Renewing Your Mind

Cures for Antinomianism

26 min
Feb 6, 20264 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Sinclair Ferguson explores the biblical cure for antinomianism (lawlessness in Christian life) by examining the Christian's relationship to God's law. He argues that through union with Christ via the Holy Spirit, believers are freed from legalism while remaining bound to the law as an 'in-law'—not for salvation but out of love for Christ and desire to please Him.

Insights
  • Antinomianism and legalism are interconnected problems; legalism is the root issue, and antinomianism is a reactive overcorrection that doesn't fully address the underlying misunderstanding of grace and law
  • The law of God is not abolished in the New Covenant but transformed in function—it shifts from external constraint to internal motivation written on believers' hearts by the Holy Spirit
  • Understanding biblical theology's progression (creation, fall, Sinai, Christ, fulfillment) is essential to resolving confusion about the law's role; each stage reveals how God's purposes advance while maintaining continuity
  • The relationship between law and gospel is harmonized in Christ's person and work; He bore the law's condemnation so its righteous requirements could be fulfilled in believers through the Spirit
  • Negative commandments in Scripture (especially the Ten Commandments) encode positive principles about God's character and design for human flourishing, not restrictions born from divine jealousy
Trends
Renewed theological interest in historical church controversies (e.g., Marrow controversy) as frameworks for addressing contemporary doctrinal errorsGrowing emphasis on union with Christ as the central organizing principle for Christian ethics and sanctificationShift in evangelical teaching from law-gospel antithesis toward law-gospel harmony, reflecting deeper engagement with Reformed theologyIncreased focus on the role of the Holy Spirit in transforming believers' relationship to God's moral law from external obligation to internal delightResurgence of biblical theology methodology in pastoral teaching to help congregations understand progressive revelation and covenantal development
Topics
Antinomianism and lawlessness in Christian theologyLegalism and grace in Christian lifeUnion with Christ through the Holy SpiritBiblical theology of God's lawOld Covenant vs. New Covenant relationship to the lawThe Marrow of Modern Divinity controversyMoral law, ceremonial law, and civil law distinctionsSanctification and obedience in Christian ethicsThe Ten Commandments and their enduring relevanceGospel and law harmony in ChristImage of God and natural lawJeremiah 31 and the New Covenant promiseRomans 8:3-4 and law fulfillment in believersGalatians 3-4 and the law as pedagogueChristian freedom and obedience
People
Sinclair Ferguson
Vice chairman of Ligonier Ministries; primary speaker delivering theological teaching on antinomianism and the law
R.C. Sproul
Referenced as upcoming speaker for next week's Renewing Your Mind episode on the love of God
John Calvin
Historical theologian cited regarding the abrogation of ceremonial law upon Christ's coming
Quotes
"The law and the gospel harmonize in the person of our Lord Jesus Christ."
Sinclair FergusonMid-episode
"We can't say to Christ, I want you, but I don't want your father's commandments. I never liked your father's commandments and they always condemned me."
Sinclair FergusonMid-episode
"Adam heard as much of the law in the garden as Israel did at Sinai. But only in fewer words and without thunder."
Sinclair Ferguson (quoting The Marrow of Modern Divinity)Late-episode
"The promise of the new covenant is that when the spirit of Christ comes and indwells believers, he writes the law of God into our hearts."
Sinclair FergusonLate-episode
Full Transcript
We don't live in the days of the Old Covenant, we live in the days of the New Covenant and the gift of the Holy Spirit. But the question is, what does the Holy Spirit do? What is the promise of the New Covenant? The promise of the New Covenant is that when the Spirit of Christ comes and indwells believers, He writes the law of God into our hearts. There are dangers surrounding both legalism and lawlessness in the Christian life. In the 18th century, there was great controversy in Scotland about the book, The Marrow of Modern Divinity. And the questions it raised for the church. It was a significant moment in Scottish church history, but it's also a topic that's relevant for you and me today. This is the Friday edition of Renewing Your Mind. And today you'll hear one message from Sinclair Ferguson's series, The Whole Christ, on how we should deal with lawlessness in the Christian life, or what is often called anti-nomenism. To learn more about the Marrow controversy and hear Dr. Ferguson go in depth on legalism and lawlessness, request this Gospel-rich series, The Whole Christ, when you give a donation at RenewingYourMind.org, before midnight to 9. We'll unlock the series for you in the free Ligonier app, and we'll send you the DVD and a physical copy of the study guide. But be quick, as this offer is only available today. So what is the cure for lawlessness? And what is the Christian's relationship to the law of God? Here's Ligonier's vice chairman, Sinclair Ferguson. We've been talking recently about these problems, endemic problems, really, in the Christian life of legalism and anti-nomenism. And one of the things we've been seeing so interestingly is that legalism is the basic problem. It was what was injected into the relationship between the Lord and Eve in the Garden of Eden by the serpent, who very subtly turns her into a legalist, distorts the commandments of God, and gives her the sense that God is not a gracious God, giving kind commandments for their benefit. But God is a kind of jealous person who doesn't want any joy, any happiness, wants to restrict their lives. And then the reaction that sets in of anti-nomenism. And in our study we were seeing last time, how there is throughout the history of the Christian church a sense in the masters of the spiritual life, that anti-nomenes are never fully and finally delivered from legalism. Only the grace of God in the gospel can deliver us from legalism. But in many ways the problem is not simply that we don't understand the gospel well. It is that we also don't understand the law well. So how do we begin to understand the relationship that a Christian believer has to the law of God? Paul has a very striking way of putting this in 1 Corinthians 9 verse 21. He says that yes, it's true that in Christ Jesus, from one point of view, we are set free from the law. But from another point of view, he says, I am in law to Christ. And if you just step back from that expression and think about it, Paul is not speaking there in terms of family relationships, that expression in law is a very good way of thinking about the relationship that we now have as Christians to the law. We are not directly related to the law as though in order to be saved we needed to keep the law. Because Christ has kept the law for us. But as you remember Paul says in Romans 7, we have had an old husband who has died and so we are now free to marry another to marry Christ. And so through faith by the ministry of the Spirit, we are united to Christ that Bible uses that metaphor, doesn't it? We are married to Christ. But when we are married to Christ, what happens to the law? Well, the law becomes our in law. The law becomes our in law. Now, I remember my Latin teacher at school telling me that the oldest recorded joke in the world was about a mother-in-law. And we are all familiar with that. Kind of difficulty. A man marries a woman he loves. And it's the case of marry me, marry my mother. You can't have me as your wife without having my mother as your mother-in-law. Now, she is not directly related to you. But if you are a right-thinking husband, you want not only to love your wife, but to please your mother-in-law, there may be times when the mother-in-law who wants the very best for this relationship proves to be slightly irritating to you. But if you love your wife through your wife, you are related to her mother. She is your mother-in-law. And as you grow in wisdom and in grace, you live in a way that more and more pleases your mother-in-law for this reason that you are more and more pleasing your wife, blessing your wife. And in a sense, all illustrations break down, but in a sense, that's a good illustration, isn't it, of how we are related to the law. We can't say to Christ, I want you, but I don't want your father's commandments. I never liked your father's commandments and they always condemned me. And he says, marry me, and I will have borne all the judgment of God against your breach of the commandments, but marry me and you will become the in-law of the law. The law and you through me will be related to one another. So that by God's grace, what Paul had said in Romans 8, 3 and 4, begins to become true. That in Christ's flesh, the law was fulfilled, its penalties fully paid in order that now married to Christ through the Spirit, the just requirements of the law might be fulfilled in us who walk not according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit. The law and the gospel harmonize in the person of our Lord Jesus Christ. And it's this that points us in the direction of the gospel cure for our antinomianism. The gospel cure for our antinomianism is our union with Jesus Christ through the Holy Spirit, who in that bond leads us to love the law and be obedient to the law. Now sometimes it's just at this point that Christians kind of difficulties because when you read through the New Testament, especially for example in Paul's letters and also in the letter to the Hebrews, there seem to be some very negative things said about the law. For example, Paul speaking about the law and second Corinthians 3 speaks about the laws having no glory at all. Yes, it seemed to have glory in Moses' day, but now he says, well point of view, it is no glory at all. It does not suggest that we can be done with the law. Maybe an illustration will help here. And again, of course, illustrations break down. I remember going to school when I was four years old and I've no memory of doing anything but loving elementary school. I was having the time of my life. But then I went to high school and I realized that the teachers in elementary school had been dragons. They hadn't taught me very much. Didn't get any Latin in elementary school or trigonometry in elementary school. And so now I look back on elementary school and I think that was like being in prison. But now there's this wonderful freedom to study all these subjects with these people who seem to know so much. And then I leave school and I go off to university. And I remember first lecture in the English lit class at university. A very distinguished Shakespeare expert is the professor. I had been studying one of Shakespeare's plays for six months in my last year in high school. I learned more about that play in this man's first lecture than I'd learned in all the six months. And suddenly I'm free from all that. These people, my teachers, they didn't really know anything. But these people. And I live in a day when they put money in your pocket to go to university. I'm more money than I've ever had in my life. Of all these hours I have to go to half a dozen lectures, sit a few exams, write the occasional paper. I can read my Bible, I can read other books, I can go and play golf. Boy, this is really living. And these long vacations. I guess there are still exams at the end. And in the Scottish system, they're really well exams at the end. And in a sense, since the last exams you sat with the only ones that would matter for the rest of your life, the fair amount of pressure. And then I become a minister of the gospel. And there are no more exams except I realize there's at least an exam every Sunday. But this is this is this is freedom for me. And so you see at each stage of my life, I was having the time of my life. I never noticed that there were any restrictions really placed on me. There was so much to enjoy. There was freedom until I moved on to the next stage and then by comparison saw that the previous stage had been so restricting. And it seems to me that that's how the New Testament Christians who had gone through the barrier between the old covenant and the new covenant, that's how they saw things. In fact, Paul says precisely this at the end of Galatians 3, beginning of Galatians 4, he says, as old covenant believers, we were like underage children. We were ares, but none of the inheritance was actually coming to us. We were still waiting for it. Now we have entered into the full privileges of sonship and we say what no old testament believer ever said, never said, Abba, Father. And so we are to understand that when the New Testament seems to speak critically of the law, it's not an absolute statement. It's really saying, now look at how the law worked. There were the commandments of God and then those commandments were surrounded by civil regulations. And then there were all those regulations about the liturgy so that you were restricted and constrained because just like children, just exactly like children. God was saying, it's for your good that I don't just let you loose. But then when you look back, you understand that the Mosaic Administration, the law in that sense by comparison with the internationalism and the liberty and the sense of God being Abba, Father, all of this is gloriously new and so by comparison. Those old days look as though they were the shadowlands and now you're beginning to live in the sunshine and the fact of the matter is there is more yet to come. We may be enjoying the Christian life now, but it's little compared to the glory that is to be revealed. So you see God moves his purposes on in these staging posts. Remember I said the problem was not just that Antonovians misunderstood the gospel. It was that they misunderstood the law. So let me take a few minutes in our session on this occasion just to explore how the Bible thinks about the law of God. And to walk us through a series of stages in biblical theology that I think very much help us to appreciate why God gave the law and how the law functions. To do that, we actually do well, I think, to begin with Romans 2, 14 and 15. Romans 2, 14 and 15 is an interesting statement Paul makes. He's thinking about the New Testament age. And he says a very striking thing there in chapter 2 verses 14 and 15. He says Gentiles who do not have the law by nature may do what the law requires and there are a lot of themselves even though they do not have the law. What's he saying here? He's saying you look around the world and you see that there are Gentiles who live according to the commandments of God as though the faded image of those commandments was still on their hearts. They don't do it perfectly. He goes on to say their thoughts, excuse them sometimes and other times accuse them. So now why is this? He says they show Romans 2, 15 that the work of the law is written on their hearts. Now there are some scholars who think that Paul is speaking here about believers who are Gentiles. It seems to me that it's quite inappropriate in this section of Romans where he's dealing with the ungodly, whether they are Jew or Gentile to think that suddenly he starts speaking about Gentile Christians. Now I think what he's saying is this. But in the creation of man, God wrote his law into our constitution so that instinctively we did what pleased God. It was in our DNA just as later on legalism is injected into our DNA. And he's saying that the image of God has not been destroyed by the fall. It has been seriously marred by the fall. But it shouldn't surprise us that in every culture there will be echoes of those laws that God built into our constitution. And Paul seems to me to be alluding to that here in Romans chapter 2. Actually the marrow of modern divinity put this rather well. Listen to this. Adam heard as much of the law in the garden as Israel did at Sinai. But only in fewer words and without thunder. You see what he's saying? And then we move on to the next stage. Here is fallen man. His mind is darkened, his heart is twisted. The law of God has been written into his life because he is the image of God. He reflects the character of God. But now it's distorted. It's as though the mirror is smashed and broken and the law of God is no longer clear. Sometimes yes, you know, if you read some of the scholarly work you will notice that especially unbelieving scholars are always looking for parallels to the ten commandments in the ancient nearest to try to show that the ten commandments are dependent on the laws of the ancient nearest. And stubbornly resist the notion no. Of course there will be similarities between the law of God and the laws of the ancient nearest in different countries because the works of the law however damaged they may seem to be still written on the human heart. What happens at Mount Sinai is that what was written on the heart and has now become unclear is now made clear by God by writing it on tablets of stone so that we can be in no doubt what the law of God that was originally written in our hearts was meant to say. But it was also given to a community a particular ethnic community. And so there are certain particularly ethnic dimensions that surround it this people in this land at this time. There also as we discover in the New Testament there are God's children in a period when they're under age Paul puts it in Galatians 3 and 4 so what do you do with underage children. I wouldn't have been able to do it my wife would have been able to do it but neither of us sat down with our children when they were 3 and explained to them how electricity works. But we did say whatever you do don't go and poke that thing into that socket in the wall we covered over the sockets in the wall because the easiest way to guard them was to give them negative commands. And when God carries his children as the Old Testament scriptures describe it as he carries them through the desert. It is of course natural that since he's speaking to sinners and to children under age that by large the 10 commandments come in a negative form. Not because God is a negative God but because it's the best way for children under age to learn positive principles which is why when Jesus explains the commandments in Matthew 5, 21 to 48 he says don't you see that these negative statements enshrine positive commands. Because God wants you to live again he wants to recreate you after his image and likeness as he had created Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. And at the very heart of that relationship yes there were civil dimensions yes there were liturgical ceremonial dimensions the very heart of that relationship was the 10 commandments. Sometimes scholars say well the law was the law no Old Testament believer thought of the laws anything but one single sheet of paper didn't make these distinctions that theologians have made between moral and ceremonial and civil you know that's not true I tell you why it's not true. The only part of the law that was placed in the arc of the covenant was the 10 commandments. That said something that said that yes there is a unity in the law God gives to us but there is also a dimension to the law God gives us that it's rooted and grounded in these commandments that are placed in the arc of the covenant indicating that they belong to the very heart of the relationship. This is the lifestyle that is pleasing to the heavenly Father. And yes of course the ceremonial law was given until Christ came. But then as Calvin says when the Nunde son arises you know around striking matches in order to be able to see. The the little jade drops out because the great high priest has come and yes the civil laws are abrogated because they were given for this nation that had its purpose in God's economy until Christ came it had a very special purpose in God it was God's servant until God's final servant came. And so the laws that govern Israel are not laws that are to be distributed internationally they belong to a particular people in a particular place in a particular time. Yes we may learn lessons from them. And so there is stage three of fulfillment in Jesus Christ and this is of course what Paul is saying in Romans chapter 8. The condemnation of the law as well as obedience to the law both meet in Jesus Christ and then there is the fulfillment of the law in as a fourth stage. The very point that Paul makes in that pivotal statement in Romans 8, 3 and 4 that Christ bore the judgment of God against our breach of the law not in order for us to say. Law is no longer relevant but in order that the requirements of the law might be fulfilled in us who walk not according to the flesh but according to the spirit. An interesting thing that people sometimes quote Jeremiah 31 in this context don't they? We don't live in the days of the old covenant we live in the days of the new covenant and the gift of the Holy Spirit. But the question is what does the Holy Spirit do? What is the promise of the new covenant? The promise of the new covenant is that when the spirit of Christ comes and indwells believers, what does he do? He writes the law of God into our hearts. And we're bound to ask the question, well which law of God does he write into our hearts? The answer? The same law of God that was written for Israel and placed at the heart of the relationship in the arc of the covenant. Because what the spirit does is transform us into the likeness of Jesus Christ that we may be restored to the likeness of the Heavenly Father. In a sense so that we may be restored to Eden but not only restored to Eden prepared for the new Eden that will come when thank God by the Spirit in the presence of Christ. At last the commandments of God will be easy to obey. That makes you say it doesn't it even so come Lord Jesus. Don't you look forward to that day when God's law is easy to obey and we can obey it perfectly and joyfully. This is the Friday edition of renewing your mind on your host Nathan W. Bingham. Today's message is from Sinclair Ferguson's series The Whole Christ and it's a series that clearly presents the gospel and confronts errors and challenges to the gospel exposing where some of our thoughts might not be consistent with the gospel we first believed. So in addition to introducing you to a moment in church history that may be unfamiliar to you it deals with vital truths that every generation needs to be reminded of and every generation needs to affirm. Requests this series on DVD along with the physical copy of the study guide when you give a donation at renewingyourmind.org but when you call us at 800 435 4343. We'll send these to you and we'll unlock the messages in the free Ligonier app so you can start watching before the package arrives in the mail. But be quick as this offer ends at midnight to night. The address again is renewingyourmind.org or you can use the link in the podcast show notes and like always there's a digital version of this offer waiting for a global listening audience at renewingyourmind.org slash global. Thank you for your support. As a reminder for our listeners near Houston, Texas I'll be there March 17 for renewing your mind live. Enjoy a night of teaching and fellowship pick up some renewing your mind swag and a $20 gift certificate for the Ligonier.org online store. You can learn more and register at renewingyourmind.org slash Houston and I'll see you next month. Christians affirm that God is love but do we really understand the love of God and what it means to be loved by God. That will be RC Sproul's focus next week beginning Monday here on renewing your mind.