a company or a factory to make that switch from, you know, making a part for a consumer good like a car to a part for a weapon? Apparently it's not that hard at all. Obviously it depends on what they're doing, but in terms of engines and board systems and computer systems and electric engines for drones, for example, it's very much the same thing. Boyan talked to one company that's already making the switch. It's called Deutz. Deutz is one of Germany's oldest engine makers. Deutz, one of the modernest fuel tanks in Europe. Well, one thing you need to know about Deutz is not just any old engine company. It is the oldest engine company in the world. Boyan recently interviewed the company's CEO, who actually used to work in the defense industry. And he decided now we need to transform the company. You know, we can't go on as we used to. And so we need to look farther than just the car industry. So what do we have? And what Deutz had, the CEO found, were products that could be adaptable. You know, the engines they sell to car makers, they can be used also with modifications. They can be used for tanks and armored vehicles and other kind of vehicles used in the defense industry. They can also be used for drones. Deutz acquired a drone company in 2025. But otherwise, it's largely been able to supply new customers by retooling what they already had. I mean, there's a minor kind of retuning. They have to reprogram some computers and robots. They have to retrain some of the workers. But they're using existing production lines. This is the most important thing. They're not out there building new factories. You know, that costs a lot of money to build a new factory in Germany. It's north of one billion in this business. you know. Boyan says that German companies like Deutz also have a kind of cultural advantage when it comes to manufacturing. They're known for being really nimble because they've had to respond to a demanding global market. If you're a car parts supplier in Germany, you have to be the best and you have to be quick and you have to be responding to the market in real time. If you can't do that, you're gone. And there's a reason why some of these companies have been around for almost two centuries, you know, because they've been responding to the market, you know. So they are very quick to adapt, very quick to scale up. That ability to adapt is what Germany is hoping to leverage in its nascent defense industry. And the war in Iran is opening up another big opportunity. American defense manufacturers have dominated the global weapons trade for decades. But as the fighting continues the U and its allies in the Gulf have burned through their stocks of weapons particularly things like Patriot missile systems which are used to defend against airstrikes And American companies can move fast enough to replace them So you know in the near future the United States will not be able to supply its own armed forces sufficiently, let alone the allies in Europe. And, you know, they're not stupid. They know this. I mean, I think even Vladimir Zelensky, the president of Ukraine, said, we know that we're not getting the stuff from America now that we need because they used it all up in the Gulf. In a weird way, that is a boost for European and particularly German defense manufacturers because now they need to step up and fill in the gap. German companies are stepping up. Deutz now supplies engines for Patriot systems used by Saudi Arabia. And Volkswagen is currently in talks with the Israeli government to supply parts for the Iron Dome, their sky shield against missile and rocket attacks. So as you've been spelling out, Boyan, Germany has a lot riding on this major pivot. Are there signs that the pivot to defense is the solution to their economic problems? Well, we're talking about less than a year now, you know. Depends. For some companies, some companies were pioneers in it. Others are kind of jumping on the bandwagon now. So it's early days. But individual companies show that there is a very positive effect. I mean, we talked about Deutz. You know, Deutz made the pivot and the bet paid off. The company grew 15% in revenue last year. Which is a stark contrast to what some of these other companies have been seeing, right? Exactly. I mean, this is a company that supplies the car industry. So you would have expected them to be, you know, in a very tough spot. But actually, these guys are growing. They're very happy. With some companies seeing growth, employment numbers are also showing positive signs. Many of the workers who lost their manufacturing jobs, they're finding new jobs in the defense sector. If Germany is able to pull off this giant shift in its industrial economy, what could it mean for Europe? Well, it could only mean good things for Europe. Because if they preserve the supply chains, if they preserve the workforce, if they preserve the market and the factories, keep the factories running, then that means their partners across Eastern Europe and elsewhere will benefit from it. So, you know, Germany coming back to growth is absolutely brilliant news, you know. Because effectively, without Germany, the European Union economy is essentially an old people's home with a huge mortgage. Is this plan of Germany's kind of banking on a world with more conflict? So is that kind of the bet that Germany is making here? Absolutely, they're making that bet. And I think they're quite right. I mean, you'll hardly find any geopolitical analyst who will tell you there will be peace and prosperity in the world in the coming years, you know. It's not looking like that. Russia is not going to stop being Russia the way it is at the moment, you know, and Russia is a huge menace on the European continent. It's very obvious that the war in Iran is not going to pacify the region in any conceivable sense and that Iran will then sort of become a peaceful nation. It's very obvious that China is expanding and is flexing its own muscles and America is trying to sort of frustrate those efforts. Essentially, they're not banking on war. They're banking on the anxiety and the fear of war. And it seems to be working so far. That's all for today, Tuesday, May 5th. The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. Additional reporting in this episode from Shelby Holiday, Michael R. Gordon, and Vera Bergengruen. Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.