ZOE Science & Nutrition

Recap: We need to talk about metabolism | Shawn Stevenson & Tim Spector

14 min
Dec 30, 20255 months ago
Listen to Episode
Summary

Shawn Stevenson and Tim Spector explore what metabolism truly is beyond the calorie-counting myth, explaining how the body converts food into energy through complex biochemical processes. They discuss how ultra-processed foods create 'metabolic clogs' that reduce calorie expenditure by up to 50% compared to whole foods with identical macronutrients, and introduce the concept of metabolic health as an efficiency measure rather than a simple body composition metric.

Insights
  • Metabolism is not simply calories in versus calories out—it's a complex energy conversion system involving millions of biochemical inputs including food quality, microbiota composition, and individual metabolic fingerprints
  • Ultra-processed foods can reduce post-meal calorie expenditure by approximately 50% compared to whole foods with identical calories, fats, proteins, and carbohydrates due to metabolic inefficiency and digestive disruption
  • Only 12% of US citizens are metabolically healthy, indicating a widespread failure of conventional dietary guidance based on calorie restriction and food pyramid recommendations
  • Individual metabolic health cannot be assessed through a one-size-fits-all approach; factors like gut microbiota composition, food sensitivities, and ancestral dietary patterns must be considered
  • Metabolic health should be defined as the efficiency of the body's energy management system, not merely body composition or fitness appearance, as someone can be fit but metabolically unhealthy
Trends
Shift from calorie-centric nutrition science toward systems-based understanding of metabolic health and food quality impactGrowing recognition that ultra-processed foods have metabolic costs beyond their caloric content due to additives and compounds that disrupt digestionPersonalized nutrition gaining prominence as understanding deepens that individual metabolic fingerprints require tailored dietary approachesIncreased focus on metabolic health metrics (triglycerides, HDL/LDL ratios, insulin response) as primary health indicators rather than weight or BMIReevaluation of whole grain recommendations as potential gut irritants for certain populations, challenging decades of dietary dogmaIntegration of microbiome science into metabolic health assessment and dietary recommendationsGrowing skepticism toward simplified nutritional education models that ignore biochemical complexity and individual variation
Topics
Metabolism and energy conversion biochemistryUltra-processed food impact on metabolic efficiencyMetabolic health definition and measurementCalorie expenditure and thermic effect of foodGut microbiota and metabolic healthIndividual metabolic fingerprints and personalizationWhole grain versus refined carbohydrate metabolismInsulin response and blood glucose managementFood quality versus caloric quantityMetabolic clogs and digestive disruptionEpicoloric controllers and metabolic regulationNutritional science education and dogmaBody composition versus metabolic healthAdditives and pesticides in processed foodsAncestral dietary patterns and modern nutrition
Companies
Kraft
Referenced as producer of Kraft singles cheese product used in metabolic study comparing processed versus whole food ...
People
Shawn Stevenson
Co-host discussing metabolism, food quality impact, and metabolic health with detailed scientific explanations and pe...
Tim Spector
Co-host providing scientific perspective on metabolic health definition, efficiency metrics, and personalized nutriti...
Quotes
"Metabolism is really about the sum of all the different pieces that can create and generate energy and that feed into each other."
Shawn Stevenson
"When people ate the processed food sandwich versus the whole food sandwich, they had about a 50% reduction in calorie expenditure, a calorie burn, after eating that processed food sandwich."
Shawn Stevenson
"Only 12% of United States citizens are metabolically healthy. Only 12%. That should be outrageous, like blow our minds."
Shawn Stevenson
"Metabolic health is the energy management system of the body and its efficiency. It's how all the bits in the body work together."
Tim Spector
"We can't have this kind of cookie cutter approach to things. These are some of the things that go into our own unique metabolic fingerprint."
Shawn Stevenson
Full Transcript
Hello and welcome to Zoey Recap, where each week we find the best bits from one of our podcast episodes to help you improve your health. We often hear people talk about metabolism, whether it's fast, slow, strong or sluggish. It's one of those health buzzwords that's often said but rarely understood. Yet understanding metabolism is essential. It influences how we process food, how much energy we have, and our risk of developing health conditions like diabetes, cancer and heart disease. In this episode, Sean Stevenson and Tim Spector cut through the confusion. Together, they'll explain what metabolism actually is and empower you to take control of yours. I'd love to start right at the very beginning. Sean, what is metabolism and why does it matter? From a rudimentary perspective, it's converting food into energy. That's looking at energy through this very isolated vanilla way. There's this entire microcosm of events. Metabolism is really about the sum of all the different pieces that can create and generate energy and that feed into each other. For me, it's really based on that principle of energy cannot be created nor destroyed. It can only be converted from one form into another. This energy exchange, even if we're looking at that very vanilla version of it, of food is creating energy, where does the food come from? What are the pieces and parts of the food that create the energy? There are other things besides food that are getting converted into energy for us as well. Whether that's body fat, whether that is oxygen and how it relates to all these different pieces, there are literally millions of parts and inputs that determine metabolism. It isn't just food. Even from the perspective of food being used as energy, the endpoint being the mitochondria, which we'll get to, I'm sure, and talk a lot about, when we eat a food, it doesn't just become energy. It gets converted into a currency that our body can actually use. Our body runs on a certain currency, and so there's so much work involved in converting that food into the currency that our body can use. Sometimes that conversion doesn't happen. Our body isn't converting everything that we eat into that currency that we're using. Sean, could you talk me through that maybe in a very simple way? Let's imagine I eat a piece of bread. Let's use actually a good example, since you mentioned bread. There was this fascinating study published recently in the journal Food and Nutrition Research, and they had test subjects to ... This is a crossover study, so everybody's doing both things, to consume a sandwich of either whole multigrain bread and cheddar cheese or a sandwich of what they'd even be ultra-processed food, which was white bread and cheese product. Here in the United States, Kraft is a big cheese company. That's what I grew up eating, but it's called Kraft singles because they can't legally call it cheese. There's not a cheese in the cheese. It's this cheese product. They had test subjects to consume both sandwiches at different parts of the study. Now, keep in mind, these sandwiches have the same amount of protein, fats, carbohydrates, and the same amount of calories. When they ate the two different versions of these sandwiches, very different things happened with their metabolism. In particular, the expenditure of the calories they consumed. When people ate the processed food sandwich versus the whole food sandwich, they had about a 50% reduction in calorie expenditure, a calorie burn, after eating that processed food sandwich. Something happened. To create a very simple understanding, it basically created metabolic clogs. It blocked the body's ability to use that energy efficiently and to get rid of it. What does our body do? It's going to do what it can to protect us. If even that means holding on to some of these calories to try to figure out what to do with this later at some point, and not to mention all the other pieces that come along with that, it's not just the calories from the food. As Tim knows this as well, there's a lot of other compounds that come along with ultra-processed foods, whether this is thylates, whether this is pesticides, and all these other things that can disrupt our metabolism. When it boils down to it, if we can just consolidate this whole idea, when we're choosing to eat a certain food, it's not just this calorie conversation. Tim and I talked a lot about this when I had him on my show. It's so much bigger. There are all these, and this is the term I want to share with everybody, epicoloric controllers. They're these epicoloric controllers that are determining how our body is processing the food that we're eating. Today we're going to expand from the conversation of just calories and understand that our metabolism, when it boils down to it, it is the conversion of food into energy. Yes, but there are all these other really wonderful factors for us to pay attention to. Today I want to help everybody to just refine it to some very simple ideas, because it can be complex, obviously. There's so many pieces to cover, but today I want to share some of the top things that are the epicoloric controllers that we can apply in our lives to make better choices and to have a more efficient metabolism overall. You looked at these two different meals that looked almost the same. In theory, they're like bread and cheese, bread and cheese, but one is sort of ultra-processed, and one is sort of much more whole grain and natural and real cheese. You're saying that metabolism is the way that you convert food into energy, but although both of them have the same number of calories, you think that the metabolism has to be the same. You're saying that with this ultra-processed food, somehow your body's metabolism was completely different and it's sort of held on to a whole bunch of those calories and stored them as fat, basically, whereas with that more natural food, it sort of burnt them up, even though they were the same calories. Did I understand that right? Now, we can't say that the study doesn't reveal whether or not it's getting stored as fat, per se, but the body is slowing down its processing of that energy. There's going to be a tendency, especially over time, that more and more of that's going to get stored as fat. But as Tim mentioned, in the short term, it can just be everything's kind of slowing down. Your body, from my perspective, is just trying to figure out what to do with this stuff because it is newly invented and based on the things we really evolved eating, where we have a level of efficiency, and our bodies are incredibly intelligent and resilient. They could figure out how to process that cheese product if it's forced to. But ideally, is that optimal? Probably not. I think the follow on question that was one of the top questions that we had was around metabolic health. So just as I think I'm still a bit confused really about exactly what metabolism is, I'm definitely also confused about what metabolic health is. What does it mean? I love that this is a big part of the conversation today because when I graduated from college, I studied nutrition, I studied biochemistry, and I was not taught about quote, metabolic health. It's just like, even in my first nutritional science class, we were first of all taught the food pyramid. This was the 90s. My teacher, the professor, was basically, he came in and he shared that if you want to lose weight, you expend more energy than you take in. Right? Simple as that. If you want to gain weight, you consume more calories than you expend. And that was it. If you want to stay the same, they need to be the same. And a little side note, and I don't talk about this often, but my teacher was significantly overweight. I'm not saying that this was a character flaw or anything like that, but I'm sure that he was doing a lot of things that he was trying to teach us, but they just simply weren't working for him. And he just needed, in his mind, I just need to cut more calories. I need to do better. And we start to punish ourselves because this dogma that we've been taught isn't working out. And it does work for some people. Because at the time, he's teaching us and he's applying, we need to eat seven to 11 servings of, quote, healthy whole grains every day. And that's the basis of our diet. And so some of the principles that I took from that is basically, you know, if it's white, it's not right. All right? So no more refined carbohydrates. I'm not going to eat this regular pasta that I grew up eating. Let me get whole wheat pasta. Right? I'm not going to eat the white bread that I grew up eating in the United States. It's like Wonder Bread and Bunny Bread. And now I'm going to eat whole grain bread. I'm going to eat a lot of brown food. And this is not taken into account my unique metabolic fingerprint. Right? So these are some of the things that go into our own unique metabolic fingerprint and our own unique metabolic health. And part of that is our own unique microbial fingerprint. And what if somebody has a hard time with their microbial makeup trying to process a lot of these, quote, healthy whole grains? What is that going to do to their metabolic health? What is that going to do to their energy assimilation and expenditure? Right? All this stuff matters. And we can't have this kind of cookie cutter approach to things. And so an example that really like it stayed with me for years that I couldn't understand. And I would go to this Chinese food restaurant that was right off campus. And I was like wondering why the store owner and their family, I would go around the time when they're having their lunch and they were like eating white rice and like steamed vegetables. And I'm just like, why are they eating white rice? Don't they know that, you know, this is so much better for you to eat brown rice. And what it was truly, if you, you know, my wife is from Africa as well. She's from Kenya. And they've been eating white rice for a long time. Yes, there can be parts of the container or the brand of certain things that can add fiber, but they can also be a gut irritant for a lot of people as well. And so I think some people, our ancestors figured out centuries ago that if we want to efficiently process this food without side effects, if we're looking for caloric energy, right? If that's our goal with this thing, we might want to get rid of this because it can create some gut irritation for some people. And so getting that background education and not being taught what metabolic health is, which is what is right for me right now to efficiently process my food, to feel good, to of course, a body composition can come into the mix as well. It's like an outpicturing. And your opening like rapid fire question was, can we have an outpicturing of fitness and still be metabolically unhealthy? Absolutely. It is a part of the equation. There are all these different parts. And so ultimately, and the most recent data here in the United States, and again, I think that the number of course, it can shift a little bit, but I think it's pretty close. Only 12% of United States citizens are metabolically healthy. Only 12%. Only 12%. That should be outrageous, like blow our minds. But the question is, again, this is what we're talking about. What does that mean? What is metabolic health? Well, in this particular study, they were looking at triglyceride levels. They were looking at HDL and LDL ratios. They were looking at, yes, body composition, body fat percentage and things like that. But it's still looking at things through a very small frame. So I'm not going to be the guy that comes on this show and tells you this is exactly what metabolic health is. I have this problem writing books to the public to try and explain metabolism. And my editor says, what is metabolism metabolic health? Well, the best way I described it, and I love your thoughts on it, is it's the energy management system of the body and its efficiency. It's how all the bits in the body work together and how efficient it is or whether it's inefficient and it's having to work too hard to keep the house warm or cool or whatever it is, is keeping it exactly at that right temperature all the time, regardless of what you're doing. Do you think that's a reasonable way to... Absolutely. Efficiency is such a key word in this, but that can be misconstrued because we can be very efficient in converting that white rice into glucose and shoot up our blood glucose, have a huge response from insulin. Yeah, it's efficient to convert that into energy, but is that metabolically healthy for us? And so we've got to take into account that efficiency means multiple things as well. Yeah, it means not having side effects and means not having other things happen to the system that make it go wrong. At Zoe, we never stop being curious about how people respond to food. So we recently asked thousands of people about their breakfast, what they eat and how they feel about it. Their answers may surprise you. Over 70% told us that their breakfast is balanced, yet only 6% get enough fiber. If you've been listening to this podcast, you know that's not enough to be balanced. And it's no wonder that only 16% felt energetic after eating. Clearly, breakfast is broken. But what if you could get a breakfast that actually supports your energy and gut health? Meet Daily 30, our 30 plant gut supplement that's out to fix breakfast one scoop at a time. Daily 30 is designed by Zoe Gut Health Scientists and features four grams of fiber and ingredients that support gut health, digestion, energy, immunity and skin and hair. Deliciously crunchy, you can sprinkle it on yogurt and berries, porridge, avocado toast, eggs, even pancakes. Tastes great on lunches and other meals too. As we've discussed repeatedly on this podcast, healthy habits are easier to start in the morning. So why not get your 30 plants in before 10am? Find your breakfast fix and try the new formula at zoe.com slash daily30. Our scientists have just redesigned Daily 30 to include even more plants, including raspberries, goji berries, fermented green tea kombucha, kale and marine algae. By the way, whenever we share what Daily 30 can do, UK law requires us to say that it's a natural source of calcium, which supports gut health and digestion, and copper, which supports energy, immunity and skin and hair. If you tune in regularly, you know what we think about this. Honestly, we prefer to let the benefits of Daily 30 speak for itself. Go to zoe.com slash daily30 to get started. Try it for a week and see how you feel.