PTI

Did the Bills make the right decision?

24 min
Jan 27, 20263 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

PTI hosts discuss the Buffalo Bills' hiring of Joe Brady as head coach to replace Sean McDermott, analyzing whether the decision addresses the team's Super Bowl drought. The episode also covers NBA All-Star Game decline, tennis controversies, NFL playoff performances, and various sports industry trends.

Insights
  • Organizational accountability in sports often scapegoats coaches while protecting star players and front office executives from blame
  • Star player input on coaching hires has become standard practice in modern sports, giving elite athletes significant organizational influence
  • All-Star Game decline stems from systemic league and player culture issues rather than single moments, requiring comprehensive solutions
  • Rookie offensive linemen face steep learning curves against elite pass rushers, requiring quarterback awareness and protection adjustments
  • Professional sports leagues struggle to balance player privacy/autonomy with media coverage demands and fan engagement expectations
Trends
Quarterback-driven coaching hires becoming normalized in NFL front office decision-makingPlayer empowerment extending to coaching staff selection and organizational directionAll-Star Game format experimentation reflecting declining fan engagement in exhibition eventsIncreased surveillance and camera coverage in professional sports creating player privacy concernsRookie quarterback development becoming central to franchise strategy and coaching hire justificationOffensive coordinator-to-head-coach pipeline gaining prominence in NFL hiring cyclesPlayer mental health and emotional expression management becoming public relations considerationsDefensive edge rusher quality as primary challenge for rookie offensive linemen in playoffs
Topics
NFL Head Coach Hiring DecisionsBuffalo Bills Organizational StrategyJosh Allen Quarterback InfluenceSean McDermott Coaching AccountabilityNBA All-Star Game DeclinePlayer Empowerment in SportsRookie Offensive Lineman DevelopmentDrake May Quarterback PerformanceNFL Playoff Performance AnalysisProfessional Tennis Conduct StandardsCoco Gauff Racket Smashing ControversyAustralian Open Tournament CoveragePro Bowl Selection CriteriaAaron Rodgers Pittsburgh SteelersMike McCarthy Coaching Strategy
Companies
ESPN
Jeff Saturday identified as ESPN NFL analyst providing expert commentary on NFL coaching and player performance
Sirius XM
Frank Isola noted as contributor from The Starting Lineup on Sirius XM radio network
People
Joe Brady
36-year-old offensive coordinator hired as Buffalo Bills head coach to replace Sean McDermott
Josh Allen
Buffalo Bills quarterback who reportedly blessed and influenced the hiring of Joe Brady as head coach
Sean McDermott
Former Buffalo Bills head coach fired after failing to reach Super Bowl despite strong regular season performance
Drake May
New England Patriots rookie quarterback who ran keeper play without informing offensive linemen
Will Campbell
Patriots rookie left tackle struggling against elite pass rushers in playoff games
Aaron Rodgers
Veteran quarterback Mike McCarthy reportedly wants to retain for Pittsburgh Steelers next season
Mike McCarthy
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach seeking to retain Aaron Rodgers for quarterback development purposes
Coco Gauff
Tennis player caught on camera smashing racket after Australian Open quarterfinal loss to Alina Svitlina
Alina Svitlina
Ukrainian tennis player who defeated Coco Gauff 6-1, 6-2 in Australian Open quarterfinal
LeBron James
NBA player criticized by Kevin Garnett for not accepting one-on-one challenge from Kobe Bryant in 2012 All-Star Game
Kobe Bryant
NBA legend who issued on-court verbal challenge to LeBron James in 2012 All-Star Game
Kevin Garnett
Former NBA player who criticized LeBron James on his podcast for declining All-Star Game one-on-one challenge
Peyton Manning
Former NFL quarterback who ran keeper plays without informing offensive linemen, per Jeff Saturday
Terry Bradshaw
Pittsburgh Steelers legend selected first overall 56 years ago, led team to four Super Bowls
Billy White Shoes Johnson
1970s Houston Oilers punt and kick returner celebrating 74th birthday, only 75th anniversary team member not in Hall ...
Devin Hester
Chicago Bears return specialist in Hall of Fame, compared to Billy White Shoes Johnson for Hall of Fame eligibility
Shadur Sanders
Cleveland Browns quarterback selected to Pro Bowl as alternate despite seven touchdowns and ten interceptions
Mike Tomlin
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach whose playoff success record is being addressed through quarterback development strategy
Jeff Saturday
ESPN NFL analyst and former player who played one season under Mike McCarthy with Aaron Rodgers
Mike Wilbon
PTI co-host leading discussion on NFL coaching decisions and sports industry trends
Quotes
"Whether or not it turns out to be a great hire is going to depend on one thing. Can he get further than Sean McDermott did? Can you get to a Super Bowl? Can you win one?"
Frank IsolaEarly segment
"Josh Allen went like this with the hire. He gave it the blessing. They were going to hire who the quarterback wanted."
Frank IsolaEarly segment
"Now there's no buffer between the two of them. It's him and it's Josh Allen, even though I still don't think that team is good enough or has the personnel."
Mike WilbonEarly segment
"I went to this place because I didn't want kids to see this, but I needed to get this out. Of course you need to get it out."
Frank IsolaTennis segment
"You're not just going to take and physically dominate play after play. But if you get enough leverage on the play, you can catch an edge."
Jeff SaturdayNFL analysis segment
Full Transcript
From 30 for 30 podcasts. Brian Pata, senior defensive lineman from Miami, gunned down. The key to this case, it's Brian. An hour before he died, he was on the phone arguing what's about. This might be a hit. You want the truth. They just want a conviction. They're placing the arrest. We had a killer amongst us. Murder at the U. Listen now. Pardon the interruption, but I'm Mike Wilbon. It's National Chocolate Cake Day, Frank. What's your fav dessert? Come on. Phil and Frank, favorite flan. You should have. I see what you did there. Now, what's your favorite dessert? It ain't flan. Mint chocolate chip. Mint chocolate chip. That's a good one. Your mind is so basic. And vanilla cake, I like that. Vanilla ice cream with chocolate sauce. An old-fashioned chocolate sundae. That's a Chicago specialty. No special thing? Yeah baby. You have to eat a deep dish pizza. No deep dish. You New Yorkers, stop talking about deep dish. We don't do that. Baked pizza. Lasagna that is. It is, that's why we don't eat it. Welcome to BTI. Tony's busy doing cameos for TGL telecast. I saw that. So here to do his work for him is our great friend from the starting lineup on Sirius XM, Mr. Frank I sold you. They didn't hit their mark. Go. Just don't ever mention Deep Dish on this show again. Let's start today with the man the Buffalo Bills have selected to succeed Sean McDermott as head coach, offensive coordinator Joe Brady. The 36-year-old Brady has been an offensive assistant with the team since 2022 and has led the offense as the OC the last two-plus seasons. Brady is said to have a close relationship with Josh Allen. Frank, how's this hire sit with you? Well, number one, it's a great job because you get Josh Allen. You ask any guy that's going to become a first-time head coach, do you want a great quarterback? So absolutely. Yes. Whether or not it turns out to be a great hire is going to depend on one thing. Can he get further than Sean McDermott did? Can you get to a Super Bowl? Can you win one? So clearly they think. But Brady had been interviewed with a lot of teams, Arizona, the Raiders, the Ravens. So clearly they thought they were going to lose him. They wanted to keep him in the building. But I do love the story of all the people involved with the interview. The owner, the GM, a couple of family members. Oh, and also Josh Allen. Do you know what that means? Josh Allen went like this with the hire. He gave it the blessing. They were going to hire who the quarterback wanted. Mike, you know this. Any sport, if you have a star that big, they're going to have a lot of say. And obviously, this is what Josh Allen wanted. No doubt about it. But one of the things strikes me, Frank, and that is that all this lack of getting to the Super Bowl and winning it is being blamed on Sean McDermott. I totally agree. Because the ownership out there has that awkward press conference last week. Yep. Right? And it just seems that they're saying, okay, you know, we can keep all these other pieces in place, which is all of them. Yep. We're not going to blame any of this on Josh Allen, nor would I. We're not going to blame this on the offensive play caller, even though he's been an assistant, a top assistant for two years and a cog in this thing for three. We're not blaming either one of them. We're not blaming the GM for not putting more talent around Josh Allen. We're going to blame Sean McDermott and fire him. And I'm like, wow, so you know what? Joe Brady better be damn good. Yeah. Because now there's no buffer between the two of them. It's him and it's Josh Allen, even though I still don't think that team is good enough or has the personnel. They have an entire offseason to do something about it, but I don't think it does. So under Brady, they finish second in points and fourth. They had an MVP, and they also had the guy that led the league in rushing. So offensively, they've been good enough. You mentioned that about McDermott. So Pagoula says he walks into locker room after the game. Everyone's despondent. Yeah, because you just lost. You just lost the game. An awful loss. And Josh Allen's despondent. Yeah, because he had four turnovers in the game. You're supposed to be. The biggest mistake Sean McDermott made to this day is still the squib kick to the Chiefs. Yeah. That was the game that they should have won, and they should have been playing. They should have been playing an AFC Championship game. But to sit there, clearly everyone is staying, Mike, except Sean McDermott. That could fall under the old cliche and coaches hate this. Wow. We need a new voice in the locker room. All that nonsense. But it doesn't seem like that. They took that thing hard. As they should. As they should. But there was no indication outwardly that the players who were taking it hard were blaming it on Sean McDermott. But the owner did and the GM did. And now, okay, so this is what you got. Better make good. Yeah, so Brady had a backer in Josh Allen. He also had a good agent because he interviewed, like I said, Cardinals, Raiders, Ravens, Dolphins. A lot of places. They thought they were going to lose him, so they hired him. All right, let's move to the NBA and Kevin Garnett's tough words for LeBron James. Garnett said on his podcast, everyone has a podcast, Mike, that LeBron fouled up the tradition of the NBA All-Star Game in 2012 when he passed the ball twice in the final seconds rather than go one-on-one with the great Kobe Bryant. All right, Mike, people love to blame LeBron for so many things. Do you blame him for the decline of the All-Star game? Not at all. Not at all? No. The All-Star game was going down. It was headed down. I don this is one of those cases Frank where I never spent any time trying to figure out who to put the finger on for specific blame The whole culture is to blame The league is to blame And the top players all of them share in some blame Now, for those of us who were around that game and the aftermath, yes, Kobe Bryant issued a on-court verbal challenge we all could hear to LeBron James. And I don't know why LeBron didn't take him up on it. Part of the culture and the history of the All-Star game was to take people up on it. Whether this was, I mean, remember, we got beef going back to Jordan in a freeze-out. We have stuff with Kobe and Michael. In 98. And so it all seemed, if not in good fun, it all seemed to be acknowledged in real time. This, though, stuck, and LeBron gets the blame for this? I'm not going with that. I think in that moment, I do understand LeBron not just going along with the spirit of the game. Kobe wants to go with him one-on-one. So the first pass. Like a hockey fight. Let's drop the gloves. Exactly. And LeBron declined. So he throws it to Darren Williams because they were down two. Darren Williams shoots a three. Darren Williams was eight for ten at that time. So you could say it was a basketball play. If you watched the replay of it, I had a close look at it today. Kevin Durant on the other one comes over in double teams. And LeBron, that's his instincts. That's right. So I'm not going to – the players might think that moment. I think the fans think you don't show up ever in the slam dunk. Kobe and Michael did it. So now Zion Williamson doesn't show up for the slam dunk. That hurts the weekend, Mike. And I think the other thing was. What hurts the weekend is they don't give a damn about Sunday. They don't want to play the game. And maybe that was a player empowerment thing. But there's a couple years ago, Luke is not trying in the All-Star game. Nikola Jokic. And then last year, they turned the All-Star game into a round robin. And then you have the game was spent with. It was a Kevin Hart celebrity roast. and then we were celebrating inside the NBA because, as you know, they went away even though they're back this year. Yeah. So the game gets hijacked, but the players need to try more. That's the biggest issue. And the league needs to try. And the league got it wrong again. The league was scared again. It's a gutless move to put this all-star game out there. You walk right up to the line where you can get something that people are engaged by and either two or three players or their agents, You know who I'm probably talking about. If you want to blame people, two or three players or maybe one and an agent, they don't want to do it so you don't do it, so you put something out there on Sunday that's so embarrassing the commissioner had to admit the following Monday he was embarrassed. A couple years ago, they had Larry Bird and Dr. J ask the players to try hard in the game. I've said this before. You look at the baseball all-star game. Ohtani might get two at-bats. Aaron Judge may get two at-bats. The fans understand that other guys are going to play. Go to the players, the night before the game, how many minutes you want to play. Nicole Yoko say, I'll play eight minutes. All right, play those eight minutes. Call the top players in the office in the offseason and say we're not going to have an all-star game. That's an embarrassment. So participate and help us put together something that's honorable instead of that garbage that's out there. Jalen Brunson, Tyrese Maxey, Tyrese Halliburton, those guys would have played harder. They didn't play them last year. If the Stars don't want to play, pull them out of the game. Send them home. Exactly. Exactly. Won't happen. No. League didn't have the guts. Let's go to the Australian Open, where Coco Gauff went down swinging. Gauff was caught by a hallway camera smashing a racket to bits after a 6-1, 6-2 quarterfinal loss to Alina Svitlina. Gauff said she didn't think the moment needed to be broadcast because she thought she was in a private space, no cameras, and swore off breaking rackets on court in front of the cameras. A while back, are you with her? All right, so the only thing more broken than that racket is her serve. In the first set, five double falls. She was broken five times a match. She had seven doubles. The match was 59 minutes. So Sabalenka, the year before, two years earlier at the U.S. Open, I love the way Sabalenka did it. She walked into the area where players warm up and they have their physios with them. She finished second, so they give you that silver plate. She calmly put the plate down, casually walked over, and then just smashed her racket. I think it's a very human thing to do. I can understand why Coco Gauff is an image thing, but then talk to the tour. Tell them not to put the camera there. The biggest issue with Coco Gauff right now is her serve. Her serve is terrible. By the way, I thought Coco Gauff's explanation was spot on. And she said, I went to this place because I didn't want kids to see this, but I needed to get this out. Of course you need to get it out. Yep. I got it out once against St. Ben's when I lost in high school and did that to the only three rackets I had or could afford. Coco Gauff is totally fine smashing her racket. It's the serve. She's got to get together before we get to say the French Open. She's got a few weeks left, but that's all that matters here, and players should go to the network or televising networks and the tour and say we need a space where there are no cameras. Exactly. Do whatever you want to do. And they have the power to do it. but it was very similar to Sabalenka where she calmly walked over. She's not ranting and raving, and then she just smashes a racket. And I thought when it happened with Sabalenka, maybe Sabalenka publicly didn't make a big deal of it, but I thought some of the players were thinking, whoa, whoa, because there are cameras now everywhere. Everywhere you go, there's a camera. And I think the players are thinking that. And you know how it works with the locker room, too. There is a sanctity of the locker room I know that not the locker room but they view that as an area which should be off limits And it should be off limits And you know you don need every single moment to be It's not the Truman Show. It's a damn tennis tournament. But, no, everybody gives in to this. Now, let's see what the players do. And their representatives should go to the tour and the participating networks and say, figure out a space now before the next ball is struck. Yeah. Six Americans on the men's and the women's side made the quarterfinals. That's the most we've had in the quarters since the 2002 U.S. Open. And quite a few American stars have gone out, too. But not Coco's bracket. We're taking a break. We're coming up. Drake may didn't tell his lineman about the keeper that clinched the Super Bowl berth. We're going to ask Jeff Saturday about that. We'll also ask him about Mike McCarthy's desire. Wait for it, Mike, to have Aaron Rodgers return next season for the Steelers. No! No! One more. No Aaron Rodgers. We have some NFL questions for our great friend, ESPN NFL analyst, Jeff Saturday. And Jeff, I am still curious about Drake May running for that game ceiling first down without telling his lineman that he was going to keep it. And first, I'm wondering, does this happen often? And secondly, how would you have felt about not knowing when you look up and see your quarterback peeling left with the game on the line? Hey, we never knew, Will, but we never knew if Manning was going to pull that thing. He never told anybody. You pull that thing. We're going to run zone. Everybody run zone as hard as you can. And let me tell you what it does. It stops what you call the peak, right? It's innate in all of us. You're blocking, you're blocking. You kind of want to just peek over. Hey, where is that? Did he make it? Did he get there? You know, is the crowd going crazy? Like all those things, they need a full sellout. Like just push as hard as you can run the play called. But we never knew. I was never offended. I didn't want to know for that exact reason. I don't want to be the reason pulling up on my block. Because, you know, Peyton wasn't Drake made. I mean, he runs a 7040. You know what I mean? 70. So you got to make sure he gets all the advantages he can get. You ain't got no speed on the edge, bro. just make it just get there we'll all be happy inside baseball moment that was a great improvised play all right let's stick with the Patriots offensive line how concerned should they be about their rookie left tackle Will Campbell yeah he's struggling struggling Frank I mean and here's the deal this is not going to be solved right I mean he hadn't I mean he hasn't taken this large leap come playoff time and the truth is he's played some vicious defensive ends Like if we're being honest, this isn't like just run-of-the-mill guys are coming and just beating the brakes off the guy. He's facing the best of the league. Like all three of the defenses they faced in the playoffs have all been legitimate and all had good pass rushing edges. It's part of being a rookie left tackle. And I love the fact that he's fighting out there. He's doing the stuff he's trying to do. He's trying to work his technique. Sometimes it's good. Sometimes it's not. I will say this, though. From Drake May's perspective, he has to be aware of that and understand most of the time in Campbell's problem, he's getting pushed in the pocket. So meaning he doesn't necessarily just whiff, but the guy's putting power to him and driving him back. May's got to know that. Keep two hands, secure the ball, so the guys can't reach over the back edge and knock the ball over his shoulder. That's the biggest thing that you get concerned with, getting driven back as a left tackle. Obviously, the Nolan Ryan is a no-no, right? You're a no-hitter out there. He's going to kill the quarterback. But the getting pushed back, You know, you can limit some of that. I like that analogy. All right, the Patriots defense, they've been strong against the run this year. If you're tasked against, you know, running against them, what would you tell your line mates? Yeah, creativity from the run game, right? Understand that, like, inside zone, outside zone, can we get some motion? Can we get some things that take some – make some eye candy. Like, get linebackers looking, maybe get them rocking, maybe get them stepping out of the gap so you can catch an edge. But the biggest thing about run game, it's leverage the man that you're blocking and leverage the play. And so from Seattle's offensive line, that's exactly what they're going to be coached on. Make sure their hat's in the right place where you're leveraging the play and let Walker or whichever running back is do the rest. You you're not just going to take and physically dominate play after play. But if you get enough and that's the one thing about Seattle, even when they weren't efficient in the run game, they stayed true to it. Mike McDonald, he didn't he didn't bail off of it. He's like, well, we're going to keep doing it. They've gotten better as the season has progressed. So you got to like they're going to stick with it, even when it's not efficient. Well, let's go after we take you back to the end of your playing days. You played, of course, one season under Mike McCarthy and with Aaron Rodgers. McCarthy said today or indicated today he wants Rodgers back next season. If Rodgers wants to be with the Steelers, Jeff, it seems awfully short term and not really resolving anything to me. But how do you feel about this? Yeah, I think from McCarthy's perspective is it buys him a little time, right? I mean, you're replacing the guy, right? Mike Tomlin is the guy. The only knock on Mike Tomlin has been winning in the playoffs. So for him to draft a quarterback and go win in the playoffs, especially in that division he's in, to get in the playoffs is going to be work enough. I think he would like to be able to kind of lean on that vet right being Aaron Rodgers But the truth is they going to have to figure something out for the future Aaron Rodgers in the future And why you brought Mike McCarthy in, right? At 62 years old, going to the Steelers is to develop a quarterback. So you've got to trust that he can do it, get the right guy, find the right timing of doing it, whether it's mid-year or even watch for a year and come in the second year. But I think that's really why he would appreciate Aaron Rodgers being there for another season. They're very comfortable knowing the offensive, knowing what each other's thinking. So obviously there's some familiarity there. But being able to develop a guy under that, I think, is really what would benefit him the most. Only part that scares me is another season having to talk about Aaron Rodgers. Thanks, Jeff. We appreciate it. Appreciate it, fellas. Thanks, Jeff. Let's take one last break. But still to come, the Pro Bowl weekend is diminished. But so much that Shadur Sanders deserves an invite. And how fortunate was Arizona to escape BYU last night? That was a good game. Good in. It was. Good in. Locked shot. Time to get happy, people. Happy 74th birthday, Billy White Shoes Johnson. Johnson was best known as the premier punt and kick returner of the 1970s over his first four seasons in the league for the Houston Oilers. Johnson returned five punts and two kicks for touchdowns and scored 12 touchdowns in his role as receiver, punctuating so many of his scores with his rendition of the Funky Chicken. A knee injury in 1979 caused Johnson to miss his sixth season. He spent a year in Canada before returning to the NFL with the Falcons and winning the 1983 Comeback Player of the Year. Johnson's the only member of the NFL's 75th anniversary team not in the Hall of Fame. If Devin Hester of the Bears is in, damn it, he should be, then so should Shoes, Frank. How much fun was Billy White Shoes Johnson? We'd go to the park, he'd score a touchdown, and everyone would do that dance that he did. Yes. You know, he played two games in 79. He was not in that AFC Championship game. That was the Mike Renfro play in the corner of the end zone, which should have been a catch. Houston should have tied the game. Dan Pastorini threw that ball. Good memory on your part. All the way. Happy anniversary, Terry Bradshaw. On this day 56 years ago, the Steelers selected Bradshaw with the first overall pick in the draft. Pittsburgh had landed that pick by winning a coin flip with my Bears. Bradshaw told me a couple of Super Bowls ago he was so certain he would be drafted by the Bears. He told his dad, quote, By tonight, I'm going to be a teammate of Dick Butkus and Gale Sayers. Bradshaw was so excited. And then he went fishing. It wasn't until he returned home that he learned the Steelers had drafted him, not the Bears. So while Bradshaw led Pittsburgh to four Super Bowls, Bears fans dealt with a succession of quarterbacks through the 70s. That included Bobby Douglas, Gary Huff, Bob Avellini, Mike Phipps. That's a list. All right. How about this? Pittsburgh in that same draft third round, they take Mel Blunt. The following year, they take Franco Harris. Then in 74, four of the five guys they drafted, all these guys are Hall of Famers. Lynn Swan, Jack Lambert, John Stallworth, most underrated wide receiver of all time. Great. And Mike Webster. They mastered it. They killed it. Starting with Terry Bradshaw. Crazy. Just looked great in the 12th, midnight blue uniform. Happy trails to the Pro Bowl games for Drake May. The Patriots quarterback will be focused on the Super Bowl, so he'll be replaced by, wait for it, Shadour Sanders. Sanders threw seven touchdowns and ten picks this season for the Browns, but he gets the nod to join Justin Herbert and Josh Allen because alternates Patrick Mahomes, Daniel Jones, and Bo Nix are out for the season, and Trevor Lawrence opted to not participate. Frank, this game is so bad, they got rid of it. So why are they inviting players and substitutes to a flag football game? It's a television show, and a lot of people like Shador Sanders. What's the big deal? All right, so he made the Pro Bowl. There's a difference between all pro and Pro Bowl. Let's not blame Shador Sanders. I'm not. I think people want to see him. One omission. Bill Belichick was not elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame on the first ballot. You're surprised. He didn't win enough Super Bowls, Mike, maybe. Come on. We're running out of show. Let's get to the big finish. Ridiculous. The Titans will reportedly hire Brian Dayball as their OC. You like that? And their head coach is a former Jet head coach, Robert Sala. I don't mind at all. Number one, Arizona survived a scare from number 13 BYU last time. I know you were watching. The Bounce is amazing to watch, but Arizona really tough out the rest of this season. Duke and quarterback Darian Mensah settled their dispute. He'll be allowed to transfer out. Does that make sense? Yes, it makes sense because college football doesn't make sense. Max McClung will not go for his fourth slam dunk title in a row. You're disappointed. Yes, I'm not going to see him like in the NBA playoffs. I want to see him. Last one, women's soccer friendly tonight. USA versus Chile. Are you intrigued? I know those South American teams are getting better. Trini Rodman played the other night. She was the captain. I got big contact with Washington. We're out of time. Thanks for watching. I'm Frank Isola. I'm Mike Robon. Same time tomorrow, Knucklehead. We can call that room for Smash Me Rackets the McEnroe Room. That's a great name for it, right? Johnny Mac, not Patrick. The Sports City. BTI.