Rachel Maddow Presents: Burn Order

Episode 3: One Drop

54 min
Dec 8, 20254 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

This episode of Rachel Maddow Presents: Burn Order examines the forced incarceration of Japanese Americans during World War II, tracing how government officials used racial classification and dubious legal justifications to imprison over 100,000 U.S. citizens. The narrative reveals how white agricultural interests in California, combined with military overreach and the abandonment of constitutional protections, enabled one of America's darkest chapters of racial persecution.

Insights
  • Constitutional protections were deliberately circumvented through legal opinions sought outside the Justice Department when internal lawyers refused to endorse mass incarceration based solely on race
  • Economic motivations—specifically white farmers' desire to seize Japanese American agricultural land—were primary drivers of the policy, disguised as military necessity and national security
  • The government applied racial purity standards so extreme that infants with as little as one-sixteenth Japanese ancestry were forcibly removed from orphanages and foster homes and imprisoned
  • Individual acts of resistance and compassion from outside the camps, though rare, provided crucial psychological sustenance and evidence that some Americans recognized the injustice
  • The policy's cruelty extended to separating families, denying pregnant women adequate nutrition, and forcing citizens to renounce their nationality as the only perceived path to family survival
Trends
Use of national security rhetoric to justify racial targeting and mass detention of citizens without due processExploitation of wartime emergency powers to advance pre-existing nativist and white nationalist political agendasCircumvention of constitutional checks by seeking legal opinions from sympathetic government lawyers outside established oversight structuresWeaponization of federal welfare and administrative records to identify and target vulnerable populations based on ancestryDifferential treatment of foreign fascist sympathizers versus citizens of enemy ancestry, revealing racial rather than security-based motivationsEconomic seizure of minority-owned property and assets under cover of military authority during wartimeIntergenerational trauma resulting from state-sanctioned racial persecution and family separation policies
Topics
Japanese American Internment and Mass IncarcerationConstitutional Rights Suspension During WartimeRacial Classification and Citizenship RevocationMilitary Authority Over Civilian PopulationsWhite Nationalist Political Movements in CaliforniaAgricultural Land Seizure and Economic MotivationsDue Process Violations and Legal CircumventionForced Family Separation PoliciesOrphan and Foster Child Removal Based on AncestryWartime Propaganda and Fear-MongeringGovernment Record-Keeping and SurveillanceResistance and Civil Disobedience During InternmentIntergenerational Trauma and Historical ReckoningExecutive Order 9066 ImplementationConcentration Camp Conditions and Living Standards
People
Carl Bendetson
U.S. Army officer who designed and finalized the mass incarceration plan for Japanese Americans based on racial class...
General John DeWitt
Lieutenant General who signed and implemented Bendetson's incarceration plan and opposed Japanese American return to ...
President Franklin D. Roosevelt
Signed Executive Order 9066 on February 19, 1942, authorizing mass incarceration of Japanese Americans
Attorney General Francis Biddle
Justice Department official who initially resisted mass incarceration but capitulated on February 17, 1942
Edward Ennis
Justice Department lawyer who refused to sign legal opinions endorsing mass incarceration based solely on race
Earl Warren
California Attorney General in 1942 who promoted false narrative of Japanese Americans as disloyal fifth column threat
Ken Ringle
Naval Intelligence expert whose analysis found no justification for concerns about Japanese American loyalty
Norman Mineta
Ten-year-old U.S. citizen forced onto trains to Santa Anita Racetrack and Heart Mountain concentration camp in Wyoming
Satsuki Ina
Born in concentration camp to U.S. citizen parents; labeled enemy alien at three months old; author and psychotherapist
Eiko Yoshinaga
High school senior who eloped to stay with boyfriend, became pregnant in Manzanar, separated from dying father
Father Hugh Lavary
Catholic priest who protested removal of orphans with Japanese ancestry from Los Angeles orphanage
Rachel Maddow
Host and executive producer of the Burn Order podcast series examining Japanese American internment
Quotes
"I am determined that if they have one drop of Japanese blood in them, they must all go to camp"
Carl Bendetson
"These Japanese are protected by the same constitution that protects us. If you harm them, you must first harm me"
Unnamed elected official
"I was a United States citizen at birth. I had all of the rights promised to all citizens in the Constitution, yet I abruptly lost all those constitutionally protected rights"
Norman Mineta
"This helped her to remember that someone outside cared"
Satsuki Ina (describing her mother's quilted blanket from Quaker women)
"It was a question of whether the white man lives on the Pacific coast or the brown man"
Growers' Shipper Association official
Full Transcript
As President Trump continues implementing his ambitious agenda, follow along with the MSNow newsletter Project 47. You'll get weekly updates and straight to your inbox with expert analysis on the administration's latest actions and how they're affecting the American people. The American people are basically telling the president that they are not okay with any of this. Sign up for the Project 47 newsletter at MS.NowSlashProject47. The old Southern Pacific train depot in San Jose, California. Today, it's a busy commuter rail station, cal train and Amtrak thousands of commuters every day. Imagine this same spot in the early morning hours of May 29, 1942. There are hundreds of families from San Jose standing here uneasily. They're not sure what to expect. They've been ordered to report here at the train station to line up here so the U.S. government can load them on to trains. Among them is a rowdy, happy, very high-spirited, ten-year-old boy named Norman. For a ten-to-eleven-year-old kid, this was old boy, an overnight train ride, a long train ride. Norman's in the fifth grade. He's born and raised in San Jose. It's the only place he's ever lived. This Friday morning, when he and his family report to the train station, it feels to him almost like an adventure. There was some excitement about getting on a train and going somewhere, and it's like you've never been on a train before. That's Norman's son, David, who now himself lives in San Jose. Despite Dad talking about it as an adventure, I got to believe that he was picking up on the anxiety and the fear from his sisters, his brother, and his parents. In the weeks leading up to this day, Norman's parents had been forced to sell off. Basically everything they owned, nearly all the family's possessions, had to give away their dog. There was a lot of stuff they had to get rid of. One was a car that they had bought fairly recently, and they had to sell it for a fraction of what they had paid. There was a dog. There were so many things that they had to move and start and move on, not knowing where they were going, what was happening. The family had been forced to dispose of their possessions, sell off anything they could or store it somehow, and they had almost no time to do it. There are records in the National Archives now from towns all over the West Coast, places like San Jose and Hayward and Castro Valley in the Bay Area. Handwritten messages taken down from white citizens calling government offices. A woman looking to pick up a turnkey ready to go beauty shop business. A man looking for a half-ton truck. It was white citizens in California, inquiring with the government about how they could get their hands on the property, the houses, the apartments, businesses, cars, trucks, tractors, even farm animals. Property that their Japanese-American neighbors were being forced to dispose of. But that's how the whole Meneta family, including 10-year-old Norman, have ended up at the old Southern Pacific Train Depot, with only the possessions they can carry, while the United States Army has trains waiting for them. On the day that they were going to the trains, he asked if he could wear his Boy Scout uniform. So grandma and grandpa said, okay, you can do that, and you can bring your baseball stuff. I was wearing my Cub Scout uniform, and the baseball, baseball glove, and baseball bat. When I got on the train, the MPs confiscated the bat, on the basis the bat could be used as a lethal weapon. A lethal weapon, he was 10. If it wasn't clear then that this might not be the big adventure that Norman had been expecting. It would become clear to him just a few moments later, when that train started pulling out of the station. We were on the train moving on a San Jose, and I looked up and saw these tears coming down from my den. It's so powerful to me that grandpa would cry leaving San Jose. Family around him, his home. You know, in San Jose vacated, cleared out, thinking like we may never see that, and be able to come back to it again. That makes me emotional thinking about that. Where this train was going, how long this family would be gone. It wasn't at all clear to the Mineta family, even once they were on board the train. Frankly, it was barely clear to the government at that point. In the immediate wake of Pearl Harbor, the US Justice Department and the FBI had arrested thousands of Japanese immigrants, citizens of Japan. They had arrested and imprisoned them under the Alien Enemies Act. They seized their houses and their businesses, any money they had, and they had done that with only the barest semblance of due process. But there were some in the US government who wanted even less due process than that, and they wanted more people rounded up. Here's Justice Department lawyer Edward Ennis. He's not in talk to Lieutenant General DeWidd. He wanted the civilian authorities, the Department of Justice, to in turn more Japanese aliens than we were in turn. They wanted more Japanese aliens, more Japanese immigrants, more non-US citizens, rounded up. But these officials, they also wanted more than that. They wanted non-immigrants rounded up. They wanted US citizens rounded up. And the Justice Department was refusing to do it. Attorney General Biddell here, caution's one and all, that this is not martial law, wherein the right of haveiest corporuses suspended in civil rights go glimmering. The day after Pearl Harbor, even as the Justice Department and the FBI were arresting citizens of Japan who are here in the United States, even as they were using the Alien Enemies Act to do that. The Justice Department also put out a statement making clear that the Constitution was not broadly suspended, that no broad group of people was going to be targeted by the government. The Justice Department, in fact asserted, that they would protect any targeted groups of citizens or immigrants from discrimination. The Justice Department put out a statement to that effect, the day after Pearl Harbor. And then again, the day after that, and then again, the day after that, and then three days later, and then two weeks after that, all through December 1941. Matter-facuration of citizens or outing an individual according to Justice Department, the J. Enrico and Mr. Land were condemned for use by the military. The citizen family didn't, you know, we just didn't get too serious to hear it. They were just telling the Army, we're not going to do this. We're not going to do this. If the Justice Department was going to block the government from rounding up U.S. citizens, well, what could be done to get around that? Carl Bendetson, at the U.S. Army's Western Defense Command, began to study the idea of stripping people of their U.S. citizenship. Edward Ennis at the Justice Department was asked to make some proposals of how to do it. Members of Congress started considering legislation. The law already banned immigrants born in Japan from becoming U.S. citizens, so there wasn't a population of naturalized U.S. citizens who they might target for denaturalization. No, what they were talking about was stripping U.S. citizenship from people who were born in this country. People like 10-year-old Norman from San Jose, the kid with his baseball on the train. Norman was a U.S. citizen from the moment he was born here on U.S. soil. It's called birthright citizenship. It's in the Constitution. The government considered trying to get rid of birthright citizenship, revoking it from anyone of Japanese descent. Simply to make it easier to lock them all up. But the problem was, this was going to be a huge lift, legally speaking. I mean, this was going to take changing the Constitution. To avoid a fight that big, to avoid something that time-consuming, frankly, they decided instead to give themselves a shortcut. They went around the Justice Department and got a legal opinion in February 1942 that said that, okay, actually it was constitutional, to round up and lock up U.S. citizens on the basis of nothing other than their race. No Justice Department lawyer would agree to sign off on any such opinion. So they went to other government lawyers outside the Justice Department, lawyers who were willing to do it. They were leading any department on their damn business, they just called them to it. Well, no, we wouldn't write one. I was very disappointed in this opinion. It was none of their damn business back then. With that opinion in hand, Carl Bendetson finalized his plan for Japanese Americans and Lieutenant General John DeWitt signed it. The plan stated that Japanese people are, quote, an enemy race. That even for Japanese American citizens, people born here who had lived in this country their whole lives, who were in Carl Bendetson's words, Americanized. Even in those Japanese American U.S. citizens, he said, quote, the racial strains are undiluted. Every U.S. citizen of the Japanese race, he said, was a potential enemy. Quote, racial affinities are not severed by migration. Racial affinities. And so race would be the whole plan. Race would be the sole basis for removing Americans from their homes, putting them on trains and forcing them into domestic prison camps. Carl Bendetson's plan to do it is finalized on February 14th. The Justice Department under Attorney General Francis Biddle, they give in and stop fighting it on February 17th. The president signs the executive order to do it on February 19th. The army gets these powers. Bendetson and DeWitt get these powers. And in a matter of weeks, tens of thousands of U.S. citizens, like Norman Manetta, are ordered to the train stations and sent to the camps. 100,000 persons of Japanese ancestry were evacuated from their homes in military zones. The majority of these are known to be loyal Americans. The army, of course, is glad to have the president's order, permitting the delineation of jack-out areas on the west coast. I was a United States citizen at birth. I had all of the rights promised to all citizens in the Constitution, yet I abruptly lost all those constitutionally protected rights that most of us take for granted. So the army would be taking over on U.S. soil, and the due process conversation would, frankly, be over. What that meant for the Manetta family would start to become clear when the train they were on finally pulled into its destination. The train had taken them from San Jose in the San Francisco Bay Area to Los Angeles to the Santa Anita Restrack. What the army had done was to commandeer all of the restracks and fairgrounds in Washington, Oregon and California. Those facilities had built-in living quarters, namely horse tables. This was the U.S. Army forcing them into horse stables. Men, women, elderly people, children, babies. The family went from their family home into a horse stall at Santa Anita. There was hay and horse urine and feces in the horse stalls. As they had necessarily been cleaned or prepped to become living quarters for people. The idea that all these horse stalls people were living there, people, my dad and his family and their neighbors, yeah, it's... yeah, it's pretty painful to think of then. Ten-year-old Norman Manetta and his family would be held at the Santa Anita Restrack, not for a day or two or a week. They were held there behind barbed wire with armed guards for six months. As they waited for the U.S. government to finish building, the permanent camp they would be sent to next. They're told that they're going to be moved somewhere else and my understanding was they didn't know where. They get on trains and they still don't know where. They're in blacked out trains and it takes the day trip and then they wind up sort of in the middle of nowhere. Where they wind up is more than a thousand miles from home in Wyoming at a remote, remote location called Heart Mountain. There wasn't anything out there. I've only been there a few times in my life and it isn't the middle of nowhere. Heart Mountain would be one of ten new detention camps, effectively prison camps, FDR at the time called them concentration camps, that had been set in motion by Carl Bendetson and John DeWitt at the U.S. Army's Western Defense Command. They imprisoned immigrants and American citizens alike for years without trial and without charges. And without those people, those families knowing if or when they would ever return home. Here are these tens of thousands of Japanese Americans that show up one night and then here they are. These families, once they were there, they had to figure out how to make the best of it. This was Carl Bendetson's America. It was the spring of 1942 and this was just getting started. I'm Rachel Maddo and you're listening to Rachel Maddo Presents Burn Order. One hundred thousand persons of Japanese ancestry were evacuated from their homes in military zones. There was no reason, absolutely not, to fear me. This is the easiest country in the world in which to have a fifth color. It was a very frightening time for them. I really felt that maybe they're going to take us out someplace in the desolate area and shoot us all. Now I understand that what they had to do was figure out how to survive. As President Trump continues implementing his ambitious agenda, follow along with the MSNow newsletter Project 47. You'll get weekly updates and straight to your inbox with expert analysis on the administration's latest actions and how they're affecting the American people. The American people are basically telling the president that they are not okay with any of this. Sign up for the Project 47 newsletter at MS.Now slash Project 47. Episode 3. One Drop There's a famous picture taken by Dorothy Alang. It's in black and white. It's taken in April 1942. It's in the files of the National Archives now. And the photo is titled Eviction Order. The photo shows a line of people in downtown San Francisco. They're all dressed in what looks like their Sunday best. And the foreground of the photo is a young woman. She's pregnant. She's peering around the crowd of people ahead of her. She's trying to see what's waiting for her at the front of the line. Over her shoulder, you can just make out these signs that are tacked on to the side of the building. The signs say notice, instructions to all persons of Japanese ancestry. That photo is taken right in Japan town out in front of a community center called Kimongaku-en. Children went to language school there. They had programs there. This is Dr. Satsuki Ina. She's a psychotherapist and author and a filmmaker. This was the designated place where everyone in the neighborhood to be removed at that time and date were to line up and register so that they could be given their family number that would be used to identify them during the period of their incarceration. In this photograph that Dr. Ina is describing, the woman in the foreground, the pregnant woman in line, that's her mom. That picture captured, you know, I think the anxiety and the concern on my mother's face. Satsuki Ina's parents are both American citizens. They're both born here in the United States. They've just celebrated their first wedding anniversary and they are expecting their first child. It should be a time of great joy. But five days after this photo is taken, Satsuki's mother and father report for incarceration. It was a very frightening time for them. Her mother, her name is Shizuko, is handed paper tags on a piece of string. And the tags have written on them their new family number. One, four, nine, one, one. They waited for the posters to be posted in their neighborhood to be assigned the time and date that they were supposed to show up. And if they didn't, they could be subject to ten years in prison and twenty thousand dollar fine. Like Norman Manetta and his family in San Jose, Shizuko Ina and her husband have no choice really. But to report, in their case, to the local bus station. And there they are, herded up and cataloged by number and loaded onto buses and shipped off by the US military. At the Tantran race track, they were initially placed inside of former horse stables that had been quickly whitewashed and very unsanitary conditions. Shizuko Ina is 25 years old. She's a US citizen. She's not accused of any crime. And she is in her first trimester of pregnancy. My mother wrote in her diary that she wasn't getting enough food and she was concerned about the baby that was growing inside of her wasn't getting the nutrition that was needed. She had morning sickness but was very, very ill, extremely ill from being pregnant but also being in a circumstance where they had to use military style latrines with no privacy when using the bathrooms. While they were locked up at the Tantran race track in the horse stalls, Satuki's mom kept a diary. She could look through the chain link fence and on a Sunday see families taking a walk, pushing the baby buggies, driving by for a Sunday drive. While they were behind the barbed wire fence where they had no idea what their future held for them, how long they would be held, they had no idea. And my mother said in her diary, I wonder if today's the day they're going to line us up in Judas. Satuki's parents will soon be moved from that race track from Tantran near the San Francisco airport to a more permanent camp in Utah. And it's at Topaz, Utah inside that prison camp hundreds of miles from home where Shizukoina gives birth. When she gave birth there, the hospital was barely supplied with equipment and medication and she had to give birth without any anesthesia. After the birth of their baby boy in those circumstances, theina family is moved again from the Topaz camp in Utah to a different one in California. And it's here inside their new camp at Tully Lake where they learn that Shizuko is expecting again. After they had been sent to Tully Lake shortly after, I was born. Satukiina is born behind barbed wire in a prison camp in her own country. It was not until recently that she discovered the official government records from her time in that prison camp as a newborn. When I started researching, I came across my own files and it gives my name, I think, I'm three months and in the column about status, I was an enemy alien. A three month old US citizen, a brand new baby girl born to US citizen parents on US soil, she's labeled an enemy alien by her own country. She's locked up at three months old because she's considered to be a danger to the nation. What does it take to be considered dangerous to the country at this time? After he designed this policy, after he designed this program of mass incarceration of Japanese Americans, Colonel Carl Bendezin was asked to weigh in on what should be done about a group called the Silver Shirts. American Justice returns a verdict of guilty in the trial of William Dudley-Palle Silver Shirts leader. He's convicted on 11 counts of criminal sedition. The Silver Shirts were not Japanese Americans. The Silver Shirts were a homegrown, fanatical, right-wing, armed fascist movement that had been agitating for a violent takeover of the US government. The Silver Shirts in California, in Washington State and elsewhere, they had been caught stockpiling weapons, including stolen US military weapons. In preparation for the moment when they thought they'd be able to seize power by force in America and then ally our country with their hero. Hitler. Well, Carl Bendezin, now in his role as the person who has devised the program to remove people from the Western United States because they've been deemed dangerous to the US government and the war effort. Carl Bendezin is asked in a declassified internal army memo. He's asked what to do about the Silver Shirts and about others like them, about Nazis and fascists. Bendezin's response was that no, actually these people should not be bothered. He personally reversed decisions already made by the US Army. To remove from the West Coast some specific members of the Silver Shirts and other fascist groups, because he said these people were US-born citizens. And even though he admitted that they might intend to quote, seriously impede or even thwart the National War effort, he said the remedy for that kind of a threat should be quote through civil processes in the Federal Criminal Court. US-born citizens of Japanese descent should receive no such treatment. They should be rounded up as a group and put in prison locked up as a threat no matter what, but a vowed supporters of the fascist regimes we were fighting, even people who were members of armed groups that advocated the overthrow of the US government. Those people should be adjudicated as individuals through all the normal channels afforded by the US Constitution. You could be forgiven for suspecting that maybe security wasn't the whole motivation for what was going on here. Maybe something else was at work. This is the easiest country in the world in which to have a fifth color. Earl Warren, future Supreme Court Chief Justice Earl Warren, in 1942, he was California's Attorney General. There is no more likely place for it to be than right here in California. Warren said that it was not possible to distinguish between dangerous and loyal Japanese Americans. He proclaimed that American-born Japanese are a menace. He said they were a treasonous fifth column hiding in plain sight. Warren had been a member of a group called the Native Suns of the Golden West, a group which used the slogan, Keep California a White Man's Paradise. Well before World War II, the Native Suns were part of a group called the Joint Immigration Committee, which tried to block any Asian people from being allowed to immigrate to California. They were particularly opposed to Japanese immigrants, who they said were plotting to gain control of the state. The Japanese community was thriving and they were growing more and more successful and as that happened, the threat to the economy was played up and white nationalists were saying that they were a threat, they were wanting to take over. The white, nativist, white nationalist groups in California pushed for textbooks to be rewritten, to remove any passages that might be seen as favorable to the Japanese. They specialized in fear-mongering about the Japanese birth rate. They multiplied like rabbits, they were devoted to the emperor, many racist stereotypes were perpetuated. When the Pearl Harbor attack happened, groups like these, pounced. The California Joint Immigration Committee held a meeting right after the attack where one member stood up and announced, this is our time to get things done that we have been trying to get done for a quarter of a century. Their effort was joined by California farming groups across the state. Western Growers' Protective Association began agitating with California's members of Congress to support a policy to ship all the Japanese, whether of foreign or American birth, back to Japan. Quote, now is the time to do this and to do it right. Another group, the Growers' Shipper Vegetable Association, was right behind them stating, quote, we have a golden opportunity now and may never have it again. I think those are the perfect conditions to move, right? To move folks out, take land, take property. Long before World War II, long before the Pearl Harbor attack, groups like these were agitating against Japanese Americans. These groups had a lot of power in California politics, which might help explain why even though the Pearl Harbor attack was in Hawaii, and Hawaii had a much larger population of Japanese Americans. It was only in California and on the west coast, not in Hawaii, where there was mass internment, mass incarceration of Japanese Americans. Here's Justice Department lawyer Edward Ennis again. It's curious that, with a much larger, relatively larger population of Japanese and Japanese Americans in Hawaii, it was never any serious thought of evacuating Hawaii. It was possible to evacuate the Japanese Americans from the west coast, and there was a great political advantage in it. It turned over their lands to their white neighbors. Their white neighbors were not hiding their motivations here. One official from the Growers' Shipper Association in California said, on the record, we're charged with wanting to get rid of the jabs for selfish reasons. We might as well be honest. We do. It's a question of whether the white man lives on the Pacific coast or the brown man. He then said, quote, we don't want them back when the war ends, either. They wanted Japanese Americans gone, regardless of the war. They would seize this opportunity that the war gave them. But really, what they were after was a racial cleansing of the state. And at the US Army's Western Defense Command, Carl Bendetson and General John DeWitt, they were happy to oblige. General DeWitt opposed the return of any Japanese Americans to the west coast, even after the war. This was their chance to get this done, and they took it. When I first saw DeWitt early in December, I don't think it ever occurred to him that he would be allowed to give a military order, which would say that all the states of California and Oregon and Washington were barred to American citizens of Japanese ancestry as well as aliens. His reach for a larger power only came about when he learned elements in California, principally the farmer growers had an avaricious eye on Japanese farming land. An avaricious eye on Japanese farming land. White farmers wanted the land that Japanese Americans were farming. And so, this is how they would take it. This would be sold to the public and ultimately to the courts as a security decision, military necessity, national security. But the government knew from their own experts, from Ken Ringle, the Naval Intelligence expert on this issue, that there was no justification for concerns about Japanese Americans loyalty. The military knew from agencies like the FBI and the FCC as well as their own experts, that the supposed sabotage plots involving Japanese Americans that people like John DeWitt kept hyping. These were fantasies, they were not real. The Justice Department and the FBI even knew that there were no Japanese American spies or saboteurs at all, none who had been discovered anywhere. There were American fascists and some spies for Japan among them, but not Japanese Americans. Still though, they said it was security, and they went for it. What I believe happened is that the determination was more political than military. It was a political project to target this one immigrant community, this one minority community, and this was just the chance to make it happen. The White farmers in California got to their congressmen and the congressmen made it clear that if he asked for such power, that it would be approved. He would realize that he could ask for authority to do a great deal more than the Department of Justice was willing to do, and he was right. And if these were the real motivations for this policy, not military necessity, but this, this grubby reality. That may help to explain why the policy was carried out the way it was, just the cruelty of it. Why the US government, for instance, would label a three-month-old baby an enemy alien? There's a trauma unexpressed that I lived with, that I grew up with, and felt. Why the US government would identify a ten-year-old boy in a Cubscaught uniform as a lethal threat? Was I supposedly a saboteur, a spy, a secret agent? No one has ever explained to me what threat I posed. The only organizations I belong to were the Cubscouts and the Methodist Church Youth Group. There wasn't a national security imperative driving this policy. This was racial. This was blood and soil. How else to explain the lengths that John DeWitt and Carl Bendeson decided to go to here? Even children who were in foster care and orphanages were removed. Infants and babies, without a home, without parents, but who supposedly had some trace of Japanese blood in them. They went and got them. One orphanage located in Los Angeles run by the Catholic Church got orders from the army, from Carl Bendeson, to locate any child in its care of Japanese ancestry and immediately send those children to Manzanar, to one of the prison camps. The Catholic priest running the orphanage father Hugh Lavary protested directly to Carl Bendeson. He argued that many of the orphans in his care were only half Japanese, some of them less than a quarter Japanese. He says he was told by Bendeson. Quote, I am determined that if they have one drop of Japanese blood in them, they must all go to camp. The nuns working at that orphanage reportedly tried moving the babies, whisking away as many kids as they could, before the army could come in and take them. Inside of the Manzanar concentration camp, they had built an orphanage for children without parents, children who had been removed from places where they were being taken care of. These were babies' infants and very young children. Even the official running the Manzanar prison camp described the imprisonment of orphans there as a travesty of justice. The Catholic priest running that Los Angeles orphanage described Carl Bendeson as operating like a quote, little Hitler. Anybody with one-sixteenth Japanese blood was not likely but was a threat to national security, and that was a justification for taking these children and putting them into prison. The army identified foster kids who were thought to have any trace of Japanese ancestry. They went into foster homes and took those kids away from their foster families. How did they know where to find them? Well, Carl Bendeson and army officials reportedly got the children's names by combing through federal welfare records to locate foster children who might be even partially Japanese. One six-year-old boy who was sent to Manzanar later said that he never even knew his birth mother was Japanese until the government came for him and sent him off to the prison camp. The real life consequences for the real lives of people affected by this. It was just devastating. For Satsuki Ina, her parents were forced to weigh an almost impossible choice of whether renouncing their American citizenship and seeking to be deported from this country might be a better option than languishing away in prison camps indefinitely, with the real possibility of being separated from each other. The fear of separation was very real. They had no idea what was going to happen to the family. What my parents faced was if the only way to protect the family was to be deported, the only way to be deported was to renounce your citizenship. Satsuki's parents were born here. They were US citizens. This was their country. But seeking to be deported to another country, at that point, looked to them like it might be the better option. To them, that was the better alternative to an indefinite incarceration. So not an easy decision, but the only decision. When I read my parents' letters and diaries, I realized that they never had a question of loyalty. Their decisions to renounce was a loss of faith in the country of their birth. They had no trust that their children would be safe. How long they were going to be viewed as the hated people. After renouncing their US citizenship in order to try to keep their family together, Satsuki Ina's parents were then separated by the government anyway. Her father was singled out inside their camp in California and transported to another faraway camp this time in North Dakota. They were brought in and held as enemy aliens. One of the first things that they were issued, government issued, was a denim jacket. And on the back of the denim jacket were the capital letters E A for enemy alien and a circle around it in white. And he was told that if you try to escape, this is the bullseye that will use to shoot you. They had no idea what was going to happen. They had to now understand that what they had to do was figure out how to survive. Survive. Somehow, some way. Keep your family together and survive. That would be the same objective for another young mother sent off to the camps. A young woman named Eiko Yoshinaga, who would change the course of US history by the time she was finished. That's next. Simone Sanders Townsend and I have known each other for more than a decade. We're friends and colleagues and on our new podcast MSNow presents Clock it. We are positioning ourselves at the intersection of culture and politics. Clock it is where we talk about what we see in here in the news so you can start to clock it too. MSNow presents Clock it. Listen now. New episodes drop Thursdays. For every listing and bonus content subscribe to MSNow Premium on Apple Podcasts. I belong to a group called the Junior Misses. Eiko Yoshinaga is a senior in high school in Los Angeles. It's the end of 1941. There were about a dozen of us and we would quote sponsor down says just as an excuse to be able to meet the boys. Eiko and her friends are admittedly very fixated on boys. But she is getting ready to graduate. She is making plans for the future. She's dreaming about the future. Living in a dream world thinking I'd be the next Japanese well known dancer or singer dreaming. Maybe I'll be the next Japanese bitty grey bowl or Eleanor Powell. In 1940, 1941, Eiko Yoshinaga is living her own version of the American dream. That would of course all change radically in December 1941 because of Pearl Harbor. I had just been at a party and we were going home and the radio un-nosed it. We just couldn't believe it. We were sort of in a state of shock. For Eiko and her friends and her family, what began as shock would quickly turn into the realization that this was coming home to them. Eiko is just months from graduating from high school. She's an honor student. She has plans to go to secretaryal school after graduation. She has her next steps planned. She has her whole life stretching out ahead of her. And then this. We knew that there was a connection between what happened and us, simply because we were Japanese. But we had no idea the extent of the damage that would be done to us as a community. When Eiko starts to hear about the construction of camps, rumors about roundups and mass removal orders. Her mind goes to the worst place possible. I really felt that maybe they're going to take us out someplace in the desolate area and shoot us all. I really felt that they might do that. Eiko has a boyfriend at the time high school sweetheart. And when the incarceration orders start to come down. And the deadline is set for her and her family to report. She and her boyfriend decide to illope. It's an impulse decision. They don't want to be separated from each other. And this seems like maybe the way to stay together. And so Eiko does not go with her own parents. She's now a newly wedged. And she and her brand new, teenage husband are sent together to Manzanar. The rest of Eiko's family gets sent further away. They get sent to a different camp in Jerome, Arkansas. And they're just miserable at this decision that she made. I think they were upset at my selfish motive to do this. All in a flash, Eiko goes from high school senior preparing to graduate to married, separated from her family. And then once she's at Manzanar, she soon finds that she's pregnant too. Here I was still a child myself. It was a hard time. It was a difficult time. You do the best you can under the circumstances. They had a child camp, a daughter. This is writer Frank Abe again, who knew Eiko well. Eiko asked me transfer to Jerome because her father was sick. Her father's very ill. And she wanted her father to see his granddaughter and hold her. When Eiko asks for this transfer, the government allows her and her daughter to go. But not Eiko's husband. They just said he's your father, not his father. So he can't go. I don't know why. It was a very cruel decision. And I just never could understand it. So it was a long, hard, five day train ride across country. And I didn't have a seat. Eiko makes this journey across the country with her luggage holding her newborn baby daughter without a seat on the train. So standing or sitting on her luggage. She's just hoping to get there in time. I was getting off the bus and they were taking my father on a gurney into the hospital ambulance. I grabbed my daughter to run over to him. And that was the one and only time he got to see her because on Christmas Eve, 10 days later my father passed away. So this was the plan. This is what they did. This was what Carl Bendetson and John DeWitt, and ultimately the president, FDR. This is what they turned life into for this minority group in America. I mean, this, you know, this is a form of experience for Eiko as well, you know, fueling her desire to understand what happened, why they were put in this circumstance. If your country does something like this, if your country pursues a policy like this, one that you find to be cruel or wrong, what can you do as a citizen? What can you do as a country to try to stop it, to try to end it? Like Eiko Yoshinaga, the mother of Satuki Ina was also pregnant and scared when she was inside one of these camps. My mother actually told me the story that every Sunday women from the American Friends Service Committee, she referred to them as the Quaker Women, would come to the other side of the fence and throw over fresh fruits and vegetables to the prisoners. And so she would go there every Sunday and a woman probably saw that she was pregnant, called her over and managed to heave this place. She would heave this beautifully quilted cotton blanket over the fence to my mother and then looked at my mother and said, I hope this helps. And she held on to that story so much so that when she was very ill and I saw the blanket on her bed was pretty raggedy by then. It had cotton batting in it and it was frayed. And I just said, shall we get you a new blanket? Let's get a fresh new blanket for you. And she actually grabbed the top of the blanket and she said, no, she didn't want a new blanket. So I asked her, what is so important about this blanket? For me, it had a lot of negative connections to their trauma of being incarcerated. But for her, she said, this helped her to remember that someone outside cared. And I got really choked up about that, thinking how much that meant to her and why she would want to keep it on her bed even when she was dying. It helped to remember that someone outside cared. Someone on the outside, somebody on the other side of that fence knew that this was wrong and was going to do something, even something small to try to stand against it. That was rare. There was no organized protest, there were no petitions, there was no effort to challenge the mass removal. People watched on the streets as the buses took them away. What hurt them the most, what was very painful for many of them was that America had turned their back on them. That was true for most Americans. There was no mass movement of protests or loud objections or shows of solidarity, there was nothing at scale at least. But that meant that the people who did stand up, the people who did take individual action alone, that took a very special kind of person. Including precisely one elected official, one unbending politician, who stood quite alone when he put his career on the line to say no, to refuse to do it. And in so doing, he changed the lives of thousands of Americans who were otherwise being betrayed by their own country. They were American citizens and everything that that term held needed to remain true. It was indisputable in his mind. And he couldn't understand, frankly, why people didn't get it. And so he went out and tried to convince him, he points at them and says these Japanese are protected by the same constitution that protects us. If you harm them, you must first harm me. And that is next time on Rachel Maddo Presents Burn Order. Rachel Maddo Presents Burn Order is a production of MSNOW. This episode was written by myself, Mike Yarvitz and Kelsey Desiderio. The series is executive produced by myself and Mike Yarvitz. It's produced by Kelsey Desiderio and Jen Mulraney-Donovan. Our associate producer is Vasilios Carcelakis, archival support from Holly Kloppchen. Katie Lau is the senior manager of audio production for MSNOW. Additional audio engineering and sound design by Bob Mallory. Bryson Barnes is the director of podcasts and live streaming for Versant Media. Our web producer is the great Will Femmea. Our senior executive producers are Corey Nazo and Laura Connoway. Aisha Turner is the executive producer for MSNOW audio and Madeline Herringer is the senior vice president for audio, digital and long form. Original music, including our theme music, was created by New York-based Japanese composer Mi-Yu Sato. Very special thanks to Dr. Satsuki Ina. Her incredible book is called The Poet and the Silk Girl. It's out right now in paperback. I cannot recommend it highly enough. Again, it's called The Poet and the Silk Girl. She's also the co-founder of Suru for Solidarity, which is a Japanese-American social justice organization. An enormous thanks to the organization Densho for providing archival material for the series and for everything that they do. You can find out much more about this series at our website, ms.now slash earn order. You know, I'm putting a quote, a sledding on the quote, it's a great sport to get into a great big box in the wintertime. With the snow and the wind and the have, and you get to find a little hill, and you just go tumbling inside the box down the hill and letting the slippery snow and the wind just push you down. Well, as I recall, co-text 24 case boxes were great for this kind of sport. And one time as we were sliding along, we went right through the under the fence. And we were picked up by the military, we were breaking out a camp kind of thing. So here we were as 11 and a half year olds, being picked up in the Jeep and being, I mean, you know, really being threatened and then, and just really being scared out of us, going down to the brigade and sitting there crying and promising, no, we won't ever do it again. Thank you. Simone Sanders Townsend and I have known each other for more than a decade. We're friends and colleagues, and on our new podcast, MSNow presents Clock It, we are positioning ourselves at the intersection of culture and politics. Clock It is where we talk about what we see in here in the news, so you can start to clock it too. MSNow presents Clock It. New episodes drop Thursdays for every listening and bonus content subscribed to MSNow Premium on Apple Podcasts.