Payne Lindsey

Mentioned in 7 analyzed podcast episodes across 4 shows

Podcast creator and host known for founding Tenderfoot TV and producing multiple investigative and paranormal series including *Up and Vanished*, *Radio Rental*, *High Strange*, and *Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer*. He serves as lead investigator and creative force behind these documentary-style podcasts, collaborating with other producers and industry figures at major podcast events like CrimeCon.

Appears On

Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Radio Rental Up and Vanished Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer

Episode Appearances

Crime Stories with Nancy Grace · Apr 3, 2026

VANISHED IN MONTANA: ASHLEY HEAVYRUNNER'S FAMILY DESPERATE PLEA

“Independent investigator who has conducted 40+ interviews and posted $50,000 reward for case information”

Missing Indigenous Persons CasesTribal Jurisdiction and Law Enforcement AuthorityFederal vs. Tribal Law Enforcement Coordination

View Analysis

Radio Rental · Feb 6, 2026

The Schoolyard

“Host of Radio Rental and Tenderfoot TV podcasts, introduces the special episode”

UFO sightings and eyewitness testimony1977 Broadhaven Wales UFO incidentMass witness accounts and corroboration

View Analysis

Up and Vanished · Jan 31, 2026

26 | This is the Captain Speaking

“Host of Up and Vanished podcast series and creator of High Strange season”

Podcast Defamation and Legal LiabilityFree Speech vs. Defamation ProtectionTrue Crime Content Monetization

View Analysis

Up and Vanished · Jan 16, 2026

25 | Final Boarding Call

“Host and lead investigator of Up and Vanished podcast conducting investigation into Joseph's disappearance”

Missing Persons InvestigationTimeline Reconstruction and InconsistenciesWitness Credibility Assessment

View Analysis

Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer · Jan 15, 2026

Inside Monster: Hunting L.I.S.K (with Maggie Freleng and Josh Zeman)

“Podcast producer at Tenderfoot TV; met Zeman at CrimeCon; collaborated on Monster podcast production”

Long Island Serial Killer investigation and Rex Heuermann arrestSuffolk County Police Department corruption and political power consolidationEvidence suppression and investigative obstruction by law enforcement leadership

View Analysis

Radio Rental · Dec 5, 2025

Episode 99

“Creator of Radio Rental and High Strange; executive producer of the podcast series”

Campus Security Impersonation and Predatory TacticsKaylee Sawyer Act and Campus Safety LegislationIntuition and Personal Safety Decision-Making

View Analysis

Radio Rental · Nov 28, 2025

Episode 98

“Creator of Radio Rental and host of High Strange paranormal investigation series for Tenderfoot TV”

Unexplained Mass DisappearancesDoppelgänger Folklore and Modern InterpretationsParallel Universe Theory

View Analysis