Justin Herbert
Mentioned in 28 analyzed podcast episodes across 10 shows
A quarterback for the Los Angeles Chargers who is frequently discussed in NFL podcasts for his elite talent and arm capabilities, yet remains a subject of debate regarding whether he consistently performs at an elite level, particularly in playoff situations. Podcasts analyze his potential for improvement under new offensive schemes and compare his play to other young NFL quarterbacks, while also examining the gap between his regular season performance and postseason results.
Appears On
Episode Appearances
3 and Out with John Middlekauff · Apr 15, 2026
Where will Love go, Dontayvion Wicks or AJ Brown in Philly, Mailbag
“Analyzed for playoff performance expectations; 2025 season critical for career trajectory evaluation”
3 and Out with John Middlekauff · Apr 10, 2026
NFL Offseason Mailbag: Mendoza Overhyped? Herbert, Hurts, or Darnold? Criticism for Dak?
“Evaluated as preferred QB option over Hurts/Darnold despite playoff performance concerns; compared to Peyton Manning trajectory”
First Things First · Apr 2, 2026
Victor Wembanyama scores 41 back-to-back, Raiders sign Kirk Cousins, Lakers vs. Thunder, BUD List
“Chargers QB; discussed in context of offensive improvements and coaching hire”
Felger & Massarotti · Apr 2, 2026
Christian Gonzalez and Drake Maye Contract Talks // 5 Questions with Murray - 4/2 (Hour 3)
“Precedent for year three extension; signed $262M deal in July 2023”
First Things First · Apr 1, 2026
Luka and Lakers dominate March, Jalen Hurts & Eagles struggles, Tiger Woods arrested, Nick’s Tiers
“Paired with Harbaugh and McDaniel; playoff performance questioned but arm talent and toughness praised”
First Things First · Mar 6, 2026
Nuggets beat Lakers, Jayson Tatum to return from Achilles tear, Brou’s NBA MVP Ballot, Title Pie
“Los Angeles Chargers quarterback; analyzed regarding AJ Brown trade fit and offensive line needs”
3 and Out with John Middlekauff · Feb 27, 2026
LIVE from The NFL Combine Day 3, Longtime NFL reporter Albert Breer stops by, NFL Films Sr Producer Greg Cosell joins the show
“Chargers quarterback discussed regarding talent evaluation and playoff performance criticism”
Heed the Call NFL Podcast with Dan Hanzus & Marc Sessler · Feb 27, 2026
Quarterback Carousel Check-In + Combine News & Rumors
“Chargers QB; discussed for potential breakout under new OC Mike McDaniel's flexible scheme”
First Things First · Feb 26, 2026
Spurs on 10-game winning streak, Jaylinn Hawkins joins the show, BUD List, Bills S.B.o.B?
“Chargers QB debated whether he qualifies as elite despite elite traits and new offensive coordinator”
3 and Out with John Middlekauff · Feb 26, 2026
LIVE from The NFL Combine, Seahawks GM John Schneider stops by, Los Angeles Chargers voice Matt "Money" Smith joins
“Chargers quarterback; analyzed for playoff underperformance despite regular season talent”
Locked On Packers - Daily Podcast On The Green Bay Packers · Feb 23, 2026
HEAD OF THE PACK: Jordan Love is THE young quarterback to build around in the NFC
“Los Angeles Chargers quarterback; tied with Love and Rodgers on turnover-worthy play rate rankings”
The Herd with Colin Cowherd · Feb 12, 2026
THE HERD - Hour 2 - QBs that overcame adversity, the drama between Jonathan Kuminga and the Warriors, Trent Dilfer
“NFL QB; used as comparable for Mendoza's Hall of Fame talent with remedial progression”
The Herd with Colin Cowherd · Feb 11, 2026
THE HERD - Hour 2 - The early top 10 teams for 2026, NFL draft prospects, Greg Cosell
“Los Angeles Chargers quarterback; team investing in offensive line protection”
The Bill Simmons Podcast · Feb 9, 2026
Seattle Spanks the Patriots, Drake Maye’s Mystery Stinker, and Parent Corner With Cousin Sal
“Seahawks quarterback who won Super Bowl MVP award”
The Mina Kimes Show featuring Lenny · Jan 29, 2026
Maye Day Maye Day? MVP and Every NFL Award
“Los Angeles Chargers QB; included in Mina's MVP voting as impact player despite team performance”
The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL · Jan 22, 2026
The duality of this cycle's coaching hires, and the moves still to come, with Jourdan Rodrigue
“Los Angeles Chargers quarterback; paired with McDaniel to implement new offensive system”
PTI · Jan 21, 2026
Should the MLB Implement a Salary Cap?
“Chargers QB; discussed in context of Mike McDaniel joining as offensive coordinator”
Collector Nation · Jan 16, 2026
Sports Cards Aren’t a Hobby Anymore… They’re an Industry
“LA Chargers quarterback; biggest weekly loser with 9% card value decrease and drop from player ranking 48 to 235”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Jan 14, 2026
Mike Tomlin Steps Down! Steelers' Next Steps, and Hottest Coaches Available.
“Chargers QB; discussed as reason Chargers offensive coordinator job is attractive to rising coaching candidates.”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Jan 12, 2026
Wild-Card Recap: Comeback Caleb, 49ers Shock Eagles, Bills Bounce Jags, and Taco Bell Zyns
“Los Angeles Chargers quarterback who was most-hit QB this season; wristband malfunction during broadcast highlighted equipment management issues”
The Bill Simmons Podcast · Jan 12, 2026
Round 1 Winners (Da Bears!) and Losers (the Eagles!), Plus Guess the Lines With Cousin Sal
“Chargers quarterback struggling with offensive line protection and hand injury in playoff loss to Patriots”
The Bill Simmons Podcast · Jan 10, 2026
A Hawks Power Play, Plus a Round 1 Playoff Mega-Preview With Joe House and Billy Gil
“Los Angeles Chargers quarterback discussed for playoff history and fumbling concerns”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Jan 9, 2026
Dolphins Fire McDaniel, Wild-Card Preview, and Craig Watched 'Lord of the Rings'
“Chargers QB facing 54 sacks this season due to offensive line injuries; Patriots matchup critical”
PTI · Jan 7, 2026
Why Washington Star QB Demond Williams Entering Portal Sparked Drama!
“Chargers QB facing Drake May Sunday Night; constrained by run-first offense despite elite ability”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Jan 5, 2026
Week 18 Recap: The Most Steelers Game Ever, Seattle's Dominance, MVP Debates, Playoffs are Set, Myles Garrett's Record, and Madonna is Before Our Time
“Chargers QB whose absence highlighted team's vulnerability despite 11-win season with backup QB”
The Ryen Russillo Show · Dec 29, 2025
NFL Franchise QB Value Rankings w/ Mike Sando, Plus CFB Playoff Quarterfinal Confidence Rankings w/ Danny Kanell
“Included in top-tier trade value group; physical durability and consistency highlighted”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Dec 29, 2025
Week 17 Recap: Purdy-Caleb Magic, Maye MVP Hype, Classic Steelers L, Playoff Murderers, and Fish Brosmer
“Carrying team with 7 different left tackles; MVP-caliber performance despite roster limitations”
The Ringer NFL Draft Show · Dec 22, 2025
Week 16 Recap: Lawrence’s Leap, Steelers LMAO, Seahawks Insanity, Clutch Caleb, Old Al Michaels, and the Holidays Are Coming
“Playing with broken hand post-surgery; dragging mediocre team despite injuries and limited support”