Mike McCarthy
Mentioned in 42 analyzed podcast episodes across 10 shows
A former Green Bay Packers head coach with a 174-112 career record and Super Bowl experience, he was recently hired as the Pittsburgh Steelers head coach in a controversial move that broke the franchise's tradition of long-term coaches. Podcasts discuss his hiring as both a notable veteran addition to the AFC North and a potentially questionable choice given concerns about his lack of recent success and offensive innovation. As an offensive-minded coach, he is central to the Steelers' quarterback strategy and roster decisions, particularly regarding Aaron Rodgers and other quarterback evaluations.
Appears On
Episode Appearances
Nightcap · Apr 13, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Has NFL figured out Lamar Jackson + Steelers LEGEND Heath Miller joins!
“Discussed as new Steelers coach facing QB uncertainty and playoff expectations”
Nightcap · Apr 13, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 2: Heath Miller on Steelers Mike McCarthy hire, retirement, hilarious training camp stories
“Discussed as new Steelers head coach hire and his quarterback development background from Green Bay”
Club Shay Shay · Apr 7, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Rodgers waiting for pay day? Lamar reports to Ravens workouts, Burrow's Flag Dreams
“In communication with Aaron Rodgers regarding contract decision and quarterback succession planning”
Nightcap · Apr 7, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Rodgers waiting for pay day? Lamar reports to Ravens workouts, Burrow's Flag Dreams
“Discussed his communication with Aaron Rodgers and confidence in backup quarterback Will Howard”
PFT Live with Mike Florio · Apr 2, 2026
Will Aaron Rodgers play for the Broncos? (4/2 Hour 1)
“Analyzed for Will Howard evaluation and potential Ty Simpson draft smokescreen strategy”
3 and Out with John Middlekauff · Apr 1, 2026
NFL League Meetings Reaction Day 2: MNF Doubleheaders are no more, Thanksgiving Eve Games, NFL Flag Football
“Acknowledged phone call with Aaron Rodgers and praised Will Howard as quarterback prospect”
Pack-A-Day: Your Daily Packers Podcast · Apr 1, 2026
Matt LaFleur Was NEVER On the Hot Seat!
“Confident Aaron Rodgers will be Steelers starting QB; previously coached Packers”
NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal · Mar 31, 2026
32 Takeaways from AFC Coaches Breakfast and Dave Canales Steals the Show
“Expressed surprise at being hired, discussed regular communication with Aaron Rodgers about potential return”
Club Shay Shay · Mar 31, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Steelers to draft a QB? Browns back Deshaun Watson, Shedeur Sanders number change
“Discussed for quarterback strategy, play-calling approach, and hiring of offensive coordinator”
Nightcap · Mar 31, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Steelers to draft a QB? Browns back Deshaun Watson, Shedeur Sanders number change
“Expressed hope for finding QB at right time in 2026 draft; hiring Ryan Angelicho as offensive coordinator.”
First Take · Mar 31, 2026
Hour 2: Better Case for MVP: SGA or Wemby?
“New Steelers head coach; known for work with young quarterbacks; positive conversations with Aaron Rodgers ongoing”
Club Shay Shay · Mar 23, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Mike McCarthy expectations, Jarvis Landry GOES OFF on Stefanski, JSN GETS PAID!
“New Steelers coach whose offensive philosophy and expectations are primary discussion topic”
Nightcap · Mar 23, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Mike McCarthy expectations, Jarvis Landry GOES OFF on Stefanski, JSN GETS PAID!
“New Pittsburgh Steelers head coach whose offensive philosophy and leadership style are primary discussion topic”
Nightcap · Mar 10, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Steelers Free Agency REACTION: Pittsburgh TRADES for Pittman Jr + Le'Veon Bell joins!
“New Pittsburgh Steelers head coach; offensive-minded coach implementing system changes and empowering GM Omar Khan”
Club Shay Shay · Mar 10, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Steelers Free Agency REACTION: Pittsburgh TRADES for Pittman Jr + Le'Veon Bell joins!
“New Pittsburgh Steelers head coach replacing Mike Tomlin; offensive-minded coach hired to implement culture change”
Nightcap · Mar 9, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Maxx Crosby TRADED to Ravens, Steelers SEARCHING for QB Answers
“Steelers head coach; praised for measured approach to QB evaluation and roster building strategy”
Club Shay Shay · Mar 9, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Maxx Crosby TRADED to Ravens, Steelers SEARCHING for QB Answers
“Steelers head coach; expressed confidence in Will Howard's abilities and potential development”
Nightcap · Mar 6, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: REACTION to DJ Moore trade to Bills + Pittman Jr. to Pittsburgh? Maxx Crosby DRAMA
“Steelers head coach; hiring consultation with Pat McAfee and QB strategy discussed”
Club Shay Shay · Mar 6, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: REACTION to DJ Moore trade to Bills + Pittman Jr. to Pittsburgh? Maxx Crosby DRAMA
“Steelers head coach; discussed consultation with Pat McAfee regarding leadership style and quarterback strategy”
First Things First · Mar 5, 2026
Bears trade D.J. Moore to Bills, Celtics ‘can win it all’ with Tatum returning, BUD List
“Dallas Cowboys head coach; discussed team's playoff contention and free agency approach”
Club Shay Shay · Mar 2, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Steelers QB Plans: Anthony Richardson to Pittsburgh? + Gainwell to test Free Agency
“Steelers head coach; will call offensive plays; decision-maker on QB selection”
Nightcap · Mar 2, 2026
Deebo & Joe - Part 1: Steelers QB Plans: Anthony Richardson to Pittsburgh? + Gainwell to test Free Agency
“Steelers head coach; will call offensive plays; his scheme preferences critical to QB evaluation decisions”
Miller and Moulton · Mar 2, 2026
March 2, 2026 Hour 2
“Pittsburgh Steelers head coach; mentioned regarding Aaron Rodgers' previous destination”
NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal · Feb 25, 2026
25 More NFL Combine Nuggets, Bills GM Brandon Beane and Steelers GM Omar Khan Join the Show!
“Steelers head coach hire; described as passionate Pittsburgh Steeler with similar vibes to Will Howard”
First Take · Feb 25, 2026
Hour 1: Issues with Luka Passing up the Final Shot?
“New Steelers head coach; previously coached Aaron Rodgers with Packers; hire discussed as questionable”
Pack-A-Day: Your Daily Packers Podcast · Feb 25, 2026
Brian Gutekunst Speaks at the Combine!!!
“New Pittsburgh Steelers head coach discussed as potential impact hire in AFC North”
CHGO Chicago Bears Podcast · Feb 25, 2026
Former Packer AJ Hawk LOVES the Revival of the Chicago Bears Rivalry
“Former Green Bay Packers head coach who emphasized Packers-Bears rivalry significance to players”
The Herd with Colin Cowherd · Feb 13, 2026
Sharp or Square - NFL Offseason Mailbag - Free Agent QBs, NFL Future Bets and more
“Hired as Steelers head coach; discussed as controversial hire breaking franchise tradition of long-term coaches”
The Rich Eisen Show · Feb 12, 2026
Hour 1: Seahawks’ Victory Parade Top 5 Moments, plus Hall of Fame DB Rod Woodson
“New Steelers head coach; surprising hire given age and lack of recent success”
Sharp or Square · Feb 12, 2026
NFL Offseason Mailbag - Free Agent QBs, NFL Future Bets and more
“New Steelers head coach; debated for playoff performance and offensive creativity concerns”
The Dan Patrick Show · Feb 11, 2026
Hour 2 - The NBA's Tanking Problem, Jason Garrett
“Pittsburgh Steelers head coach whose connection to Aaron Rodgers impacts quarterback decision-making”
The Colin Cowherd Podcast · Jan 31, 2026
Prime Cuts - Super Bowl Preview, Belichick Hall of Fame Snub? Broncos Win With Bo Nix, NFL Coaching Carousel
“New Pittsburgh Steelers head coach whose hiring and coaching resume compared to John Harbaugh”
The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL · Jan 30, 2026
The coaching cycle that just won't quit
“Hired as Pittsburgh Steelers head coach; described as uninspiring retread hire returning to familiar offensive system”
The Colin Cowherd Podcast · Jan 29, 2026
Belichick Hall of Fame Snub? Super Bowl Preview, Sam Darnold’s Redemption Arc, LeBron Still Dominates At 41
“Steelers new head coach analyzed as safe hire lacking innovation; compared to other coaching options”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Jan 28, 2026
Mega-Mailbag: Belichick Misses HOF, Shedeur Makes Pro Bowl, Bills Hire Joe Brady, and Craig Was an Extra in 'The Fate of the Furious'
“Hired as Steelers head coach; emphasized maintaining traditional organizational approach in press conference”
PTI · Jan 27, 2026
Did the Bills make the right decision?
“Pittsburgh Steelers head coach seeking to retain Aaron Rodgers for quarterback development purposes”
The Mina Kimes Show featuring Lenny · Jan 27, 2026
The Brady Bunch? Bills Hire a New HC, and Recapping the Seahawks and Patriots Wins
“Hired as Steelers head coach, bringing extensive experience but raising questions about organizational direction and quarterback future”
The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL · Jan 27, 2026
What's next for the Rams and Broncos after falling just short of the Super Bowl?
“Hired as Pittsburgh Steelers head coach; criticized as uninspired hire lacking fresh perspective despite 185 career wins”
PTI · Jan 27, 2026
This Patriots defense is historically DOMINANT!
“Hired as Steelers head coach with 174-112 career record and Super Bowl experience from Green Bay tenure.”
The Right Time with Bomani Jones · Jan 26, 2026
Darnold Leads Seahawks to Super Bowl, McCarthy to Steelers, Deion Fining Players? | 01.26
“Hired as Pittsburgh Steelers head coach, representing controversial departure from organizational tradition”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Jan 26, 2026
Championship Sunday: Darnold's Moment, Pats Bury Stidham, Steelers Hire Mike McCarthy, and Blue Man Group
“Newly hired Pittsburgh Steelers head coach replacing Mike Tomlin, criticized for lack of innovation”
The Bill Simmons Podcast · Jan 26, 2026
Darnold Does It, Snow Game II: Mile High, Pats-Seahawks, and the Wild Taipei Climb With Cousin Sal
“New Steelers head coach hired; compared to John Harbaugh and other elite coaches by win-loss record”